@UpperCrustthe3rd Wow, I've never been called a jackoff, nor have I ever heard the term.
Anyways, there's no need to be rude. It's not like a made some horribley awful asumption that was caused from me reading the description. I just asked a question that could have been answered from the description.
This is a good cover. I like how brave you were to put this up, 'cause for some reason I could see some diehard NMH fans getting upset (of course, anything other than a pure recreation gets some people mad). Also, props for the creative use of the slinky. It'd be cool if you keep putting covers up.
Hey, you know the book Will Grayson Will Grayson by John Green and David Levithan? If there will ever be a movie of it, I WANT YOU TO PLAY JANE. SO BAD. YOU ARE THE FACE THAT WAS IN MY HEAD WHILE READING THE BOOK. Thank you.
I hope this was not too creepy. I didn't mean to be creepy.
@beleam I wish I knew girls who listened to Neutral Milk Hotel, this world would be a better place with more of you, you take the fail and out fefail...I mean female xP
I don't mind that she copied julia nunes. I would have preferred her to just perform the song without using nunes style though. After checking out her other videos I came to the conclusion that she cannot sing and play at the same time though. I hope she proves me wrong. Ukelele is a good instrument to cover many NMH songs from that album... If she did a cover of two headed boy, in the aeroplane, or king of carrot flowers I would have to come back and see.
@danscullo I finally figured out what you meant by this. I sang "pack up". Is it "pick up"? I listened to the original and it could be either. Maybe even both at the same time.
You should make an MP3 of this because I'd probably listen to this more than the original. Your We Are Scientists cover is pretty great too, you should try some Bright Eyes or Animal Collective!
Nah it wasn't the slinky. And I really should wait a few minutes before I post because that was a mean comment I left.
Out of the thousands of albums I've listened to, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is my favorite of all time. It's like the Gospel of music. And your version is like a Latter Day Saints commercial. . .
Okay when you're rocking out at around 2:19 that was when I went, THIS IS THE BEST VIDEO EVAR!
basically, this is an awesome original cover, and I really like it!
But I will say, that's it's a completely different song, at least from my perspective, like the NMH version gives me images of beautiful, horrible chaos and the destruction that came with WWII mixed with Jeff's love trying to find its way through the noise.
This is really awesome you have great taste in music and a genius vision of what a youtube video should be. Seriously the whole idea behind this video is one of the most original things I've ever seen! Totally agree with the comment that says this needs more views.
awww, so cute XD
cowykay 3 weeks ago
you suck
evtikarina 2 months ago
You are rather lovely
joewashere193 2 months ago
reminds me a bit of julia nunes
fearthecoconut 2 months ago
One question-
Is that a slinky?
BassBOY0GIRL 3 months ago
@BassBOY0GIRL look at the description, jackoff.
UpperCrustthe3rd 2 months ago
@UpperCrustthe3rd Wow, I've never been called a jackoff, nor have I ever heard the term.
Anyways, there's no need to be rude. It's not like a made some horribley awful asumption that was caused from me reading the description. I just asked a question that could have been answered from the description.
So, I believe that you would be the "jackoff"
BassBOY0GIRL 2 months ago
@BassBOY0GIRL I'm just giving you a hard time.
but really, read the description before.
UpperCrustthe3rd 2 months ago
fuken retadret.
nightfield10 3 months ago
Your voice is a bit awkward in this song, but I really like it. It seems akin to the ukulele, if that makes sense.
HorseThymeFresh 3 months ago
Comment removed
venimdenim 3 months ago
Comment removed
venimdenim 3 months ago
mmm need to work on your singing timing an voice but good instrament skills
hydemanful 3 months ago
great :3
theforsakenpiggies 3 months ago
The singing and the guitar bastardization was disgusting.
TheBrohammad 3 months ago
Clicked on the link by accident, now I am in love with you ! :))) Superb :)
sn3hul4k 3 months ago
This is a good cover. I like how brave you were to put this up, 'cause for some reason I could see some diehard NMH fans getting upset (of course, anything other than a pure recreation gets some people mad). Also, props for the creative use of the slinky. It'd be cool if you keep putting covers up.
TeaMugCollective 5 months ago
The swastika guitar video is better...
frenchsaber 5 months ago
If this werent so awkward and painfully bad, it might not be terrible
GnomesAmok 5 months ago
@GnomesAmok dude seriously? it gets off beat for like 2 seconds, other than that, this is amazing. so why dont you just leave.
pawbassist 5 months ago
You are beautiful and bring a smile to my face when you sing this song. Some boy must be very lucky :)
LeMightySabre 7 months ago
interesting!
Gopfs 10 months ago
I came here expecting a terrible cover of an amazing song. I'm glad to say I that's not the case.
You're no Jeff Magnum, but kudos for a great job. :)
leon14320 10 months ago
Hey, you know the book Will Grayson Will Grayson by John Green and David Levithan? If there will ever be a movie of it, I WANT YOU TO PLAY JANE. SO BAD. YOU ARE THE FACE THAT WAS IN MY HEAD WHILE READING THE BOOK. Thank you.
I hope this was not too creepy. I didn't mean to be creepy.
mariannerrrd 10 months ago
@mariannerrrd A-tothefreakin-men! and DFTBA!
howdyheygoodneighbor 5 months ago
I love your face when you use the slinky. It makes me super happy.
katesarcasm17 10 months ago
This is so beautiful. You are awesome and this is one of my favorite videos on youtube.
RisingOctopus 11 months ago
singing right in the camera is so fucking funny
Kingdagmarius 11 months ago
I love this =D
timcraft 11 months ago
learn how to sing and wear makeup
burlymugg 1 year ago
I've been contemplating on getting a ukulele. Anything like playing guitar? haha.
Turbojugend41493 1 year ago
seems like jaaaaaa
johnmorisi8 1 year ago
Marry me?
joepubic89 1 year ago
haven't lost yet... moving on.
CocaineMountaineer 1 year ago
you fall in love you lose; hipster edition
Wwhackk 1 year ago
Very nice, I'm quite impressed.
It makes me want to learn the Ukulele. I think I'll skip on learning the slink though, seems as if it would be quite difficult.
MrShadyau 1 year ago
@MrShadyau You can't even imagine the slink-induced forearm cramps.
beleam 1 year ago
@beleam may i ask you how old are you? :)
nimr0dSLO 1 year ago
@nimr0dSLO
Twelve.
Just kidding. 21. 19 in this video.
beleam 1 year ago
@beleam I wish I knew girls who listened to Neutral Milk Hotel, this world would be a better place with more of you, you take the fail and out fefail...I mean female xP
TreyMMA 2 months ago
GOEIE DING CHIMCHIMII!!
joreentjuh 1 year ago
This is weird but awesome. But, weird. But, really, awesome!
neiladri 1 year ago
This is the most beautiful thing on YouTube.
RisingOctopus 1 year ago
I love this song! You're awesome!!!! beautiful voice and cover!!! :)
GrlWitRosesInHerEyes 1 year ago
niice (:
xxXer0xxxOWNED 1 year ago
You can't sing for shit, but I still want you to marry me.
tropelow 1 year ago
Excuse me ma'am, but i think i love you :D
TheLatterRainAndSun 1 year ago
as hipster as it gets
Weyyyyyy99 1 year ago 27
I can't make a handjob joke because the motion wouldn't work. It just looks like you're repetitively smashing it! No stars!
Nah, I gave this video a thumbs up. Don't worry. The slinky effect is gold.
bamlaflamme 1 year ago
This makes me happy purely because of the slinky :P
MurkusGobert 1 year ago
Anne Frank
swifty09 1 year ago
That was cool- well done :)
Robbyd91 1 year ago
Nice. :o) Beautiful interpretation.
timhaas1 1 year ago
FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK
fxhasthemovies 1 year ago
Next time, turn up the heat in your room so that you don't have to have a coat and hat on. It's probably easier to play with warm fingers too.
fxhasthemovies 1 year ago
you're like a way cooler julia nunes
SilentEcho33 1 year ago 3
@SilentEcho33 I don't think that's possible.
But thanks!
beleam 1 year ago
@beleam hahaha julia nunes is cool and all, but she doesn't cover NMH
SilentEcho33 1 year ago
@beleam I hate to agree but no one can be cooler than Julia Nunes (she's from my hometown... I'm bias :P ) But you're totally close. This was great.
rockshow1806 1 year ago
Nice voice. I like how you pay attention to details, like going "up" and "down" just at the right time. Like!
RandoMonkeyz 1 year ago
fuck.
Lastscionz 1 year ago
@Lastscionz Yes.
beleam 1 year ago
We should do it.
SuperCoberst 1 year ago
@SuperCoberst Totally.
beleam 1 year ago
this is awesome.
craftygangsta 1 year ago
Nice use of a slinky as an instrument. :D
I love this.
Adorable. =D
whatabeautifulscene 1 year ago
how long did it take u?
johnboton0 1 year ago
this is nice.
TheMarbleIndex3000 1 year ago
:)!
sonpierce 1 year ago
i think i just fell in love with you. i shit you not.
Mintsmak 1 year ago
@Mintsmak I think I just fell in love with the phrase "i shit you not"
beleam 1 year ago
I had a smile on my face that whole time. And the the slinky shots would come in, and I couldn't stop my self from crying from the cuteness overload.
bringinSXEback 1 year ago
i <3 girls who cover nmh
chicostick12 1 year ago
What model of uke do you play on?
candiclaus 1 year ago
@candiclaus A Kala Curly Mango Concert Uke. It gets a lot of "Oooo, pretty" from people, if that's what you're going for.
beleam 1 year ago
Really interesting. I like how it was shot in 3 seperate parts. Best edited NMH cover I've ever seen.
tylerprime1 1 year ago
best cover of this song on youtube, by far.
jonnyheadphones 1 year ago
how come we didn't date in high school? the hell is wrong with with the universe.
CampHoldout 1 year ago
@CampHoldout Probably because I was like 10 when you were in high school.
beleam 1 year ago
Omg she's so cute!!
wondergirlcassie 1 year ago
I loved that you used a slinky.
njaimmusic 1 year ago
Wonderful filmmaking all around!
And I'll take a Slinky over one of those egg-shaker things any day
bastlake 1 year ago
I Loved this. It makes me so happy. You made my day. :) Thank you.
TheFroman421 1 year ago
good job. nasty nmh's omen
MatIasWolff 1 year ago
Its shit.
Shit, right?
Accelerator11 1 year ago
This was awful..
SlaughterTheFrail 1 year ago 2
Badass!
TheOuroborosWyrm 1 year ago
I like your hat. Seems very Mangum-y.
cowboyardee 1 year ago
very nice. awesome song, good cover. love the slinky.
snowpoon 1 year ago
I don't mind that she copied julia nunes. I would have preferred her to just perform the song without using nunes style though. After checking out her other videos I came to the conclusion that she cannot sing and play at the same time though. I hope she proves me wrong. Ukelele is a good instrument to cover many NMH songs from that album... If she did a cover of two headed boy, in the aeroplane, or king of carrot flowers I would have to come back and see.
foottraffic20 2 years ago
you copied julia nunes
Nprorwicz 2 years ago
@Nprorwicz Dammit, Postmodernism.
beleam 2 years ago 2
Haha that was great!
crappybassist96 2 years ago
this is great. I love the slinky.
ShzaMack 2 years ago
Anyone else reminded of Julia Nunes while watching this?
Anyways, good cover. I enjoyed it :)
yeslauren 2 years ago
Yes, yes, yes. It was like the 2nd minute when I realized it wasn't. :P
slaggathorn 2 years ago
@yeslauren As soon as I started this up, I was instantly reminded of Julia Nunes, for sure. :P
HeroOfFish 2 years ago
This is so creative and completely awesome!
father4eyes 2 years ago
you're pretty and sing nice.
I like you. Lots
TheMarbleIndex3000 2 years ago
pretty sick :D
iwillcommitdeicide 2 years ago
i am in love with you.
TheComedytragedy 2 years ago
you fuckin rule ! dont stop what you do
adamkubiw 2 years ago
I like thi version very nice xD
AnneAulisRobin 2 years ago
Cute =)
Jamieeelovesyouu 2 years ago
fantastic, I love these NMH videos of people doing these songs and understanding it doesnt have to sound like american idol bs...
strongassstuntman 2 years ago
Do you sing "hack off" instead of "pick up"? Great version BTW.
danscullo 2 years ago
@danscullo PACK up.
wexpayne 2 years ago
@danscullo I finally figured out what you meant by this. I sang "pack up". Is it "pick up"? I listened to the original and it could be either. Maybe even both at the same time.
beleam 2 years ago
You should make an MP3 of this because I'd probably listen to this more than the original. Your We Are Scientists cover is pretty great too, you should try some Bright Eyes or Animal Collective!
CORPULENCEISKING 2 years ago
Hmm. Your version lacks the feeling of the original. It just sounds like. . . a teenager hacking through the song.
ortholamew 2 years ago
Oh. Was it the slinky? I don't think the original has a slinky in it.
beleam 2 years ago 11
Don't be ridiculous. The slinky is a unifying theme throughout the whole album.
NoStarsMusic 2 years ago 2
Nah it wasn't the slinky. And I really should wait a few minutes before I post because that was a mean comment I left.
Out of the thousands of albums I've listened to, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is my favorite of all time. It's like the Gospel of music. And your version is like a Latter Day Saints commercial. . .
ortholamew 2 years ago
Sounds like a teenager? No shit. This was good, keep up the good work.
Vaynor 2 years ago
I feel as if i have just been wooed.
bigmac364 2 years ago
This cover is fantastic! im stoked on the slinky! Definatly should cut a recording of this!!!!!
honaluluhunk 2 years ago
ahh a slinky
adorable
tr0nk 2 years ago
my favorite cover on youtube so far. kudos for doing justice to a song rather than mocking or destroying it. i'd give you a high five if i could
moons47 2 years ago 5
This is absolutely fantastic. Excellent job.
jfinan3 2 years ago
oh god, you're fuckling adorable
sh1mz0r 2 years ago 21
my sentiments exactly.
greatflyingfetus 2 years ago
BONERRRRRR
mowshowitz 2 years ago 3
OHMAHGAWD!
Okay when you're rocking out at around 2:19 that was when I went, THIS IS THE BEST VIDEO EVAR!
basically, this is an awesome original cover, and I really like it!
But I will say, that's it's a completely different song, at least from my perspective, like the NMH version gives me images of beautiful, horrible chaos and the destruction that came with WWII mixed with Jeff's love trying to find its way through the noise.
Yours, makes me happy, haha.
Oh, and you being cute helps too!
hashiepashi 2 years ago
really nice!
heyutang 2 years ago
Haha nice job. That was the most original cover i've ever seen on youtube. NMH is the best
Caribou4 2 years ago
Great cover of a beautiful song. Great job!
RJDorado 2 years ago
Nevermind I'm not in love anymore
Schizima 2 years ago
Beautiful. Not a bad cover too.
Seriously though, loved every minute. Awesome job.
charliebucketmusic 2 years ago
How creative! This video makes me feel happy when i watch it! Thanks for putting it out there for the world to enjoy.
dropkickmurphys49 2 years ago
Thanks thanks thanks!
beleam 2 years ago
best cover of holland 1945 I've ever heard/seen
texistheword 2 years ago
This is precious. :]
I love the first slinky shot in the beginning.
Kyuditsky 2 years ago
hahaha you are adorable.
laaahwren 2 years ago
i seriously loved this video. check my cover of in the aeroplane over the sea if you have the chance. its not as good as this but its alright.
jd201soccer 3 years ago
You're my new favorite person, Ever.
youthofathens 3 years ago
This is really awesome you have great taste in music and a genius vision of what a youtube video should be. Seriously the whole idea behind this video is one of the most original things I've ever seen! Totally agree with the comment that says this needs more views.
drunkendestruction 3 years ago
Wow, thanks! You get an A+ for leaving such a nice comment =)
beleam 3 years ago
Cute!! I love the creative "instuments" that you use. Hehe. I like the "Nunes" feel about your video.
You just gots a new subscriber!;)
m1ssychr1ssy09 3 years ago
Hooray! Thanks!
beleam 3 years ago
this needs more views
giobot 3 years ago
I could not agree with you more.
beleam 3 years ago
i cant stop watching it(:
ashley likes it to:D
youve gotten so good! :)
i likee the slinky:P
dianaOsummer 3 years ago
Aww, thanks, Summer! I'm glad you guys like it =)
beleam 3 years ago
A+ as in Awesome +
hoosierhiver 3 years ago
Thanks a lot!
beleam 3 years ago