@Archieloverful Siobhan made a lot of mistakes after her Idol run was over. Too many to count, actually. It has been heartbreaking to watch her disappear into obscurity.
@BrianLC1982 i was wondering what kind of mistakes she made. When she was hot she should of ran with the ball...did she start a bad band with no talent and choose bad songs she could of been on the radio all over America
@Archieloverful Siobhan went back home to Cape Cod and spent five months recording an EP with her crappy old band (Lunar Valve). She finally released a solo album through her website a few weeks ago, but the songs are really bad. I think her career is pretty much finished.
@BrianLC1982 "Her career pretty much finished? " Far from it. Her new CD is amazing. Each song is wonderful . Deep lyrics, great arrangements, good melodies, and most of all..... Siobhans great voice. Archie, I totally disagree with Brian. Go to siobhan magnus.com, and give a listen to the samples they have for us to listen to. I have the CD. It is, in a lot of ways, nothing less than brilliant. Siobhan is as amazing as ever!! Very proud of you Siobhan
Siobhan's new single "BLACK DOLL" is out now! See the official video on Siobhan's youtube page "Siomag" NEW ALBUM coming 10/30. visit her official site smagnus or her fansite siofan for all the latest info
Pff keep wishing Siobhan to be better than James, what were you watching? I'm not even a huge fan of James but Siobhan fans are so delusional. We all know that's false, but good thinking.
@halabrdave You're delusional. You're manipulated by Randy Jackson and Jeni-whore Lopez. James wasn't even good half of the times he sang on stage. So sad to see people still believing the production's lies, so sad, so sorry.
@Bornthatwayy Well, it's sad to see there's very little support for James even inside idol, I just thought he was pretty great. Not a fan, but like him better than the country kids and his best performance was better than Siobhan's best, no doubt. But the good thing is I think Haley blows them all out of the water, don't you agree? ;)
@halabrdave I dislike the country kids. Haley is better than everyone and Siobhan is not far behind for 2nd place. I didn't really like James, he says he's metal yet he sings Green Day songs and autotunes his voice. Too fake. But he's a good singer, no doubt.
@Archieloverful Shes nowhere now. Siobhan was never signed. Shes still living in Cape Cod Massachusetts and putting out some music independently but the songs are really bad :\
@Archieloverful Siobhan has been busy in Nashville recording her new album due out at the end of this month. She has been doing concerts almost non-stop, and she has released 2 singles from her new album. One is Beatrice Dream, which is also on YouTube, as well as Black Doll. Go to her fan site siofan, to keep up with what she's up to. Also. Black Doll is also available for downlad on Amazon, as well as iTunes
The more I watch this performance the more I like it. I find it better than Stevie´s and Ray´s. Yes, as you read it! SIOBHAN, the Jury was extremely unfair with you. Too much criticism, and they influenced audience badly. Look at 2011 Contestants, not a quarter of the talent we saw last year. I'm sorry
There is no one like Siobhan. She is still The BEST!!! For those wanting to know what she's up to, check out her website, or her fan site, siofan. She has her first major concert coming up in June.
@tonks1988 i don't think so. But, this cover is good too. :) Siobhan is really aMazing. :) She should have a concert with Adam and Durbin. It would be way too awesome!
@tonks1988 yeah I think it's a good cover. I just feel with every durbin songs he puts his emotion into it. And his maybe im amazed performance was one of the best idol performance ever.
@fabioadias there is something magical aobut this girl! check her out with her band Lunar Valve! she is rockin it with them! but I still am hoping for a solo cd, too!
@ZombieZifiction I follow her and she is heavy into her band, Lunar Valve and just put out a cd...not sure if major label though, I think not. just local and you can obvioulsy d/l her stuff. she is rocking some cool covers and they have some orignals. 1 is really good.
i dont think the idol realize it but comming out with an album will do them no good at all lee has a album on the way out this guy has to market the hell outta this album because nobody knows him only memorable thing on idol was crystal siobhans notes and adam being on there because lees album is gonna flop terribly i mean look at kris and he was on the best season and the winner
You all seem to talk about her vocal range and her high notes, and I do agree with you, but there is one thing you forget: She does not only have an incredible vocal range, but most of all she has such a tremendous feeling, sensibility and warmth to her tone and she has an amazing perception of music and rhythm. She is so in the moment when she sings. And I just want to add that Kelly Clarkson may be able to reach high notes with power, but her lack of true emotional connection is palpable
Lee was dreadful and never got over his stage fright. I think fans of American Idol will pretty much buy and accept whomever the record label chooses to promote. Lee is much better than he showed on Idol but the truth is he really didn't have any great vocal performance on the entire season.
To be honest, I watched American Idol over the yrs & I think this season, America fucked up in voting. IF, I repeat, IF we're really looking for the BEST SINGER, literally, then Siobhan Magnus should've WON!! she has the best vocal RANGE in that season. I voted for her! I mean, hello, didn't ppl hear the unbelievable high notes that girl can belt out??!!!!
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU i see your point and i dont disagree, she clearly has the largest range, but these shows arent entirely about vocal ability, they should be but they arent. they are also about popularity, and more people thought lee and crystal were better, so you can't really say that america fucked up as the majority of america just had a different opinion to you. but i agree, siobhan should've won the competition, her version of superstition was amazing :)
@mrjohnbutler I heard that someone posted the wrong voting number on her facebook page, where they posted, um, some kid's number instead of hers. Then she got voted off after that. So I guess, yea, America didn't fuck up but it i did got fucked up somewhere. Haha. Which was a shame.
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU - that assumes that being a good singer is just about range, which it isn't. I agree that idol voting is rarely on point, but I don't mind that Siobhan didn't win this season. A lot of singing is in interpretation and expressiveness, and she certainly wasn't exceptional in either category.
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU She has 4 octaves of perfect pitch. Simon needs to be in the men's room when its time for him to speak. I am really getting tired of his sorry, arrogant, egotistical ass.
I sensed at the beginning that Lee would win & could do no wrong, the show is rigged. Crystal had a couple good weeks, then her amazon style ego took over & her arguing with the judges every week got real old, the rest of the Idol group on Larry K said she is the ass kisser of the group & as Simon said, she sings for herself.
I LOVE Siobhan she truly has the most incredible range in her voice, with coaching & training, she will evolve as A Star Is Born.
So thaaaaaat's it huh? Just find out how to entertain/please the ppl and judges in a good way throughout the whole way and you're all set? Sheesh, someone more talented shoulda said that in season 2 til now
lee is not good!!!if he lives here in Philippines he would be not known as he is renown in America...Philippines wants belters!!!!but he can sing but not too great as Siobhan!!!
I don't know the reason why some people hate her but she's just one of a kind and deserves to be on the Top 10 but much better if judges just put her on Top 2 or 3.
This girl had more talent than Simon Cowell could possibly recognize in her first fucking audition. LoL. I could make more money than that asshat by accident. Which is what he did. Accidental - Simon Cowell has no fucking clue what talent is. LoL.
I wanna go to CD Store, pick a Siobhan Magnus's Album, after pay money, oh my god. look what I got,But. before that, we'll wait AND SEE... i hope... Blues, soul, dark, soft bla bla bla...living for the city, summertime, GRAMMY IS YOURS, SIOBHAN. take one or three how about that.
Super Awesome Live Performance, this live song can absolutely Definitely compares with + Fallin' + studio version....you know. Alicia, The Superwoman.
@ligia1383 Hey I respect your opinion, even with comment you posted on Justin bieber's video "i'm not a fan but this song is hot" (LOLLMAOROFL). But you shouldn't deny that you're also a Siobhan Maniac like her die-hard fans. You even commented about Siobhan on a Susan Boyle's video ??? LOL WTF =))
@Sepia1989 So you're honestly telling me you have never looked up an artist you DON'T like to comment negatively about them...Uh let's see....Adam Lambert maybe.
her voice here seemed really FReSh.. as the show progressed it seemed her voice got more and more tired.. and strained and ended up being really nasal. she's really cool i thought it was her and crytal..
Siobhan, you are a very talented singer. How come you didn't win the American Idol?! Unbelieveble!To me you are incomparable.You deserved to win.I hope you don't give up.Just go ahead.
@horseygirljane take nothing away from any of them...they all had something that was good, but Siobhan seems to be the most unique...not copying anyone at all! (and no, not Adam Lambert...he needs to copy her!). Lee is a hybrid of Dave Matthews and David Cook, Crystal: Janis and Bonnie Rait.
@generationaluv none of them were "copying" anyone. if they were copying anyone they would not have made it to that stage. even though siobhan seems to be the most original, they are all unique artists and will make it far in the music industry. no need to hate on anyone.
@horseygirljane I didn't say someone doesn't have a right to their opinion. I was just giving mine, but thanks for the reply cuz I don't want to be making anyone mad.
Watching this clip brings back memories, the quirky little girl has truly grown up and will soon become the most successful idol to come out of season 9.
She's the best looking girl to have ever been on idol. She's also the best singer to ever be on idol. Siobhan is the whole package, and has a great future coming her way :)
@marzxyz I totally agree. Siobhan has made it her own. like you, I never really cared for Stevie's version. But now when I think of this song, In my mind I only hear Siobhan singing.
I can't believe Lee, Casey, and Aaron outlived her.
calvininsf 2 weeks ago
she reminds me a bit of allison from the breakfast club.
JC122994 3 weeks ago
Tremendously hot girl
Archieloverful 3 weeks ago
Why didnt she get a record deal anyone?
Archieloverful 1 month ago
@Archieloverful Siobhan made a lot of mistakes after her Idol run was over. Too many to count, actually. It has been heartbreaking to watch her disappear into obscurity.
BrianLC1982 3 weeks ago
@BrianLC1982 i was wondering what kind of mistakes she made. When she was hot she should of ran with the ball...did she start a bad band with no talent and choose bad songs she could of been on the radio all over America
Archieloverful 3 weeks ago
@Archieloverful Siobhan went back home to Cape Cod and spent five months recording an EP with her crappy old band (Lunar Valve). She finally released a solo album through her website a few weeks ago, but the songs are really bad. I think her career is pretty much finished.
BrianLC1982 3 weeks ago
@BrianLC1982 "Her career pretty much finished? " Far from it. Her new CD is amazing. Each song is wonderful . Deep lyrics, great arrangements, good melodies, and most of all..... Siobhans great voice. Archie, I totally disagree with Brian. Go to siobhan magnus.com, and give a listen to the samples they have for us to listen to. I have the CD. It is, in a lot of ways, nothing less than brilliant. Siobhan is as amazing as ever!! Very proud of you Siobhan
VioletFlameMusic 3 weeks ago in playlist Siobhan
Thanks for sharing.
delorsegerrior 2 months ago
she is the bomb man this girl can sing dam i love her
Archieloverful 2 months ago
Comment removed
DreamersTheater 3 months ago
Comment removed
DreamersTheater 3 months ago
Siobhan's new single "BLACK DOLL" is out now! See the official video on Siobhan's youtube page "Siomag" NEW ALBUM coming 10/30. visit her official site smagnus or her fansite siofan for all the latest info
siolbybon342 3 months ago 4
Pff keep wishing Siobhan to be better than James, what were you watching? I'm not even a huge fan of James but Siobhan fans are so delusional. We all know that's false, but good thinking.
halabrdave 4 months ago
@halabrdave You're delusional. You're manipulated by Randy Jackson and Jeni-whore Lopez. James wasn't even good half of the times he sang on stage. So sad to see people still believing the production's lies, so sad, so sorry.
Bornthatwayy 4 months ago
@Bornthatwayy Well, it's sad to see there's very little support for James even inside idol, I just thought he was pretty great. Not a fan, but like him better than the country kids and his best performance was better than Siobhan's best, no doubt. But the good thing is I think Haley blows them all out of the water, don't you agree? ;)
halabrdave 4 months ago
@halabrdave I dislike the country kids. Haley is better than everyone and Siobhan is not far behind for 2nd place. I didn't really like James, he says he's metal yet he sings Green Day songs and autotunes his voice. Too fake. But he's a good singer, no doubt.
Bornthatwayy 4 months ago
I could listen to her belt those extremely high notes. forever.
Insouciantly 5 months ago
Man she can sing.
Archieloverful 5 months ago
Where is she now? I loved her singing? Oh man she can sing like no tomarrow.
Archieloverful 5 months ago
@Archieloverful Shes nowhere now. Siobhan was never signed. Shes still living in Cape Cod Massachusetts and putting out some music independently but the songs are really bad :\
melirose89 4 months ago
@Archieloverful oh i still loved her on the show.
Archieloverful 3 months ago
@Archieloverful Siobhan has been busy in Nashville recording her new album due out at the end of this month. She has been doing concerts almost non-stop, and she has released 2 singles from her new album. One is Beatrice Dream, which is also on YouTube, as well as Black Doll. Go to her fan site siofan, to keep up with what she's up to. Also. Black Doll is also available for downlad on Amazon, as well as iTunes
VioletFlameMusic 3 months ago
wonder if she would have done better in front of better judges that they had this year? I do!
generationaluv 6 months ago
Comment removed
YankeesRock4eva 7 months ago
If James, Siobhan and Adam screamed altogether at the same time, the world would explode.
Iason100 7 months ago 38
@Iason100 LOL
SuperPanetone 7 months ago
@Iason100 i'd like that to happen!!!!swear!
micciloi 7 months ago
adam lambert's cousin right??
makantang 7 months ago 2
Comment removed
dmarek1212 8 months ago
Comment removed
ernevalente 8 months ago
Somebody has got to get ahold of and post the full footage of this!
hendrixgreengilmour 9 months ago
I wish there was a full version of this song by Siobhan. In my opinion she sings it in the best way. She's amazing. She should have recorded this.
IceAndFireSC 9 months ago
woohoo Siobhan Magnus fans have only 14 days until she releases the 1st single from her fall album.
siolbybon342 9 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@siolbybon342 wow really? can i get it from itunes?
lbulaoat 9 months ago
Love her
Archieloverful 10 months ago
The more I watch this performance the more I like it. I find it better than Stevie´s and Ray´s. Yes, as you read it! SIOBHAN, the Jury was extremely unfair with you. Too much criticism, and they influenced audience badly. Look at 2011 Contestants, not a quarter of the talent we saw last year. I'm sorry
Amazonascamelot 10 months ago
Best ever ! you go girl. love your voice and personallity
headgomer 10 months ago
i like this alot than james durbin version!
mommasguy 10 months ago 3
i like this one. :) hope she stayed longer. crystal and her would have made an epic finale.
arkhaili 10 months ago
There is no one like Siobhan. She is still The BEST!!! For those wanting to know what she's up to, check out her website, or her fan site, siofan. She has her first major concert coming up in June.
VioletFlameMusic 10 months ago
@VioletFlameMusic that's cool
mrkgt12 10 months ago
Siobhan put the scream in the right place. That's Siobhan's speciality.
Sepia1989 10 months ago 2
Durbin make his too rocker style.
SailorVVV 10 months ago 2
this is actually better than durbin's cover.
tonks1988 10 months ago 45
@tonks1988 i don't think so. But, this cover is good too. :) Siobhan is really aMazing. :) She should have a concert with Adam and Durbin. It would be way too awesome!
mrkgt12 10 months ago
@mrkgt12 well we all have our opinions, right? Adam/Durbin Concert? Not excited about that either.
tonks1988 9 months ago
@tonks1988 it's a big YES for that!
But i like james durbin too!
:)
mommasguy 10 months ago
@tonks1988 I respectfully disagree. I just feel so much more emotion from Durbin's cover. ALthough this is a small sample
bostonfan013 9 months ago
@bostonfan013 I happen to like Siobhan's tone more than Durbin's. So what I like it is not necessarily the same as others.
tonks1988 9 months ago
@tonks1988 yeah I think it's a good cover. I just feel with every durbin songs he puts his emotion into it. And his maybe im amazed performance was one of the best idol performance ever.
bostonfan013 9 months ago
@tonks1988
No way.
Ladiesman1447 8 months ago
@tonks1988 durbin sucks
Jujuhzinhanfg 8 months ago
@Jujuhzinhanfg durbin sure has some talent but he is just a poser.
tonks1988 8 months ago
@tonks1988 Yeaaah sureee, i wldnt hate on other people. Just saying. Karma you know.
SnazySpaz 7 months ago
@SnazySpaz I'm not hating. I said the guy has talent but I've seen better. period.
tonks1988 7 months ago
@tonks1988 exactly.
Jujuhzinhanfg 7 months ago
@Jujuhzinhanfg Some other peoples might nawt think Durbin suckss......I <3 siobhan, but Durbin DOES NOT suck
SnazySpaz 7 months ago
awesomeness...
kristinecamacho2 10 months ago
I still miss her, lol.
fabioadias 10 months ago
@fabioadias there is something magical aobut this girl! check her out with her band Lunar Valve! she is rockin it with them! but I still am hoping for a solo cd, too!
generationaluv 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
UPDATE SIOBHAN MAGNUS ON HER OFFICIAL SITE:
smagnus.com
mommasguy 10 months ago
Siobhan should have made it further just like Adam should have won :/ AHHHH
MondayNites 10 months ago 2
why is she not doing anything major right now?
ZombieZifiction 11 months ago
@ZombieZifiction I follow her and she is heavy into her band, Lunar Valve and just put out a cd...not sure if major label though, I think not. just local and you can obvioulsy d/l her stuff. she is rocking some cool covers and they have some orignals. 1 is really good.
generationaluv 10 months ago
it will be a long time before we see this much style & talent again
karenstrange1 11 months ago
it will be years before we see a femal singer with this much style & talent again
karenstrange1 11 months ago
IT'S GOING TO BE YEARS BEFORE A I SEES A FEMALE SINGER WITH THIS MUCH STYLE & TALENT !!!
karenstrange1 11 months ago
she should've audition this season.
mrkgt12 11 months ago
a year flies.
GipsyPinstrument 11 months ago
she so amasing.. wow!!!!!
robertfelipe24 11 months ago
yeah siobhan cape cod represent! Haha
twiddlemyfingers 1 year ago
unfortunately she peaked right on that week
tdreamgmail 1 year ago
when simon and elen looked at each smiling when siobhan did the high note looked soo corny, but funny. lol 0:56
5450daniel 1 year ago
She blows me away
Archieloverful 1 year ago
Scale 1 to 10 9.8 shes nice
Archieloverful 1 year ago
Siobhan I love you so much
Archieloverful 1 year ago
love it gal:P
clickit 1 year ago
She is so good and hot
Archieloverful 1 year ago
After Adam lambert, American Idol should be finished.
Jessieashu 1 year ago 3
Very Nice Siobahn
Archieloverful 1 year ago
make this your single please!!!
kakiramos 1 year ago
PURE STAR!!! very original and breathetaking in every way.
Katarinkass1 1 year ago
I've never heard someone with such a wide range in their voice, WOW!
matbolabc 1 year ago
Truly gifted...I can't keep my eyes and ears of of her!!!!
generationaluv 1 year ago
PURE STAR IN THE MAKING- SO GOOD
Archieloverful 1 year ago
nice nice.... jk it was AWESOME!! hahaha.
FreakingWillow 1 year ago
i dont think the idol realize it but comming out with an album will do them no good at all lee has a album on the way out this guy has to market the hell outta this album because nobody knows him only memorable thing on idol was crystal siobhans notes and adam being on there because lees album is gonna flop terribly i mean look at kris and he was on the best season and the winner
DOMINIW5 1 year ago
she is the finest thing to ever walk across that stage. .. period
tele65 1 year ago 3
You all seem to talk about her vocal range and her high notes, and I do agree with you, but there is one thing you forget: She does not only have an incredible vocal range, but most of all she has such a tremendous feeling, sensibility and warmth to her tone and she has an amazing perception of music and rhythm. She is so in the moment when she sings. And I just want to add that Kelly Clarkson may be able to reach high notes with power, but her lack of true emotional connection is palpable
Kickeriki 1 year ago 4
@Kickeriki Agreed. Siobhan has a vocal tone that I could listen to every single day.
shukigkato 1 year ago
SHE WAS BOSS
tennisdude1003 1 year ago 2
She definetly should have won....who the heck is Lee again?
tennisdude1003 1 year ago
Siobhan is amazing. This song was better than anything that the winner and runner up did. Sio is going to be a star!
NortheastAI 1 year ago 4
can you still say that was just Super? or bitchin or groovy or cool or hip or slick. this guy is impressed in a grandpa kinda way. :-)
60viking 1 year ago
I can't get over it...haha Love Siobhan and AdamL. I almost watch their performances all over again..:))
MagnertSiobLex 1 year ago
Lee was dreadful and never got over his stage fright. I think fans of American Idol will pretty much buy and accept whomever the record label chooses to promote. Lee is much better than he showed on Idol but the truth is he really didn't have any great vocal performance on the entire season.
cbotten106 1 year ago
Loved her.
Cydonia 1 year ago
I would buy a full version of this song by Siobhan.
desdagrl 1 year ago 3
@desdagrl me 2, who wouldnt!!!!!
mrpuppiedawgz 1 year ago
To be honest, I watched American Idol over the yrs & I think this season, America fucked up in voting. IF, I repeat, IF we're really looking for the BEST SINGER, literally, then Siobhan Magnus should've WON!! she has the best vocal RANGE in that season. I voted for her! I mean, hello, didn't ppl hear the unbelievable high notes that girl can belt out??!!!!
imLovinKellyCCarrieU 1 year ago 65
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU The votes DID screw up. Some fan page out there put Aaron's # instead of Siobhan's # even though it was a Siobhan fan site.
chunkylard 1 year ago
there are more people out there who dont have sense of the good ones
and there are less of us who like this kind of people
we are definitely the best others dont have any clue
jkadvices 1 year ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU I'm sure nobody even remembers who the hell won last year.
tipofmytongue1024 1 year ago 6
@tipofmytongue1024 Agreed :X
SuperPanetone 1 year ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU i can do it too and i think that a lot of ppl could do it
to0ia 1 year ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU i see your point and i dont disagree, she clearly has the largest range, but these shows arent entirely about vocal ability, they should be but they arent. they are also about popularity, and more people thought lee and crystal were better, so you can't really say that america fucked up as the majority of america just had a different opinion to you. but i agree, siobhan should've won the competition, her version of superstition was amazing :)
mrjohnbutler 10 months ago
@mrjohnbutler I heard that someone posted the wrong voting number on her facebook page, where they posted, um, some kid's number instead of hers. Then she got voted off after that. So I guess, yea, America didn't fuck up but it i did got fucked up somewhere. Haha. Which was a shame.
bitemehoonk 9 months ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU I agree with you. She should've won the competition. Great vocals!
IdolGlotze 10 months ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU - that assumes that being a good singer is just about range, which it isn't. I agree that idol voting is rarely on point, but I don't mind that Siobhan didn't win this season. A lot of singing is in interpretation and expressiveness, and she certainly wasn't exceptional in either category.
Archaebob 9 months ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU what good is that high note if she cannot use it well?
kingj0n 9 months ago
@kingj0n heck yeah she can! >:(
=))) well... it doesn't matter to me! cause she will always be still my favorite and winner of that season..
10respect 9 months ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU Agreed,,,and as funny as Ellen is, when did she become a musician?
Mark6024 8 months ago
@imLovinKellyCCarrieU She has 4 octaves of perfect pitch. Simon needs to be in the men's room when its time for him to speak. I am really getting tired of his sorry, arrogant, egotistical ass.
Mark6024 6 months ago
Comment removed
Sasquatch351 1 year ago
awsomness its self!
SiobhanMagnusFans 1 year ago
Not sure how anyone with any love whatsoever for real music can't find this performance (short as they gave us here) to be as good as it gets.
generationaluv 1 year ago
if i could sing like that i would sing every word that came out my mouth
dacorner8 1 year ago
can anybody on the planet belt higher than her? Kelly Clarkson? Carly Smithson? hmmmm Christina Aguilera?
I would love to know--one of you music majors make a note-by-note video to find the answer. But I still love them all :)
absolutjared 1 year ago
@absolutjared try searching for kelly clarkson's natural woman ^_^
christianjamesalegre 1 year ago
Her auditions are great but when the top12 started her performances got awful
iiJkRii1 1 year ago
@iiJkRii1 Other than "Throught the Fire" name one awful Siobhan performance. I can name at least 6 Lee awful ones.
Idolheaded 1 year ago
@Idolheaded
I sensed at the beginning that Lee would win & could do no wrong, the show is rigged. Crystal had a couple good weeks, then her amazon style ego took over & her arguing with the judges every week got real old, the rest of the Idol group on Larry K said she is the ass kisser of the group & as Simon said, she sings for herself.
I LOVE Siobhan she truly has the most incredible range in her voice, with coaching & training, she will evolve as A Star Is Born.
She is loved & adored
origins1965 1 year ago
A fantastic performance by a great singer!!
dannysauceda1990 1 year ago
siobhan should have won lee is boring and crystal ugh only thing i can say i think she sucked
QW33RGA5M 1 year ago
So thaaaaaat's it huh? Just find out how to entertain/please the ppl and judges in a good way throughout the whole way and you're all set? Sheesh, someone more talented shoulda said that in season 2 til now
introuble4ever07 1 year ago
I wonder if she'll marry me?
sandp500analysis 1 year ago
I love you! Your are so great. I love your voice
Archieloverful 1 year ago
idk howmany times ive listened to this, probably a 100 times
SHES AMAZING
she is in my top 3 idols, along with adam and KELLY
man i hope american idol is still around next year
Bernerker 1 year ago 2
that song for who ?
ChelsieHightowerFan1 1 year ago
lee is not good!!!if he lives here in Philippines he would be not known as he is renown in America...Philippines wants belters!!!!but he can sing but not too great as Siobhan!!!
micciloi 1 year ago
I don't know the reason why some people hate her but she's just one of a kind and deserves to be on the Top 10 but much better if judges just put her on Top 2 or 3.
penpen125 1 year ago
This girl had more talent than Simon Cowell could possibly recognize in her first fucking audition. LoL. I could make more money than that asshat by accident. Which is what he did. Accidental - Simon Cowell has no fucking clue what talent is. LoL.
Grey80002 1 year ago
She looks like Demi Lovato
JulianTheGreat01 1 year ago
How did Casey get into the top 3? He's good but not deserving of a spot in the top 3, he got really boring. No offence to those casey fans.
Azelf3 1 year ago
I wanna go to CD Store, pick a Siobhan Magnus's Album, after pay money, oh my god. look what I got,But. before that, we'll wait AND SEE... i hope... Blues, soul, dark, soft bla bla bla...living for the city, summertime, GRAMMY IS YOURS, SIOBHAN. take one or three how about that.
yiishuian 1 year ago
Make this to Studio Version? THAT IS VERY VERY GOOD IDEA.
I really wanna know "THEN", Not only few seconds...
yiishuian 1 year ago
Super Awesome Live Performance, this live song can absolutely Definitely compares with + Fallin' + studio version....you know. Alicia, The Superwoman.
........................alright...just close.
yiishuian 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is there a Studio Version of this? Please make one Siobhan! Please! Please! Please!
Make one for "Think" too!! Please! Please! Please!
SinnersaintMocha 1 year ago
Is there a Studio Version of this? Please make one Siobhan! Please! Please! Please!
Make one for "Think" too!! Please! Please! Please!
SinnersaintMocha 1 year ago
@SinnersaintMocha Both of those choices are great, but I would pay $10+ for a full studio of "House of the Rising Sun".
shukigkato 1 year ago
@shukigkato i would do the same for paint it black
keehret 1 year ago
@SuperPanetone Fuck you!I'm entitled to my own opinion.
ligia1383 1 year ago
@ligia1383 Hey I respect your opinion, even with comment you posted on Justin bieber's video "i'm not a fan but this song is hot" (LOLLMAOROFL). But you shouldn't deny that you're also a Siobhan Maniac like her die-hard fans. You even commented about Siobhan on a Susan Boyle's video ??? LOL WTF =))
Sepia1989 1 year ago
@Sepia1989 Um why are you keeping track of my comments???
ligia1383 1 year ago
@ligia1383 just click your channel and they appeared right in front of my eyes xD. And why are you keeping track of an annoying bitch ??? LOL
Sepia1989 1 year ago
@Sepia1989 So you're honestly telling me you have never looked up an artist you DON'T like to comment negatively about them...Uh let's see....Adam Lambert maybe.
ligia1383 1 year ago
@ligia1383 I LOVE Adam Lambert
Sepia1989 1 year ago
SHE SUCKS LIKE MONKEY BALLS
NelenaJomez4eva 1 year ago
She's Best
joeybell24 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Annoying bitch!!!!!
ligia1383 1 year ago
She is amazing ! xD
silvavh1302 1 year ago
Will they have full versions of these final performances on the season 9 dvd?
Mariomaniac37 1 year ago
Visit siobhanmagnusfans dote com for more videos and infos about Siobhan Magnus. Yay to Siobhan :D
wildatsmurf 1 year ago
IF YOU WANT TO SEE MORE OF SIOBHAN, LOOK UP "SIOBHAN IF I CAN DREAM."
It's a REALITY SHOW with SIOBHAN!
LuniaVideo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
her voice here seemed really FReSh.. as the show progressed it seemed her voice got more and more tired.. and strained and ended up being really nasal. she's really cool i thought it was her and crytal..
spotzyglitch 1 year ago
Siobhan, you are a very talented singer. How come you didn't win the American Idol?! Unbelieveble!To me you are incomparable.You deserved to win.I hope you don't give up.Just go ahead.
olgacmendo 1 year ago
she's great :) but people need to stop saying she was the only good one... lee dewyze is incredible!
horseygirljane 1 year ago
@horseygirljane I must agree with you on that =p Both Lee and Crystal were also amazing, and a top 3 made by then plus Siobhan would rock =(
SuperPanetone 1 year ago 16
@horseygirljane take nothing away from any of them...they all had something that was good, but Siobhan seems to be the most unique...not copying anyone at all! (and no, not Adam Lambert...he needs to copy her!). Lee is a hybrid of Dave Matthews and David Cook, Crystal: Janis and Bonnie Rait.
generationaluv 1 year ago
@generationaluv none of them were "copying" anyone. if they were copying anyone they would not have made it to that stage. even though siobhan seems to be the most original, they are all unique artists and will make it far in the music industry. no need to hate on anyone.
horseygirljane 1 year ago
@horseygirljane lee sucked, he was alway flat on all the songs, and it sounded bad
keehret 1 year ago
@keehret we all have the right to our own opinions... even if they are stupid! :)
horseygirljane 1 year ago
@horseygirljane I didn't say someone doesn't have a right to their opinion. I was just giving mine, but thanks for the reply cuz I don't want to be making anyone mad.
keehret 1 year ago
@horseygirljane your deaf! bleh! :))
pukehontazz 1 year ago
@horseygirljane Lee DeWyze is incredible? Hardly.... Good singer yes but not incredible by a long shot.
bitemehoonk 1 year ago
Comment removed
DreamersTheater 3 months ago
oh f***. why not a full song
yiishuian 1 year ago
Wow.
yiishuian 1 year ago
I would love to see her do a "duet" with Jonny Lang- he covers this song like no other...
SherriesBrother 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
All she had was that scream, otherwise her singing voice is just.. nothing special at all.
But man that scream, especially in this song.. Love it.
jaybogataj 1 year ago
when siobhan eliminated.... american idol got the lowest raring since 2003 ...hahaha... what a sweet revenge....
filthyjester 1 year ago
*sigh* if she could make it to the final ...
Sepia1989 1 year ago
Watching this clip brings back memories, the quirky little girl has truly grown up and will soon become the most successful idol to come out of season 9.
Anifreak561 1 year ago
Follow Siobhan on twitter@SiobhanMagnusAI
bagelhole 1 year ago
She's the best looking girl to have ever been on idol. She's also the best singer to ever be on idol. Siobhan is the whole package, and has a great future coming her way :)
limak24 1 year ago 3
A'though I like Stevie Wonder, I never liked this song until I heard Siobhan Magnus sing it. What an amazing voice.
marzxyz 1 year ago 2
@marzxyz I totally agree. Siobhan has made it her own. like you, I never really cared for Stevie's version. But now when I think of this song, In my mind I only hear Siobhan singing.
skatekidd77 1 year ago
want a BIG studio album.
yiishuian 1 year ago