I was in teh forces...then I grew up. Simple: Join the forces and put yourself in a position whereby you directly or indirectly kill other human bein/s, just because some posh dickhead and his'Boss' told you to. Retarded fucking history of this planet! Thank God mass communication allows the thinking to think for themselves!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this is gay whoever likes this song dont suport me my brother and every other miitary member it sucks s bad im embarresed to even know people dont support us
7/11 bomb attacks on london? The 205 cases M15 have had to stop from public bombings in the UK, this is as big and bigger then the IRA. Go to Iraq, they are happy, they have a good well training army because of us.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I fucking hate these videos you all are trators you fucking know that OUR TROOPS ARE GIVING YOU THE RIGHT TO SMOKE YOUR POT while you sit on your asses doing nothing i personaly think you should all be beaten for being against your own country.. all out troops need are more fuck holes not giving support to them i hate you all who are against it you morons obamas name is borak osane obama your all supporting a ahrib hes not black
I'm not against my country, I support our boys but I feel we are involved in pointless wars we can't win. However I believe the military has no right setting up "recruitment days" in colleges. War is not honourable and glorious, it is a living hell. Children and young people are very easily influenced and believe they are doing the right thing without being told the whole truth. And I suggest you learn to spell before you insult people more intelligent than yourself.
your stupid... a real fucktard I dont support the war in IRAQ..... or OBAMA hes just as bad if not worse then bush ..he sent another 36 thousand troops.You dont even know why were in IRAQ you retard.. why are you even commenting on shit you know nothing about? Obama is only half moron... but thats besides the point.. POint is you dont know whats going on.
I agree with both valoskater1 and my girlfriendisfat yet like the us the enemies we fight have similar views on how they see us all this at times is is complete bullshit and valoskater1 I thank you from the bottom of my heart for the freedoms you and your brothers and sisters in arms protect every day and at times with paid with your lives may God bless and keep you safe
fuck ever last one of you im in the navy i fight for you people an this is how you reward me an the restof us soldiers . to tell you the truth i think it's sad that people hate the people who protect them the most
valoskater1: Many, many soldiers never see combat. Every protester see the point of a gun, handcuffs and jail at the hands of storm troopers. Who were you fighting for again? Thank you Amy Goodman and Democracy Now.
yes we thank you for fighting, but...we don't want you fighting. In fact we protect you...we fight so that there is peace and that you don't risk your life and your family's mental stability. War is a stupid thing. I have lost so many people i know to war. It would be best if the military werent needed for fighting. and instead getting an education and skills you need. Not how to fight.
I am a 10 year veteran, I no longer have a responsibility to follow orders from a commander in chief. I have a duty to ensure that I use my vote to elect a commander in chief who is not a corporate servant who fabricates reasons to send troops into harms way. I will vote to bring the troops home and end the military Industrial complex that controls this nation. I have already voted Obama. He is the only candidate closest to my ideals who can move toward that goal. You are a patriot for serving.
The navy has you in a uniform for a reason cant you think for yourself? Just becuse your told something dont mean you have to belive in it. The navy uses fear as a way to brainwash the masses if you had freedom from this presucution youd leave the navy but if you belive everything they tell you then youll do it. Dont fight there is no need to fight thats what destroys are planet.
Guys, tyou argue the beat ruins the anti-war feel? Its a PUNK band, they DO have a certain style to maintain for fans. Would you Listen to "queen, greatest hits" if there was suddenly a fiddy cent style rap song in the middle or would that throw off your ability to join said cassette/CD?
war doesn't forge peace war creates destructions and famine and diseases.The aftermath of war is hunger, soldiers with post-war deformity. Infrastructure shattered, countries end up in recession and perhaps even depression. Glory is not in war my friend Glory is in the acceptance of peace and love. Love is what brings us on earth so let love reign from seas to shining seas. One Love!
The reason we went in Iraq because Saddam was going to sell his Oil in Euro instead of the dollars. Now that Iran is talking about the same thing and i won't be shock & awe that we will go to Iran next. It's not about freedom or getting Saddam out. In the 70's and 80's he was our buddy . It's about the mighty dollar!!!!!!
Two of my faves would be "Unknown soldier" by the Doors and "War" by Edwin Starr, Stiff Little Fingers did some goodens too, and covered Bob Marley's "Johny Was" very well. I am a League fan, but this is not great. I'm not saying that liking it makes you a simpleton, it's a matter of taste afterall.
Thanks for the information. I have viewed the videos. I find "1916" to be too romantic and uncritical about the battle and the deaths themselves. I find "The Call Up" to be better, with a glimse of everyday life before battle and against battle. "The Call Up" gives hope, "1916" only sorrow.
I didn't really feel like '1916' romanticised war so much as emphasised the tragic waste of it, maybe BECAUSE of the way it is romanticised- (or promoted or whatever)- but I do agree that, yeah, '1916' IS a HORRIBLY sad song, and that 'The Call Up' DOES give hope!
I do think the video tries to emphasize "the tragic waste" of war. But, the music they choose, and the scene the writer paints, has a bit of glorification to it, which overwhelms the tragedy and loss theme for me. It is an attempt that is too deeply buried.
Well, perhaps the tragic irony might be lost for some, I understand what you are saying. Very little glory, tho, in that mental picture of kids dying in the mud, and he does even say something at the end about how no-one would remember their names...
I think my criticism is more of the music form and the choice of the tragic form itself. The music form is like an old church hymn or a military type song that tends to romanticize the scene for me, with shades of heroism. And, the tragic form of drama tends to emphasize the inevitability of death and destruction. In this way, as we discussed before, it gives less way forward than a song like "The Call Up" which gives youth a plan of action to avoid tragedy and go toward love and life.
Yes, I can see what you're saying. It's less about the lyrics themselves than the drama of that type of music. 'The Call Up', I agree, is a very positive song, and I think it says something for each person thinking about where this is going, and that they have to take responsibility and not just be led off to a war.
And it's the tragic dramatic form of the story also, independent of the music, that ends in inevitable death. That is always the case with tragedy. It is a negative example, if any example at all.
I don't think the tragic form is the ultimate analogy for our time, no. Neither I think, is comedy for that matter. Literature and art are representations of a reality that can be harder to grasp. Don't worry. An action produces a reaction, etc.
Rubbish, almost as bad as Status quo's "In The Army Now", which is probably the lamest anti war song of all time. I love this bands early stuff though and have the cd in the car, but this is poor in so many ways.
Do you have a child in Iraq? A friend? A relative? Lets bring them home. You do not have to carry a rifle as they do. They carry a rifle to protect their lives and the lives of their friends in a bad situation. You do have a weapon just as important as their rifle to secure safety for them. Ron Paul. Your dollars are his bullets. He needs ammo now! Dig down our active vets are in peril and need you. Any amount will do! Just do it!
I liked the Perfect crime album too, but it lacked the production of 1st album, needed more balls, Branded was great live, not so good on album. Long live the League
No war but class war.
bjarczyk 1 year ago
I love how nobody is actually commenting on the song, ya know, the whole point of this video? >.>
megafonzie666 1 year ago
I was in teh forces...then I grew up. Simple: Join the forces and put yourself in a position whereby you directly or indirectly kill other human bein/s, just because some posh dickhead and his'Boss' told you to. Retarded fucking history of this planet! Thank God mass communication allows the thinking to think for themselves!
barrach7 1 year ago
Oi, oldsham BOiz. Norniron, Brits and Glory
ByzanzRebel 2 years ago
I don't think that anybody except the government exactly know why there are troops in Iraq.
just wish Obama could take them back.
Waste of lives and money. With that money Obama could fix many problems.
blojbabis 2 years ago
FIGHT WAR NOT WARS!
blojbabis 2 years ago
who gives a fuck about war!
this is an awesome song!
MrPookieNinja 2 years ago
this nation was built with war
71tminers 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is gay whoever likes this song dont suport me my brother and every other miitary member it sucks s bad im embarresed to even know people dont support us
71tminers 2 years ago
No war but class war friend. You're fighting for the wrong people.
bjarczyk 2 years ago
but his nation ad this world formed from war
71tminers 2 years ago
huh?
bjarczyk 2 years ago
fuck war,and fuck all the militaries,if people wanna die for a poxy shithole
nation,that is there problem.
but dont expect everybody else to have
sympathy for you,nobody asked you to join
up.patriotic arselicker.
coshthedriver78 2 years ago
you wanna talk shit you white bitch asshole go grab a gun and fight like a real man and stop hiding behind closed doors and talkin crap
71tminers 2 years ago
i would quite happily get a gun and blow
your pathetic patriotic head off,if you dont
like what i have to say then fuck off,and keep away from this anti war song.
WHY COULDNT YOU AND YOUR USELESS BROTHER DROP DOWN DEAD,FUCKING ARSELICKERS TO THE
GOVERNMENT.
coshthedriver78 2 years ago
Comment removed
tomsmusic100 2 years ago
@coshthedriver78 Spoken like a true cunt
H20654 1 year ago
@71tminers i did cunt, and we were there for no fucking reason at all
papason4041 6 months ago
7/11 bomb attacks on london? The 205 cases M15 have had to stop from public bombings in the UK, this is as big and bigger then the IRA. Go to Iraq, they are happy, they have a good well training army because of us.
Kiphillphil 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I fucking hate these videos you all are trators you fucking know that OUR TROOPS ARE GIVING YOU THE RIGHT TO SMOKE YOUR POT while you sit on your asses doing nothing i personaly think you should all be beaten for being against your own country.. all out troops need are more fuck holes not giving support to them i hate you all who are against it you morons obamas name is borak osane obama your all supporting a ahrib hes not black
fallinprayer 2 years ago
lol shut up you doucebag
gertrude90 2 years ago
I'm not against my country, I support our boys but I feel we are involved in pointless wars we can't win. However I believe the military has no right setting up "recruitment days" in colleges. War is not honourable and glorious, it is a living hell. Children and young people are very easily influenced and believe they are doing the right thing without being told the whole truth. And I suggest you learn to spell before you insult people more intelligent than yourself.
Fenrisianspirit 2 years ago
WAR IS FUCKING SICK FUCKIN IDIOT!
We wouldnt need the troops ifff people were to juss relax!!!! FUCK!! AND NOT EVER ONE SMOKES POT FAGGET!
Punkabilly187 2 years ago
puppy killer
kuknacka 2 years ago
Hey you fucking retard go smoke pot and die you ass hole your the reason we go to war to fuck off
ok2ful 2 years ago
your stupid... a real fucktard I dont support the war in IRAQ..... or OBAMA hes just as bad if not worse then bush ..he sent another 36 thousand troops.You dont even know why were in IRAQ you retard.. why are you even commenting on shit you know nothing about? Obama is only half moron... but thats besides the point.. POint is you dont know whats going on.
rickhorror 2 years ago 5
great band,great track.
long live the league.
fuck queen and country.
coshthedriver78 2 years ago 2
pretty tame for ANL whats happened to them? they sound old & worn out, so f'n wot...
ranknrusl 3 years ago
Get a fuckin life
pkt888 2 years ago
I'm a US Marine. This is one cool tune. Also check out "EAS song" on youtube.
Navy dude - you've been brainwashed.
skjelv 3 years ago 2
hahahaha yeah Ive seen it too. Im stationed out here on MCBH 1/12. where you at?
timotei1221 2 years ago
What an amazing song. Afganistan?
pkt888 2 years ago
sea smurf isn't so cool
standardbog 3 years ago
I agree with both valoskater1 and my girlfriendisfat yet like the us the enemies we fight have similar views on how they see us all this at times is is complete bullshit and valoskater1 I thank you from the bottom of my heart for the freedoms you and your brothers and sisters in arms protect every day and at times with paid with your lives may God bless and keep you safe
MetalHeadFreak7978 3 years ago
fuck ever last one of you im in the navy i fight for you people an this is how you reward me an the restof us soldiers . to tell you the truth i think it's sad that people hate the people who protect them the most
valoskater1 3 years ago
valoskater1: Many, many soldiers never see combat. Every protester see the point of a gun, handcuffs and jail at the hands of storm troopers. Who were you fighting for again? Thank you Amy Goodman and Democracy Now.
TurningRedInAmerica 3 years ago
yes we thank you for fighting, but...we don't want you fighting. In fact we protect you...we fight so that there is peace and that you don't risk your life and your family's mental stability. War is a stupid thing. I have lost so many people i know to war. It would be best if the military werent needed for fighting. and instead getting an education and skills you need. Not how to fight.
Mygirlfriendisfat 3 years ago
people do not hate you.
nigel65deck 3 years ago
I am a 10 year veteran, I no longer have a responsibility to follow orders from a commander in chief. I have a duty to ensure that I use my vote to elect a commander in chief who is not a corporate servant who fabricates reasons to send troops into harms way. I will vote to bring the troops home and end the military Industrial complex that controls this nation. I have already voted Obama. He is the only candidate closest to my ideals who can move toward that goal. You are a patriot for serving.
Cellularwakeup 3 years ago 2
not in my name
standardbog 3 years ago
The navy has you in a uniform for a reason cant you think for yourself? Just becuse your told something dont mean you have to belive in it. The navy uses fear as a way to brainwash the masses if you had freedom from this presucution youd leave the navy but if you belive everything they tell you then youll do it. Dont fight there is no need to fight thats what destroys are planet.
lococavasa 2 years ago 7
Fuck the country. Fuck the government. Long live Punk!
TheFlight815 3 years ago
a great track.
punk means fuck and country.
long live punk.
coshthedriver78 3 years ago 2
Right
pkt888 2 years ago
Guys, tyou argue the beat ruins the anti-war feel? Its a PUNK band, they DO have a certain style to maintain for fans. Would you Listen to "queen, greatest hits" if there was suddenly a fiddy cent style rap song in the middle or would that throw off your ability to join said cassette/CD?
WhiteTiger225 3 years ago
of all the anti war songs never heard one quite like dylans masters of war and carllant early warning and of course jimi hendrix machine gun
suepurrrr 3 years ago
War is peace, peace is the time spent preparing for the next war.
jubbles2343 3 years ago
Hopefully that was a joke.
broncosfan1415 3 years ago
nope, its just the truth. An intelligent man prepares for war in times of peace.
jubbles2343 3 years ago
Humans thrive on chaos, for, when does man grow the most then when all life around him is threatened to come crashing to a stop?
WhiteTiger225 3 years ago
'The Call Up' by the Clash and '1916' by Motorhead.
lachattenoire27 3 years ago
war doesn't forge peace war creates destructions and famine and diseases.The aftermath of war is hunger, soldiers with post-war deformity. Infrastructure shattered, countries end up in recession and perhaps even depression. Glory is not in war my friend Glory is in the acceptance of peace and love. Love is what brings us on earth so let love reign from seas to shining seas. One Love!
trevorlexus 3 years ago
this is a lot different conpared to there other songs
scaramouch11 3 years ago
yeah that is true i think its a bullshit war about money, i should say fuck terrorist
thomas242007 3 years ago
The reason we went in Iraq because Saddam was going to sell his Oil in Euro instead of the dollars. Now that Iran is talking about the same thing and i won't be shock & awe that we will go to Iran next. It's not about freedom or getting Saddam out. In the 70's and 80's he was our buddy . It's about the mighty dollar!!!!!!
shakil2 3 years ago
yeah totally fuck the islam nation and their god
thomas242007 4 years ago
ok hater
amigooo77 3 years ago
if this is a poor anti-war song, in your opinion, what is a good one?
will you name one for "we simple folk?"
:)
firetaker25 4 years ago 2
Two of my faves would be "Unknown soldier" by the Doors and "War" by Edwin Starr, Stiff Little Fingers did some goodens too, and covered Bob Marley's "Johny Was" very well. I am a League fan, but this is not great. I'm not saying that liking it makes you a simpleton, it's a matter of taste afterall.
crom08well 4 years ago
'The Call Up' by the Clash and '1916' by Motorhead.
lachattenoire27 3 years ago
Thanks for the information. I have viewed the videos. I find "1916" to be too romantic and uncritical about the battle and the deaths themselves. I find "The Call Up" to be better, with a glimse of everyday life before battle and against battle. "The Call Up" gives hope, "1916" only sorrow.
firetaker25 3 years ago
I didn't really feel like '1916' romanticised war so much as emphasised the tragic waste of it, maybe BECAUSE of the way it is romanticised- (or promoted or whatever)- but I do agree that, yeah, '1916' IS a HORRIBLY sad song, and that 'The Call Up' DOES give hope!
lachattenoire27 3 years ago
I do think the video tries to emphasize "the tragic waste" of war. But, the music they choose, and the scene the writer paints, has a bit of glorification to it, which overwhelms the tragedy and loss theme for me. It is an attempt that is too deeply buried.
firetaker25 3 years ago
Well, perhaps the tragic irony might be lost for some, I understand what you are saying. Very little glory, tho, in that mental picture of kids dying in the mud, and he does even say something at the end about how no-one would remember their names...
lachattenoire27 3 years ago
I think my criticism is more of the music form and the choice of the tragic form itself. The music form is like an old church hymn or a military type song that tends to romanticize the scene for me, with shades of heroism. And, the tragic form of drama tends to emphasize the inevitability of death and destruction. In this way, as we discussed before, it gives less way forward than a song like "The Call Up" which gives youth a plan of action to avoid tragedy and go toward love and life.
firetaker25 3 years ago
Yes, I can see what you're saying. It's less about the lyrics themselves than the drama of that type of music. 'The Call Up', I agree, is a very positive song, and I think it says something for each person thinking about where this is going, and that they have to take responsibility and not just be led off to a war.
lachattenoire27 3 years ago
And it's the tragic dramatic form of the story also, independent of the music, that ends in inevitable death. That is always the case with tragedy. It is a negative example, if any example at all.
firetaker25 3 years ago
1916 is about the first modern war, the war that wiped out an entire generation of young men in Europe.
"The war to end all wars!"
It didn't excactly, did it? I heard ANW first in the early eighties and we thought it could not get any worse than it was back then.
We were wrong, weren't we?
Motorhead has it right, there's no bloody hope. Mankind is sitting on it's branch, happily cutting it off by the trunk.
LarS1963 3 years ago
I don't think the tragic form is the ultimate analogy for our time, no. Neither I think, is comedy for that matter. Literature and art are representations of a reality that can be harder to grasp. Don't worry. An action produces a reaction, etc.
firetaker25 3 years ago
ahh shut up winers
the band is killer
destroy all islam
1onmepillie 4 years ago
Sorry,I meant a bollocking.
escudo2oz 4 years ago
Rubbish, almost as bad as Status quo's "In The Army Now", which is probably the lamest anti war song of all time. I love this bands early stuff though and have the cd in the car, but this is poor in so many ways.
escudo2oz 4 years ago
Have to agree it's so poor compared to their earlier stuff
packster10 4 years ago
I thought I was going to get a blocking, I hate to knock them, and it's all a matter of taste, but this isn't what I'd listen to the League for.
escudo2oz 4 years ago
i think its great if you look at just a chill protest song.
however if you look at it like an other ANWL song then your gonna think its lame.
punkhippe 4 years ago
can't stop listening to it..
roeesharf 4 years ago
i wish peas and justice
afrowiener 4 years ago 2
Yeah. And I like mushy peace with my fish & chips!
DoubleSpliff 4 years ago
Do you have a child in Iraq? A friend? A relative? Lets bring them home. You do not have to carry a rifle as they do. They carry a rifle to protect their lives and the lives of their friends in a bad situation. You do have a weapon just as important as their rifle to secure safety for them. Ron Paul. Your dollars are his bullets. He needs ammo now! Dig down our active vets are in peril and need you. Any amount will do! Just do it!
ubuchuckp4 4 years ago
Did anybody know that the sax player on this song was Wesley Magoogan ,the guy who played on the Hazel O'connor classic 'Will You'..what a player
idol3 4 years ago
What a great song, with very powerfull lyrics. Animal's vocals are very good. Not sure when this one came out.
ALFWEDARF 4 years ago
I liked the Perfect crime album too, but it lacked the production of 1st album, needed more balls, Branded was great live, not so good on album. Long live the League
damnedjimmy 4 years ago
i like the perfect crime album too
doz4174 4 years ago
with the clash onr of the best bands ever
Smrdjoni 5 years ago
The song's opposed to "Queen and Country", not for it.
roylopear 5 years ago
I actually kinda liked the perfect crime album...
DeSadeTO 5 years ago