I know that this critique is pretty much two years late, but whatever. I liked it, man. It told the story pretty well and told it in a coherent fashion. However, the lip syncing was a bit dodgy at points, and the few angles of you playing guitar got a little bit stale after a while.
Also, while you did a great job matching the video with the lyrics, I feel that you could have done a better job of matching the video percussively, if that makes any sense.
I am very well aware of how stale the singing and guitar gets. I threw them in hastily trying to get the video finished because I didn't have a lot time to submit the video for the contest. However, I'm not as familiar with this percussive idea. Do you mean rhythmically matching scene changes to the song?
laughable....extremely laughable...good production, very good production, it's obvious you worked really hard on it, but dude.....lol you can't take it seriously...that flower moment is sooo tender lol EMO
oh dude, you totally should have sung the last few words as the wounded soldier. it would have been like crying out in pain and singing at the same time.
well... i kind of did, right at the end, during the dissolve from me singing "shout it out" to the wounded soldier, it fades during "out" so that it ends with the soldier screaming "OUT!"
lol, thanks. much appreciated! it means a lot. the lip syncing could have been done a LOT better, but i was really short on time. im glad you like it though
it was very rushed. all of the guitar, indoor, and military scenes were filmed in the course of just a couple of days, and i had a struggle trying to get it all edited in time (skipped school).
[hey, its matt! even though im talking to you on AIM too...] Nice, aniki! I give 5 stars. I really like the flower... kinda methaphorical or whatever. -^^- Good job! [It's your Methuen-Dracut buddy, in case you didn't guess.]
well, just one guy playin guitar and singing looks kinda lame. next time you should get a band together ;) and I think you should wear your guitar lower and maybe try to jump around to get more action.
yea, i can see what you mean... but i purposely tried to make it ALMOST repetitive... you know... boarderline, so it just seemed fammiliar. like i didn;t use identical scenes from the beginning, i changed them a bit to resemble flashbacks.
hey hazard, great job on the music vid. i live the part when you step on the lone piece of vegetation in the sand, but the next guy purposely moves to avoid doing the same. all in all i really liked the vid. again great job, hope you win. good job on the guitar too.
thanks, i appreciate it. and... i dont know... i first posted in the discussion when it wasn't accepted, suffenly i noticed it got accepted into the group... perhaps they had pity on me? i sure hope so!
tell me what you think it means, and what the story represents/what heppens. i had a particular idea set in my mind making it, but i wanna see how others interpret it.
That was actually very enjoyable and entertaining. One of the best of these, ehm, types of videos I've seen, well done guys :)
neeson360 2 years ago
Thank you. Much appreciated.
HazardSFGF 2 years ago
I know that this critique is pretty much two years late, but whatever. I liked it, man. It told the story pretty well and told it in a coherent fashion. However, the lip syncing was a bit dodgy at points, and the few angles of you playing guitar got a little bit stale after a while.
Also, while you did a great job matching the video with the lyrics, I feel that you could have done a better job of matching the video percussively, if that makes any sense.
Spaztar 2 years ago
thank you pat, andheart.
I am very well aware of how stale the singing and guitar gets. I threw them in hastily trying to get the video finished because I didn't have a lot time to submit the video for the contest. However, I'm not as familiar with this percussive idea. Do you mean rhythmically matching scene changes to the song?
HazardSFGF 2 years ago
Yeah. I was having a bit of a brain fart, so I didn't exactly know how to express that clearly.
Spaztar 2 years ago
And not just scene changes, but the actual action in the video as well.
Spaztar 2 years ago
Incredible, men. That's so good. congratulations =)
Cirhian 2 years ago
thank you!
HazardSFGF 2 years ago
This is awesome as man!
MVlog9 3 years ago
laughable....extremely laughable...good production, very good production, it's obvious you worked really hard on it, but dude.....lol you can't take it seriously...that flower moment is sooo tender lol EMO
Jewrican555 3 years ago
heh...
no
emo is ZOMGZORS I H@T3 MY LYFE!!!! *cuts wrists and bleeds on flowers as they wilt*
flowers can make things emo, or increase the emo level, but it really depends on the circumstances.
IMO, it isn't emo, its reminiscent. And yes, there is a difference.
HazardSFGF 3 years ago
thanx man, i appreciate that.
HazardSFGF 3 years ago
This was rlly good, you should become a music video producer one day, you could make soem sick ass videos
AntiBalsac4 3 years ago
oh dude, you totally should have sung the last few words as the wounded soldier. it would have been like crying out in pain and singing at the same time.
vedox1024 3 years ago
well... i kind of did, right at the end, during the dissolve from me singing "shout it out" to the wounded soldier, it fades during "out" so that it ends with the soldier screaming "OUT!"
HazardSFGF 3 years ago
oh shit that was amazing!
SquirrelHunter000 3 years ago
i thought this was amazing...it gave me chills at the end...great job
-Branflakes
RA street team
branflakes819 3 years ago
thanks man. i really appreciate it. a lot of it was rushed, and i wish i had taken a slower job to get it right... but hey, whats done is done.
HazardSFGF 3 years ago
i love the bit where you/the other guy steps on the flower. around 2.10
mushhroom16 4 years ago
still love it ^_^
always will.
you shoulda won!!!!
dorothywashere 4 years ago
Yeah, I've commented this like 3 times...but I watch it all the time. [Favoite song]
And rayrayskaterman...you suck.
This was amazing.
5 stars...and favorited.
=]
danijean168 4 years ago
lol, thanks. much appreciated! it means a lot. the lip syncing could have been done a LOT better, but i was really short on time. im glad you like it though
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
frikin sweet guys, but whered you get a sniper and a carbine lmao
DCKID725 4 years ago
Sniper: Tokyo Marui M14.
Carbine: Classic Army M15A4.
google it ;)
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
good effort.
Some camera angles were spectacular, and some weren't so good.
great ending.
DanniDookie 4 years ago
it was very rushed. all of the guitar, indoor, and military scenes were filmed in the course of just a couple of days, and i had a struggle trying to get it all edited in time (skipped school).
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
very wierd
kawasakipolaris 4 years ago
and that is... why?
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
that was gay
reyreyskaterman 4 years ago
just about as much as your fuckin name you douchbag gaygayh8erclitt
get a life instead of insulting people's movies.
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
Awesome.
I can play a little bit.
Anyway, the video rocks.
Hope you win...or won...
[[still hot]]
danijean168 4 years ago
lol... no
i didnt :'(
the guy from Germany won, and by no surprise. it was an awesome vid...
but im still hoping for runner up.
and thnx
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
Oh, and I love how you use a war type of thing.
Can you really play the guitar?
[Still hot]
danijean168 4 years ago
lol, thanx. i apreciate it. Yes, ive been playing the guitar for almost 4 years now <3
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
That was really good.
You're hot.
danijean168 4 years ago
Actually not bad. This is the first vid I have seen, so I can't say its the best yet, BUT VERY IMPRESSIVE
rsc3 4 years ago
thank you very much. any suggestions for improvement?
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
5 stars. I believe that it is worthy of winning this contest, among the videos submitted so far.
mannwhosoldtheworld 4 years ago
thank you very much. i really appreciate it.
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
[hey, its matt! even though im talking to you on AIM too...] Nice, aniki! I give 5 stars. I really like the flower... kinda methaphorical or whatever. -^^- Good job! [It's your Methuen-Dracut buddy, in case you didn't guess.]
mylovelygaara 4 years ago
well, just one guy playin guitar and singing looks kinda lame. next time you should get a band together ;) and I think you should wear your guitar lower and maybe try to jump around to get more action.
besides that it's pretty good!
oh...almost forgot: i don't like disturbed ;)
cheers
madrabbit 4 years ago
well... its kinda difficult to just... throw a band together willing to do shit like this. and yea, i understand the action thing.
and disturbed is the shit.
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
yea, i can see what you mean... but i purposely tried to make it ALMOST repetitive... you know... boarderline, so it just seemed fammiliar. like i didn;t use identical scenes from the beginning, i changed them a bit to resemble flashbacks.
thanks though. i really appreciate it
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
hey guys, the ratings are getting lower and lower. if you dont like it, dont just give it a bad rating. please say why. i want to know. thanks!
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
hey hazard, great job on the music vid. i live the part when you step on the lone piece of vegetation in the sand, but the next guy purposely moves to avoid doing the same. all in all i really liked the vid. again great job, hope you win. good job on the guitar too.
MindlessAH 4 years ago
the battleground scenes= well blocked. i envy the guitar skills, by the way.
CindyLidia 4 years ago
Yeah a Mac! Did you do yours on imovie? I did.
PraiseCheesus 4 years ago
Hey its aaron. Nice job bud.
SkaterBoy91 4 years ago
So did you get in the contest? It posted to the group.
I really like it. It has a story with a point. The editing and the effects are nice.
hobbitygirl 4 years ago
thanks, i appreciate it. and... i dont know... i first posted in the discussion when it wasn't accepted, suffenly i noticed it got accepted into the group... perhaps they had pity on me? i sure hope so!
HazardSFGF 4 years ago
tell me what you think it means, and what the story represents/what heppens. i had a particular idea set in my mind making it, but i wanna see how others interpret it.
HazardSFGF 4 years ago