Beethoven symphony no. 10 in E flat major "Unfinished" (Part 2 of 2)

[minene09]

!!!!!thas amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mcbeastie19601]

The melody in the opening and closing andante sections of this work is so beautiful it almost has me in tears. Whether you think it is Beethoven or Cooper, it is undeniably great music.

[thebloads]

@DrownedAtLakeBodom I kinda disagree. Hearing music with your ears is totally different from perceiving music. He never stopped perceiving music in his head.

[yohannbiimu]

The only thing that bugs me about this is that the development section doesn't sound like it is developing themes from the exposition of this movement.  It sounds like a development section for another piece entirely. Seems to me like it's parts of two different pieces. I like the music, but in terms of form it doesn't sound like what Beethoven would have composed for a first movement for a symphony.

[berniewa2008]

Thanks to Beethoven, to Cooper, to the orchestra musicians, and - not least - to you, "colevany", posting it here, combined carefully with such beautiful visual impressions !

[COLEVANY]

@berniewa2008

I'm glad you liked it. Thanks for watching and enjoying!

[berniewa2008]

@DrownedAtLakeBodom Sorry, I do not see any evidence of this theory at all. Just 1 example: J. S. Bach has not become deaf (and blind just in the very end of his life) And why at all should there in the world be such a "ballcance"? There's no reason to suggest that

[mrlouis1421]

I'm correcting myself. I meant the "Pathétique" sonata.

[mrlouis1421]

The "Appassionata" theme recurs here also. Putting together fragments of unfinished works simply adds fresh music for us to enjoy. Think of all the composers who were never born because their would-be parents broke up or were infirtle. Let's be grateful for ALL that we treasure in life.

[Andromeda1741]

You know he was also going to write a music textbook. If only his brother hadnt given him the coldest room in the house when he was sick.

[DuduKorg]

I'm writing a little symphony... I hope this year I will be able to finish it and find a orchestra to play... I think the world needs more symphonists and classical composers in general... We must not let the classical music just in past!!

[SirSebastianWang]

@DuduKorg

I'm writing a symphony too! My third movement is based on this part.

[DuduKorg]

@SirSebastianWang That`s amazing!! I`d love to listening wen you finish it!!

[anisuthideyakoindu]

Whatever: at least this shows Barry Cooper to be a genial composer, who attributed this work to his master, Ludwig Van Beethoven. After this life, at least if we harken on to God's words, we will be able to hear many unknown works, even of masters who remained unknown!

[Agomongo1235]

BEETHOVEN PLEASE SEND ME UR GREAT EAR SO I CAN FINISH WAT U STARTED AND INTENDED TO PUT ON THIS BEAUTIFUL WORK PLEASE IT KILLS ME NOT KNOWING WAT U WERE GOING TO WRITE

[EpsilonEnsis]

@Agomongo1235

"Please send me ur great ear"? lol. Beethoven was completely deaf at the end. A lot of good his ear will do for you.

[mmaybrown]

This sounds like Beethoven so much. Why people would try to discredit him on creating this symphony is unbelievable

[ulimaino]

great work of mr. Cooper..