TJ the Amazing Atheist's justification for the state is flawed

[LiberAnarchy]

BUT WHO WILL BUILD THE ROADS! Surely, private companies can't or more communal communities can't devise their own arrangements like voluntary taxation or communal effort for things that one need not spend time in school to learn. Anyway, many cities already contract private companies for things like roads and trash pick up. Free markets require people associating with one another.

[greenghost2008]

@LiberAnarchy "A market of anarchists!"(look up this youtube vid) Fuck the roads.lol otherwise good anwser.

[LiberAnarchy]

@greenghost2008 I'm sorry. You misunderstood my tone, but it's my fault. I began sarcastically but then gave a serious comment about how we can do things w/o a state. Education is a great example. Private schools are an option. So are Montasory (sp?) schools, non- schooling, home schooling, some neighborhoods take turns allowing parents to teach the young children. There was a time when older students would be payed by the younger students to teach them. So really, you and I agree. :)

[greenghost2008]

@LiberAnarchy oh I know. I understood you. Did you watch the vid. I suggested?

[JMXification]

Can you provide yourself with roads, health care, currency, fire protection, libraries, ect? Voluntary groups? You cant be serious, man. Really? Im not seeing your point as realistic at all. Maybe Im missing something or you arent being very convincing in your argument. Just sayin..

[greenghost2008]

@JMXification Are you telling me you make your own cloths, built your own car, or make all your own food? Of course not.

[JMXification]

@greenghost2008 Thats my point.



[greenghost2008]

@JMXification my point is that those things you mentioned good be offered on a voluntary basis