Please stop having your "debates" here,it has been gone on for about a week.They could directly/indirectly annoy people.
Anyone can criticize.But it depends on how constructive the criticizm is.However,people can also make suggestions for his improvement to be a better player,because none is perfect.If you want to express your opinion(s) on others' criticizm/suggestions,first look at their point of view positively.If your opinion is constructive,no objection.If not,you know what to do.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It's fast but very messy. He seems to lose the plot about half way through the video. Kind of a shame, should have stuck to basics rather than jazzing it up.
I can appreciate the original piece much more. If played entirely on piano it should be slower and have more feeling.
I mean the part at 1:20 is a pathetic excuse at originality. If he wanted to create the feeling of the entire song - all instruments - then he should have played it on an Electone.
I think 1:20 may have been acceptable if it was slower altogether and he didn't lose tempo right afterward, probably because that's not actually in the song.
@kztar621 I beg to differ some movie critics have never touched a camera in their lives and yet they still get to offer their opinion on them. People criticize music all the time whether or not they know how to play an instrument or read sheet music.
@kztar621 That's stupid. So you're saying that I can't say "this movie is bad" unless I have proof I, personally, can make a better movie? Not only does that make little to no sense at all, but it's also just a pain in the ass.
Customer at a restaurant: "This soup tastes like crap."
Chef: "Let's see you make a better soup then! Oh, you can't? Then shut up and eat the fucking soup!"
Movies cost huge amounts of cash to make, or huge amounts of time, while music just takes an hour a day of practicing to get good at. You can't even compare criticizing music to a movie, they aren't related.
And I agree with kztar, unless you can play better, you can't say jack.
@mario11168 There isn't such thing as a criticism that is "right" in the sense you're using it. Criticisms are opinions and viewpoints. There isn't exactly any objective correct opinion to have on something. So, unless you have "better" talent, you can't say anything bad about something? I would say, if I believed in that BS, that it would work both ways then; that you can't say anything good about it either. You aren't experienced in this field; what do you know about what's good OR bad?
@cosmosofinfinity And obviously you don't have to be a professional to say something about it, that's part of the freedom of speech in America, say what you want and no one can say jack about it.
But, we have the right to argue what you say, and I argue that if you can't do better than the person you are criticizing, then it makes you look like someone who has nothing better to do than to tell other people they're bad even if you can't do any better in the first place.
@mario11168 So bottom line, opinions aren't about whether or not you can do better. An opinion is just how you feel about whatever given thing. If you like it, you say it's good. If you don't like it, you say it's bad. You don't need to be a professional at something to have a thought about it. And you totally missed the point of my comparison to movies; how much resources it takes to create each one had nothing to do with anything.
You and kztar621 are basically telling people with
@cosmosofinfinity Resources have to do with everything. Could I make a movie better than say a Twilight movie? No, because I have no resources to do so, but I still think there are much better movies than Twilight.
Piano's are much easier to come by compared to other resources like movie resources (I've been playing piano and violin for 5 years now) but, being a critic to a movie and music are completely different things. Can you do better for the piano? If you can, you can criticize.
@mario11168 ... with not-so-positive opinions on things to just shut up. Which frankly, is immature and intolerant. The naysayers are entitled to their opinion regardless of whether or not they can do better. Much in the same way that you are a naysayer towards other naysayers, without doing much of anything to make yourself not as much as an asshole as they are.
And since this a long-ass comment, I will label this comment as part 3 of a 3-part comment series.
@mario11168 If you're not even going to bother trying to understand the 3rd comment, then seriously fuck you. And the resources don't factor in to whether or not you have the skill or mental capacity to do something better. I'm pretty sure I can make a way better movie than Twilight, IF I had the resources. But I don't, so I won't. But that doesn't mean I don't have the "skill" to do it. Most people who can do better don't have Hollywood budgets. And yes, you can have opinions of other people's
@mario11168 Incoherent to a Neanderthal, maybe. I already said all I needed to say in my first comments, so I don't know why I bothered to go the extra mile when it was clear you were either not going to understand or not going to give a shit. Hope that you would become less of an idiot, maybe? Well, here's another example of why hope is irrational. Thanks for wasting my time, go fuck yourself, and have an appropriately horrible day because frankly, I don't respect you, and I won't pretend to.
@mario11168 Oh, and I'll say one last thing. My first comparison, which I mentioned in my original comment that should have made my point clear from the get-go:
Customer at a restaurant: "This soup tastes like crap."
Chef: "Let's see you make a better soup then! Oh, you can't? Then shut up and eat the fucking soup!"
If you take the side of the customer, your logic is inconsistent. If you take the side of the chef, I rest my case.
@cosmosofinfinity Mm, nice waste of time there buddy, I'm not gonna bother reading it since I have to do something else right now; just wanna let you know.
Anywho, hope ya feel proud. You accomplished nothing lolz
@cosmosofinfinity Thing is, there might actually be a valid argument if you weren't some incompetent obvious teenager or some young adult insulting me for no particular reason. I have no quarrel with you good sir, now I have to go explain to myself why I even spent the last hour talking to a rock.
@mario11168 The valid argument you are implying has already been presented, but you seem to be ignoring it:
Customer at a restaurant: "This soup tastes like crap."
Chef: "Let's see you make a better soup then! Oh, you can't? Then shut up and eat the fucking soup!"
If you take the side of the customer, your logic is inconsistent. If you take the side of the chef, I rest my case. How many times do I have to copy/paste this? Oh well, not like you're going to think about how that example applies
@mario11168 ... to your logic. If you bothered to understand the context of that situation, you would know that you don't have to have experience in the same field as someone else to recognize that what they have produced is something of lackluster or just downright sucky quality.
But you must be some kind of busy, successful "adult"! You've got important things to do! That's why you initiate arguments over the internet and upload let's plays! Remember, at first, I was never talking to you.
You need to stop comparing things like movies and food to music. Movies are dependent on resources, we've been through this. Food is dependent on taste. Sure, same with music, but can you say the piano player sucks just because you don't like the song said piano player played? Unless you're better, no.
My freaking goodness I have got to stop arguing with you. You're a thick headed individual who probably voted for Obama.
@mario11168 Not that it's relevant, but I didn't give a crap about any of the candidates. The idea is the same with all of those things: Someone is created something, and based on similar experiences, it could have been better. The process of how it's created has nothing to do with whether your critique is valid; you are basing it on how good a similar thing (created similarly) was.
That you even care about channel views is something I'm not even going to bother to get into, but no problem.
@mario11168 (continued)... opinions, but saying someone's opinion doesn't matter just because they won't/can't make a better version is, by fact, flawed logic. If Roger Ebert made the shittiest movies of all time, that does NOT just suddenly make all of his criticisms any less credible. His 1-star rating of a movie would still be valid, same as with his more positive ratings. Skill/talent and validity of opinion do not normally have anything to do with each other.
"I think that to criticize someone you have to be better than that person on the matter you are criticizing." so cant I criticize a director If I am not able to make better movie? cant I criticize a writer if I dont like his book but I dont know how to write one?
He's saying you shouldn't criticize if you have no say in how to improve their work. In order to improve an object in an area, you need to have knowledge in that area. Like I for one think that he pedaled too much towards 2:35. Criticize unless you can give tips on the guy's playing.
@kztar621 Your argument is really just one big ad hominem attack, you know. "You can't do it better? Then everything you have to say is stupid." Just because someone can't do something themselves, doesn't mean they can't identify when someone else is doing it incorrectly. There's no necessary reason for one to follow the other. It all depends on the criticism itself, not the personal ability of the critic to do it themselves. Not all laymans' positive opinions are invalid, and same for negative.
@KeroDono Well, Mr. Representative of Everyone, I don't really care about the amount of people who care. I think it needed to be said, I cared enough to post a comment, so I did. Just clarifying a common argumentative fallacy on the Internet. It's for whoever cares about having sound logic, really. And if YOU don't care, YOU can go fuck yourself, basically.
So epic, Tell me where the music sheet is please
Pokejoseph1 2 months ago
so...beautiful...
MaryxSasuke 3 months ago
so beautiful *_*
Kisumisu02 4 months ago
have a cup of tea gentlemen and STOP FIGHTING~
sonicheroin 6 months ago 3
Such hack skills. So AWSOME. As pro as marasy. Love it!
VeryNiceBoii 9 months ago
Comment removed
VeryNiceBoii 9 months ago
Is sooooooooo EPIC!
konataakira 9 months ago
I was unable to find a tutorial of this, could you possibly make one if time allowed? ('-_-) I really just want to learn the part at 0:26 to 1:36
nofacenick22 9 months ago
Almost better than original.
ShinningFinger01 9 months ago
INTERNET FIGHT!!!
Darkipod95 9 months ago
If you want to promote the song, why not just have a link to the song instead of giving more views to yourself?
headcheeez 10 months ago
FREESTYLE!
Ending was pwned :D
Darkipod95 11 months ago
Kickass. Nice job, and only seemed rushed on a few parts.
hlpbgh 11 months ago
I've been playing piano for over a decade and my only complaints for this is that it's played on a digital piano
RomanianOrphansLOL 1 year ago
somebody know the name of his piano?
1Ghostable1 1 year ago
@1Ghostable1 phil
AmeKurou 5 months ago
awesome
63872639 1 year ago
Great video
ebon51987 1 year ago
STEALING A VIDEO TO PROMOTE IT?
this is more like getting views unrightfully. fucking delete it
Sercan1995 1 year ago
@Sercan1995 actually, this video is gone from the author's channel for some reason, so I'm glad someone saved it. No skin off anyone's back.
Zuron 6 months ago
where can you get sheet music for this? please link (= and great job
RaspberryNutCrunch 1 year ago
Please stop having your "debates" here,it has been gone on for about a week.They could directly/indirectly annoy people.
Anyone can criticize.But it depends on how constructive the criticizm is.However,people can also make suggestions for his improvement to be a better player,because none is perfect.If you want to express your opinion(s) on others' criticizm/suggestions,first look at their point of view positively.If your opinion is constructive,no objection.If not,you know what to do.
Thanks.
lavar36 1 year ago
Anyone else mentaly singing 'Sadistic Eirin' through the whole thing?
OtakuCookin 1 year ago
glorious so glorious
FRYKYMEN2 1 year ago
o.O
LouisaLuLu1 1 year ago
Well, someone just put Lyrica out of a job.
Originalprof 1 year ago
You Too GOOD, i'm envy with you !!!
Axetylen 1 year ago
wooow, that's insane *o* his hands are just.. dancing, lol wish I could do the same >:
rukiachan33 1 year ago
@rukiachan33 it's not that way hard, if you play piano since a lot of time ;)
videohenryk 1 year ago
@videohenryk well, maybe, but I'm still a beginner x3 love this music btw *-* I always mess up all the game when it starts playing >_> *dead*
rukiachan33 1 year ago
@rukiachan33 i did start learing it today (15-7-10) and it's quite simple
videohenryk 1 year ago
@rukiachan33 well, i did start playing it today (15-7-10) and it's quite simple, just find the sheet and READ!!!
note that i play since 3 years ago
videohenryk 1 year ago
pretty good !
FoXMaSteR001 1 year ago
Yo can you put the original youtube link in the info please? Thx. This is awesome.
jflalor 1 year ago
relamente bueno!
rikcyleo 2 years ago
Awesome very well played i like the sound of it
andrew598 2 years ago
The beginning sounds a bit like Fire Emblem. xD Although, its amazing! >=D
iVietBoiChris 2 years ago
Lol, it does.
stormfur2 2 years ago
normal, its a mix of multiple songs
Samy69IchigoRulz 1 year ago
@Samy69IchigoRulz
It isn't a remix, it is a song in Touhou series, original version can be found here:
watch?v=gOlsmgYqkNg&hd=1
HenryM8205 1 year ago
wow that is beautiful...
angelsamurai101 2 years ago 21
so am i
Feshman117 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's fast but very messy. He seems to lose the plot about half way through the video. Kind of a shame, should have stuck to basics rather than jazzing it up.
DirEnGay 2 years ago
when is the last time you played for the normal end in IN? the actual piece is messy as hell. the remixes actually usually clean it up.
captainsoban 2 years ago
I can appreciate the original piece much more. If played entirely on piano it should be slower and have more feeling.
I mean the part at 1:20 is a pathetic excuse at originality. If he wanted to create the feeling of the entire song - all instruments - then he should have played it on an Electone.
DirEnGay 2 years ago
I think 1:20 may have been acceptable if it was slower altogether and he didn't lose tempo right afterward, probably because that's not actually in the song.
Sunfalcon325 2 years ago
thumbs up, just for your name :P
UndefinedValue 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anyone can criticize.
But not anyone can do what this guy does.
I think that to criticize someone you have to be better than that person on the matter you are criticizing.
However, your channel lacks any kind of attemp to show any kind of creativity from you.
So prove me wrong and show us how it's done correctly bitch, and if you can't then shut it.
kztar621 1 year ago 39
@kztar621 You don't have to be better to criticize. Movie critics aren't necessarily amazing actors, screenwriters, or directs
ComradeMagnum 1 year ago
@kztar621 I beg to differ some movie critics have never touched a camera in their lives and yet they still get to offer their opinion on them. People criticize music all the time whether or not they know how to play an instrument or read sheet music.
412356 1 year ago 13
@kztar621
Professional wine tasters don't drink wine every day, they drink very little of it.
A person with a good hearing can criticize a person that is playing an instrument.
That person does not need to know how to play the instrument at all, but it can notice errors in the play.
Stojke2K9 1 year ago
@Stojke2K9
But he can't notice the smaller errors and point out the variations that are possible in a piece. Let alone, not everyone has a good ear for music.
ILJeP 1 year ago
@ILJeP
If a professional audio technician cant notice small errors, than there are no errors to worry about.
Stojke2K9 1 year ago
@Stojke2K9
But you're saying if that person has not touched an instrument at all and just has good hearing, and that's about it.
ILJeP 1 year ago
@kztar621 That's stupid. So you're saying that I can't say "this movie is bad" unless I have proof I, personally, can make a better movie? Not only does that make little to no sense at all, but it's also just a pain in the ass.
Customer at a restaurant: "This soup tastes like crap."
Chef: "Let's see you make a better soup then! Oh, you can't? Then shut up and eat the fucking soup!"
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity How many times are critics actually right?
Movies cost huge amounts of cash to make, or huge amounts of time, while music just takes an hour a day of practicing to get good at. You can't even compare criticizing music to a movie, they aren't related.
And I agree with kztar, unless you can play better, you can't say jack.
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 There isn't such thing as a criticism that is "right" in the sense you're using it. Criticisms are opinions and viewpoints. There isn't exactly any objective correct opinion to have on something. So, unless you have "better" talent, you can't say anything bad about something? I would say, if I believed in that BS, that it would work both ways then; that you can't say anything good about it either. You aren't experienced in this field; what do you know about what's good OR bad?
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity And obviously you don't have to be a professional to say something about it, that's part of the freedom of speech in America, say what you want and no one can say jack about it.
But, we have the right to argue what you say, and I argue that if you can't do better than the person you are criticizing, then it makes you look like someone who has nothing better to do than to tell other people they're bad even if you can't do any better in the first place.
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 So bottom line, opinions aren't about whether or not you can do better. An opinion is just how you feel about whatever given thing. If you like it, you say it's good. If you don't like it, you say it's bad. You don't need to be a professional at something to have a thought about it. And you totally missed the point of my comparison to movies; how much resources it takes to create each one had nothing to do with anything.
You and kztar621 are basically telling people with
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity Resources have to do with everything. Could I make a movie better than say a Twilight movie? No, because I have no resources to do so, but I still think there are much better movies than Twilight.
Piano's are much easier to come by compared to other resources like movie resources (I've been playing piano and violin for 5 years now) but, being a critic to a movie and music are completely different things. Can you do better for the piano? If you can, you can criticize.
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 ... with not-so-positive opinions on things to just shut up. Which frankly, is immature and intolerant. The naysayers are entitled to their opinion regardless of whether or not they can do better. Much in the same way that you are a naysayer towards other naysayers, without doing much of anything to make yourself not as much as an asshole as they are.
And since this a long-ass comment, I will label this comment as part 3 of a 3-part comment series.
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity I also have no clue what you said in part 3, so I will discard it in my argument.
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 If you're not even going to bother trying to understand the 3rd comment, then seriously fuck you. And the resources don't factor in to whether or not you have the skill or mental capacity to do something better. I'm pretty sure I can make a way better movie than Twilight, IF I had the resources. But I don't, so I won't. But that doesn't mean I don't have the "skill" to do it. Most people who can do better don't have Hollywood budgets. And yes, you can have opinions of other people's
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity Oh dear, it appears I'm arguing with an incoherent person. Oh well, there goes all hope of you understanding anything I'm saying.
Have a nice day :)
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 Incoherent to a Neanderthal, maybe. I already said all I needed to say in my first comments, so I don't know why I bothered to go the extra mile when it was clear you were either not going to understand or not going to give a shit. Hope that you would become less of an idiot, maybe? Well, here's another example of why hope is irrational. Thanks for wasting my time, go fuck yourself, and have an appropriately horrible day because frankly, I don't respect you, and I won't pretend to.
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@mario11168 Oh, and I'll say one last thing. My first comparison, which I mentioned in my original comment that should have made my point clear from the get-go:
Customer at a restaurant: "This soup tastes like crap."
Chef: "Let's see you make a better soup then! Oh, you can't? Then shut up and eat the fucking soup!"
If you take the side of the customer, your logic is inconsistent. If you take the side of the chef, I rest my case.
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity Mm, nice waste of time there buddy, I'm not gonna bother reading it since I have to do something else right now; just wanna let you know.
Anywho, hope ya feel proud. You accomplished nothing lolz
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 Ignorance is bliss, isn't it?
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity Thing is, there might actually be a valid argument if you weren't some incompetent obvious teenager or some young adult insulting me for no particular reason. I have no quarrel with you good sir, now I have to go explain to myself why I even spent the last hour talking to a rock.
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 The valid argument you are implying has already been presented, but you seem to be ignoring it:
Customer at a restaurant: "This soup tastes like crap."
Chef: "Let's see you make a better soup then! Oh, you can't? Then shut up and eat the fucking soup!"
If you take the side of the customer, your logic is inconsistent. If you take the side of the chef, I rest my case. How many times do I have to copy/paste this? Oh well, not like you're going to think about how that example applies
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@mario11168 ... to your logic. If you bothered to understand the context of that situation, you would know that you don't have to have experience in the same field as someone else to recognize that what they have produced is something of lackluster or just downright sucky quality.
But you must be some kind of busy, successful "adult"! You've got important things to do! That's why you initiate arguments over the internet and upload let's plays! Remember, at first, I was never talking to you.
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity I'm a teen, thanks for asking lmao
You need to stop comparing things like movies and food to music. Movies are dependent on resources, we've been through this. Food is dependent on taste. Sure, same with music, but can you say the piano player sucks just because you don't like the song said piano player played? Unless you're better, no.
My freaking goodness I have got to stop arguing with you. You're a thick headed individual who probably voted for Obama.
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 Not that it's relevant, but I didn't give a crap about any of the candidates. The idea is the same with all of those things: Someone is created something, and based on similar experiences, it could have been better. The process of how it's created has nothing to do with whether your critique is valid; you are basing it on how good a similar thing (created similarly) was.
That you even care about channel views is something I'm not even going to bother to get into, but no problem.
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity Oh and thanks for the extra channel view
mario11168 1 year ago
@mario11168 (continued)... opinions, but saying someone's opinion doesn't matter just because they won't/can't make a better version is, by fact, flawed logic. If Roger Ebert made the shittiest movies of all time, that does NOT just suddenly make all of his criticisms any less credible. His 1-star rating of a movie would still be valid, same as with his more positive ratings. Skill/talent and validity of opinion do not normally have anything to do with each other.
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@kztar621
"I think that to criticize someone you have to be better than that person on the matter you are criticizing." so cant I criticize a director If I am not able to make better movie? cant I criticize a writer if I dont like his book but I dont know how to write one?
eVialix 1 year ago
@eVialix
He's saying you shouldn't criticize if you have no say in how to improve their work. In order to improve an object in an area, you need to have knowledge in that area. Like I for one think that he pedaled too much towards 2:35. Criticize unless you can give tips on the guy's playing.
ILJeP 1 year ago
@kztar621 Your argument is really just one big ad hominem attack, you know. "You can't do it better? Then everything you have to say is stupid." Just because someone can't do something themselves, doesn't mean they can't identify when someone else is doing it incorrectly. There's no necessary reason for one to follow the other. It all depends on the criticism itself, not the personal ability of the critic to do it themselves. Not all laymans' positive opinions are invalid, and same for negative.
cosmosofinfinity 1 year ago
@cosmosofinfinity As much as I support your argument:
Shut up.
KeroDono 10 months ago
@KeroDono Why?
cosmosofinfinity 10 months ago
@cosmosofinfinity No one really cares. Sorry to break it to ya.
KeroDono 10 months ago
@KeroDono Well, Mr. Representative of Everyone, I don't really care about the amount of people who care. I think it needed to be said, I cared enough to post a comment, so I did. Just clarifying a common argumentative fallacy on the Internet. It's for whoever cares about having sound logic, really. And if YOU don't care, YOU can go fuck yourself, basically.
cosmosofinfinity 10 months ago
@cosmosofinfinity Lol'd @ the f*ck yourself thing.
Alright then, jeebus. Just letting you know that all you've probably done is fill up the entire comments section on this video with walls of text.
KeroDono 10 months ago
@cosmosofinfinity For what it's worth, I was going to say pretty much the same thing to the asshole. So at least one person cares.
trdl23 8 months ago