I have loved United States my whole life.... I saw them as the ideal and great nation. And since I was a kid, I have always dream of going there myself to see the amazing nation (which I did).
For that to change into despise is a bit surprising even for myself. But I seriously got tired of how US does thing...
To clarify things, a South Vietnamese pilot mistook the South Vietnamese soldiers for enemy soldiers and dropped the napalm, Americans had nothing to do with the napalm strike.
GearBits: I wasnt trying to speak for all Americans, just myself. I have my views, and am entitled to them. And yes, we are in debt because of a bullshit government, however, i did not vote for them. I live here, am a proud American veteran, and stand by my beliefs. If you werent born here, or dont like America, then leave. And for RudeDan, to say that shit about deserving 9/11, that shit isnt funny, its fucked up.
Fuck USA? Is that why we have the best military? Oh and why is it all you foreign faggots have top come over here and "try" to make a living. Go the fuck back home. If your not born here, you shouldnt be able to live here, cause you fuck everything up. I will admit, our government is absolutly bullshit, and i do not trust them.
"Less publicized is film shot by photojournalists Alan Downes (ITN) and Le Phuc Dinh (NBC), which shows the events just before and after the photograph was taken. [...] Sections of the film shot were included in Hearts and Minds, the 1974 Academy Award–winning documentary about the Vietnam War directed by Peter Davis."
Không ai dàn dựng nổi cảnh này đâu. Nếu chưa biết thì mời bạn xem phim Hearts and Minds đi đã rồi hãy phát biểu nhé.
y se supone que ellos son los k luchan contra los dictadores tiranos enemigos a la ¿democracia?...
y juzgan sin ninguna conciencia histórica a muchos países donde no se respetan derechos humanos y varios no pueden entender por que el odio a estos asesinos de niños...
por supuesto que los demás son el diablo ellos no; ellos son nuestros protectores. demócratas o republicanos ambos iguales de crueles. lo mas triste es k nada ha cambiado
Why do everyone think every bomb is dropped by the US? im not american, nor vietnamese. Im peruvian. If you are planning on commenting such an important video, at least get your facts right. we all know the US isnt the best or most pacific country, but i dont think we should bash them for that. Not all americans are the same, we are all humans, we all have our flaws.
I do agree about war, though. Why cant we just keep it to words, instead of getting to bombs? what's wrong with us, humans?
Video clip trên giống y chang clip trên trang ITN Source (chỉ khác watermark). Và theo wikipedia thì ITN Source là nhà cung cấp video tư liệu lớn nhất thế giới. Vì youtube không cho comment đường link nên tôi không post kèm theo ở đây được. Ngay trên trang youtube này, bạn có thể search " vietnam napalm itnsource " cũng ra được video "gốc" và có đường link để ban tới trang chủ của itnsource. Như vậy đã quá rõ ràng, không có dàn dựng chi cả.
Our governments then buy their products and leave a staving and poverty ridden ridden society to struggle without reasonable medical care etc, and causing no end of needles suffeing to those on the reciving end as this poor girl and millions like her have endured . The lunatics are running the asylum......
My god what a savage race of animals the human can be when driven by the powers that seek only to fill their own selfish gains in the name of creating peace. We were and very much still are blindly led into wars that in the end only make things worse.
The arms trad is the biggest industry in the world, do you think those who run this industry's wake up in the morning and think ...Ah how can we keep the world at peace today, no they think of ways to enter wars....
Kim Phuc was so brave for such a young age, despite her heavily burnt body she seems so calm. War will always makes innocent people suffers.
And it seems that we (people) can't live along with each other without going into a war. Even after all these casualties we didn't learned our lesson. I'm disgusted about this so great "human kind" we all praise about.
Siempre los perjudicados es la gente inocente =(! cómo es posible que aun después de tantos años se vean atrocidades como estas! El mundo está de cabeza!
I'm vietnamese, and i am sure the US didn't drop the bomb. I was the VNAF (southern vietnam air force), but they did not drop the bomb on "purpose". It was a coordination mistake and the village had to take the BURN!
Guys, the general PEOPLE in the US aren't bad. I'm live there, and I agree we did some bad stuff, but what country hasn't? Germany-the holocaust. Seriously. Every country has their bad spots. So stop acting like America's the only one that does. People in America aren't the bad ones. Besides, pretty much everyone over here disagrees with the government.
@letyran62 Just so you know, that wasn't a US bomber. That was a SOUTH VIETNAMESE bomber, they dropped napalm on the village so that they would drive out the north's soldiers who had over run it. Get your facts right
the pilot of said plane emigrated to the states after the war. The girl had to jump through hoops to defect to canada in 1988. But no military objective was worth this. The use of napalm should be illegal.
The girl met up with the pilot years later, and she choose to forgive him because he didn't know what was happening and what would happen as a result of it.
it wasn´t the americans! a south-vietnamese pilot dropped the napalm bomb on mistake.
just telling the facts.
there are many reasons to hate the US-politics (not the americans!!!!! they just suffer from the gouvernment and the brainwashing done to them!) but this is not a reason to do so.
Nobody actually know how this war eventually started, only those earlier Goverment knows.. what i learn from my grandpa that if not US singapore will never gonna make it under the world most horrible criminal of war JAPAN ...my grandma die so as my relative... fuck those war starter... killing innocent ppl
Actually there are reasons why the war was started. At the beginning, Vietnam was part of a french colony. America back then was under the pressure of the cold war and they didnt want the domino theory (spread of communism) to occur and the french were an important ally in USs fight against worldwide communism. It first started by giving aid to France. Little by little America became more involved and then Johnson started operation rolling thunder...
I mean no disrespect by saying that a superpowers often act barbaric. They do. Britain, Germany, USA , China, Russia. They all do or did. But the people in general in those countries are friendly and nice in general.
Yeah and we started the holocaust too. You fool- people of all nations have such capabilities. Let's remember that Cain, the first murderer, was also American. That's sarcasm in case yer too dull to figure it out. How about the war over the "Holy Land" in the middle east? How long's that been going on? Remember when America started that one? Of course not- 'cause it never happened- because this kind of $hit can happen anywhere by anyone. So besides being misinformed, why post such ignorance?
In fact Americans with the Brits among other nations started the war by declare Israel as a independent country. What are Israel doing now? Its sad to say they are throwing palestinian people out of their own houses because they need space. How brutally disrespectful is that? Using bulldozers to trash their homes. We all know where Israel get their weapons. And we all know what country supports every move made by Israelis. Palestinian people are living in ghettos. That is ironic
Since I was a young girl this pictures are burnt in my mind and in my soul. I´ll never forget! I always ask myself: why do peolple kill, kill innocent children, why????
You know how the took a picture of this? It was shown to Nixon and he denied the photo, saying that it was a fake. *sigh* American politcians. I hope Obama will do somehing right and earn a proper reputation for america.
Well, he'd do better to just use the English abbreviation. When I'm talking about the US I use those letters and not VS like it is in my language. This is an international forum after all.
que se puede esperar de un engendro,españolete gay como vos rubencita,jajajaja!!!!de tanto palo en el culo perdíste toda sencibilidad,seguro decis lo mísmo con la carne quemada que deja eta en tu paisucho,jajajajaja!!!
solo puedo decir mendigas guerras, y pinche gente k las provoca han de tener tanta mierda en la mente k solo piensan en ellos sin ver el daño inmenso k provocan, pongan se apensar si es k pueden k esos pekeños hubieran sido sus hijos.
For the people saying "Ameican this and American that" This was a SOUTH VIETNAMESE air strike!
zimmyzimgir2 1 month ago
-Don't worry good people of Vietnam, we are here to fight for your freedom.
-MY FUCKING HOUSE!
Pikazilla 1 month ago
it is sad 2 c innocents being hurt
aidenjosephcano 1 month ago
I have loved United States my whole life.... I saw them as the ideal and great nation. And since I was a kid, I have always dream of going there myself to see the amazing nation (which I did).
For that to change into despise is a bit surprising even for myself. But I seriously got tired of how US does thing...
lolipedofin 4 months ago
To clarify things, a South Vietnamese pilot mistook the South Vietnamese soldiers for enemy soldiers and dropped the napalm, Americans had nothing to do with the napalm strike.
SuperSerum114 4 months ago
@SuperSerum114 What so evar... As if the americans hadn't done enough crime in Vietnam
Awoeller 3 months ago
@Awoeller Exactly my point, they've done enough already. Why blame them for something they didn't even do?
SuperSerum114 3 months ago
@Awoeller Idiot, it was a South Vietnamese air strike.
FireInTheOrganism 2 months ago
GearBits: I wasnt trying to speak for all Americans, just myself. I have my views, and am entitled to them. And yes, we are in debt because of a bullshit government, however, i did not vote for them. I live here, am a proud American veteran, and stand by my beliefs. If you werent born here, or dont like America, then leave. And for RudeDan, to say that shit about deserving 9/11, that shit isnt funny, its fucked up.
matthewtaylor264 5 months ago
everything will be remembered!
waltage 5 months ago
Fuck USA? Is that why we have the best military? Oh and why is it all you foreign faggots have top come over here and "try" to make a living. Go the fuck back home. If your not born here, you shouldnt be able to live here, cause you fuck everything up. I will admit, our government is absolutly bullshit, and i do not trust them.
matthewtaylor264 6 months ago
@matthewtaylor264 Please do not pretend to speak for all Americans. Your intolerant, bigoted views are abhorrent and unwelcome.
GearBits 6 months ago
@matthewtaylor264 fuck you not usa
robertsasyannick 5 months ago
@matthewtaylor264 best army in the world? america could sell all its tanks to clear its debt . oh how embarresing.
glynhoyland 5 months ago
que poca madre tienen los POLITICOS nada de cambio siempre estaremos igual insensibleeesss
brindlid 7 months ago
They did the same thing to Cuba. Look up "Operation Mongoose/Northwoods".
schueaj 8 months ago
how would anyone that has a soul do that?!
MrJayIsTheShit 8 months ago
As an American, I'm sorry for the atrocities my country brought to Vietnam and so many other countries : /
RudeDan 8 months ago
@RudeDan you should be cunt, you deserved 9/11
m9i4c 7 months ago
@m9i4c
lol
Make sure to get to bed early kid, you don't wanna be cranky in the morning. hahahaha
RudeDan 7 months ago
Fuck USA
gwogatobis 8 months ago
@gwogatobis The bomb in the video wasn't dropped by an American but a Vietnamese pilot. And i'm not American or defending the Vietnam war...
distubedrat 7 months ago
@distubedrat South Vietnamsese pilot that is..
distubedrat 7 months ago
"Less publicized is film shot by photojournalists Alan Downes (ITN) and Le Phuc Dinh (NBC), which shows the events just before and after the photograph was taken. [...] Sections of the film shot were included in Hearts and Minds, the 1974 Academy Award–winning documentary about the Vietnam War directed by Peter Davis."
Không ai dàn dựng nổi cảnh này đâu. Nếu chưa biết thì mời bạn xem phim Hearts and Minds đi đã rồi hãy phát biểu nhé.
trangnghiem83 10 months ago
y se supone que ellos son los k luchan contra los dictadores tiranos enemigos a la ¿democracia?...
y juzgan sin ninguna conciencia histórica a muchos países donde no se respetan derechos humanos y varios no pueden entender por que el odio a estos asesinos de niños...
por supuesto que los demás son el diablo ellos no; ellos son nuestros protectores. demócratas o republicanos ambos iguales de crueles. lo mas triste es k nada ha cambiado
Rafaframa 10 months ago
Amerikan Bitch....
hlas21 11 months ago
por que dios porque permiyes eso doy mi vida por esos angelitos para este sufrimiento
nicolitas123 11 months ago
The napalm bomb was dropped by the South Vietnamese. The results were the same .
TheJohhnyrotten 11 months ago
Why do everyone think every bomb is dropped by the US? im not american, nor vietnamese. Im peruvian. If you are planning on commenting such an important video, at least get your facts right. we all know the US isnt the best or most pacific country, but i dont think we should bash them for that. Not all americans are the same, we are all humans, we all have our flaws.
I do agree about war, though. Why cant we just keep it to words, instead of getting to bombs? what's wrong with us, humans?
naokarachi 11 months ago
@naokarachi They did HIroshima too ..American style..Fuck them
gwogatobis 8 months ago
pooooor kidss!!!
Kujariibu 1 year ago
Omg I just finnished eating a whole turkey. I am still hungry.
benadril 1 year ago
unforgivable crime. like the holocaust victims, the Vietnamese should build memorials every where.
blackhawck70 1 year ago
the price of worshipping power and money
blackhawck70 1 year ago
Video clip trên giống y chang clip trên trang ITN Source (chỉ khác watermark). Và theo wikipedia thì ITN Source là nhà cung cấp video tư liệu lớn nhất thế giới. Vì youtube không cho comment đường link nên tôi không post kèm theo ở đây được. Ngay trên trang youtube này, bạn có thể search " vietnam napalm itnsource " cũng ra được video "gốc" và có đường link để ban tới trang chủ của itnsource. Như vậy đã quá rõ ràng, không có dàn dựng chi cả.
nhaqueyt 1 year ago
Comment removed
nhaqueyt 1 year ago
Comment removed
nhaqueyt 1 year ago
Comment removed
nhaqueyt 1 year ago
Our governments then buy their products and leave a staving and poverty ridden ridden society to struggle without reasonable medical care etc, and causing no end of needles suffeing to those on the reciving end as this poor girl and millions like her have endured . The lunatics are running the asylum......
bbscone 1 year ago
My god what a savage race of animals the human can be when driven by the powers that seek only to fill their own selfish gains in the name of creating peace. We were and very much still are blindly led into wars that in the end only make things worse.
The arms trad is the biggest industry in the world, do you think those who run this industry's wake up in the morning and think ...Ah how can we keep the world at peace today, no they think of ways to enter wars....
bbscone 1 year ago
@bbscone YEAH! DOWN WITH THE ARMS TRAD! DOWN WITH THE ARMS TRAD!
lebensraummetal 1 year ago
chiến tranh là mở cửa địa ngục
puzli1111 1 year ago
Kim Phuc was so brave for such a young age, despite her heavily burnt body she seems so calm. War will always makes innocent people suffers.
And it seems that we (people) can't live along with each other without going into a war. Even after all these casualties we didn't learned our lesson. I'm disgusted about this so great "human kind" we all praise about.
mrtkcd77 1 year ago 2
What happened to the burned baby? Did he survive?
octopusmagnificens 1 year ago
@octopusmagnificens i think he did. :3
JanaDAMAGE 1 year ago
Lo miro y no entiendo... hay cosas que jamás entenderé... los humanos somos capaces de las peores atrocidades...
nursingten 1 year ago
Siempre los perjudicados es la gente inocente =(! cómo es posible que aun después de tantos años se vean atrocidades como estas! El mundo está de cabeza!
rocksan2306 1 year ago
cerdos de mierda, ni siquiera se apiadan del dolor de un pobre niño indefenzo
eeuu debería arder en el infierno
tr0tamund0 1 year ago
Yo tambien sere Hippie...
SnowingMad 1 year ago
NO HAY PALABRAS PARA ESTO.......
edidechicali 2 years ago
I'm vietnamese, and i am sure the US didn't drop the bomb. I was the VNAF (southern vietnam air force), but they did not drop the bomb on "purpose". It was a coordination mistake and the village had to take the BURN!
tomknight200 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
lBlackAccount 1 year ago
@tomknight200 Yeahhh. Thanks!
lBlackAccount 1 year ago
South Vietnamese are the ones who dropped those bombs not the americans!
There are only two US troops were within 60 mi (97 km) of the scene, neither of whom had any say in the bombings...
HSKnico666 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
lBlackAccount 1 year ago
@HSKnico666 Yeah...Thanks!
lBlackAccount 1 year ago
sere hippie ahora ._.
otakumizu 2 years ago
Que hijos de la grandisima puta.... creo que no hay mas palabras..
busero63 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
at first when i saw those poor kids running scared..i thought that michael jackson was behind them
halodedm 2 years ago
Guys, the general PEOPLE in the US aren't bad. I'm live there, and I agree we did some bad stuff, but what country hasn't? Germany-the holocaust. Seriously. Every country has their bad spots. So stop acting like America's the only one that does. People in America aren't the bad ones. Besides, pretty much everyone over here disagrees with the government.
CanIhavesomemoreMuse 2 years ago 2
that la da man sao nguoi mi co the lam nhu the nhin nguoi phu nu om dua be ma toi ko cam noi nuoc mat , why american drop a bomb, it so savage ???
theluxifer18 2 years ago
U.S. military continues to bomb villages, not need a video to understand it . (afghanistan )
letyran62 2 years ago 2
really??
why? in thougt that when obama became president this will end
ISoHEoBASSIST 2 years ago
@ISoHEoBASSIST this happen long time ago duh
PopPrincess714 1 year ago
@letyran62 Just so you know, that wasn't a US bomber. That was a SOUTH VIETNAMESE bomber, they dropped napalm on the village so that they would drive out the north's soldiers who had over run it. Get your facts right
Morrell84 1 year ago 2
the pilot of said plane emigrated to the states after the war. The girl had to jump through hoops to defect to canada in 1988. But no military objective was worth this. The use of napalm should be illegal.
swastikausa 1 year ago
AMERICANS YOU ARE NAZISTS!!!
MsWeber2009 2 years ago
just USA
ISoHEoBASSIST 2 years ago
Comment removed
Rachman1337 2 years ago
US did 9/11
GodRMK 2 years ago 2
fuck the us
i hope the yanks will burn in hell like they want 9 y/o girls to do
plep02 2 years ago
@ tudovis: You are pathetic to assume that this clip is rebuilt by VN Communists. At least wiki it first to see who recorded this clip.
May I also assume that you posted this clip only for your anti-communism purpose?
neptune192 2 years ago
The girl met up with the pilot years later, and she choose to forgive him because he didn't know what was happening and what would happen as a result of it.
averagebananas 2 years ago
thats the U$A, that is terrorism, that's why millions of people all over this planet loath and hate the US government and they always will
Guevaristas 2 years ago
Completely agree.
Ogasso 1 year ago
ดูแลน้ำตาไหลรอ้งไห้เลย
สงครามเกิดจากความขัดแย้ง ของคนแค่ ไม่กี่คน
ก็ทำให้ผู้คนล้มตายมากมาย
เมื่อไหร่มนุษย์จะอยู่ร่ามกันได้อย่างสันติสุขซะทีนะ
aodbu 2 years ago
Y'all dnt know nothing about viet nam war just shut up..
EDEBOYZ 2 years ago
it wasn´t the americans! a south-vietnamese pilot dropped the napalm bomb on mistake.
just telling the facts.
there are many reasons to hate the US-politics (not the americans!!!!! they just suffer from the gouvernment and the brainwashing done to them!) but this is not a reason to do so.
susititan 2 years ago
And Americans wonder why the world hate them!
powersoulboy 2 years ago
Es demasiado horrible...
DecemberMoon93 2 years ago
i think shes screaming "Too Hot,Too hot!"
i wish that the bastrd that caused that got what he desurved
zeldazackman 2 years ago
holy shit fucking my lai massacre
americans can be violent yo i wana throw up now
xdcmasterx 2 years ago
wasent the us'a troops turned out to be south vetminese, sorry my english is terrable
zeldazackman 2 years ago 2
USA has been always a crime state and terror state.
Kurdiyar 2 years ago
Nobody actually know how this war eventually started, only those earlier Goverment knows.. what i learn from my grandpa that if not US singapore will never gonna make it under the world most horrible criminal of war JAPAN ...my grandma die so as my relative... fuck those war starter... killing innocent ppl
MrSGH18 2 years ago
@MrSGH18
Actually there are reasons why the war was started. At the beginning, Vietnam was part of a french colony. America back then was under the pressure of the cold war and they didnt want the domino theory (spread of communism) to occur and the french were an important ally in USs fight against worldwide communism. It first started by giving aid to France. Little by little America became more involved and then Johnson started operation rolling thunder...
melogpie 2 years ago
This is horrible, I'm glad it was filmed though, people should learn from mistakes like these.
noodlez327 2 years ago
they were children, why ?
gangstazHT 2 years ago
what happens now in Irak or Palastine is not less brutal but the world learned to become silent when the vicitims are Arabs.
romadona11 2 years ago
not true . The majority of the world is against. But one nation in the security council always votes WITH the Israelis and that is USA
peace
RolandRhodes1 2 years ago
marshmellows anyone?
joeylodes 2 years ago
this shows how americans can really act. They sure can act barbaric if they want to. And they often do.
RolandRhodes1 2 years ago
war is war, always brutal
hawkz1293 2 years ago
I mean no disrespect by saying that a superpowers often act barbaric. They do. Britain, Germany, USA , China, Russia. They all do or did. But the people in general in those countries are friendly and nice in general.
RolandRhodes1 2 years ago
Actually, these bombs were dropped by the vietnamese. Still sad though.
graceloveseventing 2 years ago 2
yes sad. But somone sold them this weapons. Who could that be?
RolandRhodes1 2 years ago
The South Vietnamese who were supported by the US.
growingup2204 2 years ago
Yeah and we started the holocaust too. You fool- people of all nations have such capabilities. Let's remember that Cain, the first murderer, was also American. That's sarcasm in case yer too dull to figure it out. How about the war over the "Holy Land" in the middle east? How long's that been going on? Remember when America started that one? Of course not- 'cause it never happened- because this kind of $hit can happen anywhere by anyone. So besides being misinformed, why post such ignorance?
ziegegeist 2 years ago
In fact Americans with the Brits among other nations started the war by declare Israel as a independent country. What are Israel doing now? Its sad to say they are throwing palestinian people out of their own houses because they need space. How brutally disrespectful is that? Using bulldozers to trash their homes. We all know where Israel get their weapons. And we all know what country supports every move made by Israelis. Palestinian people are living in ghettos. That is ironic
RolandRhodes1 2 years ago
Since I was a young girl this pictures are burnt in my mind and in my soul. I´ll never forget! I always ask myself: why do peolple kill, kill innocent children, why????
Eilan1108 2 years ago
PEACE PLEASE
debaldiaan 2 years ago
You know how the took a picture of this? It was shown to Nixon and he denied the photo, saying that it was a fake. *sigh* American politcians. I hope Obama will do somehing right and earn a proper reputation for america.
xsweetredrosesx 2 years ago
That baby's skin was dangling from his toes!! shit!!
LayinThaSmackDownTV 2 years ago
america.... coming again to save the mother fucking day.. yeh... NO
fudge1monkey 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fucking EU ! Fucking Killers ! Faking Nixon, Bush and Obama !
morsa84 2 years ago
I'm sorry, but what do the EU, Bush and Obama have to do with this?
wasneeplus 2 years ago 2
EU is the Spanish and French abbreviation for US. Probably in other languages too. It can cause confusion.
lemonrind 2 years ago
Well, he'd do better to just use the English abbreviation. When I'm talking about the US I use those letters and not VS like it is in my language. This is an international forum after all.
wasneeplus 2 years ago
que yankis hijosde putas!!!!
restaurador32 2 years ago 2
yo digo no esos hijos de re mil puta en la otra vida tendran su merecido
ericass1981 2 years ago
I can say none of those motherfuckers are in heaven
chromechild88 2 years ago
si tienes toda la razon que bronca da esto
ericass1981 2 years ago
yea I hope you meen the pilots !
bigbadbrad0 2 years ago
Very sad. Increible... lo que la guerra puede hacer.
Vean mis videos.
mearte 2 years ago
i know why you cry
spacenacht 2 years ago 2
se lo merecían
lRubeNll 2 years ago
Comment removed
NacionalNacionalUY 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
¿vas a llorar? sólo es carne amarilla quemada
lRubeNll 2 years ago
que se puede esperar de un engendro,españolete gay como vos rubencita,jajajaja!!!!de tanto palo en el culo perdíste toda sencibilidad,seguro decis lo mísmo con la carne quemada que deja eta en tu paisucho,jajajajaja!!!
anali72s 2 years ago
ainss que sabras tu lo que es un gay sera que tienes uno cerca
ellagotriana 2 years ago
Hola Ruben la minina espera repuesta ....(l) (o)y(o)
ellagotriana 2 years ago
solo puedo decir mendigas guerras, y pinche gente k las provoca han de tener tanta mierda en la mente k solo piensan en ellos sin ver el daño inmenso k provocan, pongan se apensar si es k pueden k esos pekeños hubieran sido sus hijos.
pilligael 2 years ago 2
esses filhos da puta com essas gurras vão tomar no cú
123vinimaxo456 2 years ago
im speechless.
Fr3di1993 2 years ago
I cry every time I see this
LADYfreshhh13 2 years ago
Cái này mà bảo là giả thì đúng là đầu đất.
ditmecovang3que 2 years ago
horror
deforme999 2 years ago