...the guy had freakishly huge hands, and a technique to match, never mind all that, all you hear is the music...the interpretation, by "contemporary standards" is fairly eccentric, he does all kinds of strange little things all over the place, but none of it stands out...it is all so freaking convincing...he is on the side of the angels...or they on his...
This is my favorite recording of this piece. The brief moment of silence at 1:42 has always been my favorite use of space, like the musical version of the gap between the fingers on The Creation of Adam.
Lipatti was said to be dissatisfied with this recording and hoped to re-record it...unfortunately he passed away before his wish could be fulfilled. Despite how the pianist himself had felt...this is sheer perfection...a slice of heaven.
Comparing ddifferent interpretations of a work like this is supposed to be stupid by definition, but this here sounds so stupefyingly convincing, you want to say, after this, all those other people should not try to get near the piece, because all they can do is to make fools of themselves, right? His secret seems to be underplaying deliberately; he has a reserve of power and technique, and you sense it there hovering...
Perfection!!!...Lipatti gets everything just right...the rhythm, tempo (no, it's NOT too fast!)...sound, just the right amount of rubato...Lipatti makes it an authentic Venetian boat song, full of romance, longing, nostalgia..a masterful performance of one of Chopin's greatest works that all pianists can aspire to-- but never will-- equal or surpass
I couldn't agree with you more. Every time I listen to this I am out on that gondola with Lipatti, feeling the lapping of the currents in the lagoon and the glistening reflections of light on the water.
i played this piece as part of my finals recital for my BA degree in 1976. I'd never heard of Dinu Lipati in those days, and quite frankly it's probably just as well because if I'd heard his version of the Barcarolle I would never have had the nerve to play the piano in public at all let alone this late, autumnal Chopin masterpiece. He achieves such astonishing colours with such effortless elegant phrasing. I only wish he played this piece a little slower.
I've heard just about all the recordings of this magnificent piece, and only Lipatti is at the top of some very distinguished ones. This is music making and piano playing at its absolute greatest. Other good recordings are Horowitz's RCA recording, Rubinstein's 1957 recording, and Moiseiwitsch, but Lipatti's will always be unsurpassed overall. What a tragedy he died so young!
This is most definitely the best and Rubinstein isn't even in the same league. Rubinstein's playing has no poetry, it is all too square, to one-dimensional dynamically, and has no sense of the sea. After all, this magnificent music is not called Barcarolle for nothing! I have never understood the Rubinstein cult--his playing always leaves me cold.
When I was young, my father gave me a score book of this. But I couldn't solve out how to play, with Right-hand of 7 notes & Left-hand of 11 or 13 notes!?!?!?
un mare ,mare muzician roman ...sant ferm ca Henry Mancini stia de el ..!!! respecte Maestre
Gioagla 3 days ago
This is one of my favorite works by Chopin. This recording by Lipatti is quite special. Restrained, poetic, intensely personal yet pure Chopin.
lamazopa21 1 month ago
Dinu Lipatti , fiu al Mamei Divine !
inocentiu5 3 months ago
Snow drizzles outside
Gentle glow in the fireplace
Warmth of a woolen blanket
Lipatti on the iPod.
VVKY10 3 months ago
...the guy had freakishly huge hands, and a technique to match, never mind all that, all you hear is the music...the interpretation, by "contemporary standards" is fairly eccentric, he does all kinds of strange little things all over the place, but none of it stands out...it is all so freaking convincing...he is on the side of the angels...or they on his...
fredericfranc 4 months ago in playlist fredericfranc's Favorited Videos
This is my favorite recording of this piece. The brief moment of silence at 1:42 has always been my favorite use of space, like the musical version of the gap between the fingers on The Creation of Adam.
RenegadeMinister 5 months ago 2
Divin
ericmarseille2 6 months ago
so marvelouse playing MAGIC.....
moshiko7701 6 months ago
it's magic!!!!
thinkgreenlovepurple 7 months ago 2
it isn't music, it's life's essence
when I listen to it my heart beats in rithm
4cledefa 8 months ago
it isn't music, it's life's essence
4cledefa 8 months ago 3
Glad to see so many others agree that this is truly the definitive recording.
iscarfe 9 months ago
sounds nothing like Barcarolle.
nicolkidmanlover5201 9 months ago
Rubinstein's tone is always perfect but I prefer Dinu's playing because I feel like it can stop my brain and my heart.
jasquilaria 10 months ago 5
Amazing!
coolcallboy 1 year ago
Lipatti was said to be dissatisfied with this recording and hoped to re-record it...unfortunately he passed away before his wish could be fulfilled. Despite how the pianist himself had felt...this is sheer perfection...a slice of heaven.
dantitustimshu 1 year ago 5
Pure poetry. Lipatti is astoundng.
mycatsapunk 1 year ago
Who's the fucking guy who disliked this??
How can we disliking this??? It is the perfect Barcarolle!! Lipatti's sound, his simplicity makes him better than the others
petrof4056 1 year ago 4
Wonderful playing. I love it.
funklover24 1 year ago
Perfection!
PhillipLWilcher 1 year ago 2
Comparing ddifferent interpretations of a work like this is supposed to be stupid by definition, but this here sounds so stupefyingly convincing, you want to say, after this, all those other people should not try to get near the piece, because all they can do is to make fools of themselves, right? His secret seems to be underplaying deliberately; he has a reserve of power and technique, and you sense it there hovering...
fredericfranc 1 year ago 10
This is THE ONE! The definitive Chopin Barcarolle!
WayneYLeigh 1 year ago 8
Look at the size of those hands!
stockcar5472 1 year ago
unbelievable
callseba 1 year ago 2
for me one of the most beautiful versions of this piece, so poetic.
pianopianissima 1 year ago 3
Bellissimo...
danielbream 2 years ago 6
Clara Haskill a friend was an admirer...could you find a better recommendation...
goroundit123 2 years ago 3
i just noticed now the bell-like ringing quality of the piano especially in the treble towards the end. wow!
libetta 2 years ago 5
S'il avait vécu plus longtemps, sans doute Dinu serait-il devenu une référence absolue pianistique...(il en est déjà une quelque part)
Paulo78180 2 years ago 4
Great!!
emmy14931 2 years ago 5
For 20 years now this recording has had my vote as the most perfect piano recording ever made
geschwitz4 2 years ago 10
Lipatti shall live on in our hearts forever! Bravo!
paulostroff99 2 years ago 9
Perfection!!!...Lipatti gets everything just right...the rhythm, tempo (no, it's NOT too fast!)...sound, just the right amount of rubato...Lipatti makes it an authentic Venetian boat song, full of romance, longing, nostalgia..a masterful performance of one of Chopin's greatest works that all pianists can aspire to-- but never will-- equal or surpass
soami2u 2 years ago 15
I couldn't agree with you more. Every time I listen to this I am out on that gondola with Lipatti, feeling the lapping of the currents in the lagoon and the glistening reflections of light on the water.
ckrause5 2 years ago 9
*Sigh*
How I love classical music. <3
MusicFromTheStars 3 years ago 5
i played this piece as part of my finals recital for my BA degree in 1976. I'd never heard of Dinu Lipati in those days, and quite frankly it's probably just as well because if I'd heard his version of the Barcarolle I would never have had the nerve to play the piano in public at all let alone this late, autumnal Chopin masterpiece. He achieves such astonishing colours with such effortless elegant phrasing. I only wish he played this piece a little slower.
fatbaldcunt 3 years ago
Lipatti is at the heaven...in our hearth .. ever
ilovescarlatti 3 years ago 11
I adore Lipatti and Chopin. Here they come together in 8 minutes of great beauty.
gibbogle 3 years ago 24
I've heard just about all the recordings of this magnificent piece, and only Lipatti is at the top of some very distinguished ones. This is music making and piano playing at its absolute greatest. Other good recordings are Horowitz's RCA recording, Rubinstein's 1957 recording, and Moiseiwitsch, but Lipatti's will always be unsurpassed overall. What a tragedy he died so young!
billyguns2 3 years ago 9
le son Lipatti...quelle merveille!
lilycrumble 3 years ago 17
Thank you very much for posting this! Really sensational playing! P.S.The Barcarolle is composed in F sharp MAJOR:-)
olenushka77 3 years ago 11
Marvellous playing, marvellous piano sound, excellent recording quality, very clear. Thanks for sharing, this is superduper 5 stars.
musicdivinemusic 3 years ago 10
We love you, Dinu. We miss you... Why did you die so young?
K189T 3 years ago 5
This is definitely the best recording ever of this masterpiece! Only a few can match this performance, Rubinstein and Sofronotsky...
Thanks for posting this!
nico22059 3 years ago 11
This is most definitely the best and Rubinstein isn't even in the same league. Rubinstein's playing has no poetry, it is all too square, to one-dimensional dynamically, and has no sense of the sea. After all, this magnificent music is not called Barcarolle for nothing! I have never understood the Rubinstein cult--his playing always leaves me cold.
ckrause5 3 years ago 8
try also Cortot's version (a bit more aggresive but has the same essential qualities music-wise) and Horowitz
libetta 2 years ago 3
Sensational! Bravo! TY.
paulostroff99 3 years ago 5
「この曲が弾けるようにならないかな?」と父が楽譜をくれたのは、高校生の時だったかな。 どーして右手が7つの♪で左手が11の♪が一拍なのかが理解できず、、、
When I was young, my father gave me a score book of this. But I couldn't solve out how to play, with Right-hand of 7 notes & Left-hand of 11 or 13 notes!?!?!?
yoyoloveT 3 years ago 3