@Elkapan and according to my Music Professor (I'm a Music Minor in Violin Performance) he is also mocking Shostakovich hence the melody from this 7th symphony) Especially at 2:18, at that point my professor put his thumb to his nose and kinda wiggled his fingers. Can't you just picture Barkok doing that to Shostakovich?
The music is interesting and beautiful in its own way. To bad that the basstrombone glissande is not very often played unbroken like the tenor glissando.
I got introduced to bartoks' music by my uncle who was born in transylvania then came to the states in 1934 as a child and then orphaned at 9 years old then served in ww2 in the navy then spent 30 years as a merchant marine,I always respected his taste since he head seen the world;when I listen to bartok I think of him,may he and bartok R.I.P.
I had the same question, it was ok but i just babbled on for ages cos I couldn't think of much to say but I'm just glad the 5th movement didnt turn up, I would have cried if it did lol.
It went quite well. I don't know about you, but our question was on the introduction of the first movement.... so boring to write about as nothing freaking happens in it :P but I wrote everything I could think of :) How did you find it?
I love this bit of bartok, i think he wrote this in america to cater for the more tonal loving audience but it still has all the niceness of his other stuff, he also mimics a bit of shostokovic in the middle not too sure why...anyone?
The mimicking of Shostakovich came about when Bartok heard a performance of Shostakovich's Seventh Symphony on the radio whilst working on the Concerto for Orchestra. When he came across the famous, trite military motif, he deplored it and parodied it in the Intermezzo.
Personally, I think Shostakovich knew about the trite quality of the symphony, but when you analyse his situation, it was REQUIRED of him to compose in such a constrained matter.
Not sure which part you guys mean, but the theme starting at about 2:10 is clearly taken from an operetta by Franz Lehar and quite popular in Bartok's time in Hungary. Check it at
As 37 pessoas não sabem o que dizem ou nunca ouviram esta peça bem tocada. E ela merece ser bem tocada. Mas valeu o esforço. Saudações de Portugal para a Galiza!
Acho que não concordam com você 37 pessoas no mundo.
Mas se olharmos para os rostos dos espectadores acho que terei que concordar parcialmente com você ;) Opino que não está tão mal conduzida. Saudações da Galiza.
As a musician I can say that it's a very good sign that the orchestra managed to play this well despite the empty seats; it can be very demotivational to see a sea of empty chairs.
ps....amazing! :) studying this for my A levels at the moment and at first i hated it but now i've really grown to appreciate the amount of effort that was put into all 5 movements, cant get enough!
Very nice interpretation of this amazing movement from this amazing 'concerto'. Its played a little more quickly than what I am accustomed to, but no matter. Very nice!
Do you have the 'Game of Pairs' by chance?
The plethora of empty seats in the background saddens me.
I am studying this piece for A-level, its amazing. MVT always makes me smile, with the drunken interlude. The trombone glissandi symbolise vomiting. Its well palyed, but Im not fond of the conducting, his beats are very vague sometimes.
Hmm I disagree... I studied this piece for the first year of my music degree... Research I conducted told me the trombone glissandi symbolised the drunken gate crashers being turfed out onto the street while the partyers continued their waltz. However that section caused a great amount of scandal and questioning at the time of its release... It was thought it to be a jab at a fellow composer, I can't remember who though, but it's clear it still today is the cause for disagreement and discussion!
no one can these days, either there's no incentive (world full of zombified pop gimps who writhe on the floor in agony the moment a little sophistication enters their ears)
i find myself prefering shostakovich to most other composers, but am constantly drawn back to Bartok and the like. Wonder if the world will ever allow such genius to have a voice again?
i believe it would interest you to know that Bratok in fact hated shostakovich, and ridiculed him in this particular work by using a melody from shostakovich's seventh symphony in the interruption section as a rude Russian barging in on peaceful Hungary country life. Also bartok did not understand the popularity of shostakovich's seventh symphony and believed it to be banal and uninspired. Just thought u might like to know why you are drawn to bartok of shostakovich
This piece is mocking the listener- It invokes anger by a mocking violence by orchestra....
Elkapan 4 months ago
@Elkapan and according to my Music Professor (I'm a Music Minor in Violin Performance) he is also mocking Shostakovich hence the melody from this 7th symphony) Especially at 2:18, at that point my professor put his thumb to his nose and kinda wiggled his fingers. Can't you just picture Barkok doing that to Shostakovich?
DivaGlamFabxoxo 1 month ago
I love this piece! This is my first time hearing it. A very pleasant experience. Thanks for posting!
favoriteofGod 5 months ago
beautiful.
hihiim18now 10 months ago
This Bartok at his most 'normal' and 'conventional'. Still good though.
Bagas 1 year ago
The music is interesting and beautiful in its own way. To bad that the basstrombone glissande is not very often played unbroken like the tenor glissando.
svenlarsson 1 year ago
house looks packed
dmking122 1 year ago 14
Szép vagy, gyönyörű vagy Magyarország:) kihallani!!!
ricsetke 1 year ago
Greetings from Hungary! Good performance.
777Jubilee153 2 years ago
i think he could have given a bit more time lag between changes in the sections - everything was a bit too rushed
otherwise i like this performance
budjibird 2 years ago
Sounds beautiful. Never heard this one before (and I don't know why?) Why!?!?!?!?!?
CarlosIsDown 2 years ago 4
@CarlosIsDown is parody of theme invasion of 7th symphony's shostakovich :)
borninlust18 1 year ago
@CarlosIsDown thats odd its one of if not the most popular piece of his
mysecretscankill 8 months ago
I got introduced to bartoks' music by my uncle who was born in transylvania then came to the states in 1934 as a child and then orphaned at 9 years old then served in ww2 in the navy then spent 30 years as a merchant marine,I always respected his taste since he head seen the world;when I listen to bartok I think of him,may he and bartok R.I.P.
blitzspeer 2 years ago 13
I had the same question, it was ok but i just babbled on for ages cos I couldn't think of much to say but I'm just glad the 5th movement didnt turn up, I would have cried if it did lol.
cezcez23 2 years ago
Fabulosa interpretación. Me ha llegado al fondo del alma.
Greetings
ariastoteles 2 years ago
The perfformance was very good pitty I now hate Bartok after studying this piece for a full year.
cezcez23 2 years ago 2
Same boat as me mate lol
Muscl3Mus3um 2 years ago
Me three
Got the exam on friday, and I can't wait for it to be over :P
NikNammerz 2 years ago
I had the exam today 2, how did it go for you? Fair play after it I'm glad I never have to do Bartok again lol
cezcez23 2 years ago
It went quite well. I don't know about you, but our question was on the introduction of the first movement.... so boring to write about as nothing freaking happens in it :P but I wrote everything I could think of :) How did you find it?
NikNammerz 2 years ago
I love this bit of bartok, i think he wrote this in america to cater for the more tonal loving audience but it still has all the niceness of his other stuff, he also mimics a bit of shostokovic in the middle not too sure why...anyone?
d4j3b 2 years ago
The mimicking of Shostakovich came about when Bartok heard a performance of Shostakovich's Seventh Symphony on the radio whilst working on the Concerto for Orchestra. When he came across the famous, trite military motif, he deplored it and parodied it in the Intermezzo.
Personally, I think Shostakovich knew about the trite quality of the symphony, but when you analyse his situation, it was REQUIRED of him to compose in such a constrained matter.
Disclaimer: I like Shostakovich.
DannyDaWriter 2 years ago 2
Not sure which part you guys mean, but the theme starting at about 2:10 is clearly taken from an operetta by Franz Lehar and quite popular in Bartok's time in Hungary. Check it at
watch?v=mGgdL-9muIQ
the tune starts at 1:30
pseudobombast 2 years ago
Beautiful piece but I I think he rushes the 1st theme group. I love Dutoit's reading of this piece as well as Boulez's.
majin2912 2 years ago
Éljen Bartók és minden nagy Magyar.
balu65 2 years ago
1:14 would be the best leitmotif ever. I love bartok
violinmerchant 3 years ago
As 37 pessoas não sabem o que dizem ou nunca ouviram esta peça bem tocada. E ela merece ser bem tocada. Mas valeu o esforço. Saudações de Portugal para a Galiza!
anasousaana 3 years ago
olha como um maestro pode assassinar uma musica que pensava que era impossivel de estragar
anasousaana 3 years ago
Thank you.
darahbee 3 years ago
Que má é a menina!
Acho que não concordam com você 37 pessoas no mundo.
Mas se olharmos para os rostos dos espectadores acho que terei que concordar parcialmente com você ;) Opino que não está tão mal conduzida. Saudações da Galiza.
oleiros70 3 years ago
Could you please be more specific about what you don't like?
darahbee 3 years ago
@darahbee I would of just left "thank you." up there that way he thinks you are being sarcastic in understanding that language.
WTBBabyFactory 1 year ago
Seems like it would be a difficult piece to play/conduct. But it sounds so great! Love this piece.
laurenx46 3 years ago
This is one of my all time favorites.
manolotube666 3 years ago
it'sa little fast. but other than that fine
fagottist 3 years ago
why so many empty seats?
johnnythemusicguy 3 years ago 2
As a musician I can say that it's a very good sign that the orchestra managed to play this well despite the empty seats; it can be very demotivational to see a sea of empty chairs.
Well played.
apanapane 3 years ago
It actually looks relatively well-filled beyond the first few rows. That's quite odd, as normally the first rows are the first to sell...
AuthenticPunkDance 3 years ago
well, add me to the list!! ;)
mangosalado 3 years ago
Oh, my god, the conductor is really alike to Stanley Tucci!!! :D
It sounds like the soundtrack from a fairy tale movie, with enchanted princess, a witch, talking bunnies, (and arabian prince)!! :p
mangosalado 3 years ago 2
I see Stephen Colbert at first and then Stanley Tucci. :)
TimeSignatureManiaq 3 years ago
it's such a shame to see all those empty seats!!!
louloutally 3 years ago
u know u have a good ear is when u can play the timp part for this and nail it! either this guy had a good ear or 6 timp.
Dabombmh1990 3 years ago
i frakking love this movement of the concerto. my fav part is when the violas solo
jackfckntwist 3 years ago
ps....amazing! :) studying this for my A levels at the moment and at first i hated it but now i've really grown to appreciate the amount of effort that was put into all 5 movements, cant get enough!
markssetgo1 3 years ago
i love how at around 2.40 bartok has a dig at shostakovich's 7th symphony :) anyone have the other movements on here?
markssetgo1 3 years ago
This is one of my favorite pieces in all of classical music
paulrichardschuster 4 years ago
nice job! that's a real fun piece to conduct and i enjoyed watching you do it too :-)
paulmauffray 4 years ago
Thanks! Very nice. I'd love to see a performance of the whole work here. Every movement of the piece is great and contrasting to the one before.
Waggler 4 years ago
Very nice interpretation of this amazing movement from this amazing 'concerto'. Its played a little more quickly than what I am accustomed to, but no matter. Very nice!
Do you have the 'Game of Pairs' by chance?
The plethora of empty seats in the background saddens me.
RainMan34 4 years ago
Amazing! One of my alltime fav concertos.
By any chance does anyone have any videos of the other movements? Ive been DYING to see those!
cheers
andrewchen120 4 years ago
I am studying this piece for A-level, its amazing. MVT always makes me smile, with the drunken interlude. The trombone glissandi symbolise vomiting. Its well palyed, but Im not fond of the conducting, his beats are very vague sometimes.
Blouchenob 4 years ago
Hmm I disagree... I studied this piece for the first year of my music degree... Research I conducted told me the trombone glissandi symbolised the drunken gate crashers being turfed out onto the street while the partyers continued their waltz. However that section caused a great amount of scandal and questioning at the time of its release... It was thought it to be a jab at a fellow composer, I can't remember who though, but it's clear it still today is the cause for disagreement and discussion!
xoxCindersxox 4 years ago
Shostakovich's Seventh Symphony.
and both interpretations are acceptable.
IB music HAS taught me a lot, as it turns out.
leanne1912 4 years ago
This is one of my fav pieces. The first 2 movements in particular amaze me. I can't imagine writing anything like that.
Convisis 4 years ago
no one can these days, either there's no incentive (world full of zombified pop gimps who writhe on the floor in agony the moment a little sophistication enters their ears)
or there are no geniuses left in humanity.
zoltai9 4 years ago
mm agreed, definately a good piece, and well played. the shostakovich parody is clever. bartok was alright,man
soundandfury25 4 years ago
i find myself prefering shostakovich to most other composers, but am constantly drawn back to Bartok and the like. Wonder if the world will ever allow such genius to have a voice again?
zoltai9 4 years ago
dear zoltai9
i believe it would interest you to know that Bratok in fact hated shostakovich, and ridiculed him in this particular work by using a melody from shostakovich's seventh symphony in the interruption section as a rude Russian barging in on peaceful Hungary country life. Also bartok did not understand the popularity of shostakovich's seventh symphony and believed it to be banal and uninspired. Just thought u might like to know why you are drawn to bartok of shostakovich
penline101 3 years ago
Great job on a great piece!
CameronCrazie1998 4 years ago