Ryan Hart The Hardcore American idol

[elvenskwig]

Inhales are awful.

[moonharpz321]

screamo...

[GoMJB12]

He's wearing a My Chemical Romance hoodie that's blurred out!

[Trevb0t]

LOL he's not even doing the screams, he's inhaling. And Silverstein isn't hardcore OR metal. (nor is he good at all)

[jrpg0630]

Emo shit....

[MP40wnage]

i love silverstein

[Exiom96]

Hardcore?

metal?

This is hardcore: watch?v=99Oix0nLngc

[TheMango121]

......This is emo... Not hardcore, not metal.... Strait emo.

[Franktheman149]

This is why justin bieber, rebecca black, gaga, nicki minaj rule the world LOL People are so lame.

[2Emos1Razor]

"Too hardcore for you man" Lol wow....

[bloggieguy]

This guy is a faggot. He does not deserve to win american idol even though his voice is okay

[bloggieguy]

of course he goes to pop music. Their are two different types of deathcore: 1. The cool kind even sabbath and iron maiden fans can listen to. Like Trivium, Children of Bodom, Messhugah, etc. 2. The gay kind like Black Veil Brides, Asking Alexandria, Veil of Maya, etc.

[buckethead77]

@bloggieguy How can you even compare Black Veil Brides and AA to Veil of Maya? what a stupid comment haha

[OphidianWithin]

@bloggieguy Trivium Bodom and Meshuggah are not Deathcore, Veil of Maya is deathcore. Meshuggah and Children of Bodom are death metal, Veil of Maya is technical deathcore and BVB and AA are complete shit. Trivium isn't that good either. You sir are uneducated.

[buckethead77]

@OphidianWithin THANK YOU

[gangstermosh]

Ewwww.

[elite055]

lol he's inhaling. sounds like balls and his cleans suck too

[DuskfallBand]

he's good

[nikinanify]

-starts going of randomly- Gawd that chick is bitchy..

-then..-

YES! SILVERSTEIN! -starts listening and ears bleed-

Oh dear... god... my ears cannot unhear.. what they've just heard.. that song is now forever ruined...

[666Angel707]

i wanna grab those judges by the throat and watch their eyeballs burst as i choke the living fuck out of them.

[moneth1109]

@dannyA7Xheadbanger dumbass, It's called Vocal Fry, Check Black Veil Brides, They do that.

[092696800]

@moneth1109 dude.... you dont know a shit... that was inhale, and balck veil brides make inhale scream, if you wanna see some fry check ettiene sin, or bfmv stuff... 

[mrhoboslayer]

Lol 666 likes



[joanngelic]

AAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA­HAHAHAHHAHAHHAH!!!!! I love METAL music...x gemme wrong...but this sucks soooo hard!!

[redteam65]

why would you ever go on tv and inhale its like trying to masturbate with a cheese grater, nothing good can come out of it

[evzqz93]

i dont mean that this is metal but to all whi think it is and compare it with acdc, iron maiden and stuff, dont compare death metal black metal with old school please, just listen children of bodom, sonata artica, arch enemy, carcass, at the gates, strapping young lad they are kick ass

[floopsie666]

@evzqz93 yeah can't compare crap to music.

[SharlYDeath]

666 likes....meh



[StevieD917]

silverstein <3

[combatwarfare2]

It so funny how they react to him. Did he seriously think they'd like him?

[deathc0rR3]

1:41

the black dude did a growl.

and it sounds good right? hehe

[ipunchrock]

0:45

[MrMcJunkinator]

Inhale screams really sound terrible...but honestly if you check out his band, he's really not half bad. Perhaps if he chose a song...without screams, he may have made it further.

[TheZachman1995]

LMFAO!!! i love metal and all but damn that sucked.

[7senile]

FUCK MAN... INHALES ARE HORRIBLE... that guy needs to learn to exhale its better for him

[TheZeery]

AMERICANS !!! < NORWEGIANS !!!!

[MacacoPulando]

His harsh vocals sound like shit! What a pussy.

[CUFF3R]

Coming from a hardcore and metal fan, he was total shit.

[ghostriderrecone]

he scared the shit outta paula XD

[Anarkrest13]

they dont know good music

[Raid3r45]

Best guy i've ever seen on american idol

[Adamclayton5]

He got good though... /watch?v=1dmuXbp7cvk&list=FL7p­7jFdC_0vr7zkd5BveapQ&index=1&f­eature=plpp_video

[jdjdjdjd3330]

inhale screams are annoying but his singing was good

[Halfadomino]

hes good but its not an idol thing

[Adam27X]

I love the song but this guy really ruined it, if he stuck to the cleans at least he would have been taken seriously. He should have done Red Light Pledge.

[Spectrrrrrre]

It's really unique, he has that nasel-whiny voice that bands in the pop punk genre share. Should have just kept with the "screaming"

[SnowMonster44]

smash apart what you creatEDDDD

[ImmanPoblete]

"You know who I am?? Constantine...John Constantine....

[olanlat]

FUCK THEM METAL IS AWESOME

[2Emos1Razor]

@olanlat lol this shit isn't metal.

[olanlat]

@2Emos1Razor yeah i know it's screamo :)

[chouchoue9]

omg this sucks sooooooo bad ahahahahaa

[mcradloff]

he's actually good, just not for this

[musicrockandemo]

i didnt think he waz dat bad....he did the song i think pritty ok..

[GanjikaAranyaka]

@musicrockandemo ..shut the hell up...i hate you..i was trolled in the comment section of a different youtube video so now im taking my angst out on YOU....because youre the chosen

[musicrockandemo]

@GanjikaAranyaka

ok have fun then.....?

[mosesredsea]

fuck all the judges because they dont know metal music they only want k pop music & RnB for me its really offends me because all auditions in tv dont like metal music at all so bias

[2Emos1Razor]

@mosesredsea I think the fault is more on the guy than the judges. The guy's singing and screaming were fucking terrible. And why the fuck would you want to commercialize metal more than it already is? Putting it on American Idol? Get fucking real.

[rspots]

wow really...? so... a faggot inhale screams and then attempts to actually sing...?

[SCREAMbbySCREAM]

thank you for ruining a perfect song :)

[RedDoT3G]

inhale screams are gay lol

[Humanoid007Vonzz]

That guy screams sooo weakly xD

[ChARgERS2128]

HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA wow that is horrible

[bob13221]

WAAAB WAAAAB!!!!!!!!!!!!

[morbidangel1962]

this guy should be shot in the face

[scream9803]

woowww neta k lo canta super bin el screamo pinches jueces ignorantes k se burlan no saben ni que onda y se burlan

[legodarknight101]

Jesus I hate that kind of Metal, give me Priest, Maiden, Saxon and Sabbath any day.

[peanutbutterisfu]

@legodarknight101 fuckin typical 80's metal queers commenting,you guys are so gay its not even funny,you listen to 5 metal bands from the 70-80s and cant give into nothing else.its just pathetic yet funny at the same time.there are some sick bands out now theres no need to listen to slayer every single day.and these newer singers can really sing unlike the 80's,so take the leather jacket off,turn the radio station once in a while its 2011 get with the fucking times

[legodarknight101]

@peanutbutterisfu Sorry mate but i like to listen to something with a tune rather than mindless noise.

[2Emos1Razor]

@peanutbutterisfu Why would someone get with the times when all the music produced nowadays is just mindless, soulless garbage with absolutely no value attached to it whatsoever. Musicians nowadays care more about the dollar than they do about the actual music.

[peanutbutterisfu]

@2Emos1Razor u couldnt be more wrong.if you were ever in a band then you would know its not about the money,most bands are dead broke for a long time,its not 1980 when every band could get signed,now you have to do alot of work to get out there.they just dont sign every one any more.theres alot of newere music thats awesome,the 90's were awesome too.

[2Emos1Razor]

@peanutbutterisfu Any band in any day and age can get signed. It's not hard. Most bands start their own labels just to distribute their material, and some release their music free of charge online.

[peanutbutterisfu]

@2Emos1Razor its not like it was,and you pretty much have to give your music out free now,not many people buy music any more and thats the reason the music business is changing.i know what your saying but there isnt alot of one hit wonders like there was before.company's dont take chances like they did.

[tha3immortals]

@legodarknight101 too bad silverstein isnt metal dude

[rockandmetalfan101]

@legodarknight101 or AC/DC, george thorgood, twisted sister, metallica and srry that my generation ruined music and P.S. im 14 so i'm talking about today's music that is crap

[legodarknight101]

@rockandmetalfan101 Good man! I'm a 15 year old who liks 60's, 70's and 80's rock/metal. Up hold the good stuff.

[MegaKobe123456789]

what the fffffff

[muggle5972]

silversteins smashed into pieces just got like a million more views

[pentumplementgum]

I don't really care about how difficult and how much skill it takes to do that, screaming sucks as well as the clean singing he did, It just sounds real fuckin' gay. Do something truly metal and snarl out some fuckin' Slayer!

[peanutbutterisfu]

@pentumplementgum slayer would be a better band if there was no vocals at all

[Nillereh]

Lol he's screaming in morse code at 1:44

[mrabdrum]

@Nillereh LOL!

[dannyA7Xheadbanger]

I FUCKING HATE INHALE SCREAMERS! fuck its not even screaming just random ass noises...

[MasterYoda59]

@dannyA7Xheadbanger lmfao, what the fuck is exhaling screaming then? you cant understand any of that shit unless you actually know the lyrics, if you sit down and listen to a screamo song you've never heard before you wouldnt know what the fuck they are saying

[mariokilledpikachu]

@dannyA7Xheadbanger People think its heavy but its one of the easiest forms of vocals out there! Hes got a good solid understanding of the concept though! I mean my god it sounds like a pterodactyl for gods sake!

[DyingDeath7]

@dannyA7Xheadbanger check out his band damnear divine

[tenaciousd1888]

Randys better at screaming than this inhaler.

[jasonvoorheesfan606]

i think thats awesome haha

[sbr666]

Inhaling SUCKS!

[ArchEnemyIsN01]

how bout all you haters shut the fuck up cuz i would love to see you even get close to bein able to do that its a lot fucking harder than it sounds and if you cant deal with that then dont comment on it because really you dont see near as many people that can do that raging about your shity music tastes so

[2Emos1Razor]

@ArchEnemyIsN01 yes, inhaling is the most complicated shit ever. please enlighten us.....

[ArchEnemyIsN01]

@2Emos1Razor i would say something but i commented so long ago i cant remember what i said lol

[ArchEnemyIsN01]

@2Emos1Razor i may not like inhaling either but give him some props at least he tried lol

[Hawandy456]

I love Damnear Divine :)

[narasemanga]

these people deserve to die... just simply be gone from the face of the earth.... its fucking annoying... 

[blakan3]

@narasemanga You arent respecting other peoples opinions and tastes.

Weak, pathetic, sad, little and ignorant. And idiotic aswell.

The only trash i see in this youtube page, is you and your comment. Youre pathetic.

This guy went to the wrong show. It was good tho.

[monsterviolence]

Inhale/scream, Inhale/scream...

[BlackWolf5796]

fuck you simon.

[MegaTrolleater]

is he trying to growl.. this is fucking lame.

[phillyshell94]

he sounds like a teradactel

[phillyshell94]

simon cowell: "thank you that was catchy" lol

[BreakingBoston]

this was a terrible audition, but his band is soooo good

[Thilinus]

Great song, but that wasn't very good...

[kaycern]

damn this guy sucks at screaming

[GreendayversusU2]

Inhlaes sound freaking AWFUL.....

[theDonutmonkey]

inhaling idiot, im 14 and can growl, scream, pigsqeal, and im doing it exhaling :P HOW FUCKING HARD CAN IT BE?

[420Punkie]

Randy should start a band now. Did you hear those screams at the end?

[iaminsane2140]

i like inhaling screams but that song is exhale

[DeadlyTechProduction]

DAMMIT HE PUT MY NAME TO SHAME MY NAMES RYAN HART

[Michaelkw28]

serious fail

[moonlightXscenester]

its called screamo randy.

[decktassel]

ew inhales.

[TylerrMusiic]

He should have won

[surfingdp]

@TylerrMusiic wow bad taste of music

[BerriesMcGOO]

so did he join a band?

[PandaBear415]

I hated that. It was awful.

[silentlightpro]

They will all look stupid one day when this style becomes original.

[kwuarmelite]

i know he's an inhaling dipshit, but im pretty sure they wouldnt give corpsegrinder/phil bozeman, or any real growlers a chance, so fuck them

[titanium53]

He's retarded.

[manover18]

Ryan Hart you fag!

[T4rDKnoT666fun]

sorry, but silverstein is not "hardcore", maybe you're looking for the word "screamo".

[ImNotaWhiteGuy]

@T4rDKnoT666fun They're not screamo, you dick. They're Post-hardcore.

[T4rDKnoT666fun]

@ImNotaWhiteGuy, Call them "hardcore" all you like, I've listened to Silverstein and these guys are fags, an embarrassment to punk rock to be truthful, trust me these guys aren't hardcore. I've been to a lot of hardcore punk shows, ok I guess you can call it "post-hardcore", but it brings shame to hardcore fans across the globe.

[ImNotaWhiteGuy]

@T4rDKnoT666fun They're one of the best bands ever. Suck it, bisssssshhh!!

[Hardcore158]

@T4rDKnoT666fun Post-hardcore = another name for screamo bands. don't ask me why, but just sayin. of course it doesnt sound anything like hardcore though.

[Deathrisingdawn]

@Hardcore158 Post hardcore has nothing to do with screamo. Screamo bands hardly even exist anymore, it was popular in the 90s.

[Hardcore158]

@Deathrisingdawn haha alright man, give some examples of screamo bands then, and ill give you a list that claim they're post-hardcore, but really is pretty similar.

[Deathrisingdawn]

@Hardcore158 Love lost but not forgotten. 

[strippingcthulhu]

Ryan hart was too hardcore for 73 people

[jabestin]

He speaks like Fred. And sings like a fucking bitch. Like literally, a female dog... maybe being run over by a car.

[jabestin]

He speaks like Fred.

[Burningtubes]

Silverstein is awsome, this guy sucks

[gundamOPS]

This guy's singing is way better now!

[MrSethklok]

Sounds like a hunter

[matangaash]

the fuck? why is he inhaling? what is he a fucking hooker? 

[MrMeineNamen]

thats not any kind of metal. not death metal not black metal not viking metal not deathcore and ESPECIALLY not HEAVY Metal (as he claims later)

[squidlvrfansofall]

1:45 <3 :D



[WeBeStoZ]

I Love the song to be honest.... he sucks though lol!

[luigiluvspasta93]

lol!!!! simon fails at screaming at 1:42!!!!

[CephalicZyklon]

wow what a fag

[stormiheibeltv]

Thank god he wasn't put through; he's a horrible screamer.

[darkheat246]

@stormiheibeltv thats great

[osoevil94]

so this guy isnt even screaming right. there is a certain technique to it that most ppl cannot do and if you tried too long without knowing how youd blow your vocal chords real quick.

[MoonOvIce]

Besides...Hardcore? hardcore is Madball, Hatebreed etc. not this emo garbage!

[MoonOvIce]

That is disgusting to say the least, he's disgustingly gay, those stupid scene kid's screaming sucks major ass and most of them won't be able to do that crap in like 10 years unlike Death Metal, Black Metal vocalists or vocalists from other extreme non-emo forms of music who actually integrate SKILL into this kind of "singing".

[ArchEnemyIsN01]

@MoonOvIce <3 Death metal!

[Stryker37573]

thats not punk??

[charabdys]

dude like... i love hardcore... but... i turned red just watching this. even im embarrassed

[iceagecomet]

LMAOOO! hahahahahaha. he did the melodic part pretty good. the screaming blew.

[jacobtvpuckett]

haaaaahahaha

[hailsau007]

lol............

doesnot even know the name of the judges...

[hailsau007]

lol............



[JonathanChunPrevenge]

inhaling, shitty singing

[cRaZyBOI171]

inhaling dipshit

[tsm1th611]

@cRaZyBOI171 even if he did exhales and nailed the best screams in the world the judges would have still made fun of him and not let him through. cuz they are a bunch of close minded idiots who think screaming and hardcore is a joke.

[AntichristDemoncore]

@cRaZyBOI171 the only people who can exhale and go that high are tight pants wearin emo fags such as yourself

[cRaZyBOI171]

@AntichristDemoncore TROLOLOL everybody who exhales or doesn't scream (myself included) think that inhaling is for faggots and they always will because

1. it sounds like shit

2. anybody can do it

3. it fucks up your lungs

PEACE

[AntichristDemoncore]

@cRaZyBOI171 1. you're a faggot

2. you're a faggot

3. you're a faggot

PEACE

[grandtheftauto5588]

as hardcore as a pillow!

[RenegadeShorts]

this guy should work on left 4 dead

[IBeHotpocketin]

@RenegadeShorts haha yea! he could be a hunter or smoker!!

[TryYourEyes]

lollllllllllllllllllllllllll



[MorfGworfmim]

oh, god... it's so embarrassing to watch old people make fun of music with screaming.

[EmoElectricRainboww]

he's good.

[kennyquick3]

now if simon would've heard shane told, there'd be a different story.

[DarkprinX2500]

He is such a fag..

[MrTheguywithalife]

this is true music!!! this is what american idol should be about!!! everyone, look up this song online=)

[StarfishPrimeADO]

Robert Pattinson should stick to making movies...

[73HNiNJ4]

inward screaming and flat singing. what a douche bag

[farerse]

"im not a family guy" nice comeback:P

[zjbeast]

@jakeisagamer Ever heard of the band Cannibal Corpse?

[tyleritzkowitz97]

omfgg this is horribleeeeeee.....i cant believe he thinks hes good???

[kilborn666]

I hope he fucks up his voice for even thinking about doing inhales...

[GuitarsandGummybears]

love the song!!

[zjbeast]

I sing metal and this guy sucks..

[MasonLovesBoobies]

His screaming really doesn't suck... it sounds like Shane's. Smashed into pieces was made when screaming was relatively new, so the technique wasn't perfected yet. Back then, inhales were fine. Of course screaming's gotten better now haha.