Comparision MAC Eye Shadows-All That Glitters vs Honesty

[MercedesGames]

Thanks for this!~...what to u think of DazzleLight ?...

I want 2 new ones..so i thought i would go with ATG...and another one...

I was originally wanting a dark brown..but a cool brown..no orange in it whatsoever...Any ideas....there are so many to pick from..and not all have the greatest payoff..:(

[Lisasz09]

@MercedesGames I like dazlelight but it does have a lot of glitter in it. Expresso is a great cool dark brown!

[hannrkelley]

The voice makes me cringe!!

[lalala36710]

@hannrkelley you don't have to watch the video. If you don't have anything nice to say then don't say it at all.

[KaitlynElaine1]

Thanks for doing this! i found all that glitters at a garage sale & it was 10 cents i've never bought MAC Products but now i love it

[meglovesmakeup]

I wish i watched this before i went to mac today.. i was picking a eyeshadow- honesty and allthatglitters- i picked honesty! im so gutted! x

[TheISABEL100]

what colours would you suggest that would be nice with all that glitters? i have blue eyes if it helps! thanks

[Lisasz09]

@TheISABEL100 mulch is great, bronze, folie, and embark are all great!

[Miahhmazing]

this was helpful... but I wish I saw this before I bought Honesty today!

[Karnvir16]

how do you store your mac eyesshadows

[Lisasz09]

@Karnvir16 I use the palettes you can buy from mac

[Karnvir16]

@Karnvir16 ok , thank you for replying :)

[amandalovebaby]

This was down right helpful. Much thanks!

[kgxsandra]

i love that your videos are right to the point and helpful! :)

[sassyclassyladybug]

thanx 4 the help!!!

[gagaaumour]

all that glitter was my first mac shadow and i <3 it i wore it to day

[JadeLoves2Shop]

Thank so much.. I went out and bought All That Glitters

[lagrifa72]

great tutorial, and thanx for posting what your wearing alredy , thats very helpfull for us that like your makeup and want to get it !

[sweetbutcraZ]

i have honesty (lustre??) and it doesnt seem to really show up idk..

[kimchichick]

how similar are ALL THAT GLITTERS and NAKED LUNCH? i saw the swatches of them both, but they looked really similar, ATG being just a tad more pink. which one would you choose over the other and why?

[Lisasz09]

@kimchichick all that glitters is much more pink and pigmented (better for a lid color not a highlight) than naked lunch-which is more of a highlight color!

[kimchichick]

@Lisasz09

is Naked Lunch more gold than All That Glitters?

[Lisasz09]

@kimchichick all that glitters is much darker than naked lunch- NL is a highlight and ATG is a lid or cease color

[kimchichick]

@Lisasz09

thanks!!! :)

[ILoveDinosaurs12]

Idk which one to choose it be my first mac eyeshadow. i dont wnt to buy both, so Help! thnx

[Lisasz09]

@ILoveDinosaurs12 all that glitters is awesome!  :o)

[tumamasoyyo]

HI COULD U COMPARE ANTIQUE AND SATIN TAUPE PLEASE? BECAUSE TO ME THEY LOOK THE SAME

thank you!!!!

[Lisasz09]

@tumamasoyyo I will add it to my list0 I will probably compare it on my blog though!

[Steph4nie6822]

do u think honesty and naked lunch look very similar? :/

[Lisasz09]

@Steph4nie6822 no naked lunch looks more like grain or naked pigment!

[sssalsera]

I just boutht All that glitters... thanks!

[michibabe10]

all the MAC lustre shadows have fall out and not enough color pay off. I went with All That Glitters :-) Thanks Lisa!!

[xoxojess94]

Can you do a comparison between woodwinked and tempting? They look pretty similar to me. I already have woodwinked, but i want to know if it's worth it to get tempting as well.

[Lisasz09]

I have added this to my list to compare! :o)

[xoxojess94]

Thank you!

[MartaakaMartini]

would you recommend all that glitters all over lid?

[Lisasz09]

yes it is beautiful!

[aex3princess]

I totally love neutral looks and I'm ready to start adding some shimmer again (I used to use just shimmer and got so sick of it) and I totally want All That Glitters.

[ImaginaryWhisper]

I have both as well and if I had known they were so similar I would not have picked up Honesty. I LOVE All That Glitters.

[delici0saa]

Thanks!!

[Kagicali]

You're so funny Lisa!!!!!!!!

[niceguy045]

your so prettty.

[glitt3r707]

hello, can i have a review on loreal hip lipgloss ? xoxo hope

[Lisasz09]

I have loreal HI{P Jelly balms, but I dont own any lipglosses from them! Sorry!

[ilve2sing]

whats the difference between the skin finishes and the studio fix?

[Lisasz09]

I guess you mean the Mineralized Skinfinish Natural (MSF) and studio fix powder- The MSF is a more natural finish and is made from minerals, where studio fix is a more matte powder that is not made from minerals- the fix powder controls oils more than the MSF- I hope this answers your question!

[syuhadah]

i dropped allthatglitters and mine shattered into pieces ;(

[CoralistaGirl]

i couldn't live without all that glitters. i wear it more than any other color... it is a staple in my collection

[bonitacherry2]

ur skin looks really dark in this vid! is it the lighting that makes u look so dark? or tan? cuz i know ur skin is very light.

[Lisasz09]

well it is both it was taped in the summer when I use self tanner and the lighting makes everything pinkish! :o)

[bonitacherry2]

oh i see! ur still gorgeous regardless :)

[SaraRosexoxo1]

Hey lisa!

could you do a review on clinques dramatically different lotion

[Lisasz09]

I used this when I was in my 20's and unfortunetly it does not work for me, so I wont be repurchasing-sorry!

[xomaggiecheungox]

would you please.. please please do a review on comparision on between well dressed, dolly mix and pink swoon? Im having the biggest hardest time to choose one. I am asian, and I think im between NC 20-25. Pleasee?

[Lisasz09]

I think I have those ones on my list to review and I will try to compare them also!

[bubblegum404]

LOVE IT!!! can you compare all that glitters and woodwinked? thanks :]

[Lisasz09]

woodwinked is much more brown, it really is a different color. :o)

[bubblegum404]

thanks! so i could use woodwinked as more of a crease and all that glitters on the lid?

[Lisasz09]

yes you can do that or you can use woodwinked on the lid and a darker color on the crease! :o)

[trendsetters54]

Honesty kida sucks. I went threw it in like a month. YOU have to pack on so much to see anything. I love all that glitters. Its so pretty with any colour. I like it with soft brown on a all natural day.

[giltgold]

lustres suck. the only lustre that is decent is tempting... it's the only mac shadow i've hit pan on actually.

[beachgirl7611]

Thank you so much for the review! I saw All That Glitters at the MAC counter yesterday and thought it was so pretty. I ended up getting Jest instead. Honesty was on my list of eye shadows to try, but I think I'll pass. If you have Jest, could you compare that to All That Glitters? Thank you so much for your reviews!

[Lisasz09]

jest and all that glitters are totally different- ZI cant really compare them.

[beachgirl7611]

Thanks for the information about Jest vs. All That Glitters. I will have to look at them again side by side next time I am at the MAC counter. Have a great day!

[foxycleox]

love both of those shadows ,loving your lip colour

[vanillaprincess22]

great vid!!! thanks!!:)

[sonjiya]

i liked this video a lot, lisa :)

it's amazing that your honesty has hit pan! could you possibly suggest how to pair it? :)

[Lisasz09]

I pair it with cranberry, smut or folie and it looks great! :o)

[hanak124]

i also noticed that naked lunch by mac is very similar to all that glitters

[meowmixpurina]

there nothing alike F

[cicekly]

Hi Lisa, i have a request for you...can you tell me if mixing Style & Well dress blushes (from Mac) have the "same" result of Coralista (Benefit). Thank you. :)

[feltflower1]

For me, pardisco eye shadow is exactly the same colour as coralista! Just my opinion!

[sonjiya]

i agree! i'm glad to have seen a yt guru use paradisco like that, now it's my fave! and at a third of the price haha

[cicekly]

Thank you!!! :)

[faintsunrise]

I hope you don't mind me answering, but yes style and well dressed will look very similar!

another tip if you are looking for one like fun&games from the hello kitty collection, mixing style and peaches by mac is going to look EXACTLY the same :)

good luck!

[cicekly]

Thank you for the tips!!! I wanted to be sure before buying them. I´ll check the Peaches & Style combination as well. :)

[pinklumpysugar23]

ATG is one of my favorite eyeshadows from MAC, it's very versatile and you can wear it alone or with so many dif. colors and still looks beautiful. It's def. one to get! Thanks so much for your review Lisa! <3

[ilve2sing]

i love all that glitters i dont have honesty

but i like to wear atg with sketch the crease.

[MissCeCe112101]

you look so pretty like this! i love your hair up like that!

[projectbeautysmartie]

courdory and kid look really nice with honesty. great video!

[mqs7524]

Great comparison!

Lisa, I have a question about Origins multigrain.

I got it (in light).

Tried it out today & it is sheer as in no coverage what so ever.

I used a MAC buki with it.

What am I doing wrong?

Tnx

[missyl044]

@mqs7524 try layering it on If you have a flat top buffer brush tey using that to apply it, the denser the brush the more coverage it will give. I hope this helps you =)

[mqs7524]

Thank you.:-)

[VlogChic]

Thanks for the review!

[Policosmetics82]

great reveiw thaknk you1 I really like how this allthatglitters shows on this swatch you made - I'll have to check tath out!:)

Poli

[Frog255]

Nice vid. Thanks Lisa.

[Zoeebella]

Fantastic review!

I think I have Honesty. Sounds like I would like them both for different reasons:o) *hugs*

[Heatherettex3ily]

I was thinking about buying all that glitters. now i will!

[K8KatieK8K8]

I'm not an avid collector but I love Honesty and reach for it more often than All That Glitters.

All That Glitters has a golden pink sheen on me & I'm not a huge fan of pink on my eyes.

Honesty is a sheer but deep peach with tiny gold flecks with almost a silvery undertone to it. I agree the texture of Honesty is not the same as ATG.

Honesty all over the lid with Sable in the outer V is stunning - natural looking with a kick!

Great comparision video!

[sonjiya]

thanks for that mini-review on honesty, it's collecting dust in my palette but u've inspired me to use it! thanks :)

[K8KatieK8K8]

Thanks sonjiya - how sweet. I hope you find a new love for honesty - I think it's an overlooked color - since it's not as flashy as MAC's most talked about shadows & it's a lustre formula which most people loathe.

I'm a fan of neutrals - so finding variations in neutrals is fun for me (I'm also super fair - so ANY variation in color is obvious to me) .... and sometimes I prefer to mix in sheer washes color rather than having all of my shadows be as pigmented as humanly possible :)

[xmakeuprocksx]

awesome,

i was thinking of buying an eyeshadow from mac.

i dont have any yet!

all that glitters sounds awesome <3.

looks fab too

this was helpfull, xo

[susanloveshuskies]

Thank you. Lisa. I don't have either of these eyeshadows so this was very helpful. ~Susan

[KatieAndradee]

i love allthatglitters. i wear it on my lid all the time. its beautiful and super great for an everyday look :)

[gymnast725]

i wear al that glitters to school almost everyday!! i love it!!!

[paula42396]

awesome!

Thanks Lisa :)

[fcukyouuuuus]

Thanks for the comparison! :)

[FUNKYMACGIRL]

i use all that glitters for a natural look..its really pretty!!!!