Thinkingmuslims no the ottomans ruled by hanafi fiqh, so did the mamluks, so did the Abbasids , and so did the mughals. Did Allah make the largest and longest empires of the Muslim ummah be run using the fiqh of misguidance nay these were the greatest Muslim empires and Allah would not misguide the entire Muslims for 1200 yers
Thinkingmuslims no the ottomans ruled by hanafi fiqh, so did the mamluks, so did the Abbasids , and so did the mughals. Did Allah make the largest and longest empires of the Muslim ummah be run using the fiqh of misguidance nay these were the greatest Muslim empires and Allah would not misguide the entire Muslims for 1200 yers
It is just wrong to say that "No we must always do taqleed even if we become strong in knowledge and the daleel of our imam seems weaker than others." And one of the main reason Abu Hanifa's madhab is most popular is because it was the state religion of the Ottomans, hence, they put emphasis on hanafi imams, schools, teachers, etc. So, I'd say this is circumstantial. Allah Knows Best.
@Darulislam1 "If you look for good in someone you will find it, if you look for bad you will find bad". Shaykh is referring to "great" in terms of following, which is simply undeniable, even today. If you are unsure about something, that should be stated, you have stated a catergorical statement which is simpy an unwise thing to do. Please rectify this for future notice.
Moulana sahab, kabhi to daleel ke saath baath kariye... whether he be jaahil or aalim. due to this act, we are loosing people and they are diverting towards salafi.
Peace blessings and mercy of Almighty Allah be upon our beloved Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and His beloved Sahabah Radi Allah Anhu (The best people on the face of this Earth) and those who are with them.
Oh Muslim help each other in good things and don't help in bad things. There is a Pakistani man Tauseef Ur Rehman (Shia) he claimed that he become Salfi now. He recording his video everyday from Saudi Arab and criticizing Ulmah specially those who are dead. what is solution please help?
Imagine a person who CANNOT even recite the Quraan NOR perform Salaat OR Wudhu correctly demanding dalaail for the validity of Taqleed. THE IGNORANCE & DEVIATION OF SUCH PERSONS ARE CONSPICUOUS FOR THOSE WHO POSSESS SOME UNDERSTANDING OF THE SHARIAH.
Nowadays, in view of the spread of FREE-LANCING in the Deen,i.e. abandoning the Math-habs of the Sunnah, we find IGNORANT people seeking dalaail (proofs) for the masaa-il of the Shariah. MOST of those seeking proofs LACK knowledge of even the masaa-il of Tahaarat & Salaat. Inspite of such ignorance, they demand daleel for ANY law of the Shariah which does not find approval with their whims, fancies and nafsaani opinion.
Everyone is a muqallid. Everyone refers to scholarship to learn their deen. The only difference, of recent, is a new group has done their own ijtihad, with minimal reference to the scholars of fiqh. Hence, their seeming proximity to the primary texts gives the illusion that their way is somehow better or purer than the four Sunni Madhabs. This illusion is broken, in part, when knows that to access the primary texts requires one to be a mujtahid himself, which no modern scholar can claim.
I have a question maybe you can ask one of your teachers for me.
I am not a student of knowledge, but I followed the basic hanafi fiqh most of my life for 23 yrs. while living in Lahore, until I moved to Ontario where there was a small Muslim community who followed the Malaki fiqh. I was told that I must change my madhab, but I couldn't get used to their fiqh regarding salat and other things, nor did I want to relearn the basics so now I follow Salafi dawah.
@ankroo Yes u should repent & return back to your Madh-hab where your Imaan is safe. The teachers of the Imaams of the Madh-habs were none other than the Sahaabah and the Greatest Tabieen this world has ever seen meanwhile the teachers of the BRAND NEW Salafi sect are who and HOW far back do their teachings go. The Alhe Sunnah Wal Jamaah been considered the 4 Madh-habs for OVER 1300 years of Islam, therefore it's TRADITIONAL Islam. ORIGINAL Islam is your ONLY Salvation
@AfwaunMuMeen Perhaps you could also bring the evidence from the qu'ran and the sunnah that proves your saying of not having a madh-hab is a sin. As said before we only blindly follow the prophet (peace be upon him), as for the four imams we love them and it is allowed to follow their madh-hab however to blindly follow them is against their own teaching, if the saying of an imam is against the qu'ran or the sunnah who do we follow, do we give precedence to the imam or the qu'ran?
@evilheem Nowadays, in view of the spread of FREE-LANCING in the Deen,i.e. abandoning the Math-habs of the Sunnah, we find IGNORANT people seeking dalaail (proofs) for the masaa-il of the Shariah. MOST of those seeking proofs LACK knowledge of even the masaa-il of Tahaarat & Salaat. Inspite of such ignorance, they demand daleel for ANY law of the Shariah which does not find approval with their whims, fancies and nafsaani opinion.
@evilheem Imagine a person who CANNOT even recite the Quraan NOR perform Salaat OR Wudhu correctly demanding dalaail for the validity of Taqleed. THE IGNORANCE & DEVIATION OF SUCH PERSONS ARE CONSPICUOUS FOR THOSE WHO POSSESS SOME UNDERSTANDING OF THE SHARIAH.------> **"WHEN YOUR SHEIKH COMES I'LL GIVE PROOF, WHEN AN IGNORANT 1 LIKE U COMES I'LL GIVE EXAMPLES. SCHOLARS ARE GIVEN PROOFS & NON-SCHOLARS ARE GIVEN EXAMPLES"** Once again, I will NO longer give "U" a comment.--->
@AfwaunMuMeen I have no desire to debate rather I wish to only clarify the truth, as for the proof I asked for it was not only for me, but for the people who see the conversation so they could see that your points are without backing, I brought you the sayings of Imam Ahmed, Imam Malik, Imam Abu Haneefah whilst you rambled on without any evidence, as for my name then this has nothing to do with the conservation and is a weak excuse, surely even you should be able to comprehend this....
The pseudo Salafi dawah is incorrect. Avoid that at all costs. However, following a madhab is correct, as long as you follow one. However, you are allowed to change, now there's no availability of Hanafi scholars for you to ask specific matters about, you must utilise the scholars of you area, so can become a Maliki. Brother, a little striving and learning some knowledge for the sake of Allah (SWT) won't go unrewarded...Only evil desires and Shaytaan will make you lazy.
@ankroo brother when i ws in england a guy used to live in my vicinity he was perhaps shafayee, but he asked me how he could adopt the hanafi madhab.I told him to stay at his madhab. One cannot switch on and off frequently......between madhabs. but bro i would say switching is much more bettter than what you have done. Rather than following pious predecessors you adopted to follow miscreants today, who are sowing the seeds of discension in the hearts of ummah.
Sorry to say this, but the man in the video didn't do a job in the way he answered the question. He makes it sound like he is comparing Abu Hanifah to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
@DeenFikar We follow the hadith which have been recorded and classified regarding their authenticity, we take the strong conclusive proofs and leave the weak fabricated narrations, this is how we obey the prophet (peace be upon him)
@DeenFikar yes i follow Prophet(peace be upon him) through his Sahii hadiths......Every muslim has beleive that Prophet Muhammad,s(peace be upon him) Grave is a piece of paradise....
@candyfall87 yes indeed we all pray that Allah guides us to the straight path and makes us of those who love the truth and of those who follow the truth, and we ask Allah to make us of those who follow in the footsteps of the last prophet Muhammed Ibn Abdullah (peace be upon him) and we ask Allah the exalted to make us of those who love the sunnah of his prophet and cling to the sunnah
It annoys me to extremes when Salafis cause arguments and spread single statements to cause confusion on videos which are supposed to stop confusion. Salafis are amazing at taking things out of context, and when their foolish statements are refuted, they still do not accept. Who are the true blind followers? Those who arrogantly do not take anyone but their own view (or a Salafi "shaykh"'s views) into consideration.
When has taqleed of an imam ever been wajib, how can it then be declared sinful? We follow no one blindly except the the messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) we take from the scholars but no one is to be relied on a mistake so this blind following is not obligatory nor do the scholars hold this view
@AfwaunMuMeen Imam Ahmed said ' the opinion of Awzaa'ee, the opinion of malik, the opinion of abu haneefah -all of it is opinion , and it is all equal in my eyes. however the proof is in the narrations (of the salaf) ' ibn abdul-barr in jaami bayaan al-ilm (2,149) there is a refutation from a person of knowledge
@AfwaunMuMeen Abu Haneefah said ' when i sat something contradicting the book of Allah the exalted, or what is narrated from the messenger then ignore my saying' al-fulaani in eeqaaz al-himam (pg 50) tracing it to Imam Muhammed and then saying 'this does not apply to the mujtahid for he is not bound by their views anyway but it applies to the blind following' is this sufficient enough or do you need to make further excuses
@evilheem Do you know WHO Imaam Abu Hanifah was addressing when he made that statement.. ALL the GREAT Imaams of that time made that statement BUT they were ADDRESSING THEIR STUDENTS who were also Scholars of the HIGHEST caliber.They were not addressing the ignoramuses of this age such as you & myself. It's amazing how u people attribute following the Salaf as blind following yet it's NOT blind following to follow every verdict handed down by the likes of Albani & Bin Bazz, is this not Taqleed
@evilheem If the SALAF including Imaam Abu Hanifah who was born 80 A.H were the BEST of generations & WE WERE ORDERED to follow them then who better to follow? Did the SAHAABAH not do Taqleed? Did they NOT blindly follow Rasulullah {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} without ever asking why or how? Even the Ahaadith you cite EVERYDAY was compiled by people who made Taqleed of 1 of the 4 Imaams? Only Allah Ta'ala grants understanding & guidance, for I have NOT been made a Watcher over u. No more comments
@AfwaunMuMeen Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
@realsoulja he never put anyone down, hes just stating the fact that imam abu hanifa was the greatest of the 4 imams, absolutely nothing wrong with saying that. And i love the other imams just as much, but follow imam abu hanifa
@realsoulja He didn't put them down, Imam Abu Hanifa was a Tabe'ee and is the Imam with the greatest amount of followers. No other imam was a tabe'ee so he could have easily been the greatest.
Does this person consider "ghair muqalid, ahlehadith, wahabi, one with no mazhab, call him whatever" to be muslim?
On the one hand you upload clips like: /watch?v=BzqBiH0Cutw
and then on the other hand you upload clips like this one.
Cant he explain to all the people that people think differently and both ways are fine. Following Imam Abu Hanifa is also fine and the people who try to follow Sahih ahadees is also fine.
@MaulanaIshaqURDU Your comments a few weeks ago were not so favourable to Hanafis. The simple fact is that Madhabs are under attack we are merely defending our selves.
@aasimazam :) JazakALLAH khair. Aasim bhai. I am sorry if I gave unfavourable comments to Hanafies.
I think the salafies will also say the same that they are only defending after they hear that they are called as "La Mazhab".There are extreme parties in both the groups (salafies and the4 madhabs). Both consider only themselves to be on Haq and consider the other to be on baatil. And it is a fact that is written in books of both the groups that there masail can be wrong. so y fight over them.:)
This is true Ghair Muqalid and so called Pakistani Salfies they tells to Arabs wrong things about Tablighi Jammat and The Hanafi Fiqh. and divide us from the teaching of Islam and tell them their Aqeeda are not good they are Mushriq, Munafiq etc.
When I watch the video of Mahraj Rabbani and Tauseef Ur-Rehman and I think that how it is possible that they are sitting in Saudi Arab and spreading hatred speeches against Ulmah-E-Haq Ahl-E-Sunnah Wal Jamamt
@pissueg Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
@pissueg Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
@mado9111 Please listen and read carefully. He says obviously "i would not say it in front of him because he would be upset", but WE think he is ignorant, which is a fair enough statment, because ignorant is someone who doesnt know.
@mado9111 The word IGNORANT means to simply not know, had a smaller word been used, it wouldn't have been a problem but because the words ignorant and ignorance has been used the wrong way the actual meaning has been forgotten. The MASSES are ignorant because WE lack undertstanding
This has been flagged as spam show
Thinkingmuslims no the ottomans ruled by hanafi fiqh, so did the mamluks, so did the Abbasids , and so did the mughals. Did Allah make the largest and longest empires of the Muslim ummah be run using the fiqh of misguidance nay these were the greatest Muslim empires and Allah would not misguide the entire Muslims for 1200 yers
SUPERSAJINZ 1 month ago
Thinkingmuslims no the ottomans ruled by hanafi fiqh, so did the mamluks, so did the Abbasids , and so did the mughals. Did Allah make the largest and longest empires of the Muslim ummah be run using the fiqh of misguidance nay these were the greatest Muslim empires and Allah would not misguide the entire Muslims for 1200 yers
SUPERSAJINZ 1 month ago
He is absoloutley right in saying that to a ignorant person or even a layman you give examples but to a scholar you give proof (daleel).
MuhammedP23 2 months ago
abe gadhe baatta kyu hai musalmano ko...
humanspeak 2 months ago
It is just wrong to say that "No we must always do taqleed even if we become strong in knowledge and the daleel of our imam seems weaker than others." And one of the main reason Abu Hanifa's madhab is most popular is because it was the state religion of the Ottomans, hence, they put emphasis on hanafi imams, schools, teachers, etc. So, I'd say this is circumstantial. Allah Knows Best.
thethinkingmuslim 2 months ago
Maulana Ilyaas ghuman sahab ko Allah Paak jazahe khair ata karay Ameen
tariqaskani 3 months ago
MashAllah,,,,,,,,,,Molana Ilyas Ghumman is Great
Ahsan3568 3 months ago
who appointed imams? Is there ayat or hadees saying we should do taqleed of such and so?
afghanmuhajir 3 months ago
Did he say abu hanifa is a greater imam than imam shafi'i?
What does he base his evidences on? Ask anyone to name the greatest classical scholars and you'll find out who they saw as greater
Darulislam1 4 months ago
@Darulislam1 "If you look for good in someone you will find it, if you look for bad you will find bad". Shaykh is referring to "great" in terms of following, which is simply undeniable, even today. If you are unsure about something, that should be stated, you have stated a catergorical statement which is simpy an unwise thing to do. Please rectify this for future notice.
hanafifiqh 4 months ago
@hanafifiqh
Sorry It seems that I have completely misunderstand
Please forgive me, I do not intent to show animosity to another brother.
Jazakalahu Khairan for that, I totaly afree with the shaikhs statement.
Once again sorry and Thank you brother
Darulislam1 3 months ago
Moulana sahab, kabhi to daleel ke saath baath kariye... whether he be jaahil or aalim. due to this act, we are loosing people and they are diverting towards salafi.
sba123999 7 months ago
Just for the record, I agree with everything AfwaunMumeen said.
oigeezer 7 months ago
Peace blessings and mercy of Almighty Allah be upon our beloved Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and His beloved Sahabah Radi Allah Anhu (The best people on the face of this Earth) and those who are with them.
Oh Muslim help each other in good things and don't help in bad things. There is a Pakistani man Tauseef Ur Rehman (Shia) he claimed that he become Salfi now. He recording his video everyday from Saudi Arab and criticizing Ulmah specially those who are dead. what is solution please help?
pissueg 7 months ago
Imagine a person who CANNOT even recite the Quraan NOR perform Salaat OR Wudhu correctly demanding dalaail for the validity of Taqleed. THE IGNORANCE & DEVIATION OF SUCH PERSONS ARE CONSPICUOUS FOR THOSE WHO POSSESS SOME UNDERSTANDING OF THE SHARIAH.
AfwaunMuMeen 7 months ago
Nowadays, in view of the spread of FREE-LANCING in the Deen,i.e. abandoning the Math-habs of the Sunnah, we find IGNORANT people seeking dalaail (proofs) for the masaa-il of the Shariah. MOST of those seeking proofs LACK knowledge of even the masaa-il of Tahaarat & Salaat. Inspite of such ignorance, they demand daleel for ANY law of the Shariah which does not find approval with their whims, fancies and nafsaani opinion.
AfwaunMuMeen 7 months ago
Everyone is a muqallid. Everyone refers to scholarship to learn their deen. The only difference, of recent, is a new group has done their own ijtihad, with minimal reference to the scholars of fiqh. Hence, their seeming proximity to the primary texts gives the illusion that their way is somehow better or purer than the four Sunni Madhabs. This illusion is broken, in part, when knows that to access the primary texts requires one to be a mujtahid himself, which no modern scholar can claim.
Synergistik 7 months ago
MashAllah this is what people need nowdays try to upload some more videos like this InshAllah
LightOfIslaam 8 months ago
ghuman is la mazhab and a dumb mola
shaair1 8 months ago
I have a question maybe you can ask one of your teachers for me.
I am not a student of knowledge, but I followed the basic hanafi fiqh most of my life for 23 yrs. while living in Lahore, until I moved to Ontario where there was a small Muslim community who followed the Malaki fiqh. I was told that I must change my madhab, but I couldn't get used to their fiqh regarding salat and other things, nor did I want to relearn the basics so now I follow Salafi dawah.
Am I considered a sinner?
ankroo 8 months ago 6
@ankroo No
The war of Mazhab is only about what is most good .Hanafi will say that this is good while maliky will say that no that is more good .
No one is wrong both want to be the best but this is upto the level of Scholars .
When in comes to common people they due to their ignorance say that only this is correct .
This is a foolish statement to say that only this is correct .
Prophet SAW prayed by both ways and thus we can also pray by both ways .
Hanafi will say that this is more good etc
TheSoldierofislam12 8 months ago
@ankroo Yes u should repent & return back to your Madh-hab where your Imaan is safe. The teachers of the Imaams of the Madh-habs were none other than the Sahaabah and the Greatest Tabieen this world has ever seen meanwhile the teachers of the BRAND NEW Salafi sect are who and HOW far back do their teachings go. The Alhe Sunnah Wal Jamaah been considered the 4 Madh-habs for OVER 1300 years of Islam, therefore it's TRADITIONAL Islam. ORIGINAL Islam is your ONLY Salvation
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
@AfwaunMuMeen Perhaps you could also bring the evidence from the qu'ran and the sunnah that proves your saying of not having a madh-hab is a sin. As said before we only blindly follow the prophet (peace be upon him), as for the four imams we love them and it is allowed to follow their madh-hab however to blindly follow them is against their own teaching, if the saying of an imam is against the qu'ran or the sunnah who do we follow, do we give precedence to the imam or the qu'ran?
evilheem 8 months ago
Comment removed
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
Comment removed
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
Comment removed
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@evilheem Nowadays, in view of the spread of FREE-LANCING in the Deen,i.e. abandoning the Math-habs of the Sunnah, we find IGNORANT people seeking dalaail (proofs) for the masaa-il of the Shariah. MOST of those seeking proofs LACK knowledge of even the masaa-il of Tahaarat & Salaat. Inspite of such ignorance, they demand daleel for ANY law of the Shariah which does not find approval with their whims, fancies and nafsaani opinion.
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@evilheem Imagine a person who CANNOT even recite the Quraan NOR perform Salaat OR Wudhu correctly demanding dalaail for the validity of Taqleed. THE IGNORANCE & DEVIATION OF SUCH PERSONS ARE CONSPICUOUS FOR THOSE WHO POSSESS SOME UNDERSTANDING OF THE SHARIAH.------> **"WHEN YOUR SHEIKH COMES I'LL GIVE PROOF, WHEN AN IGNORANT 1 LIKE U COMES I'LL GIVE EXAMPLES. SCHOLARS ARE GIVEN PROOFS & NON-SCHOLARS ARE GIVEN EXAMPLES"** Once again, I will NO longer give "U" a comment.--->
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
Comment removed
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
@AfwaunMuMeen I have no desire to debate rather I wish to only clarify the truth, as for the proof I asked for it was not only for me, but for the people who see the conversation so they could see that your points are without backing, I brought you the sayings of Imam Ahmed, Imam Malik, Imam Abu Haneefah whilst you rambled on without any evidence, as for my name then this has nothing to do with the conservation and is a weak excuse, surely even you should be able to comprehend this....
evilheem 8 months ago
@ankroo Offcourse you are.
u in Lahore u hanafi u In toronto u become Salafi then u go to US {Don't no what u will
become]
.
DeenFikar 8 months ago
@ankroo
The pseudo Salafi dawah is incorrect. Avoid that at all costs. However, following a madhab is correct, as long as you follow one. However, you are allowed to change, now there's no availability of Hanafi scholars for you to ask specific matters about, you must utilise the scholars of you area, so can become a Maliki. Brother, a little striving and learning some knowledge for the sake of Allah (SWT) won't go unrewarded...Only evil desires and Shaytaan will make you lazy.
oigeezer 7 months ago
@ankroo brother when i ws in england a guy used to live in my vicinity he was perhaps shafayee, but he asked me how he could adopt the hanafi madhab.I told him to stay at his madhab. One cannot switch on and off frequently......between madhabs. but bro i would say switching is much more bettter than what you have done. Rather than following pious predecessors you adopted to follow miscreants today, who are sowing the seeds of discension in the hearts of ummah.
jesusdagr8 6 months ago
Sorry to say this, but the man in the video didn't do a job in the way he answered the question. He makes it sound like he is comparing Abu Hanifah to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).
ankroo 8 months ago 4
Wow! MashAllah!
94hashmi 8 months ago
Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
billo772 8 months ago
@billo772 How u follow the Prophet With Open eyes as u said he is now in grave?
DeenFikar 8 months ago
@DeenFikar We follow the hadith which have been recorded and classified regarding their authenticity, we take the strong conclusive proofs and leave the weak fabricated narrations, this is how we obey the prophet (peace be upon him)
evilheem 8 months ago
@DeenFikar yes i follow Prophet(peace be upon him) through his Sahii hadiths......Every muslim has beleive that Prophet Muhammad,s(peace be upon him) Grave is a piece of paradise....
billo772 8 months ago
@evilheem may Allah grant u hidayat..
candyfall87 8 months ago
@candyfall87 yes indeed we all pray that Allah guides us to the straight path and makes us of those who love the truth and of those who follow the truth, and we ask Allah to make us of those who follow in the footsteps of the last prophet Muhammed Ibn Abdullah (peace be upon him) and we ask Allah the exalted to make us of those who love the sunnah of his prophet and cling to the sunnah
evilheem 8 months ago
@AfwaunMuMeen well said!
candyfall87 8 months ago
It annoys me to extremes when Salafis cause arguments and spread single statements to cause confusion on videos which are supposed to stop confusion. Salafis are amazing at taking things out of context, and when their foolish statements are refuted, they still do not accept. Who are the true blind followers? Those who arrogantly do not take anyone but their own view (or a Salafi "shaykh"'s views) into consideration.
oigeezer 8 months ago
When has taqleed of an imam ever been wajib, how can it then be declared sinful? We follow no one blindly except the the messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) we take from the scholars but no one is to be relied on a mistake so this blind following is not obligatory nor do the scholars hold this view
evilheem 8 months ago
@evilheem When this WAS and IS the way of the Salaf HOW can one refute...
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
@AfwaunMuMeen Imam Ahmed said ' the opinion of Awzaa'ee, the opinion of malik, the opinion of abu haneefah -all of it is opinion , and it is all equal in my eyes. however the proof is in the narrations (of the salaf) ' ibn abdul-barr in jaami bayaan al-ilm (2,149) there is a refutation from a person of knowledge
evilheem 8 months ago
@evilheem WAS ABU HANIFAH {Rahmatullah Alayh} not from the Salaf????????????
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
@AfwaunMuMeen Abu Haneefah said ' when i sat something contradicting the book of Allah the exalted, or what is narrated from the messenger then ignore my saying' al-fulaani in eeqaaz al-himam (pg 50) tracing it to Imam Muhammed and then saying 'this does not apply to the mujtahid for he is not bound by their views anyway but it applies to the blind following' is this sufficient enough or do you need to make further excuses
evilheem 8 months ago
@evilheem Do you know WHO Imaam Abu Hanifah was addressing when he made that statement.. ALL the GREAT Imaams of that time made that statement BUT they were ADDRESSING THEIR STUDENTS who were also Scholars of the HIGHEST caliber.They were not addressing the ignoramuses of this age such as you & myself. It's amazing how u people attribute following the Salaf as blind following yet it's NOT blind following to follow every verdict handed down by the likes of Albani & Bin Bazz, is this not Taqleed
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
@evilheem If the SALAF including Imaam Abu Hanifah who was born 80 A.H were the BEST of generations & WE WERE ORDERED to follow them then who better to follow? Did the SAHAABAH not do Taqleed? Did they NOT blindly follow Rasulullah {Salallahu Alayhi Wasalaam} without ever asking why or how? Even the Ahaadith you cite EVERYDAY was compiled by people who made Taqleed of 1 of the 4 Imaams? Only Allah Ta'ala grants understanding & guidance, for I have NOT been made a Watcher over u. No more comments
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
@AfwaunMuMeen Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
evilheem 8 months ago
How is Imam Abu Hanifah RA bigger and better than the other Imams RA. All Four Imams were great who made the Deen easy for the masses.
People need to to read their Biographies to know how much they struggled to gain even one Hadith.
This is a terrible Analogy. We have to do Taqleed but not to the extreme where we put down the other Great Imams of this Ummah.
realsoulja 8 months ago
@realsoulja I think he means Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) was the first Imam and has the largest following in the world....
mrwaqy 8 months ago
@realsoulja he never put anyone down, hes just stating the fact that imam abu hanifa was the greatest of the 4 imams, absolutely nothing wrong with saying that. And i love the other imams just as much, but follow imam abu hanifa
Vmax786 8 months ago
@realsoulja He didn't put them down, Imam Abu Hanifa was a Tabe'ee and is the Imam with the greatest amount of followers. No other imam was a tabe'ee so he could have easily been the greatest.
StrictlyQrnANDsnna 8 months ago
Does this person consider "ghair muqalid, ahlehadith, wahabi, one with no mazhab, call him whatever" to be muslim?
On the one hand you upload clips like: /watch?v=BzqBiH0Cutw
and then on the other hand you upload clips like this one.
Cant he explain to all the people that people think differently and both ways are fine. Following Imam Abu Hanifa is also fine and the people who try to follow Sahih ahadees is also fine.
Listen to following link: /watch?v=gCSzrKqxsgY
MaulanaIshaqURDU 8 months ago
@MaulanaIshaqURDU Your comments a few weeks ago were not so favourable to Hanafis. The simple fact is that Madhabs are under attack we are merely defending our selves.
aasimazam 8 months ago
@aasimazam :) JazakALLAH khair. Aasim bhai. I am sorry if I gave unfavourable comments to Hanafies.
I think the salafies will also say the same that they are only defending after they hear that they are called as "La Mazhab".There are extreme parties in both the groups (salafies and the4 madhabs). Both consider only themselves to be on Haq and consider the other to be on baatil. And it is a fact that is written in books of both the groups that there masail can be wrong. so y fight over them.:)
MaulanaIshaqURDU 8 months ago
SubhanAllah...Amazing, Masha-Allah...
oigeezer 8 months ago
Mashallah! Lol! Mind blowing examples! May Allah reward all of u!
candyfall87 8 months ago
Great work Ma-Shah-Allah
This is true Ghair Muqalid and so called Pakistani Salfies they tells to Arabs wrong things about Tablighi Jammat and The Hanafi Fiqh. and divide us from the teaching of Islam and tell them their Aqeeda are not good they are Mushriq, Munafiq etc.
When I watch the video of Mahraj Rabbani and Tauseef Ur-Rehman and I think that how it is possible that they are sitting in Saudi Arab and spreading hatred speeches against Ulmah-E-Haq Ahl-E-Sunnah Wal Jamamt
pissueg 8 months ago 11
@pissueg Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
billo772 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@pissueg Indeed Allah's help is sought, it may be that you have no more comments because you have no more excuses however the truth is known as imam Malik said it is not permitted to blindly follow anyone except the one in this grave (i.e the prophet) We were ordered to follow the prophet as whoever has obeyed the messenger has obeyed Allah, we do not follow other men blindly rather we take the qu'ran and the narrations of the salaf and we accept the truth and refute the mistakes
billo772 8 months ago
"JazakAllah Ta'ala Khairan Katheeran Wa Barakallahu Feekum for taking the time out to upload this"
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
Aslam Alaikom
it's not nice that the sheikh called the guy who asks a "Jahel"
Did the prophet pbuh ever tell someone in his face you are a "Jahel" ?
mado9111 8 months ago
@mado9111 Please listen and read carefully. He says obviously "i would not say it in front of him because he would be upset", but WE think he is ignorant, which is a fair enough statment, because ignorant is someone who doesnt know.
inkofscholars 8 months ago 2
@mado9111 The word IGNORANT means to simply not know, had a smaller word been used, it wouldn't have been a problem but because the words ignorant and ignorance has been used the wrong way the actual meaning has been forgotten. The MASSES are ignorant because WE lack undertstanding
AfwaunMuMeen 8 months ago
very difficult to follow... the english translation is not very good altough i appreciate the effort.
jazakallah al kheir
ps: what is kalima..?
Madhofd 8 months ago
@Madhofd Kalima = To testify. i.e the testification of a muslim is Lailaha IllAllahu Muhammadur Rasul Allah
109place 8 months ago