I myself personaly think Steve Wilson is the greatest song writer since John Lennon & the musical arrangments are just brilliant ! I seen in the comments some idiot makes a statment the songs are'nt very good & there to long for most people to enjoy ? all I can say for you set on your ass drink another beer and enjoy your .............ackie....brakie .....boring shit !
We are a band called Watershine and we play progressive metal. Although it's not always so obvious, we are pretty influenced by Porcupine Tree, and we would appreciate if you listened to our demo and maybe left a comment :) Please don't mark this as spam, we're just trying to spread our music!
The band that I always hoped to find ...but never thought I would...somehow a revisiting of the great creativeness of the seventies like Pink Floyd and Genesis and King Crimson.....BUT more and advanced....Today there are so few who are so creative in their melodies and words.....thanks for the dream come true!
After Hoping for so many years....this is the band that I always hoped to find...but never thought I would...they are truly creative in words and melody...rare these days....thanks for the dream come true
One of the greatest bands to ever grace the earth. So versatile. Pure genius in every song. Steven Wilson shits more talent than most bands more famous than PT could ever hope to be. They are sadly underrated
@kanariepietje1992 The drummer is Gavin Harrison, there are lots of his solo vids on YouTube. He's a legend (in his own right, not because of this band), infact his drumming really shines when he's not playing with this band. Think he also drummed with Kings of Crimson.
@kanariepietje1992 Anyone who knows who are this band? What is this youtube.com site about? Where am I? Who am I? Do I exist? Who is typing all this questions? Who's "me"?
Gavin Harrison. Good eye (and ear). A lot of people, myself included, consider him the world's premier rock drummer. I think he's surpassed Neil Peart.
Shouldn't Porcupine Tree be a lot more recognized by the public? most people I know have never heard of them, why so underrated? one of the most inspiring and inspared band of these days...I read comments on Pink Floyd vids and the like and too many say no one makes this quality music anymore, well...here it is!
@geomusicmove People who make statements that music isn´t good anymore these days can´t look past the shitty music you hear everywhere on the streets or on tv, I agree.
@Cigarrock well...that's your opinion, to me most of their songs are very good.
As for most people not wanting to listen to long songs, a good analogy would be that most people don't want to spend time cooking and eat microwaved stuff, quicker and easier, but better?
Most people like easy listen, not challenging, churned out music...I don't
@geomusicmove i would like you to tell me about better songwritters, (bands) because i want to expand my musical taste........... i say if you can you say too much but i haven´t seen any recomendations. thanks
@finemodels you want me to recommend better bands than who? I think Porcupine Tree is one of the finest bands of these days. To me it's the best nowadays. I also like Tool, Opeth and Oceansize. In prog rock, I personally listen to a lot of bands from the 70s ie Genesis, Yes, Rush, Pink Floyd, Yes, Led Zep, and more jazzy stuff like Soft Machine, Weather Report. Obviously there's a lot more I can't mention everyone
Colin is an excellent bassist. He is drifting away on this tune. That says a lot about where his head is at with PT's music. He is feeling it, not just playing it. They are geniuses.
Colin zoning away on the bass is priceless. It's good to see musicians that really enjoy their own music. PT isn't just going through the motions. They feel it.
What's all this about Steven being a genius? Sure he writes some great music, but genius is a bit heavy. All it shows is a lack of expression, one guy calls him a genius, that's fine, then the mob of 'think inside the box' guys repeatedly bash the comments section with the same boring comments. Genius is a big word, which is having less and less value the more it is thrown around. Just to make myself clear, I love Porcupine Tree in a big way and Steven Wilson is bloody good at what he does!
Pure talent with this band!
ITokeMarijuana420 2 weeks ago
I like this!
BrodinBrothers22 2 weeks ago
I never get tired of hearing this song.
Galileus070 2 weeks ago
Staggeringly good.
cueshark 1 month ago
This is one of the few videos which needs an autoreply button of Youtube
keegan31silveira 1 month ago 3
@keegan31silveira Replace tube for repeat in your URL and see..(no joke, no pron)
wytzedeswart 3 weeks ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Porcupine Tree
i agree, VERY under-rated band!
PinkSpklz 1 month ago 5
@PinkSpklz
Every time I listen to one of their songs I feel sorry for the people who haven't been as fortunate
MindGoingNumb 3 weeks ago
I myself personaly think Steve Wilson is the greatest song writer since John Lennon & the musical arrangments are just brilliant ! I seen in the comments some idiot makes a statment the songs are'nt very good & there to long for most people to enjoy ? all I can say for you set on your ass drink another beer and enjoy your .............ackie....brakie .....boring shit !
69pinkmeat 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Porcupine Tree 3
This song never gets old, love it!!
Crossroads551 1 month ago
baad
atashesh 1 month ago
just found - impressive!
PunainenLada 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey guys we are a band from Los Angeles you can check out our music at our youtube page or facebook(dot)com/voiceinthedark
VoiceintheDarkband 1 month ago
oh look its lee giddy , oh ......its that porcupine guy
andezbox 1 month ago
@andezbox His name is Geddy Lee
TNA796 1 day ago
@TNA796 oh sorry 697 ant
andezbox 1 day ago
i just simply loves this song..it touches my soul.
vanses2008 2 months ago
1:48 says it all!
treezrok 2 months ago
4 bieber fans
FelipGVC 2 months ago
666 likes when I saw this! \m/
gan35h 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Porcupine Tree
One of the best songs ever made.
aayush3009 3 months ago
Steven Wilson <3
This man is a genius!!!
heron422 3 months ago
Comment removed
heron422 3 months ago
<3
19flightrock 3 months ago
they are the next pink floyd.....
dhed3vil1 3 months ago 2
Comment removed
dhed3vil1 3 months ago
Este grupo es genial (great band).......y esta canción es buenisima (nice song)
rochgadol 3 months ago in playlist Liked
Comment removed
Manoncina 3 months ago
my heart stopped for 4 min 15 seconds
abhishakenatzi 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
/watch?v=LUyQx9cQaD4
We are a band called Watershine and we play progressive metal. Although it's not always so obvious, we are pretty influenced by Porcupine Tree, and we would appreciate if you listened to our demo and maybe left a comment :) Please don't mark this as spam, we're just trying to spread our music!
WatershineBand 4 months ago
Ya gotta love Progressive Rock =)
shadowlink2000000009 4 months ago
4 people are... follow me down... fuck that, this song is so peaceful, haters gonna hate and i dont care
Ildr3him 4 months ago 2
4 people are...wait, noone cares
PorcupineTreeCD 4 months ago 17
Thank You,God for saving progressive rock.Most likely the finest live recording band on the planet.Awesome job Steven..."we're not worthy"
AmmoniaBinge 5 months ago
the best group now wit intelligent music,stephen wilson is a great performer,songwriter,musician
aadrockt1957 5 months ago
does anyone else really really wanna be totally one with this music?
killercreek450 5 months ago
pure orgasm in song form.
killercreek450 5 months ago
The band that I always hoped to find ...but never thought I would...somehow a revisiting of the great creativeness of the seventies like Pink Floyd and Genesis and King Crimson.....BUT more and advanced....Today there are so few who are so creative in their melodies and words.....thanks for the dream come true!
riverzen 5 months ago 2
After Hoping for so many years....this is the band that I always hoped to find...but never thought I would...they are truly creative in words and melody...rare these days....thanks for the dream come true
riverzen 5 months ago 2
One of the greatest bands to ever grace the earth. So versatile. Pure genius in every song. Steven Wilson shits more talent than most bands more famous than PT could ever hope to be. They are sadly underrated
KaldDodeGitarist 5 months ago 2
great video i shall be buying dvd :)
heavymaiden85 6 months ago
That guitar tone from 2.47 - 3.09 is just........aaaaaah.
88Anesthetize 6 months ago 22
@88Anesthetize They dont have that guitar peace in the original version, donno why.
Just love that improvisation
rishabhverma1 3 months ago
Comment removed
88Anesthetize 3 months ago
Comment removed
88Anesthetize 3 months ago
Su Su Su Su Super Amazing Band.....I Think World Best Band!!
djaxodhks 6 months ago
beautiful
gogolplex74 6 months ago
/watch?v=P6ivZqDkIBc Same song. A slideshow. Beautiful journey.
mithilsampat92 6 months ago
Beautiful song.
AquilaSever 6 months ago
3 people don't like this video. Cuz they prefer rap and Emo garbage. Fuckin ruhtards
KaldDodeGitarist 6 months ago 2
I can't belive this is 100% live, it could just as well been a music video.
Eximious94 6 months ago
this song is sick... I love it.
MoodyRush4 7 months ago
I have jizz in my pants... :$
EduLuqueLucena 7 months ago 3
oh, mamma mia...
marcycaddeo 7 months ago
This song is just incredible!
ironknightzero 7 months ago
Barbieri is playing the wrong notes :D
3mptyLab 7 months ago
BRILLIANT.
darkravenstories 8 months ago
Beautiful, I've never heard a better band ever. ;) and that's saying something if you know me lol.
HannahTheTumor 9 months ago 3
Omg!!!!!!!So Amazing Group!!!
djaxodhks 9 months ago 2
@kanariepietje1992 It's Gavin Harrison
SlugMenace 9 months ago 2
@kanariepietje1992 - It's Gavin Harrison.
jimarillion 9 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 The drummer is Gavin Harrison, there are lots of his solo vids on YouTube. He's a legend (in his own right, not because of this band), infact his drumming really shines when he's not playing with this band. Think he also drummed with Kings of Crimson.
roxy40fy 9 months ago
Peart is still an ounce better. More experience overall. Gav has done in 6 years what it took Neil 10 years to do, but Neil will forever be master.
McYellowfish 9 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 Gavin Harrison...
bassplayer12 9 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 Gavin Harrison dude! He's a fucking beast!!! Has a very smooth/fluent way of playing drums! One of THE best I think!
OGCerrabuz 9 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 - Drummer is called Gavin Harrison. Right up there nearly with Neil Peart etc IMO
liveforprogrock 9 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 Anyone who knows who are this band? What is this youtube.com site about? Where am I? Who am I? Do I exist? Who is typing all this questions? Who's "me"?
onesppiegel 9 months ago 2
@onesppiegel I suggest you see some kind of doctor, maybe he'll help you find out who you are.. xD Kidding ;)
kanariepietje1992 9 months ago
@kanariepietje1992
Gavin Harrison. Good eye (and ear). A lot of people, myself included, consider him the world's premier rock drummer. I think he's surpassed Neil Peart.
theaterdreamer 10 months ago 3
@theaterdreamer Agreed! One of the best without a doubt..! Makes it look easy, and damn I hate that =D
kanariepietje1992 10 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 ....you need to see them live....drummer is Gavin Harrison
riverzen 10 months ago 2
every time i hear this song.....i get chills.....can listen to this song day in-day out....
sandipan8 10 months ago 2
muy buen tema
Musicmangtr 10 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 Gavin Harrison !! My President...
MrGordonWalsh 10 months ago 2
3:31 Colin found some mushrooms.
monniization 10 months ago 2
@kanariepietje1992 it's Gavin Harrison, one of the best drummers in the world.
maurobeardy 10 months ago
Amazing!
pusi8063 10 months ago
@johndoe020202 why bother → WIKI has it all..! Φ Neil Peart, right- #LOL
jimmywacked 11 months ago
@kanariepietje1992
Gavin Harrison is the Drummer.
godfrog2009 11 months ago
Shouldn't Porcupine Tree be a lot more recognized by the public? most people I know have never heard of them, why so underrated? one of the most inspiring and inspared band of these days...I read comments on Pink Floyd vids and the like and too many say no one makes this quality music anymore, well...here it is!
geomusicmove 11 months ago 39
@geomusicmove People who make statements that music isn´t good anymore these days can´t look past the shitty music you hear everywhere on the streets or on tv, I agree.
puddingball 3 months ago 3
@geomusicmove most of their songs aren't very good and are longer than most people want to listen to.
Cigarrock 1 month ago
@Cigarrock well...that's your opinion, to me most of their songs are very good.
As for most people not wanting to listen to long songs, a good analogy would be that most people don't want to spend time cooking and eat microwaved stuff, quicker and easier, but better?
Most people like easy listen, not challenging, churned out music...I don't
geomusicmove 1 month ago
@geomusicmove i would like you to tell me about better songwritters, (bands) because i want to expand my musical taste........... i say if you can you say too much but i haven´t seen any recomendations. thanks
finemodels 2 weeks ago
@finemodels you want me to recommend better bands than who? I think Porcupine Tree is one of the finest bands of these days. To me it's the best nowadays. I also like Tool, Opeth and Oceansize. In prog rock, I personally listen to a lot of bands from the 70s ie Genesis, Yes, Rush, Pink Floyd, Yes, Led Zep, and more jazzy stuff like Soft Machine, Weather Report. Obviously there's a lot more I can't mention everyone
geomusicmove 2 weeks ago
Me: Dad, what's Gavin Harrison's middle name?
Dad: Fuckin'!
Rockband2stream 11 months ago
The most beautiful song I've ever heard.
私が聞いた中で、もっとも美しい歌。
houseofleavesjp 11 months ago
this is weird i was having a really bad day, open you tube and this is the firs video that appears and suddenly everything is ok... how the??
... just wanted to share....
dakprojekt 11 months ago
GAVIN HARRISON;)))
mmm10216 11 months ago
Drummer: Gavin Harrison!
mariutis 11 months ago
Gavin Harrison
mariutis 11 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 Gavin Harrison?
mariutis 11 months ago
Gavin is phenomenal! Perfect live performance!
LOLE1991KOVIN 11 months ago
This song sounds so much better live :3
sio42 11 months ago
Colin is an excellent bassist. He is drifting away on this tune. That says a lot about where his head is at with PT's music. He is feeling it, not just playing it. They are geniuses.
Justliquor 11 months ago
@kanariepietje1992 He's called Gavin Harrison. Great drumming! check out his live show off on sound of muzak
moosethatbeats 11 months ago 2
@moosethatbeats I saw It. gorgeous show, my also favourite ;))
mmm10216 11 months ago
His name is Gavin Harrison. Also drums with King Crimson
EddYardley 1 year ago 2
@johndoe020202 Whaha sorry missed it (A)
kanariepietje1992 1 year ago
@johndoe020202
Gavin ''Frickin'' Harrison ;)
Frankengelsvoll 1 year ago
@kvv1986 I agree there
BENebuchadnezzar 1 year ago
@kanariepietje1992 His name is Gavin Harrison, amazing drummer!
minishancus 1 year ago
Diese Band macht so tolle Musik
FrankLeppini 1 year ago 2
Colin zoning away on the bass is priceless. It's good to see musicians that really enjoy their own music. PT isn't just going through the motions. They feel it.
Justliquor 1 year ago
Excellent beautifull music between all the rubbish nowerdays!
wookie128 1 year ago
What's all this about Steven being a genius? Sure he writes some great music, but genius is a bit heavy. All it shows is a lack of expression, one guy calls him a genius, that's fine, then the mob of 'think inside the box' guys repeatedly bash the comments section with the same boring comments. Genius is a big word, which is having less and less value the more it is thrown around. Just to make myself clear, I love Porcupine Tree in a big way and Steven Wilson is bloody good at what he does!
BENebuchadnezzar 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Remember when you could watch a video without having to sit through a commercial?
Remember when music videos were uploaded by users and not VEVO
Remember when all the info was to the right of the video?
Remember you could rate a video 1-5 stars?
Remember the famous yellow subscribe button?
Remember when the users controlled the site and now corporations?
WE MISS THE OLD YOUTUBE!
Post this in every video and lets start a youtube revolution!
Thumbs up to keep up top
OrangeMango30 1 year ago
Gavin is amazing for one more time!!!
oikonomidis1 1 year ago 2
awesome song
allan69shiraz 1 year ago
i think i'm in love
bkinga311 1 year ago
I love this song! take me to the different horizons!
FreddyReb 1 year ago
This song is helping me heal right now. Rest easy Alex, brother, friend.
rabbitalmighty 1 year ago
this song make me cry! Steven is a genius
theinaereproject 1 year ago
this song make me cry! Steven is a genius
theinaereproject 1 year ago
this band should be noticed!
ricardobalbontin 1 year ago
I like it and i bought the DVD ... and it's so awesome ...
Xallah 1 year ago
Great
ClassicalGuitarRulez 1 year ago
porcupine tree is one of the best bands alive .
ps4future 1 year ago 88
i love it !! Thanks for composing :-)
MrGordonWalsh 1 year ago
the best performance of this song!!!
carogm0508 1 year ago
the best performance of this song!!!! is like a journey through time and space......
carogm0508 1 year ago
this is a great song i love it so much!!!!!! thank you for sharing!!!!
musicadegigi 1 year ago
fucking beautiful song
horny0donkey0 1 year ago
Gavin. Harrison. my god.....
toolfan92 1 year ago 3
just epic...
markoo829 1 year ago
steven wilson..............
u rock \m/
wakeup570 1 year ago
I love how most if not all of their songs sound different.
mustrapefoley 1 year ago
@mustrapefoley
Me too, but I find it simply amazing that they re-use lyrics and riffs but for really awesome ways.
Like Normal/Sentimental.
legendofzelda101 1 year ago
Most bands can't do their own music live. PT is excellent.
Justliquor 1 year ago 7
I have DVD...It's a amazing release...
RonLeite1 1 year ago
beautiful song!
vergeer 1 year ago
This song is awesome!
Pieti222 1 year ago
great stuff :D
070blaze 1 year ago