Added: 2 years ago
From: MajestyOfDT
Views: 21,918,881
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (13,986)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Linda musica e lindo video!!!

  • so beautiful.. reminds my sweet friend who passed away;(( wish u were here♡

  • To all the love ones that are not with us anymore.

  • This song makes me think if my son. Love ya brayden momma loves u and misses u rip♡

  • Ta piosenka przywołuje moje wspomnienia te najpiękniejsze....

  • Ho ancora conservato e tenuto come una reliquia l'album originale di questo capolavoro. Semplicemente fantastico. Ascoltatelo con amore e passione, e nel contempo ricordando quanto di bello avete passato in quei meravigliosi anni che sicuramente mai ritorneranno.

  • People don't know what good music is any more...

    Good music touches your heart. Makes you close your eyes, sing along. It's sound raises you up, and you're floating above the ground. You can enjoy, be happy.

    And the lyrics actually make sence.

    That's called good music, people.

  • One of my favourite songs :)

  • Listening to good music, very , very beautiful :)

  • I like the Tupac cover of this song.

  • @HenryTopia What do you mean by Avril's version?... It's a completely different song. Please don't mention her on this video... Nobody cares.

  • @shaneianthony who is avril?

  • Awesome lyrics, Beautiful video... The background and all the atmosphere.. Makes you feel ina RELAX emotion...

    But... I prefers Avril's version better cuz' describes my life, the originally & pure sound.. and the video so simple.. other artist prefers do a video of fantasy with big eyes, aliens and things that dont exist :)

    Love you avril... and Great song PINK FLOYD

  • @HenryTopia Now, you are writting about how this song is great, but you prefers Avrils song...

    But a while ago you commented on this video and said how much it sucks and how you only wasted 3 minutes of your life here...

    It's funny, how you complained about Pink Floyd fans hating on Avrils video while doing the same thing here.

    Don't ask from others something what you can't do yourself. Sorry, but there is a word describing your behavior - hypocrisy.

  • Avril Lavigne is not Pink Floyd (thanks God), and I can't see the reason why are you talking about her all the time. Just because she steals names for her songs because she's not creative enough to do it herself, it does not necessarily have anything to do with Pink Floyd. So shut up and listen to this beautiful song.

  • This song is very special to me.

  • fuck Avril Lavigne...

  • I prefere Avril Lavigne's "Wish You Were Here"

  • @Lukia0795 Go to hell

    Sincerly

    Everyone who knows about good music

  • @Lukia0795

    I hope you're making shit up, because if you're not I'm gonna come down there and feed you so many Pink Floyd vinyls that you can see Avril Lavigne's "version" when you shit it out.

  • @Lukia0795 well u cud just go fuck urself cause pinkfloyds the greatist

  • @Lukia0795 Oh my, your soul must be empty then...

  • @dragman4321 8 years old kids in youtube...

  • Pink Floyd has done so much great music..thank you guys!!! You will forever be a part of my life and always in my heart!

  • Really well done video, it's simple, like the song and i think if really conveys the beauty of it.

  • Why the hell when i search "wish you were here" it shows me fisrt Avril Lavigne???? FUCK YOUTUBE

  • @RrRrRrook It's because that song is more popular amongst the today's poor minded teens, so it gets searched more often here in YouTube. This one shows after it because of the number of views. I'm glad about this, at least, because there are few people who still think, who still are smart, who have the intelligence to appreciate this work of art. Sorry, my English isn't quite perfect yet, I'm not completely fluent and I don't use translators either. Hope you get to understand what I meant.

  • This song is really great, i dont go a day without listening to it. Im only 17 and wish more people from my generation can get into such beautiful songs just like this one. Rock on pink floyd great job! :)

  • One of my father's favorite songs. I remember telling him to skip it, "Too slow!" I said. I wanted to get to "Another Brick in the Wall."

    He didn't say anything. Just smiled at me, closed his eyes, and continued singing the song.

    It would not be until many years later that I understood what he was trying to tell me.

    Wish you were here, Dad.

  • @zeyro666  <3

  • @zeyro666 so true !!!

  • 849 out of 79,000 is a small enough percentage that most of those actually very well could have been accidents.

  • this is my first time hearing this song, or any pink floyd song, and i instantly fell in love with this song. looks like im gonna be listening to more pink floyd

  • I love this song it is amazing. Thank you Pink Floyd for your awesome music.

  • Comment removed

  • que lixo

    

  • @MADINCU Se você não gosta tudo bem, é a sua opnião, e eu a respeito... Mas não há necessidade de desrrespeitar a de quem gosta...

  • 848 people can't telle heaven from hell, what a shame

  • Pink Floyd is fuckin awsome and so is alot of other old rock music.

  • Hey doofus! If you like similar styles in music check us out some people enjoy it some don't, it's not a big deal!!!

  • i wish i was there

  • Given the choice I'd rather smoke than drink tonight...

  • Comment removed

  • There's Pink Floyd and then there's everything else

  • needforweed2; sounds lke you need a good dose of the SMITHS,lol

  • I'm 5 years old and I believe the music my generation adopts as "it's music" is altogether deplorable. Seeing my generation so unintelligent and ignorant as to what "good" music is, is utterly revolting. I mean, Justing Bieber, Kesha, Lady Gaga? Come on... there is better music than that, and I applaud any child of my age that listens to more classical music than this audible garbage.

  • @needforweed2 your 5 years old an your name is need for weed an you knw the world deplorable ? lol

  • @needforweed2 First off, you're not five. Second, like I told waterhammerxxx, stop hating other people's music. There has been shitty music in EVERY generation. The Osmonds, Cher, the entire glam rock genre, Flock of Seagulls, Strawberry Alarm Clock, Grateful Dead etc. They all suck. But because they're more than 20 years old they are considered good. And if your comment was meant as a joke towards all those kids bragging about listening to old music...sorry. Keep up the good work.

  • Nao a nada a fazer a não ser curtir este som a beira do mar

  • my sister said pink floyd was more shit then justin bieber... R.İ.P sister

  • @ghasher5 sad...

  • Hey, stupid people the "growling" is a man coughing and it's part of the song. You know, like effects? You guys are so dumb stop complaining this song is beautiful and that "growling" only lasts for like 15 seconds so deal with it and shutup.

  • The grunt/cough and background noise at the beginning are part part of the original recording. Have you seriously never heard this song before? Ohhhhh we are doomed!

  • This song goes under skin till the bones....

  • i miss you grandfather :'( R.I.P

  • i wish everyone could enjoy this music

  • The dude who made/uploaded the clip had his headset on with the mic on....dumbass!!

  • @stingrrr1 what kind of growling noise and at what time in the song. I didn't hear it

  • beautiful <3

  • 0:11 somekind of growling noise listen carefully

  • nice vid :) an ofcourse legendary song :)

  • I like this song and I think Avril is also great... so why do you have to hate??!

    Just listen to music that you like and shut up !!

  • I think this song has a sentimental value on all of us :c

    Wish you were here mum, you don't need to say sorry. Just come back :c

  • MF???

  • Bellissima......

  • I CUM everyday when i hear this Song !

  • 0.57 I took a picture of the last sunrise of 2011 that is the exact same image. So beautiful!

  • @waterhammerxxx indeed.

  • @waterhammerxxx Dude shut the fuck up and stop hating other people's music.

  • @waterhammerxxx sure!

  • @waterhammerxxx It's even worse when you try to type in Somebody to Love by Queen and get Justin Bieber First.

  • how i wish my husband was still alive, i will never get over him even if didn't really love me llike my stepson said, we were 2 lost souls that nobody would just let us live our life,he told me the nite before he died he loved me more than anything...raine

  • 843 people do not wish they where here!

  • @AcowDontcare The´re stupid fuckers ;-)

  • Beautiful

  • @superangel89 same here... i wish i could...

  • is the beginning chopped off or is it just me?

  • I am in love with this song...

  • Do you think you can tell?

  • @f8x3 heaven from hell?

  • @loganator01 Blues skies from pain

  • @joseenriqueof Can you tell a green field from a cold steel rail.

  • This always makes me think of my friend Alex Michel. I never really show him that I value our friendship, but when ever I hear this song,,, I just realize how great a person he is to have in my life.

  • avril lavigne's wish you were here was the first result in my search bar.....what the fuck is wrong with humanity?

  • @TOMMASOBOY stfu up hipster trying get attention.. obviously u don't know shit about anything... suck it.

  • @xxsandmanpunkxx you* not u hahahaha how am i a hipster what i said has nothing to do with being a hipster all i was saying is that a shitty song with the same title (avril lavigne's song) as this amazing one comes up first, go get some common sense and then you can try and hold an argument with me you dumb twat

  • O MF deve ta apaixonado

  • só to aqui por causa do MF quem ta aqui so por causa dele da joinha !!

  • @gaara1234mm da joinha o caralho viado

  • my brother loved pink floyd & this song in particular...the night after we laid his earthly remains to rest his ex-wife was doing a karaoke at a local pub...we went...14 or 15 of us...she started this song & we all went up on stage & sang it, a requiem for the beloved lost...i miss you little brother <3

  • Wow, I listen to this song just because it makes me feel good when I am missing someone I considered "the one." Hearing everyone else's reasoning and how much more serious it is only proves the depth and beauty of his song.

  • I miss my family

  • the best song ever

  • my cousin died in a hiking accident 16 years ago today. her parents & brother have moved on admirably. tonight i have been racking my brain for a song to sum it up & i keep coming back to this one..... We all miss you Allison

  • @dkbeyreis My cousin is died in a accident 30 years ago today ....... i feel with you .....it was a very hard time in my familie...... i think every day at my cousin.....

  • I would put in my story, but nobody gives a shit.

  • @theboredman1 I do. =)

  • @theboredman1 i do too

  • @theboredman1 i do!\

  • @theboredman1 Ditto on the I do's, sir.

  • i wish my grandfather was here......died from cancer !!! i miss you,come back ..

  • @metallicektoras1995 Thats sad

  • Comment removed

  • @metallicektoras1995 Hi sorry for your loss, just keep all of those great memories of your grandpa close to your heart .

  • ah mom pote frankc

  • My bf loves this song, and now that I actually listened to it, I like it too. Maybe I'll give Pink Floyd a chance, just for him. <3

  • @trintrin96 wayne?

  • This song reminds me of my friend that died 3 of december 2011. I will always love you. Hope you are fine wherever you are now... I love you, we'll see again someday. I promise... <3

  • really why?

  • this reminds me a lot of beautiful and sad moments of my life!!!!!:))not a lot of songs make me feel like that....just BEAUTIFUL and sad the same time..!

  • i wish i was there...

  • happy Birthday Manson

  • Vorrei dedicare questa canzone a mia madre che mi ha lasciato il giorno di Natale...

  • I love this after my ex died it was hard for me and me and brother played this song in our living room for my ex that died in a car crash and how it eats me up inside but now I have the most amazing girlfriend now

  • happy bithday nick mason

  • HAPPY BIRTHDAY NICK MASON <3

  • @antmfangirl Happy birthday Manson.

  • mou leipeis matako mou!!!!!!!!!!!ela pare me mia aggalia k as ta xehasoume ola........

  • papadimitriouapostol has replied to your comment on Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here:

    @vickermanel u mad?

  • No. I am not mad. I find it interesting to read the responses from people based on their perception of being wronged due to an age bias. Humans are the most fascinating species that there is to study and when I study humans, my music of choice is Pink Floyd.

  • WHY, OH WHY Is avril lavigne the first result when searching this!!!!???

  • just to clear any misunderstandings, THIS ISN'T A LOVE SONG!

  • @JustOneMoreAnon this song can be interpreted to anything the viewer thanks it is! thats another thing why this song is so great!

  • @vickermanel u mad?

  • sometimes i just take my guitar, play and sing this song and think about everybody i miss. I love pink floyd

  • Why is Avril Lavigne on the suggestions !? O.o

  • @redaleftah Because there is also a song of avril lavigne named wish you were here :) I think this song is way better :)

  • @redaleftah are you retarded? she has a song with the exact same title. obviously it's showing up in the related videos

  • @jerommeke69 CHILL THE FUCK OUT DUDE !!! jeez why the fuck is everyone on youtube angry ?

  • @redaleftah lol sorry dude!!

  • @redaleftah Who is Avril Lavigne ??

  • @wmz94

    some hot girl

  • @redaleftah Because, unfortunately, she recorded this music!

  • So,So you think you can dance?

  • love love lovee

  • amo amo amooo

  • Wish You Were Here,My Angel.,

  • I come everyday to hear this song!

  • @slashrm90 i come everyday to fuck your mother

  • I'm 13 and I think avril lavigne's version is crap. and my generation, JUDGE ME!

  • @vipermatthias You are unique of your generation! Stay original my friend!

  • we're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl...

  • this song makes my heart swoon.

  • no, best ballad of all time.

  • lords of dogtown<3333

  • when i speak i almost have the same amount of enthusiasm! love this song

  • I fell asleep listening to this stoned <3

  • best scenes

  • amo pink floyd desde chico mi viejo tenia un par de discos originales discos de vinilo de floy y asta el dia de hoy que lo escucho la mejor banda de todas un saludo para todos !!!!!1

  • i just miss you dad

  • @VicenteFChile Just lost my soon to be mother-in-law. So sorry for your loss. Just know he walks in your heart everyday.

  • @VicenteFChile

    Take Care men

  • @VicenteFChile why?

  • @VicenteFChile

    I miss my father too

  • Day 10

    Low on water and food

    Caught a cold

    Still looking for 214347brandon's comment.

  • I'm in PA freezing my ass off and watching this made me warm and fuzzy :) TY

  • @69daniegyrl thats why I left Connecticut to Arizona 20 years ago...hell with that weather.

  • It reminds me when music used to sound nice, and carry a melody. Not just bunch of run on sentences and words to fill the gap between tracks with a shitty samples over it, What people don't understand in each sound track back then had to be recorded and timed just right, now any kid can ramble 3 words and make a hit, swear the shit we pass as music now is just noise bunch of people aimlessly talking and the day of guitar solos are dead

  • oh my god the guy who says he has 15 years is he a fool man whocares about you

    u make me sickkk

  • self taught no lessons thanks dad!

  • Is there any way to turn off comment view at YT?

  • Hello im 15 and I like trains

  • WTF are this comments? Age doesn't has to do with music!

    If you like listen to it, if you don't GTFO! :D

    

  • wow wow y mas wow!!!

  • That akward moment when,.. not wait, this is just how expected it to be, AWESOME

  • i wishd this played at my wedding