Added: 4 years ago
From: Carriefan104
Views: 182,202
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (240)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • totally better than original!! love it!

  • notice how at the end carrie just sits back andlets keith do his thing and she smiling the whole time you can almost see she realizes keith is one of the best entertainers of our time and this is miles ahead of the original version

  • omg...carrie is so cute here...and keith just rocks!

  • Underwood's performance is respectable, but Urban rocks it -- totally.

  • I think this is my fave version ever! Wish they'd release it

  • Awesome duet!

  • atleast SOMEBODY makes the song sound good.

    better than the ORIGINAL. damn.

  • this is MADDDDDD! oh realise do it do it do it!!

  • they're amazing!!! i love keith and carrie!!!!!!! yeah better than the original

  • better than the origonal

  • i was there!

  • i really love this version! they sound great together

  • sounds a bit like

    the garden orchestra

    ww thegardenorchestra com

  • wow,keith urban and carrie underwood singing a rhianna song? that's...new hahaha keep on righting the hits . =]

  • @JiJi424 KEITH URBANNNNNNN singin a rhianna song!!!!!!

    hahaha but he wud rock the ganjo during a hip hop song hahaha hes awesome

  • Gone the Country version of this song

  • lol, random scream at 3:13

    I love their harmony it's awesome

  • isnt carrie underwood christian lol

  • amazing carrie underwood !!

  • aw carrie is adorable<3

    way bettert han rhinnia!

  • Keith is like 500000,00000,000000,0 times better than her. aand hes smoking hot:D

  • She's like twice as big as him

  • aww carrie underwood is the best!

  • BOTH ARE GREAT!!!!

  • I wish they'd release this song... LOVE IT

  • i'm going to be seeing Keith in 5 daaays! (L)

  • this is amazing.

    kieth is the greatest!

  • ugh... queezy.

  • i love keith urban sooo much! his voice is just amazing.

  • oh i lovet his :)

  • hahaha

  • I think Keith sings this better than Carrie, which is weird, since Carrie is amazing. I think this song just doesn't fit her as well as her others. It's not big enough. She does make the most of it though. They're both great. I like this version.

  • That man gives me chills!

  • oh god carrie sound so hawt

  • Oh my gosh I love the very end when Carrie goes "Under my umber-ella-ella-ella ay-ay-ay-ay-ay-ay-ay"<3 It starts at 3:37 and I'm on my sister's youtube page so don't reply.haha. I love this video though thanks for posrting:)

  • Everybody sings it better than Rihanna

  • haha that's so right lol

    love keith and carrie, they should record a duet

  • great version

  • hes hot, shes cute, they both sound fab! what more could you ask for??!!

  • carrie is a FOX

  • L-O-V-E  IT!

  • LOL.

    I absolutely love these two,

    But for some reason, this makes me want to laugh!

  • WOW! You really are an asshole.

  • haha cute.

  • This is awesome, I LOVE IT!!!

  • I LOVE KEITH URBAN! HE IS MY IMAGINARY BF! tehe

  • Great cover. I always thought this was a rock song, from the very beggining with Rihanna and that huge commercial production.

  • I love that he knows how to play a banjo. That's a challenge.

  • Dude can play a tennis racket...haha...he's way talented. If it has strings, he can pick it!

  • Correction. That's a 'Ganjo', according to Keith Urban..

  • you know...

    ive never liked this song...

    until now.

  • I love this! haha It's so random it made me laugh. They did a great job of making it their own. I love when Keith sings "ella, ella, ella" lol They're both amazing singers!

  • i absolutely love thisss

  • wtf

  • It was written by Terius Nash, Christopher Stewart, and Kuk Harrell.

  • Carrie Rocks!! Keith too

  • Keith is a legend and Carrie is an abolute belta! Have there ever been two better looking people do a duet?

    How good is Keith to be able to pump a crowd with a song by Rhianna, and Carrie....well shes just gorgeous

  • thats ok, remember that female artist of the year award? when carrie won, faith got mad and stormed out. best moment of country music.. that and chris gains

  • ok, your opinion.

  • does anyone know who wrote this song....? Im tipping it's not Rhianna lol

  • its a hip hop guy who calls himself the dream i think. wiki the dream

  • Carrie Underwood is a great singer!!!!

    Beautiful yet talented.....

    whatever song she sang,,, it fits her....

  • Carrie Underwood is one of my favorite singers but this version of Umbrella wasn't fit for her voice.  I think it would sound great if she sang it more in a ballad like Mandy Moore (another one of my favorite singers!) did. Mandy Moore did the best version of Umbrella because she makes it sound like a beautiful love song, which it is. Taylor Swift's version/voice sounds like cat's vomiting and I don't know who ever gave her a microphone. She's a talented writer, but definitely not a singer.

  • i wish i could of gone to this concert this was in connecticut right i wish i could of gone but i went to one with just her

  • man i hate that song but i love keith urban

  • haha thats cool how they sing those song i love carrie!!

  • Bad audio...

  • i love this, great re-mix!!

  • i love this song

  • vsdf

  • I have to agree that this is not the song for them.

    You know what I would love to him them sing together?

    I would love to hear Rhiannon with Carries' vocals and Keith's guitar- he kicks Lindsey Buckingham any day.

  • ummmm its ok...

    personally.. i like all time low's version the best!! :)

  • I don't think this song was for Carrie.

  • Not exactly a song fit for Carrie's voice, and DEFINATELY not Keith's... but I don't really like Keith Urban that much so...It's a bit harsh music for this song, even Rihanna's version is softer. Taylor Swift's accustic version is better, I think. (The song doesn't have very orginal lyrics, does it? LOL)

  • @terabithianmileyfan

    taylor will spoil this song..huhuhu

  • They may be country artists, but this is not country music. They are sell outs. This song sucks, no matter who sings it.

  • Cool

  • sing your own songs...this sound terrible...rihanna's version is better

  • they are both amazing live...tremendous. interesting but well done

  • shut upp

    =]

  • I like their verison better then the original.

  • same heree

    =]

    thats prolly cause ima COUNTRY GIRL

    =]

  • If you are a Country girl, listen to Taylor Seift's Umbrella, It's REALLY GOOD

    I swear

  • lol does he call her carrie undie at the end

  • I went to one of their shows...AMAZING! Ahhh very very very very very very very very VERY good cover of this song. And I absolutly love how Carrie always calls Keith Mr. Keith Urban. Never Keith, never Keith Urban, always Mr. Keith Urban. Ahh she cracks me up. They are 2 of my favorite singers so it was so cool they went on tour together! ♥

    Monkey Hugs!

    KeithUrbnxTaySwftlvr

  • KeithUrbnxTaySwftlvr whats a monkey hug?

  • lol well keith urban's fanclub name is monkeyville, so instead of hugs i say monkey hugs =]

  • lol cute

  • Man, I wish I could go

  • LOVE IT!! LOL. I'm going on the 11th in Charleston WV! I can't wait for this one! Awesome!!

  • i was supposed to go to that but i got lynyrd skynyrd tickets instead.. haha. i heard it was a pretty good concert though from kids at my church

  • Keith is amazing... awesome cover...

    I'm going to their concert on the 25th...

    I CAN'T WAIT

  • I love those guys! They r like my fav singers eva!!!!!!!

  • What a joke. Listen to Carrie sing "how great thou art" and come back and talk to me then. I am not a believer but she has one of the best voices around and deserves everything she has and more. As for the Taylor Swift comparision, that is a joke. She is not in the same statosphere as Carrie. The do not even belong in the same discussion. Swift is pretty weak in general and her overkill of videos is gonna bite her in the rear eventually.

  • agreed!!!!

    i LOVE Carrie

  • This is pretty sweet, Keith Urban especially sounds pretty awesome, probably cause I have never heard a guy sing this song before....Carrie is great as always! However, I do have to say that TAYLOR SWIFT has sang this as a cover song for quite a long time now, and they cant quite beat her at it!

  • I love taylor swift too, but she cannot sing live.

  • I think they should release this as a single

  • IZKELWAZUP dont you dare say anything about deaf people cause my older brother is deaf and he is the greatese kid ever!!!

  • hmmm.. i think i might like this better than the original song.

  • I love this song and I love Carrie Underwood. when, i came across this video, i needed to favorite it.

  • I saw them in concert they didnt sing together though, but Keith was so sweet he brought a little girl on stage and she had a cast on her foot and he looks at her and said " guess what" and he pulled out a permanent marker and signed it !!!

    Keith also got off the stage and came into the crowd...it was soooo cool i am definately going to his concerts every time he comes btw it was in wichita kansas

  • i don't think so!They are so good !

  • oh wow i love this. amazing song + i absolutely adore carrie underwood. [[:

  • the people that listen to rap and other type of crap don't noe wat music really sounds like... that rab r&b stuff is hollywood stuff... only deaf people listen to that it's NOT MUSIC JUST A BUNCH OF NOISE!

  • ok you jerk! You know, just cuz someones deaf doesnt mean they have feelings! That is so mean how you put deaf people down like that, what have they ever done to you? what if I said "only black people listen to rap!" (Which Im not saying) you would probably be pretty mad, even if you arent black! You need to get a heart

  • hey, i agree wit that person. its only true

  • Umm, I really don't think Carrie likes Keith, and I think she knows that he got Nicole Kidman pregnant. And she is connected to Chace Crawford. Carrie Rocks!!!

  • why every artist sings this stupid song? ... mandy moore, vanilla sky, taylor swift, manic street preachers, ... and carrie with keith :P

  • y did they do her song?, i mean it is good, but i was just wondering

  • That was good i like this version better. Carrie is the bomb!

  • lol yes!!

  • I love this song and they do a good job at it, especially since they have not been touring together for long. I'm sure it was awesome live. HE ROCKS! and so does she.

    I'm not sure why people that are not their fans waste time leaving negative comments

  • I love this version too, Thank's, They are so gooood!Thank's Keith!

  • U know what, U wrong, They are so good, specialy keith, He try to give us everythink, and U don't get that, If U like them then go there.He try to give us best, and He alwaeys did,Keith play from the His heart and soul.

    That's why we like him sooooo much ,if U like it or not,that's Your problem!

  • You can tell with the way Carrie looks at Keith that she likes him.. Just an observation. She did some other weird look at Keith during the Rochester, NY concert, too.

  • If I was that close to Keith, I'd probably give him some weird looks, too! :P Or just kind of whimper.

  • No, you Suck

  • No, you Suck

  • I agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • they sound like they're karaoking with the ella's. pitiful

  • no one can quite do the Ella's like Rihanna

  • This song is such a universal song.

    It's gone through so many music genres.

    Rihanna/ Jay Z - Hip Hop/R&B

    My Chemical Romance - Rock

    Mandy Moore - Pop

    and now country.

    I love this version. =]

  • they are great! :) they were just having fun! it may not have been a good song for either of them but they pulled it off!!! two thumbs up! i love love love them!!!!!!!

  • i saw them this past saturday and they didn't sing anything together :( but keith did try out a cell phone wave which was pretty awesome haha

  • Biloxi, MS show was good but like you said I wanted Carrie to come back out.

  • i love rihanna but i love keith urban way more so i think this version is way better and they rocked and i love how keith urban puts his own twist to songs and girlpleeeez04 i ALREADY saw him on his "love, pain, and the whole crazy world tour!!!!

    ♥♥♥KEITHURBAN♥♥♥

  • shame on rihanna. this song is soooo easy to sing that's y they covered this song

  • keith and carrie did it so much better than that hip hop girl!

  • Wow. I'm not impressed by their rendition. At all. Mandy Moore covered this song too and I absolutely loved her version.

  • I don't like the other version but this one is better and they made it fun! I love Keith Urban and Carrie Underwood is great! I really hope they do this at the Charlotte Concert!!

  • Yeahh. This is so odd but I love Keith. He's such a goober. I kinda hope he does this at my concert. lol

  • I thought it was way better than Rihanna's version. I cant stand her squeaky voice so this made a change.

  • ahhhh! I wanna go to their concert sooo bad! but they aren't coming to here! i'm so upset!

  • like to see carrie do more pop. shes a good singer so she can pull it off.

  • Awesome! FRANCE loves Keith!!!!!

  • it doesnt really fit, but it kinda works! wow keith urban is hot

  • who would think that keith could do r&b!!! not a bad effort seeing as he's an aussie country singer

  • This is just funny...you can tell they were having fun with the song...I honestly can't stand this song...but its making me laugh hearing them try.

  • I like it,They can try whatever They want.Keith is soooo good,I like them both!

  • I love Carrie, but this sooooooo isn't her song. No offense AT ALL, but she is totally country and it is not her type of music!

  • LMFAO!

  • I love Carrie but I don't like this version. As a country song, I think it would be better done less "rocked out". It needs to be more soft/emotional and real.

  • haha thatss soo coool :]

    He Is iss cute

  • This isn't as good as I thought it would be.

  • Does Carrie dance?  Can't recall a video where she does.

  • gotta love the banjo, in a hip hop song lol

  • Awesome! Love Keith and Carrie

  • then why did you watch it? if you dont like either idiot

  • Ditto to what you said. I'll never get why people click on a video if they hate the people in it.

  • this is AMAZINGG! i CAN NOT wait until i see them on march 7th!! =D mm!

  • Are they on tour together? because that would be an AMAZING show

  • Yes, they are co-headlining a tour. You can get the tour dats and places at either of their websites. Plus on the off days, Carrie is headlining her own tour with Josh Turner.

  • i think-well i KNOW. carrie and keith do it 100% better than rhianna! they have better voices, do an amazing duett, and have better sound to it. it sounds just...nicer. rhinnas version almost sounds...mean? anyway great video!

  • I like the Rihanna version more,but they make an amazing duet.

    Maybe if I could listen to them sing it in a music video,I might like it more,better sound quality XD

  • she is amazingly good looking

  • HAVE ANYMORE OF KEITH AND CARRIE? I'm goin to one of the concerts on march 3rd. god they sound amazing together! <3<3<3

    CAN'T WAIT!!!

  • AMAZING! We need some more duets with these two! the Best in country music!

    Great rendition of Umbrella. Love Carrie's vocals at the bridge of the song and Keith is so amazing and talented. I can't wait until I see them in Omaha, Nebraska on March 7th!!!!!!!

  • Oh, your in for one hell of a show, Pam. Keith Urban is the defition of sheer talent and perfection live performing. You have to see this chap in concert. His shows are like a drug, once you see him once (an Urban virgin), you're addicted and wanting more of him.

    You can listen to your Kenny Chesnut, Rascal Flatts for now, but once you see him live, you will NOT regret it. And I'm no sales-marketer..

  • i shaw keith urban with deana carter a few yrs ago and im seeing him and carrie next month...cant wait

  • haha i totally AGREE! i wan an urban virgin back when i saw him in july and then it's like bam- i thought i knew and liked him before and then after his concert was when i wanted to see him again soo bad- it really is addicting- he's just such an amazing performer