Leona Lewis vs Alexandra Burke: Without You

[nawnawjunior]

I like alexandra voice because she has not only big voice but also beautiful tone

[abstellkamer]

leonaaaaa-3

[kcwacey]

both fantastic.... thats why they both have gone far ... simple as

[1994rollercoaster1]

there both just as good in different ways...

[ordinaaryy]

Alexandra!!!!

[shardsofsteel]

First the sound is bad quality. But it's really a bad idea to compare artists. It's like comparing different cultures food. You can't compare Japanese food with West African food. It's your taste. I personally think Leona has a fantastic voice, but I don't care for most of her music. Alexandra's voice is different. It is pitched lower, throatier (imo) and heavier. So comparing does no good here. Your talking preference not quality.

[MarkSmithHD]

Alexandra by far.

[OOO1239]

Leona RAPED Alex

[Stefano94x]

Alexandra.

[jess2746]

Why compare them?

Each has its value.

And clearly heights have different voices.

It is a human problem having to say who is better ...

[merrynutlump]

there is no competition! leona kills alex

[OMGImJustToAwesome]

Leona Lewis Duh, Thats A No Brainer.

[Endriking]

is this a question????Of course Leona

[sarah6777]

leona <3

[Musicluv3R4life1997]

Leona's Better, Obviously......Luv U Leona!

[cantbeliev]

@Musicluv3R4life1997

i don't understand why Alex always makes the note lower@"@

that just make the song's original feeling being lost~

TOO BAD~

[TuneeTube]

Why compare them seriously? Their both good so stop being a dick and appreciate that two women singers have powerfull voices.

[Pandalady366]

They are both great, i do favour leona but they are both brilliant!

[nika0zibrat]

leona is higher, even i can sing alexandra !

[Shiil4v]

omg how much i looove leonaaaaaa

[IwillbethereMJJ]

Leona ALL THE WAY!

[theone225]

LEONA

[candydarling947]

You cant compare them to each other because both are so differently.!

[12345Elenia]

leona lewis beats alexandra burke hands down :) xxx

[xDlauraxP]

leona lewis

[shinjuya]

i like the both of them

[Quaxiify]

defenitiv LEONA LEWIS!

[twinsmummy119]

leona lewis anyday x x x

[Allysonharkins]

I swear at 1.23 Alexandra starts feeling herself up :L

[Iphoneuser204]

LEONA

[lilytrotmanx]

Leonaa all the wayy :)

[PaulAnt2008]

Both artists are fantastic in their own right. Leona hits the high notes with incredible ease, and as such, is better at ballad-type songs. Meanwhile, Alex hits the lower notes that Leona can't, and is a better all-rounder.

For this song, therefore, Leona wins, but overall, it depends on personal preference. I love them both - they make me proud to be British! :P

[cocobandit]

I think they are both good :0)

[Malibusun84]

I think it's easy to state that in MY opinion Leona is a much better singer!

[AliLoveMusic]

Fair play to Alex, she tried her hardest and I love her voice.

But Leona smashes this. :)

[PorkPieish]

alexandra burke all the way :) i could listen to her 'all night long'

[mizzsadiee123]

No affence to alex but leona is better

[lolz835]

i gotta say i prefer leona lewis alewandra berke is great n all but leona is a true star xx :)

[mrbeccabooboo]

I gotta say..,

I love you and everything alex, but,

Leona is soo much better!

she hardly tries to sing! :)

[CKFIERCE1]

I love Alex more than Leona. Alex has that dark, powerful tone :) :). Kind of old school :)

[MallyPallyO]

marry me,

[softballgeek153]

They are both amazing singers, but they have different styles. Leona has the type of voice good for the slow, deep songs like Listen, where as Alex can sing almost anything she wants. Though, this wasn't a very good song choice for her.

I love Alexandra Burke more than anyone in the world, but Leona sang this song better.

[Endriking]

i like Alexandra but love Leona she is the best singer in the world

[btj188]

The truth of the matter is, Alexandra has JACK SHIT on Leona. I will admit- Alexandra has a stronger lower register, but thats it. Notice Leona sings in the orginal key and doesnt have it changed, unlike Alexandra who has it moved to a lower key. Leona is so flexible and verisitile with all songs- a true superstar!

[rawfannation101]

Leona shits all over Alex when it comes to vocals.

[PixieLottStan55]

If the question is who is more talented?? Alexandra would win fucking hands down! Leona is boring! when she performs all she does is stand there! she sings ballad after ballad.......she just bores me to tears.......Alexandra can sing all types of songs; ballads and upbeat party songs..........She dances and sings when she performs and looks interesting..........Leona has a certain type of voice and is talented granted....but Alexandra for me......pisses all over Leona!

[btj188]

@PixieLottStan55 You couldnt be more WRONG! If you researched Leona's tour videos you will see that she doesnt just stand there and sing ballads, she is so flexible and versitile when it comes to singing songs. Your lack of knowledge is showing you up here seen as Alexandra isnt nearly as successful as Leona, and Leona is obviously doing something right seen as she is an international superstar :)

[Endriking]

@PixieLottStan55 well i think you don't listen to Leona's songs she has mostly upbeat songs in her album.And in the tour she did in the u.k she has danced

[LeonaLewisIsAmazing]

I think they are both amazing versions and both different at the same time. If you like the husky, soulful version it's definitely Alexandra's and if you like the powerful emotional version it's Leona but I honestly think these two are fantastic female singers.

[itskylestyle]

Leona is better at this song, though I'd have to give I'll be there to Alex (if we're comparing their performances).

[JFletch87]

Clearly Leona, no contest here!

[JFletch87]

Clearly Leona on this one - no contest at all!

[ImBleedingLov3]

Leona belted Alex out effortlessly :/

[UserLosAngeles]

Leona won 2 years before alex, but that doesnt mean anything becuase we're meant to be commenting on the video, and during these performances they both had the same amount of experience. Alex is really good and soulful ... but shes no where near the level of leona ... Leona is special.

Plus, Leona has been in the public eye for 4 years nw and shes still so nice and down to earth. Alex has been around for a year nd shes already a bit cocky and big headed, nevertheless, shes a great artist.

[merrynutlump]

LEONNNAA !!!

[Darrylyates09]

to be honest with you all. everyone gives alexandra stick. she has only been the winner for 1 year and leona has been winner for 4 years so obviously leona going to be better atm. but alexandra will be better she got a stronger voice where she can do ballads and up tempo songs, alexandra in my eyes is far better

[sheMan32]

@Darrylyates09 it has nothing to do with how long Leona has been in the publice eye, when they preformed this they both had the same amount of experience. Put it this way (this is the blatant truth) Leona's rendition slaughters Alex's- but their both phenomenal singers. Although, i must admit i did like echo/spirit more than i like overcome

[AmyEmmerson]

I Love both of them but i like Leona better because she is great! Go leona

[RoryDL2009]

I sooo wish Mariah had mentored Leona for a week - she would have been like S**T!

[BlackSunshine505]

Leona...<3

[itskylestyle]

Why?

[MissLilacRose]

Alex's voice is deeper & Leona's is high pitched. U can't take anything away from these 2 gals, they're both good and they won't eva sound the same. People shouldn't be comparing the 2. Mariah met Alex during the Xfactor's master class and she was blown away by Alex.Leona has a head start on Alex,so it's not fair 2 compare the 2. Alex is already showing her potential,so watch this girl fly high cos her fans are behind her all the way! God's blessings on both Leona & Alex. Go girls,go!

[emzybo21]

Leona's voice is far better ,, can't wait for her tour!!

[roktyp78]

Sorry, but there is no comparisson, Leona is muuuuuuuuuch better. She leaves Alexandra far far behind.

[RoryDL2009]

Leona is miles ahead and has the X Factor. Alexandra stands out in this country but Leona stands out across the world.

[ibelieveintomorrow]

Honestly to say, i dont know about leona till i hear Bleeding Love, then i search about her & just know she's winner of 2006 & listen some song by her at X-factor

She really famous since BLEEDING LOVE cause this song is so BEAUTIFUL MELODY & LYRICS !

If this song not sang by Leona, its just sang by someone... i think it should be famous the world too

PS : I HAVE NO AGAINTS WITH LEONA, i like her voice. She has beautiful smooth voice but not the best. Not only her can sing !

[johnsmith8848]

hmm a duet of this woulda made a ultimate performance. alex deal with the low notes. n leona take off with the high

[piplup1262]

leona

[tururuturu]

Leona is better in the higher notes, but alexandra's lower register is great! They're both really tallented but different artists

[ruledaworld21]

LEONA MERKED HER BUT...Alex was good 2...ALEX RULES....BUT LEONAS BETTA...!

[a7abdullah]

LEONA LEWIS

alexandra burke

[CrazyMegaTeen]

even though i admit leona has better vocal ability that is not always what makes the version better or worse its just some sprt of quality in Alexandra's voice that makes me like her version better that Leona doesnt have obviously i listen to Alex and Leona but im a bigger fan of Alex and i know there is something in Leonas voice that her fans will like bette i mean its about connecting and different artists connect with differen people and it just so happens i connect more with alexandra.

[Raoulirshan]

1. Mariah

2. Leona

3. Alexandra (but I still love her:) )

[timmothycat]

Leona is sooooooo boring, alexandra has hmore emotion to her voice and she's more likeable

[tburke644]

u cannot be serious comparing a vocalist like LEONA LEWIS to a person who atempts to sing.... alex can sing but leona can SING!!! leona's in a totally diff league and it is an insult to compare her to anyone but eg. mariah carey, whitney houston, j hud or celine dion... other great female SINGERS!!!

[xxmondo14]

personnaly i think shes better singing wise than j hud and mariah, celine and whit maybe not, but alex can SING too, and the differene is she can also PREFORM!! they are both different, i love them both, leona more tho :)

[nwt1234]

i do like alexandra songs on her album but leona jus diff class

[brianpaulbeckford]

as nwt1234 said leona pissed and shit all over her

[nwt1234]

compare 2:16 - 2:21 to 2:23 - 2:28. lol i think that ends the argument. leona pisses all over her.

[SeventhSanctum1]

ur comment made me laugh i just had a mental picture of leona hovering over alex and pissing on her lol

[MrSwitchitup]

just to say u can tell leona doesnt need to put as much effort as alex to get the high and long notes but i like alex as well

[xrebel4evrx]

Leona Lewis is so much better!!! God its not even funny!!! Nd okay Alex does have an unreal body but her face is like that of a trnsvestite!! Nyways id prefer to look like Leona instead of alexandER burke!! We will c how well bad boys does in America

[SeventhSanctum1]

ur so right , leona does have a long face but her eyes , lips and skin colour are much nicer , alex has a massive jaw her mouth is so big

[ibelieveintomorrow]

I dont care what u saying but I SWEAR ALEX LOOK PRETTY THAN LEONA (at lest for me, i'm a girl ok ?) even though maybe LEONA sing better than ALEX alittle bit

LEONA has long face, it not mean she ugly. She's nice girl but not the best or better than Alex

Click thump down ? Ok cuz i dont care.e.e.e.e.e & i dont care.e.e.e.e !!!

[Gobberella]

alex has more power behind her vocals and they flow out without effort leona needs to push a bit to get the sound out. Leona is a higher voice, where alex is lower but on power and natural ease its alex all the way

[Twinkletoesoxoxox]

sorry leona fans but alex murked it

[freeyourmind3009]

Alex is the better singer and looker. Leona looklike a horse the bitch ugly. Leona voice is a nigthmare like her hero Mariah. I hate Leona.

[Twinkletoesoxoxox]

I no wat u mean n i agree she looks lyk a horse. alex is a better singer nuff sed

[SeventhSanctum1]

leona is fit

[SeventhSanctum1]

ur the freak

[sheherhello]

Alex, and Leona isn't better looking then Alex. Leona isn't nice looking in my opinion and she is boring as hell. Let don't mention she refuse to have any black men in her videos.

[pekalr]

I get that the music business is competitive, but some people here act like there's a place for only one female singer in the market, so they have to do the utmost to bash the "competition". Please.

Comparing Leona and Alexandra is like comparing apples and oranges. Vocally they are both amazingly talented, so whom one likes better is just a matter of preference. For my part I wish them both success.

[karymarl1]

Leonitaa!!!!!!!!!! she's more cute!!!

[karymarl1]

Leonitaa!!!!!!!!!! she's more cute!!!

[X7nati]

ALEX

[nananana3333]

LEONA!!!! check out my vid 'Leona Lewis is better that burke"

[logan7863]

LEONA LEWIS :)

[MrBTS134]

LEONA!!!!

[cmontgomeryx]

i would say leona, i think she has a nicer voice than alex.

remember to vote for joe mcelderry everyone!

[love4musicuk]

Leona, and I'm a fan of them both. Leona has the voice that Alex could not get. And Alex has the low notes that Leona goes quiet on

[Laquinnable]

Alex tries to hard. Leona is much better

[XBABiiXNiiCOL3X]

LEONA !!!!!

[Angel919ac]

Laura Broad is better

[EnglishGal92]

Leona, no question

[robahmet1]

Alex is a much better singer

[aapril88]

they actually both sounded quite god but they both have their own individual sound..... comparing to detemine who sounds the best may be biased upon who sounds more like mariah rather than their vocal ability

[alextwowin]

Alex was technically perfect with this song Leona was all over the place squeeking and trilling in all the wrong places Alex is powerful and a techically better singer pitchy my ass this is just blind Leona worship.

[Twinkletoesoxoxox]

agreed

[jaycewheeled]

This is really a difficult comparison for me. I tend to remember Mariah Carey's re-make and it's out of question that Leona is more similar to her than Alexandra.

But...what if this song were re-made by, for example, Toni Braxton? Then probably Alexandra's version would have been more close to what we knew about this song.

I can't really choose, Alexandra and Leona are both great.

[hapwell]

leona easily hits those top notes at the end and alexandra fails miserably. Theres your answer

[hello07601]

Ur an idiot In terms of vocals it is leona who is versatile she can sing any genre. Explain to me how alexandra is more versatile and dont give me that shit that she can dance because she fuckin cant all she does is strut i see girls drunk in clubs dancing better than alexandra she cant market herself as a dancer cuz she cant rank with beyonce britney ciara etc Alexandra is shit and shes proved shes shit. Have you heard tht mess of a first single its laughable.

[Carlieboi]

Hell No, leona isn't versatile, she can only sing ballads, she can barely sing upbeat songs...

ALEXANDRA sang a range of songs

Leona sang like 1 or 2 upbeat songs..

and struggled.

THEREFORE alex is more versatile

[hello07601]

ur one thick nigga. Leona has done multiple uptempos she can sing anything better than alexandra. Leona can sing uptempo, ballads, rock (olympics), indie/acoustic(strangers, bit ama performance, operatic (ildivo performance olympic aria), rnb, she can sing anything with consumate ease. Alexandra can barely sing in tune

[Carlieboi]

hello07601, u are some racist dick, and i am not a nigga u dumbass, fuck you ican't be bothered to argue with someone who is really stupid and racist and just really stubborn, your calling me a nigga but the person ur defending is half black..

stupid

[numba1danman]

alex sang upbeat songs .. they were oka but very very pitchy

alex sang balladss, but she has a contralto voics....no high notes and again very pitchy

leona snag mid tempo- ballad songs and guss what they were perfect in every way

btw leona was regarded as being very nervous on x factor i think we should compare when leona performs bleeding love which btw sold over 9 million copies and when alex performs her song live

[Carlieboi]

ohplz ur clearly a leona addict, ilike them both but prefer alexandra and ino her faults yes sometimes pitchy but very rare, how can you say when leona sang upbeat songs they were perfect in every way...

[numba1danman]

i aint addicted to anything but red bull....the afct si alex doesnt have as unique of a voice as leona, alex will not sell 15 million records..citation given if wanted....and alex will not be remembered in 10 years time other than that otehr girl who won x factor.

leona is outstanding and alex is quite good...its like comparing whitney houston with rihanna,,,,theyre different, alex very much of the time is pitchy btw

[Carlieboi]

Lol redbull, i'll admit tht leona's voice is more unique, alex will remembered in 10 years obviously.. and no its not like comparing whitney houston and rihanna to be fair its like comparing whitney houston and mariah carey ¬¬

[hello07601]

Alexandras vocals are average at best she can not compete on a world level like leona can

[hello07601]

Leona can sing any genre of music that makes her more versatile than alexandra alexandra cant sing full stop so pisshhhhh...........

[Duuudette786]

hands down leona even though Alex is really good too!

[hello07601]

alexandra is the thick black scum at the bottom of the barrell

leona is premium champagne

[Carlieboi]

hello07601 FUCK YOU RACIST DICKHEAD

[hello07601]

im black you idiot

[RoryDL2009]

No competition - LEONA (for so many reasons...)

I still like Alex though.

[ClaireyThePinkFairy]

leona hands down!!!

[johnsonjordan1995]

alex is rubbish compared to leona.

leona x10000000000000000000.

[nwt1234]

i think there pretty even when there singing low and quite but when they go powerful it's laughable how much beter leona is .

[charnieeX]

leona!!

[AxCherryx]

Leona deffo!!!

nd its not coz i hate alex, leona did actually sing it better!

GO LEONA!!!! :D

x

[Blaxigon]

Alex stays kinda low throughout the song, even when the chorus makes the climax whereas leona does that jump where it goes higher =) lover leonas voice

[xrebel4evrx]

Leona Lewis is simply breathtaking!!! Her preformance was stunnuing!! Alexs was good!!!!! Alex is a good singer but Leona is just so much better!! Judging on voice quality Leona Lewis is probably at themoment one of the best singers in the world!! Alexandra is not and i doubt she ever will be!!!

[Endriking]

ALex is amazing,i'm sure she will do well,but if you face the trueth,Leona is the greatest.I hate comparing great things,but this time i have to give it to Leona.She the best singer of any time.They are diffrent singers.

[jtstar08]

leona of course, i mean compare :

2:16 and 2:24 lol

alex is still really good but no where near leonas league imo

[Mariy94220]

leona's is better than alex because leona has the seem tesiture of mariah carey i think but alex has the voice is soul

[90katrien]

Leona by far!!!!!!!!!!

[Angelfully]

Alexandra's voice is rich and soulful. Leona has a sweet tone. I like both, but Alex's voice gives me chills where as Leona's only soothes my ears.

[chicklover2002]

both amazing... leona has a slightly better voice but alexandra is more of a performer with an excellent voice where leona only depands on her soulful voice! both good in a different way!

[bonjour100]

Leona definitely.

Her voice is far more audible in her arrangement. Although, Alexandra has a better control over her lower register, but that's because she is more of a contralto/deeper mezzo, whereas Leona is more of a lyric. You can't really compare.

[spela2812]

Leona just nails it. She's Fantastic!!!

[PARANA8]

lo mismo opino naim2011, leona te hace sentir la cancion con su dulce voz y la forma de matizar wow. Alex tien una potente voz pero nunca como leona, lo siento.

[naim2011]

LEONA'S VOICE KILLS ME .. WOW