Added: 4 years ago
From: americanidolfn
Views: 170,341
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (133)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hw swt, nt her vioce or her luks bt d tune

  • Not a good song for her

  • @Turkijoje77 She sounds like a big pregnant water buffalo.

  • I Love Barbra Streisand, BUT the FACT is that Barbra Never sang this song Live!

    Its a hard song to sing, and Jordin did it Live, and very well... Probably if she was in studio, she would do it even better, don't know! But you can never know how Barbra would manage to sing it live, cause she never had the courage to do it! (as well as Memories, which Barbra never sung live)...

  • great voice....pretty face and fat...what could you ask more....

  • @MsL3nny what?? fat?

  • I love her Voice ... Amazing!!!

  • She has a good voice but not as good as Barbara S. and besides, she seems to be afraid when she's singing.

  • @ayoyotle I have dug in the whole youtube... do you know where I can find the Barbra Streisand's version?

  • great voice... :))

  • I had no idea, that she was in american idol oO

    Good performance.

  • Barba does it better !

  • She'd get it

  • I Got Stabbed by an Ice-Cream Scooper!

  • just great!!!

  • What she gotta do...

    She is a woman in love

    And she's talking to me

    It's a right she defends

    Over, and over again

    She is a woman in love.

  • Nice dress!~ 

  • Okay if she's a woman in love then who is she in love with?... Mee... Lol!~

    Damm she looks sexy a 1:55!~

  • Okay if she's a woman in love then who is she in love with?... Mee... Lol!~

  • 11 people suck dick, just sayin'!~

  • i lovee her voice she  is do damm good!!!!!

  • @ilovechocolate091 I know Isn't it?

  • what a voice

  • beautiful song and beautiful performance ;)

  • Yeha the judges were right when they said she was falling off all through the song, but then again it had it's good moments (ecxspecially "it's a right I defend" the first time) and when it did she shinned like the sun! And plus I like her, so way to go Jordin Sparks!~ Because I have to tell you something right quick: when she sings I swear that sparks fly!~

  • Yhe judges were right when they said she was falling off all through the song, but then again it had it's good moments (ecxspecially "it's a right I defend" the first time) and when it did she shinned like the sun! And plus I like her, so way to go Jordin Sparks!~ Because I have to tell you something right quick: when she sings I swear that sparks fly!~

  • This brings back wonderful memories of the only AL I ever watched. All because of Jordin.. luv her

  • I just love the little eye twitch at 0:53 .

  • @obletag Lol!~ 

  • Soo long way from superstar CAROLA she is,this song she does soo mutch better..........And soo sexy she is

  • I´m not Barbra´s fan, but i think she´s a great artist and this song is gorgeus with her voice. It´s difficult, so, i can´t make a positive comparative. I hope this girl can grow as singer.

  • Carola is better.

  • miserably

  • Jesteś piękna jak i ta piosenka wz Twoich ust bbrzi pięknie

  • Well there were a few pitchy points, and sometimes shrieky... but goddamn I remember this was probably the boldest, hardest choice of song that entire season.  And I doubt anyone on AI from any season couldve sung it better. Very good considering the difficulty level.

  • i think she she sounds like beyonce...

    ...a bit : O

  • @A2Stew Beyonce thinks everyone is her vasal...Dont like her at all.. Jordan however is pure and enigmatic.

  • shes so beautiful here i like her make up here!!!nice song love it..

  • Great voice. But she's either got a really small head or shoulders like a football player!

  • streisand and gibb...Guilty album 1980--- i really am too old...:)

  • Her timing is totaly off.

    She sings it fine but she needs to listen to the music and not just sing in her own rythm.

  • very powerful voice...

    her voice make her in the top...!

  • What a freakin' hard song to sing!!! No one will ever be able to nail those notes with the clarity and commitment that Streisand did (save say Celine ), but Jordin did very well!!!! She's a fantastic singer! I could listen to this girl sing all day.

  • Obviously not in the same league of Barbra, but she actually did a very nice job with this one; I'm impressed.

  • What a beautiful woman... and this lips! ;-)

  • tadpole in love

  • Mao maning bayhana tigkuha ug lamaw sa amoa last year karon uy dato na xa...

  • This one is better left to Ms. Streisand.

  • @billyboylb If Ya Think This Is ''Interesting'' Check Out Liz McFarnon, They Need To Leave Alone

  • @ninjabluewings Yes, that was interesting...:)

  • @billyboylb  you may want to watch liz mcclarnons version. its real good

  • @curiositynz Yeah, i was surprised that I like it...but it was pretty good...:)

  • When you compare Jordin's Idol performances with the ones we are watching this year, it is amazing just how much more accomplished she was! And she would be the last to compare herself to Barbra

  • Yes, mogsmeg I couldn't agree more. There is only one that could compare with Jordan and that is Crystal this year. Their styles are different but both are amazing. Jordan is far my fav. She is truly amazing..

  • wow piękna Kobieta i ten głos

  • Of all the "Idols" over the years, I would say she gave the best performances

  • she was great on idol, but Kelly Clarkson and Fantasia were just as great and just as consistent.

  • Wow!!

  • strong voice- great singer!

  • the original is barbra streisand.... jordin did ok.... but barbra is way better!!!

  • no one could sing this better than streisand, but Jordan comes close, in my opinion.

  • Yup, no one can beat barbara, but celine dion will give her a run for her money!! this version it's ok, i wouldn't buy it.

  • She looks gorgeous and sings with such emotion. Who's the original?

  • Barbara streisand

  • Thank you.

  • I get goose bumps every time I hear her sing. She is amazing.

  • i love her voice, and she's so beautiful.

  • She is beautiful.

  • regine velasquez' version(apart from the orig.) is still the rendition to beat....

  • SHE HAS AN AMAZING VOICE! wow!!!

  • She has a beautiful voice, but it's not macthing to the song. She have to calm down in the start of the song. Like barbara streisand.

  • Love her voice. MWUAH JORDIN..

  • nmot her best but okay shes awesome

  • What's up with the crappy camera work? :|

  • Still to this day i can never understand why the judges ripped into her after this performance.

    Also, she's never looked as good as in this video.

  • Jordin looked beautiful when she sang this song.She still does.

  • She looks just as beautiful but much healthier than all those anorectic models.

  • nice nice

  • She needs more training and voice control and soul. But otherwise she has "It."

  • Hats off!

    You're simply amazing

  • cool

  • great job Jordin!

  • i luv herrrrrrr!!!!!1

  • the problem with american idol and any other singing competition is that you will always compare their performance to the original and you shouldn't. just listen to their performance as if you've never heard that song before

  • But sometimes it's impossible to pretend that you never heard the original and quite difficult not to compare the two versions. This is especially true when an AI performer chooses the signature song of an extremely famous singer like Streisand, Whitney, Mariah, etc.

  • Yes, the problem is also if they chose an unknown song they will generally loose on the popularity vote. I think as long as they don't butcher the song they should choose the most recognizable song that is vocally challenging, but within their range.

  • I Love You I Love You I Love You

    Welcome to Moti's channel

    Lets Go Pretty Bash

  • I love the way Jordin sang this.

  • I agree with you!!!! Even though it will be compared to the original!!!! She still sang it well, and performed it with emotion!!! This was good 2 say she was only 16 0r 17 years old at the time!!!

  • jordin simply sparks because she gave her best in her singing career for those who have bad write ups about her those are d people who doesnt heve a single percent of what Jordin Sparks have so just keep ur mouth close,set back and relax listen to Jordin Sparks music,then ur mind and soul wl be relaxed too.God bless

  • I think she sings it pretty well but it's not one of her best performances.

  • any comparison between her and streisand is a little ridiculous. Streisand is the voice of her generation and she was nearly 40 when she sang this....jordin is an 18 year old girl who probably didnt know this song before she rehearsed it for the show. She did a very appealing version of it and put some nice touches on it.

  • Not anywhere in the same vocal league as Barbara Streisand, she shoudln't ever attempt songs from her, her tone, vibratto control, amongst MANY other things are not up to par.

  • Well anyways I still love her!!

  • i don't understand why y'all put the camazoncams dot com????????????

  • This is my favorite song!!

  • This is a different version video clip wise as what was actually shown on Fox. The real version (CAMERA ANGLE WISE) is this here------->

    watch?v=3hsgPa1yw3I

    just paste that after the youtube dot com portion in the url.

  • Luved it!!!

  • THIS GIRL CAN BLOW!!!

  • She sang this song FABULOUSLY!!! I am not a fan of Barbara Streisand at all, but I love this song and Jordin's version was done perfectly!

  • The last time I heard this song Barbara Streisand was singing it. A Woman In Love is a beautiful song and a great choice for Jordan. She sang this beautifully. I loved it!

  • I love Jordin

  • I listen to this kind of music. :)

  • But the way she sings it is good!!!!!

  • @Pehmolelu87 old and boring??!!! you need to listen yourself some Barbra and Judy!!!!! this generation concerns me with their music choices....

  • She's great!

  • I don't know, but you might as well try, right? go jordin! (and for the record I actually thought she was really good but then again I've never heard the song before)

  • She was great, most artists we all listen to daily are "pitchy" live.

  • IM in canada. Can I vote from Montreal?

  • Man.....the beginning of this is awesome....she DOES start to become real pitchy... but man......the intensity that she sings this song is just awesome. I got chills the first time I watched it. :)

  • she's just incredibly beautiful in this video

  • i cant vote for her cause im in the middle east but plz americans vote fo her shes the best

  • SHE BETTER WIN!!!!

  • shes great

  • I can't vote because I live in the U.K, but I just have to say that I hope America votes for Jordin Sparks to be the winner because she is easily the best contestant this season.

  • i love jordin she is awsome she will win and blake will be the runner up

  • i cant believe the judges, this is one of her best performances one of the best of american idol actully

  • Vote for 3 women in the final.

  • It would be nice for another Female Top 3. Like from Season 3, Fantasia, Diana, and Jasmine.

  • Jordin Sparks! American Idol 2007

  • Jordin is the real thing !!! She's gonna win, she's the one who got it all, beautiful strong voice, nice non-poor-thing personality. VOTE FOR JORDIN !!!

  • I think what kept her this far was NOT JUST her voice, but also her stage presents, how she performs. Like people say, "the truth lies in the eyes", she's got gorgeous features.

  • really good control

  • wow!! How can she sing like that... to think that shes only 17... go go jordin!!!

  • She was soooo Not Pitchy!

  • leoplurodon11, i agree with you ,it was sooo not pitchy!

  • The comments by the judges really shocked me, because I do rate this as one of my favorites for her.

  • @americanidolfn they were hard on here most the season... which didnt make sense why as she was good, its her voice

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more