Added: 3 years ago
From: aphordonte
Views: 2,999,030
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,980)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I've never been to a video where one of the highest rated comments was negative?!?!?.....

  • Etta James didn't like Beyonce, because when Beyonce was invited to sing for the president, she sang this. Etta was mad, because it's her song, and she felt that if anyone should sing 'At Last' for the president, it should be her. And I totally agree with her. She was the original singer, and she deserves it. I do think that Beyonce did a good cover, but no one can compare to Etta. Beyonce should have chosen a different song.

  • Tina Moore has a version of "At Last" from 1995 she is a R&B singer that was back in the 90's she sang the mess out this song!!!

  • Beyonce's version of "At Last" is much better than Christina's version. Sure Aguilera has amazing vocal abilities, as well as Beyonce, but Christina has the habit of screaming and adding compassion and anger into a sweet song, her rugged shifting through the notes takes me away from this song, Beyonce did it like it was meant to be.

  • I can understand the words as Beyonce is singing.

  • absolutely beautiful

  • Beyonce, technically, is a mezzo-soprano but with vocal technique she sing "At Last" with tonality of Etta James.

    Etta is a legend but .... great great Beyoncé

    Sorry my English, but I am italian

  • oh and another thing, I also love Christina, but she really carried away when she sang this song and It's not as beautiful as the way Beyonce sang it!

  • Etta James without a doubt is one of the most amazing things that have ever happened to music, but lets give a shot for a beautiful and talented singer like Beyonce, and stop saying that she won't ever sing like Etta, well, it's impossible! every singer and his voice, Dah! so I wanna say, that there is no singer that sang this song better that this gifted young lady,so, Beyonce? you are my idol, I love you for who you are.

  • I really don't understand how anybody could possibly think that Christina Aguilera's rendition at Etta James's funeral (of all places) was better than this. This is hauntingly beautiful

  • First time I've heard this version and love it,miles better than the ghastly Aguilera distortion.

    One poster on here says that soul is the whole point of the song.This song came out in 1941

    and wouldn't be interpreted as a soul song then,so why now?

  • "NO matter what they say" SHE IS AMAZING.

  • Ewww at 2:36, lol

  • @MizzGigglez86 O,o what r u talkin about she wasn't even singing at 2:36 Lol

  • @jennaleigh226 The still shot is what I was talking about

  • OMG Christina is Better and Etta is better than Christina. And Beyoncé Who ?

  • @LeoArouca1 stfu you cunt!! beyonce is better than xtina anyday!!!

  • Beyoncé's is vocally amazing, but this version lacks of soul, which is the whole point of this song.

  • @NausAllien that was the whole point of dreamgirls. Lol she has no soul in her voice. that's why white people aren't threatned by her. :D

  • @jaraandrew100 typical negro smdh!!! Beyonce has alot of soul and atleast her caucasian fans recognize the fact that she is different than most of her peers because unlike all of them, she has soul and she can do any type of genre and fit right in so that bullshit you talking is nonsense!!!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 yeah it's just my opinion. i just think she tries to hard that's all. it's not in her the way it's in jennifer hudson or christina aguilera or jill scott. again just my opinion.

  • @jaraandrew100 and what do you mean by it not being in the way of jhud,xtina,and jill scott?????? because if you're trying to say that they did better than Beyonce then you really have lost your damn mind!!!!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 Christina has the most serious voice, that is scraping his voice sings as well as Etta James. But Beyonce sing it very well also.

  • I love Beyonce.

  • @NausAllien This version does NOT lack soul ok!!!!!!! yall need to cut that mess out seriously because that woman has TONS of soul!!!!!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 Can you force to think the way you do? No. I have my opinion and you have to respect it. I like her and think she usually has tons of soul like you said. But this song doesn't have any soul. It just her voice singing each note with ease and perfection, but has no emotions. Sorry if you disagree, but you don't have the right to force me to change my mind.

  • beyonces version is awesome!

  • RIP Etta!!!!

    

  • Etta James' version was a cover also... why do people want to forget this? -_-

  • You make it sound like she did absolutely horrible on this song. I want to hear you sing it better!

  • Beyonce has a nice voice but this one is not sooo good...

  • and also Christina's "horrendous" version was loved and praised by Miss James herself and thats what matters most. Youtube comments/opinions don't mean shit, when the legendary original put her stamp of approval on it...can't beat that.. just sayin

  • @lawlinat0r Yea the only reason why the beyonce performance was historic ( not legendary btw) wasn't about the the song or how she sang it, it was more of where she sang it . She could have done "Crazy in Love" or "Single ladies" and it still would have been a historic moment because she sang a song at the 1st black president's Inaugural Ball.

  • @JulianVRM Beyonces performance was legendary and historic at the same time and it was Beyonce who introduced a new generation to Ms.Etta James music so you can call it what you want but Beyonce always had the best version of this song along with Ms.Etta!!

  • @JulianVRM well she sung the song perfectly with a lot of soul and emotion..

    Beyonce was part of History!!

  • I love you so much V.

  • ive never seen this movie but i really want to!

  • R.I.P. Etta James

  • beyonce's cover is great

  • Thank you @iamkikec for correcting the guy who said beyonce introduced a younger generation to Etta James when it really was Christina Aguilera that did since she came out.

  • @JulianVRM I'm sorry but no, Christina Aguilera has never done anything for this song but butcher it. Everyone knows Beyonce sang this song for the President & First Lady at the Inaugural Ball, no one except internet fans know about Christina's horrendous version.

  • @JulianVRM thats a damn lie!!! xtina aint did crap!!!

  • R.IP MS . ETTA JAMES YOU WIL BE DEEPLY MISSED

  • getem beyonce gone girrl do yo thing i knw dats right

  • @Arianaschleicher15 Lmao ghetto

  • give me a break so sing the song "i was here" for Etta? u are over reacting.. Etta was a great singer but i am sorry shes not Michael jackson for dedicate such an inspired song and powerful for Etta

    she do deserve a tribute, of course but "I was here" song it's too much for singing it to Etta james. sorry

  • She needs to sing this at the Grammys. She's pretty much secured this song as an absolute classic and that is a fact. Etta's version is obviously THE classic version, but Beyonce introduced the song to the younger generation and that is something that should be noted.

  • @lawlinat0r Actually, it was Christina Aguilera who has been introducing the song to younger generations since 1999

  • @iamkikec Not... really. Christina may have been singing it throughout her career, but this performance is more legendary than anything she has ever done. Christina just butchered it.

  • Adrien Brody, Jeffrey Wright, Beyonce. Combined the 3 of them don't have a thinmble full of Etta's talent!

  • I think Beyonce should sing her song " I Was Here " to honor Ms Etta James. I know you usually sing the departed artist hit song but she have already done it live at least 2 times. " I Was Here " is a perfect song to sing to honor anyone. A mother, brother, sister, father, child etc anyone. The lyrics are just perfect and for Etta because she did make a difference and her songs are what she left us behind. If you haven't heard it than listen then like this

  • complete shit compared to Etta

  • @lynchmob2020 Beyonce made this song more relevent to the younger generation. She even won a grammy for the remake of this song. So how can her version sound like shit. Beyonce has the control of this song without over-singing and the phrasing of the words are just perfect. Etta and Beyonce are Queens. Why do you have to knock Beyonce just to say you like Etta version better. I love Bey's version but I respect Etta's because they are different. They both are great. RIP ETTA JAMES

  • @kingbeyfan1 they have country music awards, i hate country, just because they won a grammy doesnt mean its any good, i listen to heavier metal and 60's its what i prefer, this new age shit, rock pop cuntry and that other bullshit streaming out of my radio i dont agree with and its missing a certain quality to it

  • @lynchmob2020 no u r complete shit in crap!

  • @toobly1 you got me good you fucker

  • @toobly1 you got me good you fucker

  • @lynchmob2020 oh shut up u abuser

  • @lynchmob2020 get a life you jealous rat!!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 im sorry for having a difference of opinion?

  • i hope her and christina aguilera pay tribute by singing this song at the grammys!

  • cock

  • baby penis

  • chess record finest

  • R.I.P Etta James

  • why did u write fin at the end?

  • Check out Anna Corcoran's version of this song...very different - but very lovely. Comments on the video welcomed!

  • Rip Etta James!..we miss you

  • i love this <3

  • im sorry beyonce but u could have said no to the inauguration unless u were doing a duet wit the original great "ETTA JAMES"

    R.I.P ETTA WE LOVE U SO MUCH, WE ARE praying for u

  • Beyonce is great so is Etta their both legends and if u can't respect Etta the way Beyonce does then i think you shouldn't be commenting on this page.

  • RIP Etta

    and no bashing Beyonce, she is as sad as we are.

  • I mean no offense to a nother talented lady but step aside Beyonce and leave this cherished to Miss Etta and her more soulful and raw rendition...

  • This song belongs to Etta James and no one will ever live up to her iconic version. No matter who sings it, I am automatically reminded of Etta singing it and I just can't separate Etta's voice from the song.

  • Fuck You Beyonce & Youtube. When I typed in "Etta James at Last" Beyonces fucking face was at the top of the list. That was a disgrace. Fuck You B! Dont ever sing this song again!

  • Sorry, but Beyonce doesn't even come near to Etta in singing. Thank you for your gifted talent and what you brought to the music industry..Etta. RIP..

  • it was 20 years old when recorded by Etta, but she transformed the Glen Miller number. B is lovely but not in the same class as Etta on this track

  • Bey´s cover is heartbeakingly beautiful, but the original is the original, and there will never be another like her.

  • beyonce the next etta james, but etta is only RIP

  • @evilhuntersl There is no "next Etta James" There is only 1 Etta and she passed away! If Beyonce chooses to piggy back off the greatness of the Etta James or any other artist for that matter, fine! ...but she will never be like Etta James. Beyonce is only good for 2 things in my opinion. 1. Shaking her ass on screen 2. Stealing the spotlight from others. Fuck Beyonce!

  • Beyonce stick to your booty shaking and not trying to steal a classic!!!!!!!!!!!

  • RIP...

  • luv this song...beautiful voice..R.I.P Mrs. Etta James...

  • RIP, beautiful lady with such a beautiful voice. You know you made so many of us mortals happy with your voice.

  • Beyonce has a nice voice, but when you listen to the origianl by Etta James you discover the power and drive of James'. Nothing compares.

  • @JDSFLA i so agree etta voice is much more powerful and raw and i prefer Christina's version its more similar to Etta's voice r.i.p

  • @JDSFLA I actually thought that the power of Etta James was dissonance to the content of the lyrics. i thought that Beyonce sounded more like a lady in love than Etta.

  • @JDSFLA yeah her voice much darker than beyonce and it is her song

  • Fucc this song, listen to the original

  • R.I.P Etta James

  • R.I.P.

  • R.I.P Ms. ETTS JAMES......thee is no one else like you, you will be missed.

  • :(

  • RIP Ms. Etta James.

  • R.I.P ETTA JAMES! A LEGEND I cried when I listened to this song :(

  • RIP etta. wow she died in the hospital near my home. That's crazy I didn't even know she lived in the county I live in until I read it on the news. RIP your voice is awesome and beautiful.

  • R.I.P ETTA JAMES WE WILL MISS YUHH

  • R.I.P ETTA JAMES We Will Always Remember You <3

  • this is bull shit

  • R.I.P TO ETTA JAMES EVERYONES INSPRAITON love to etta<3

  • @maddie4499 what ?! she died ! ? oh my god v.v im sorry , im a little slow , but oh my goodness , i didnt even know D: i just know im in love with this song .. rest in peace , bless your soul ;/ aint this abouttah bitch man ;/

  • one of the greatest voices R.I.P.

  • @sanberdoofoo This isn't Etta James' voice...it's Beyonce's...

  • @sanberdoofoo This is Beyonce who's singing this now you idiot T_T

  • R.I.P. Etta James!

  • Comment removed

  • It's so fucking sad when you type in the search box "Etta James- At Last" and Beyonce's version comes up first.

  • Peace at last Etta. RIP

  • Rest in peace, ma'am. You are loved and will never be forgotten. Now she belongs to the ages.

  • Just beautiful. What a way to honor a legend.

  • I like Beyonce, but she's no Etta James. R.I.P to the original and best singer of this song, Etta James, of course.

  • fuck beyonce for the only reason that she always always takes the spotlight from absolutely everything. all Etta wanted to do was sing her own damn song at Obamas Inauguration and this bitch sang it?!!! and now she is gone that is fucked up.

  • @babypink912 Right on!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @babypink912 Fuck yourself. Even on a sad day like this you still find time to be hateful and childish! this is just DEGUSTING.

  • @babypink912 Oh so it's Beyonce's fault that Etta didn't get to sing at the Inaugration Ball? Are you delusional? Do you seriously think Beyonce said "I want to sing this for Obama" and it just happened. Beyonce didn't control the process, Beyonce never stopped Etta from singing this. At the end of the day, this song would not have been relevant at that time if it wasn't for Beyonce's portrayal of Etta in Cadillac Records. It's the way it is. Beyonce has SO MUCH respect for Etta James.

  • @MsDiva96 uh stfu!! ha you think Beyonce made THIS song relevant. You got to be kidding me. This song came out long before her ass was born and was already making bank with the money earned and awards so I don't need you or anyone always always always trying to praise Beyonce for making something big again. Enough with this girl. Etta did it on her own. And if Beyonce had no choice in singing at the ball than why the hell is Etta so pissed at her?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?!!

  • @babypink912 Take a second and try to THINK about what I said. It's a fact, the song would not have been relevant at that point in time without Beyonce. Or should I say without the film Cadillac records. I am not denying that the song is a classic, but of all the songs they could have chosen, why would it be At Last? She is part of the reason this song resurfaced. And in answer to your last question, being brutally honest, Beyonce is not the first person Etta has been disrespectful towards..

  • @MsDiva96 ignore them I been fighting this battle for a day now, they don't wanna admit to the facts which are that etta said that 1. BEYONCE IS A BEAUTIFUL GIRL AND I LOVE HER 2. SHE CAN SING BUT SHE CAN'T SING BETTER THAN ME and 3. SHE WAS JOKING WHEN SHE MADE THOSE COMMENTS IN SEATLLE... Not even Beyonce thinks she sings better than ETTA so I don't know what these people are mad for... and u're right, Beyonce is the reason this song is popular again 40 years later, not ETTA JAMES

  • @BKHTSO Exactly, it's a fact. The majority of the younger generations would not have heard this song at all without it being resurfaced by Beyonce and Cadillac Records. People are so badly in denial.

  • @babypink912 ETTTA wasn't pissed at Beyonce she clarified her statements and said she was joking in seattle but that in all honestly she was hurt that they asked Beyonce to sing that song instead of her cause she can sing it better... not that Beyonce can't sing but that she can sing it better.... Even at the movie premiere ETTA said BEyonce can sing but not better than her.. so ther u have it, even the QUEEN herself thinks beyonce can sing so let it go ETTA wasn't mad at Beyonce

  • RIP Etta James. Beautiful voice.

  • RIP Etta James You Shall Be Missed

  • RIP Etta

  • Beyonce has a wonderful voice. But she slurred some words and strung out a few.

    Etta was crisp and soft at times and showed more I felt honest emotions. I'ts like,

    I felt she actually had gone thru this emotional experience and not just cut a record.

    I actually I remember feeling this emotion once in my life. I know others here have too.

    I'm so sad today.

  • I still love ya doe

  • YOU KILLLED ETTA HAPPY NOW :'(

  • r.i.p. Etta and a question.. Why Beyonce don't sing Jazz! Why don't we have this jazz nowadays???

  • @kalampakas jazz is probably the most overlooked music genre right now which is very sad.

  • God rest her soul At Last she is with God Love you Etta

  • rest in peace, return if possible. you're home, etta. enjoy paradise!

  • RIP Etta James we'll always enjoy your beautiful melodies!

  • R.I.P Etta James<3

  • When you see God Etta James this song is appropriate to sing. Sing your heart out. Who could do it better? Trust me...It will give him Goose bumbs. God Speed.

  • Dull, Dull, Dull, Only a Goddess can sing this song..........Or maybe the real women with real feelings back in the day. Or only Etta James.........

  • Boo Beyonce!! You ruined this song. Etta is untouchable!

  • dude this is beyonce singing not etta james.

  • One of the best voices the world has ever witnessed. Rest in peace goddess Etta!

  • RIP Etta James!!

    

  • R.I.P Etta James

  • <3 Rip Etta James <3

  • R.I.P. Etta James! You paved the way for soo many artist today!

  • Etta should of been the one that sang this to the president

  • R.I.P. Etta. You will be dearly missed. :(

  • RIP Etta James

  • You will always be remembered in our hearts....RIP.......

  • RIP Etta James

  • Generally when people cover Etta James... well it's just a bad call. But Beyonce I would say does a solid job here. Little bit different phrasing but I'm digging it.

  • i can finally feel the emotion in her voice . not that she's not talented she's usaully sasha fierce or queen b for once she was beyonce.....

  • Beyonce was probably the best person these days to play Etta James, she did a GREAT job with the songs... Especially "At Last". But, no matter how great she did, NOTHING or NOONE beats Etta James... Not anyone that's done this song now days or in the past!!! She is a classic in everything she does!!!

  • i love all the versions, but nothing beats Etta James' original!

  • I think both Beyonce's and Christina's version were great. They just were unique in their own way. You can't say that one is better than the other, when they were both made in different styles.

  • how can edda james get mad over sum 1 so beautiful playing her ugh she should b happy

  • excelente cancion...

  • At last, Beyonce is a Mother

  • @aphordonte yes im so happy for her and jay z

  • Comment removed

  • beyonce can SANG!! lol and so can etta this is a tribute...and a good one i just appreciate good music so whos better than who doesnt matter to me

  • Beyonce kills the song...........she sang better than all competitor

  • gettem beyonce lol

  • Without etta james, maybe we wont have knew Beyonce so I think That beyonce is Thankfull for etta james and I am too

  • @Primaverraexilien Agreed somebody said that Beyonce was a product well if that is the case she knew who was her creator was.Jamesetta Hawkins

  • I love Christina Aguilera, but Beyoncé OWNED this song! I'm not saying that because I prefer Beyoncé, but because she respects the songs she learns. If she had sang it as Christina did, which is with trillions of unnecessary runs, people would have criticized her for over singing. But when Miss Aguilera does it, she is praised. Beyoncé knows when to put runs and not when not to, which Christina Aguilera doesn't. I can't imagine her singing All I Do Was Cry or as soulful as Beyoncé did, sorry...

  • @savamounange You can't really compare the two. Beyonce had to respect E.James version because it wsa a tribute to her, while Christina did the cover of the song in her concert, wich mean she had the freedom to sing the song the she wanted. If she was doing a tribute to the original singer, she would have sing it more like Beyonce, without all the groal and high note, but she wasnt. I don't understand why you always compare these two version, same song/different context...

  • love it

  • NO LIKE YUCK.

    

  • woah if i could sing like that i'd be happy. and ppl if we r gonna get pissed at eachother about whos cover is better than whos, then beyonce,celine dion and christina (and everyone else who plans on doing covers) should just stick to their own music. with this song its up to how you how you want to sing it