The beauty in a lot of what Arcade Fire does seems to be in the arrangement, rather than the composition of the music itself. However, they can do some really neat and original things that are pretty tricky (from a music theory perspective) and they sometimes make me smile for it, such as the time changes on "modern man" that gives a sort of record skipping sound every now and again. Neat stuff.
I feel like true musical talent is hard to define. I love the Clash, for example, but Joe Strummer can't sing. But he can bark and rasp out some beautiful stuff. I think I'd rather listen to a band like the Clash or the Arcade Fire than a less energetic, frenetic but more technically skilled group. I do agree that they're probably not the greatest pure musicians.
I won't lie, I don't think she's a very talented singer. In fact, I think most of this band is lacking when it comes to true musical talent.
But they're still one of the most fantastic bands on this planet. They play with such passion (best on display when they play Wake Up), and the way that the simple elements of each song make a complex and stirring whole is a feat of some truly remarkable songwriting. Despite their lack of actual talent, they might be the best band on the planet today.
@Technologiclongboard il m'avait pourtant sembler que le chanteur, marie de régine était lui américain. Quand aux autres, Sarah Neufeld est de vancouver, Richard Parry ne me semble pas etre issu d'une famille francophone, William Butler est texan, Jeremy Gara est de Ottawa (même si gara n'est pas très saxon...), Tim Kingsbury est originaire de Guelph en Ontario. je regrette, je ne pense pas qu'ils soit du canada francophone, cela n'empeche pas ce groupe d'être génial ! :)
there cant really be an argument here with this band, like even if your into different genre's of music! there soo much to be admired and respected !! they are epic live too!!
this is a really great performance and a great song. Regine is an awesome performing artist. Hate is not worth posting. Keep it to yourself or share it somewhere else if you have friends to share it though. And if you don't, I'm sorry. But don't share it here cuz that way you will never grow up
cold way kids is well known by alot of people. and MTV hahahha
and indie isnt about not being well known. its just about loving music. and loving what they do. they dont care if they dont get famous. they just love what they do. their not trying to become famous. their just pleasing the people that actually love their music.
and i think their doing a great job. and cold war kids are a very good band too.
why do you have to judge things and people?? if you dont like it then dont listen ok. and if you have nothing good to say then dont say it.
jeez people like you have to live off of drama which is sad. especially when you dont know the person...
just listen and learn to love or go away so people can enjoy themselves listening to the music they love. its music. its suppose to keep you inspired and and happy.
youre is spelled your there smart ass feminist. No she is not a deity she is a product of a corporation. Everyone thinks she is cute just because she is in a band dressing like an orphan playing a musically pointless piano bouncing around laughing along with that ritalin user drummer. shit trendy bands.
haha dude you must like this song cause this is the second video where I see you a comment of yours. Not a good comment, but it shows you are watching the videos of a band you dislike, for what reason? just to talk shit? maybe you should find something better to do
wow. think out of the box man. Have you ever thought i am watching the videos just to purely put down there over rated image? You know spread the gospel about how bad this band is? One of the main points about indi rock is to not be popular and these pop stars are contradicting themselves. MTV the whole 9 yards. go listen to real indi rock like EL TEN ELEVEN or COLD WAR KIDS. Not this pop contradiction.
I'm not stupid man, I know you just leave comments to try and prove a point. Cold war kids? are you serious? haha you should listen to REAL indie bands like EXPLOSIONS IN THE SKY, MONO, THIS WILL DESTROY YOU, CASPIAN, MOGWAI, GY!BE, MUM, DO MAKE SAY THINK etc. Besides being labeled as indie they are labeled as post-rock/instrumental/experimental bands. However, I don't like labels so I would simply call them bands that make great music, and arcade fire makes great music too.
if is a popular band so what??, the music is good for what you say trough it not for a stupid label or a genre. You are so wrong, every music is pop music, Why? because there are a lot of people who like it ok. Now, being an indie rock band is about the music and the freedom to do whatever you want with it, is not a matter of which TV channel you're music is. If you're going to judge the bands you should have a better way to do it, cause your arguments are very very poor and superficial.
indi rock bands are all about thinking there cool by being different.(not popular) It is cliche to be on mtv. They contradict themselves. Hipsters are some of the biggest prats out there. They come from rich families to live in brooklyn ny to be artist and trendy jerks thinking they know what is real art.(MGMT) Having a guy who beats on a single drum running around on stage like a idiot is stupid. Especially when you already have a drummer. See. Its different and trendy to have a single drummer
I'm agree with some of the things you say, but I don't think that is really the case of Arcade Fire, maybe The strokes is the band you are talking about. But Arcade Fire has nothing to do with what you say, they are for Montreal not Brookyln.
MGMT writes great songs, and have a very "grassroots" approach to their writing/music. It's two guys who lived in the same dorm in college and recorded music for fun. They never dreamed of being as successful as they've become. They're a couple of of normal guys who couldn't care less about the recognition they get. It's a joke to them.
I don't necessarily disagree with what you said about hipsters but MGMT are legit.
Not enough space to convince you I know, just take my word for it.
Also, think about this. You have band. Some members play instruments that don't allow them to move around too easily, which makes the presence of those individuals onstage a little-less animated, wouldn't you say? Now, many of the songs they perform don't require all members to play an instrument. For those songs, instead of having members sit-out, they become the spectacle for the audience while contributing back-up vocals etc. Makes it a lot more engaging for everyone involved don't you think?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You are a scooby scooby gumdrop narc. Have fun in your cheap hipster tight package black jeans wearing trendy t shirts. This style of music sucks anal of oscar the grouch.
sooo... you have nothing better to do than comment on music you don't like? perhaps its your hobby, i suppose it makes you feel better about yourself.
you don't know what you're talking about. %80 of the bands on mtv are not indie and are some pop rock bullshit thats kinda different than normal pop rock
Below this the two posts i posted are the translation from french to english because i think it is so beautiful and a little sad and this is my all time favorite song so thank you for putting it up
oh and the arcade fire was my first concert too, no others have compared since, it was beyond words!
It is so good to see young people enjoying themselves on stage and they are also awsome. I hope this genre whatever it is called will become what it should become
music is getting so bad in the mainstream sometime in the future the radio stations will realize wtf they were doing and they'll play all the beautiful and artisitic, music of all genres thats been coming out once lil wayne and miley cyrus are old hat maybe we'll have chance
I'm 18, and I still have never been to see a band. Arcade Fire has been the only band I've ever *wanted* to see live, because they're fucking legendary live. I really can't wait to see them. I'll probably just have a fit before it starts and wake up in hospital though. :P I know if I'm near the front and they play Haiti, I'm definitely going to pass out.
Don't encourage me. I've already idolised this band way too much, and I'm creepily in love with Regine. I really am going to pass out if I hype up my first AF concert anymore. :P
In the forest we lie hiding,
unmarked graves where flowers grow.
Hear the soldiers angry yelling,
in the river we will go.
teddyonyszkow 1 month ago
Regine had a natural beauty to her!
JuliaRPascale 3 months ago
What a beautiful ode to ones fallen country, incredible. Saw these live last year and this song was probably the biggest highlight!
Pilkymakinmusik 3 months ago
brilliant the best performance of haiti they've done
davpigboy1 5 months ago
Régine should marry me instead.
Chloroform 6 months ago
@Chloroform no she should marry me.
lol
warrinerC 4 months ago in playlist first one.
very nice
fradson123 6 months ago
I love Regine's voice and I love this song, just as much as I love any of Win's songs! Regine and Win are perfect
laurenkd89 6 months ago
Win always steps aside and lets Regine have her moment when they play this song, what a great husband. I'll strive to be like him.
chadboban 9 months ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shut up Regine!!!!!!
Rexkwondotyger 9 months ago
@Rexkwondotyger haha not funny troll
MiguelCamposTV1 8 months ago
The beauty in a lot of what Arcade Fire does seems to be in the arrangement, rather than the composition of the music itself. However, they can do some really neat and original things that are pretty tricky (from a music theory perspective) and they sometimes make me smile for it, such as the time changes on "modern man" that gives a sort of record skipping sound every now and again. Neat stuff.
nateairvin 9 months ago
this song is sex. I love it
Constantine310 9 months ago
I love this band
jose0020 10 months ago
every time I see Regine, she steals another little piece of my heart...
cinbrian28 10 months ago
my fav songs from arcade fire ... Regine is so looooovely :)
beforethree 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
too bad no one in the band can sing
verbod 1 year ago
@verbod too bad you dont have an ear for music...
KayneHindBull 11 months ago
this is just fucking awesome!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3
want to see them live :(
doouxx 1 year ago 4
One of my very fav songs from the band. Such energetic performers and Renee is such a cutie!
buddyguy88 1 year ago 3
We need good bands like Arcade Fire !!!
drummer reminds me Steven Morris !
beforethree 1 year ago 2
We need good bands like Arcade Fire !!!
beforethree 1 year ago 3
Unique - brilliant- innovative- trendsetters- emotive-talented-heartwarming!!!!
debiedog1 1 year ago 2
nice gloves
glenndar 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this band blows, French Canadians should never be allowed out of Canada
r3dfl4ck4l1 1 year ago
@r3dfl4ck4l1
f**k u
tragicallyblonde 11 months ago
Really can't get enough of this video.
Ponce1390 1 year ago
I feel like true musical talent is hard to define. I love the Clash, for example, but Joe Strummer can't sing. But he can bark and rasp out some beautiful stuff. I think I'd rather listen to a band like the Clash or the Arcade Fire than a less energetic, frenetic but more technically skilled group. I do agree that they're probably not the greatest pure musicians.
Mongoosedog15 1 year ago 3
I won't lie, I don't think she's a very talented singer. In fact, I think most of this band is lacking when it comes to true musical talent.
But they're still one of the most fantastic bands on this planet. They play with such passion (best on display when they play Wake Up), and the way that the simple elements of each song make a complex and stirring whole is a feat of some truly remarkable songwriting. Despite their lack of actual talent, they might be the best band on the planet today.
ogredm 1 year ago
@ogredm very true
weaut 1 year ago
I want to find out when the tickets will be sold for the Nashville Show coming up. Anyone know?
Bobman4671 1 year ago
Aaaah, I love that woman!
BehindTheSea29 1 year ago 5
@BehindTheSea29 she's so... lovely
beforethree 1 year ago 3
i lvoe how her beauty is in her talents
powerpoop9 1 year ago 2
le meilleur groupe que le canada anglophone nous est offert. :)
foncleaa 1 year ago 2
@foncleaa Ils sont francophones.... grandit en banlieue de Montréal pour la plupart.
Technologiclongboard 1 year ago
@Technologiclongboard il m'avait pourtant sembler que le chanteur, marie de régine était lui américain. Quand aux autres, Sarah Neufeld est de vancouver, Richard Parry ne me semble pas etre issu d'une famille francophone, William Butler est texan, Jeremy Gara est de Ottawa (même si gara n'est pas très saxon...), Tim Kingsbury est originaire de Guelph en Ontario. je regrette, je ne pense pas qu'ils soit du canada francophone, cela n'empeche pas ce groupe d'être génial ! :)
foncleaa 1 year ago
there cant really be an argument here with this band, like even if your into different genre's of music! there soo much to be admired and respected !! they are epic live too!!
PatOrg22 1 year ago
Her voice is so unique
piggylover27 1 year ago
She really looks like Helena Bonham Carter :P
xripper9 1 year ago 3
at 2:08 : a string broke..he rocks that acoustic guitar
heldenbaumi 1 year ago
this kind of music comes from the soul....no money making behind it
RYANcanada1 1 year ago 36
@RYANcanada1 Well, they are making money. That's not where the music comes from but there's money being made.
platypae333 4 months ago
this is a really great performance and a great song. Regine is an awesome performing artist. Hate is not worth posting. Keep it to yourself or share it somewhere else if you have friends to share it though. And if you don't, I'm sorry. But don't share it here cuz that way you will never grow up
ichibadbad 1 year ago 3
well said
LOCOlMOTIVE 1 year ago
To Everyone,
Regine was not born in Haiti but in Canada...but her parents were born in Haiti...
kathaiti 1 year ago 4
seeeeee... esta mina no puede masssssssssss!!!! :P
alecaper 2 years ago
hey isn't Regine from Haiti?
NeonFoxLetsPlays 2 years ago
yup
Robinhoodarch 2 years ago
What a performance!! this is what I call "real" artists
thegopher001 2 years ago 3
I just learned the girl is Haitian
FERRAT1953 2 years ago
aaaahhh this is so good
5 stars
freydey 2 years ago
and im talking about you dave1122drum.
just chill.
oh and by the way.
cold way kids is well known by alot of people. and MTV hahahha
and indie isnt about not being well known. its just about loving music. and loving what they do. they dont care if they dont get famous. they just love what they do. their not trying to become famous. their just pleasing the people that actually love their music.
and i think their doing a great job. and cold war kids are a very good band too.
sallyrayandpeace 2 years ago
oh my god you guys.
its music. chill out.
every kind of music is amazing.
why do you have to judge things and people?? if you dont like it then dont listen ok. and if you have nothing good to say then dont say it.
jeez people like you have to live off of drama which is sad. especially when you dont know the person...
just listen and learn to love or go away so people can enjoy themselves listening to the music they love. its music. its suppose to keep you inspired and and happy.
sallyrayandpeace 2 years ago
dzejaaaaaaah.....I wanna see this once live
Lukazz20 2 years ago
Wow, at 4:00 when the crowd gets singing, it seriously gives me goosebumps. Such a good song on probably the best album of the 2000s by far.
Zeokoz 2 years ago 8
this song is awesome
l2moua 2 years ago 4
Arcade fire trendy band??? omg.. you don't know nothing about it!!
filipomed 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
wow she is annoying. Bit mental moving her arms around and making drooly faces. I will take a dump on this band.
dave1122drum 2 years ago
u must be missing a link dave maybe even two since youre a guy....
regine is a diety
lexxlecrisisIII 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
youre is spelled your there smart ass feminist. No she is not a deity she is a product of a corporation. Everyone thinks she is cute just because she is in a band dressing like an orphan playing a musically pointless piano bouncing around laughing along with that ritalin user drummer. shit trendy bands.
dave1122drum 2 years ago
wow you're dumb, learn how to use your and you're right, then you can talk
eyegore21 2 years ago 3
haha dude you must like this song cause this is the second video where I see you a comment of yours. Not a good comment, but it shows you are watching the videos of a band you dislike, for what reason? just to talk shit? maybe you should find something better to do
eddiemoon21 2 years ago 3
wow. think out of the box man. Have you ever thought i am watching the videos just to purely put down there over rated image? You know spread the gospel about how bad this band is? One of the main points about indi rock is to not be popular and these pop stars are contradicting themselves. MTV the whole 9 yards. go listen to real indi rock like EL TEN ELEVEN or COLD WAR KIDS. Not this pop contradiction.
dave1122drum 2 years ago
I'm not stupid man, I know you just leave comments to try and prove a point. Cold war kids? are you serious? haha you should listen to REAL indie bands like EXPLOSIONS IN THE SKY, MONO, THIS WILL DESTROY YOU, CASPIAN, MOGWAI, GY!BE, MUM, DO MAKE SAY THINK etc. Besides being labeled as indie they are labeled as post-rock/instrumental/experimental bands. However, I don't like labels so I would simply call them bands that make great music, and arcade fire makes great music too.
eddiemoon21 2 years ago
"One of the main points about indi rock is to not be popular"
Is it really? Wow, yeah, that must be every musician's dream: not to be popular. Jesus.
soundboy89 2 years ago 3
if is a popular band so what??, the music is good for what you say trough it not for a stupid label or a genre. You are so wrong, every music is pop music, Why? because there are a lot of people who like it ok. Now, being an indie rock band is about the music and the freedom to do whatever you want with it, is not a matter of which TV channel you're music is. If you're going to judge the bands you should have a better way to do it, cause your arguments are very very poor and superficial.
josueamericanistarv 2 years ago
indi rock bands are all about thinking there cool by being different.(not popular) It is cliche to be on mtv. They contradict themselves. Hipsters are some of the biggest prats out there. They come from rich families to live in brooklyn ny to be artist and trendy jerks thinking they know what is real art.(MGMT) Having a guy who beats on a single drum running around on stage like a idiot is stupid. Especially when you already have a drummer. See. Its different and trendy to have a single drummer
dave1122drum 2 years ago
I'm agree with some of the things you say, but I don't think that is really the case of Arcade Fire, maybe The strokes is the band you are talking about. But Arcade Fire has nothing to do with what you say, they are for Montreal not Brookyln.
josueamericanistarv 2 years ago
MGMT writes great songs, and have a very "grassroots" approach to their writing/music. It's two guys who lived in the same dorm in college and recorded music for fun. They never dreamed of being as successful as they've become. They're a couple of of normal guys who couldn't care less about the recognition they get. It's a joke to them.
I don't necessarily disagree with what you said about hipsters but MGMT are legit.
Not enough space to convince you I know, just take my word for it.
Vertze 2 years ago
Also, think about this. You have band. Some members play instruments that don't allow them to move around too easily, which makes the presence of those individuals onstage a little-less animated, wouldn't you say? Now, many of the songs they perform don't require all members to play an instrument. For those songs, instead of having members sit-out, they become the spectacle for the audience while contributing back-up vocals etc. Makes it a lot more engaging for everyone involved don't you think?
Vertze 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
llol yeah arcade fire are soo from brooklyn
and u got sand in yout vagina cause u fail at life
freydey 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You are a scooby scooby gumdrop narc. Have fun in your cheap hipster tight package black jeans wearing trendy t shirts. This style of music sucks anal of oscar the grouch.
dave1122drum 2 years ago
ok u dislike it
who cares about ur musicall choices?
nobody does..why ur posting that on a vid of arcade fire thats pretty useless
sigh typicall american fool
freydey 2 years ago
sooo... you have nothing better to do than comment on music you don't like? perhaps its your hobby, i suppose it makes you feel better about yourself.
mrh2608 2 years ago
you don't know what you're talking about. %80 of the bands on mtv are not indie and are some pop rock bullshit thats kinda different than normal pop rock
nizzle2 2 years ago 5
@dave1122drum
I don't think any band sets out to not be popular.
Pankakke 2 years ago
Anybody know where i can get an mp3 of this performance??
digitalmonster22 2 years ago
just go to google and search download youtube. there are ways :p
eyegore21 2 years ago 3
Thanks for uploading, absolutely beautiful song :)
But I just noticed, is Win playing bass on this song? I could be wrong, but it looks like it....
LostColourz 2 years ago
Regine es una hermosa mujer....
nicoletti 2 years ago 2
Below this the two posts i posted are the translation from french to english because i think it is so beautiful and a little sad and this is my all time favorite song so thank you for putting it up
oh and the arcade fire was my first concert too, no others have compared since, it was beyond words!
nikkiandrudy 2 years ago 10
Thank you ^^
Manicsla 2 years ago 3
Haiti, my country,
wounded mother I'll never see.
My set family me free.
Throw my ashes into the sea.
My cousins never born
haunt the nights of Duvalier.
Nothing stopped our spirits.Guns can't kill what soldiers can't see.
nikkiandrudy 2 years ago 3
In the forest we lie hiding, unmarked graves where flowers grow.
Hear the soldiers angry yelling,
in the river we will go All the dull ones form an army, soon we will reclaim the earth Al the tears and Al the bodies bring butt our second birth.
Haiti, never free, am not afraid to sound alarm. Your children left
nikkiandrudy 2 years ago 3
i love regine
MG53895 2 years ago 2
Regine is so cute! Awesome performance!!. Love how the crowd is singing at 3:59 . I vote YES for a Live album!
taikodad08 2 years ago 3
They are the only modern band I can think of that would do a hell of a live album.
hightimesbruce 2 years ago
them and just about everybody on the "arts and crafts" label
PLA5T1KJ3ZUS 2 years ago
Don't forget about Muse. I own their live albums and they're amazing! (along with their studio ones too).
danielmizzle 2 years ago 2
great performance of a great song by a great band.
Demoman1980 2 years ago 2
Régine!
TheConchRepublic 2 years ago
This video was shot by Canal+ on French TV.
I was at this concert on 20 march 2007.
I can't forget ...
katamino1 2 years ago
It is so good to see young people enjoying themselves on stage and they are also awsome. I hope this genre whatever it is called will become what it should become
Thanks for the video
Whistlejocket 3 years ago 2
This song makes me happy. I'm in love with REgine
turioftj2003 3 years ago 2
putin va prendre d cour de chant c pourave
joelatune 3 years ago
i mean true, sorry
bato1985 3 years ago
I cannot stop watching this.
It's incredible.
Who took the footage?
elisa577 3 years ago 2
There's always something happening in music and in all arts, but it ain't always gettin airplay
aphilby 3 years ago 2
that's absolutely truth fellow, and very dissapointing
bato1985 3 years ago
music is getting so bad in the mainstream sometime in the future the radio stations will realize wtf they were doing and they'll play all the beautiful and artisitic, music of all genres thats been coming out once lil wayne and miley cyrus are old hat maybe we'll have chance
drmarkchang 3 years ago
i'd die to see them live
Robsonzee 3 years ago 3
I got to see them last year. It was my first gig, Im only 14, and slightly sad, because nothing will ever be as good.
drugmypenguins 3 years ago 3
I'm 18, and I still have never been to see a band. Arcade Fire has been the only band I've ever *wanted* to see live, because they're fucking legendary live. I really can't wait to see them. I'll probably just have a fit before it starts and wake up in hospital though. :P I know if I'm near the front and they play Haiti, I'm definitely going to pass out.
lockeforeer 3 years ago
arcade fire was the first real concert i ever saw! it was amazing! I am still talking about it 3 years later.
sussussussus 2 years ago
Don't encourage me. I've already idolised this band way too much, and I'm creepily in love with Regine. I really am going to pass out if I hype up my first AF concert anymore. :P
lockeforeer 2 years ago
Muy buena rola!! Haiti, mom pays, wounded mother I´ll never see....
Haiti never free...
The Arcade Fire es una muy buena banda no puedo dejar de escucharlos .
fridapurpura 3 years ago
very johnny appleseedish but good
timere42 3 years ago
No mamen!!! esta rola esta de huevos!!!!
traso85 3 years ago
i don't know if it's because she's from haitian descent but dem i love this song...it's noot even my style
real3rdlife 3 years ago 2
Her family lived in Haiti but moved to Canada to escape Jean-Claude Duvalier, where she was later born (near Montreal).
elisa577 3 years ago
The lead singer Regine is of Haitian descent.
kathaiti 3 years ago 3
wow son exelentes!!!!!!!!!!!
kike3243 3 years ago
They maketh a joyful noise :-)
viognniere 3 years ago
this is one of the coolest bands i´ve ever seen... finally something happening in music!!!
akorona 3 years ago 34
@akorona I agree!
valznartsy1 1 year ago
omg, it's amazing!
adlem 4 years ago 4
wow this is the first time I'm watching this. Who filmed it?
7strikes 4 years ago
incredible
fratsdomino 4 years ago
This is actually one of the best things ever.
RobotGirlCandySwirl 4 years ago 15
woooooooooooooah great !! 0.o
Lolya44 4 years ago 2
amazing, i cannot wait to c them live
forget2morrow 4 years ago