Added: 2 years ago
From: eddnoit
Views: 290,150
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (257)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • nie kaleczą rzemiosła.. ;)

  • GAVIN HARRISON IS MY HOMEBOY!!!!

  • Porcupine Tree es sin lugar a dudas una de las mejores bandas de rock a nivel mundial

  • Riverside... From Poland :) Check them out :)

  • @ingvaldandre Yes, they are great neighbour!

  • PT/ Opeth/ Tool /DT  <-----BIG FOUR!

  • @imbroglio10 I love how that list is also my four favorite bands of all time.

  • @imbroglio10 no, DT are annoying. i hate mike portnoy fans because mike is an average drummer. grrrr DT suck so hard.

  • @iWentToNam NO!

  • @iWentToNam portnoy left. That should make you happy. Hopefully mangini makes DT even better.

    I'd be happy with PT/Opeth/Riverside

  • I accidentally typed Blackest Guys when i searched this song XD

  • i thought this song was about a blind guy lol..

    "wiring loose inside my head"

    "blackest eyes"

    "got books i've never ever read"

  • Rush + King Crimson + Porcupine Tree. "a prog dream"

  • @LePirat Hell yes

  • kmo dice abajo no se ve bn, pero no deja de ser una mega bandototota, yo kmo baterista de vdd amo a gavin harrison, mis respetos kn el tipo no es un velozista pero santo groove k se karga i sus destiempos bn fumados, exelente banda, siento k porcupine tree, opeth y dream theater, son lo mas elite del metal, un saludo

  • se ve horrible

  • Porcupine+Opeth+Tool= POT

  • Porcupine Tree is not metal, that's a fact. Just listen to "Train" or "Lazarus", where's the metal there? I love them.

  • @dannopalooza so is opeth not metal because of "harvest", is kamelot not metal because of "don't you cry". Those songs may not be "metal" but it doesn't disqualify that genre title from being applied to that artist. I generally do not consider PT metal but they do have metal elements in many songs. PT is a band that incorporates many different genres such as pop rock, art rock, prog, metal, rock, and even some dance style beats. PT transcends genres which is why i think we all like them.

  • Comment removed

  • what do you think is in his garden shed?

  • @Irishlager5 Song is supposed to be about that freak serial killer Ted Bundy-that is what I keep hearing...

  • This is one of my favorite songs of all time! That jam is phenomenal, and Gavin remains a god!

  • Buenísima canción! :D. Por cierto que Porcupine no es metal, es rock progresivo :B

  • @Unweonbakan

    POrcupinetree abarca el metal progresivo desde el año 2002 mas o menos y van por esa senda. Giran con bandas de black metal.

  • @jerrycantrell24 pero... ¿metal? :S, igual tienen un sonido bien sensual (rock) en todo caso

  • amo este teeema!! <3

  • bnaza la song

  • excelente de verdad, siempre me a gustado esta banda..

  • Steven you are the best doctor I've ever seen in my life.

  • I shall find a cure for stupidity.

  • Como Se LlamA Este Concierto?

  • Why the vocals never say (in this show) ``where my dreams DEAD?`` he never says the dead in any of the times he song that part...

    LOL!

  • @SDSBass read the original lyrics for you understand, funny guy.

  • @DviniciusribeiroT i was not trying to be funny, i replied to the wrong guy lol

  • @SDSBass Sorry 4 that! I shouda been drunk dat day I spoke that...

    I was rude =(

  • Apparently this is a song about a psychopath ... damn PT can make even such a controversial subject into a fantastic song!

  • @vibhutesagar  where did you read that Blackest Eyes was a song about a psychopath? just curious

  • @IChoseTheRedPill Some lyrics forum somewhere. First I thought "no way" but reading the lyrics again it kinda fits ... of course no official source for this ...

  • OMG!

    I`ve never seen the vocalist, just imagined how would he looked like...

    And I imagined exactly this! hahaha

    Anyway, great song!

  • Divine in coma's rigreage...

  • 3:31 the bass is just perfect

  • @TelevisionOnMyMind i agree with you... the bass was played perfectly

  • Comment removed

  • Nice.

  • Why not a world tour Opeth / Porcupine Tree???

    It's a pure fucking dream!!!!

    2 greatest bands of last 20 years and maybe the 2 greatest bands of Prog Revival!!

  • @Xirukah Funny you should mention that...

  • @Xirukah YT wont allow the link, but type in OPETH vs PORCUPINE TREE - Prog Quiz. Tis amazing

  • @Xirukah you forgot the very dark side of prog : tool (ex king crimson tour mates) and meshuggah

  • @Bitemarkx Yeah....

    Tool and Meshugah are also great Prog Bands. But, for me as a Prog Lover since 70's to these days, Opeth and Porcupine are much better than the others.

    And I love Dream Theater or Mastodon or Tool.

    Opeth could reinvent Death Metal Music and mades some revolucionary and Great.. Porcupine Tree has Steven Wilson and that says all.

  • @Xirukah I agree. all of them are some my favorites bands toguether with great classic heavies bands (Black Sabbath, Iron Maiden,....)

    But Opeth is just the best

  • @Xirukah Man, I'd like to live some years more... please.

  • @Xirukah Lets add tool to that list. Porcupine tree/opeth/tool - Well thats a dream

  • @NOXLT That's a wet dream

  • @NOXLT porcupine tree/opeth/tool/riverside and I will die happy

  • @NOXLT Porcupine Tree/Opeth/Tool/Riverside for me :) Hell lets have a prog fest!!!!

  • Fucking amazing! One of the best bands around the planet. This hole concert is from outer space...

  • yeah

  • Dont take me wrong , I love porcupine tree and I consider them as music geniuses but at 0:57 and after it kinda messes the supah dupah metal sound the song has , it kinda dissapoints me :S

  • =o seguramente alguien ya te lo habia dicho, pero ellos no son metal progresivo, son ROCK progresivo..!!! Excelente banda, una de las mejores actualmente y muy subestimada...!! saludos.

  • Swim with me into your blackest eyes <3

  • What a tune!

  • This is my BRANDNEW Remember Me Lover - Porcupine Tree Cover with all instruments:

    /watch?v=FLYCQoXV1P8

  • haber si sabemos diferenciar el metal de la PSICODELIA viva la psico

  • it's so erotic when your makeup runs <3

  • No es Metal Progresivoo

  • Chicago you lucky lucky city, this is an incredible gig to have seen.

  • @Chazgd

    wasn't actually in Chicago, even though he said it

  • heavy prog, junto con rush las 2 mejores bandas

  • Perfection!

  • como que no es metal progresivo? si justamente no hay un tema entero de metal es porque justamente progresa

  • como que no es metal progresivo? si justamente no hay un tema entero de metal es porque justamente progresa

  • Es metal progresivo de calidad sin exagerar con el virtuosismo. Muy buen temaa!

  • Is the word "Progressive Metal" an insult or something ¬¬ , they are more progressive rock, and they did some progressive metal, whats the "shame" in being metal anyway ¬¬ ..., any way PT FTW <3 !!

  • Oye, no es metal. No por tener efectos en las guitarras ya es metal...

  • I HATE the term "metal". Porcupine Tree is beautiful, and could be called "psychedelyc rock", or "progressive rock", but not METAL.

    But, of course, it's MY opinion.

  • @LennonBach why couldnt metal be beautiful? ... alot of the songs on this are heavy enough to be called metal.

  • @LennonBach that's because they have become more hardcore from their beginning, but they still fucking rock!! they are pure magic, i havent feel this thing coming up my legs to my head for quite a long time... until i heard them... LONG LIVE PORCUPINE!!!!

    

  • Steven Wilson is one of the most beautiful human beings ever spawned.

  • metal progresivo??? jamas !!

  • @Totiloz em eimaste polloi edw pou akoume porcupine :))))

  • I too have secrets in my garden shed, does this make me a porcupine?

  • Sakence ese progre!

    Muy buena rolita esa del arriving somewere!

  • exelente tema..... puta ojala vengan algun dia a Chilito... bueno en realidad hagan un tour completo por sudamerica, ya que nos tienen muy votados!!

    el video del concierto anesthetize es muy bueno... veanlo

  • apla uperoxo!!!

  • 2 fanaticos de justin gayber vieron este video

  • tengo que comprar este dvd....

  • Excelente!

    aunque me lateria mas si tuviera mejor calida'

    :)

  • BUENA BANDA PROGRESIVA!!!!!!!!!!!

  • ...y en el octavo dia Dios se convirtio en Musico y se hizo llamar Steven Wilson

  • @bluezzman84 buenisima frase bro XD

  • ufff, FANTASTICO!!! HERMOSA CANCION!!!!

  • muy wena banda brother.... espero k vengan al PERÚ... y pronto

  • @ffern18 SEE PX BROTHER !! Y CLARO Q TIENEN Q VENIR SI VIENEN ACA A PERU !! YO VOY A SU COCIERTO PX AUNKE ACA NO ES MUY CONOCIDA ESTA BANDA PERO YO SOY UNO DE LOS POCOS Q CONOCEN ESTA BANDA POR ESO PUBLICO VIDEOS DE ELLOS Y ESPERO Q MAS PERSONAS DE PERU ESCUCHEN Y CONOSCAN ESTA BANDA PORK ES MUY BUENA ASI COMO TU DILE A OTROS BROTHER DE PERU Q TAMBIEN ESCUCHEN ESTA BANDA Y Q LA CONOSCAN ASI AREMOS Q EN PERU TAMBIEN SEA ALGO MUY CONOCIDO !! XD

  • @eddnoit si llegaran a ir a peru y no a chile igual haria el viaje...es una de las mejores bandas que e escuchado en los ultimos años y sino la mejor....demuestra de que algo se puede rescatar de los 2000+ ;)

  • Gavin Harrison.....one of the best drummers going.........what a talent !!!

  • @drumsyeah Right On!! Rock and Roll brother, is it just me or listen to Chris Maitland doing ShesMovedOn live. I mean, I love his vocals but doesn't it seem to you like his drumming, as frill as it is, is lagging a bit. Notice Gavin here he seems to have no problem keeping up, hence, I think the replacement.

  • @julikem I noticed that too on a few of the live songs... he's really talented, he just needs to sleep with a metronome I think :P

  • @drumsyeah One of the best???

    ...the best ;) I'm going to one of his drum clinics!!!! I nearly fainted with excitement when my dad showed me the webpage :P

  • @blackvalkyrion Tampoco es post-rock. De hecho Porcupine Tree es de los grupos más difíciles de categorizar, debido a sus influencias (como el Krautrock, entre otras), pero puedes tener por seguro que no es post-rock (que tampoco replantea al rock progresivo....de hecho no tiene nada que ver con rock progresivo), y ninguna banda de tan buen género se encuentra dentro de sus influencias.

  • NO es metal, es rock progresivo!

  • esto es simplemente rock progresivo, pero metal? en todo caso, es excelente.-

  • jajaja nunca fue metal progresivo po xD

  • best band ever: Wilson = GOD!!!

  • This is the song the open my eyes to whole entire differnt world, this was the first song that i herd upon discovering this epic life changing band, this one of the only group of musicans that hold a special place in my heart! To me there is no other band on these guys level!

  • lol The bassist is always smiling lol.......great song!

  • @beep43 Well, he does got alot to smile about ><

  • @beep43 they're singing a song about rape, what's not to smile about?

  • @beep43 whats there not to smile about. he's up on stage with his best friends playing one of their greatest songs having fans cheer for him and having a great time. i don't smile barely ever but if that was my job you wouldn't see me without a smile

  • @beep43 yeah, ive always thought about that colin smiles, but i like it and he sure does it because of the good music:)

  • @beep43 Hey, I'd be smiling all the time too, if I were playing with PT!

  • @beep43 you would be smiling too if you were jamming with steve wilson

  • Porcupine Tree rules¡¡¡¡

  • this song is so amazing live

  • es un rock progresivo k kiere ser heavy metal por momentos xDDDD

    el eslabón perdido :D

    pero suena pajita y punto!

  • @gengarfan la musica buena es buena y punto... no hay para que encasillarla... y Porcupine Tree es de lo mejor que he escuchado en la vida... es tan complejo que lo hace genial, pero no complicado.

  • @Fulanogt500 Te recomiendo Oceansize. En serio. A pesar de que PT son bueeeenisimos.

  • no quiero adentrar en estilos, simplemente creo que el rock progresivo tiene influencias de metal, por lo mismo yo no lo consideraria metal, simplemente progresivo, pero que importa si porcupine tree suena tan brutalmente bien.

  • Epic! Live it's even more intense...

  • progressive metal, progressive rock, who cares?

    lets combine these two genres into another one, and lets call it "awesomeness"

    lol

  • es rock progresivo con uno que otro toque de metal por ahi...

  • Comment removed

  • salvo por Deadwing (lo mas q se acercaron al metal) es Rock Progresivo de la new age, algo radical y diferente si estas acostumbrado a Genesis, Yes o Jethro Tull por ejemplo.

  • fucking amazing

  • Art.

  • @rlevanony Could not be described more succinctly.

  • Rock progresivo, de Metal no tiene nada!

  • Comment removed

  • esto NO es metal D=

  • @Thrym7 Es metal progresivo !! XD BROTHER !! NO ES EL TIPICO METAL LOCO Q ALGUNOS CONOCEN !!

  • @eddnoit para mí sigue siendo Rock, yo diría Metal progresivo a algo como Dream Theather

  • @eddnoit No es Metal Progresivo!!! Es rock progresivo....metal progresivo es Tool, Dream Theater,......

  • @eddnoit Porcupine Tree no tiene tantas canciones como estaas... Por lo cual me lleva a pensar que es un tipo de Rock Progressivo, solamente, aveces, se tira a metal, pero no lo es.

  • @eddnoit Y dale!! NO es Metal!!! Lo que sucede es que tienen influencias diversas. El género correcto es Post-Rock, movimiento que replantea el rock progresivo

  • @blackvalkyrion

    Esto no tiene NADA de Post Rock.

    El Post Rock es un replanteamiento del rock progresivo pero con un aspecto muchisimo mas sinfonico, por asi resumirlo. Esto ES rock progresivo.

  • @EnriquePage91 De que es Rock Progresivo no hay duda....sin embargo, algunos especialistas señalan que tiene influencias de post rock......lo cual sinceramente no estoy seguro. De lo que si estoy seguro es que no es Metal.

  • @blackvalkyrion

    Neee esos "especialistas" estan por el piso. Esto no tiene nada de post rock, el post rock es muy lento; los cambios son lentos, tardados, y generalmente es instrumental, hasta resulta "ambiental".

    BLACKEST EYES... no, no diria que es metal progresivo, pero si tiene sus influencias. Aunque es completamente comprensible pues este es el primer disco de Steven Wilson desde que empezo como productor de Opeth; desde este disco PT empezo a tornarse mas "pesado", mas "metalero".

  • @EnriquePage91 haha yo no me fijo en los tecnisismos de la musica sino en la vibra... y me suenan alternativos

  • @eddnoit No man, no es metal, tampoco es metal progresivo.

    Es Rock Progresivo, más específicamente Heavy Prog (Prog duro), con influencias metaleras, claras influencias metaleras, pero eso no lo convierte en metal.

  • @eddnoit No es metal ¬¬ es rock progresivo

  • @eddnoit Porcupine Tree no es metal, colega... no debe hacer mucho que los conoces, verdad? PT es rock progresivo, con algunas influencias de otros estilos como el heavy metal o la música ambiental.

  • @eddnoit Bueno no es exactamente metal progresivo pero si tiene un poco de...

    Ya los vi 2 veces en vivo y pfff lo mejor de lo mejor :)

  • @eddnoit NO amigo.. esto es Rock Progresivo. A partir de In Absentia sus guitarras se volvieron mas agresivas y se acercaron al metal.. pero su gènero no es metal progresivo como por ejemplo, Dream T. El sonido de sus guitarras es mas cercano al Hard Rock que al Metal actual tambien. La mejor banda hoy por hoy sin duda..y ya han venido a Mèxico dos veces!! ojalà vayan a Peru. Saludos!

  • @Thrym7 Es GOD's metal

  • @Thrym7 Pues para no ser metal, ahí tienes uno de los mejores baterías del metal probablemente ;)

    ¿Qué entiendes tú por metal? Es que hay tanta diferencia, por ejemplo entre Iron Maiden y Dream Theater... Y no me dirás que no son metal!?

  • What a Riff!!!

  • When is this from?

  • @Nightbird87 Looks like Rockpalast in Germany, don't know the year.

  • @Darkaero199 4.33 "thank you chicago!"

  • @skyseye ya i know i replied before the video ended. Didn't care enough to delete or fix it.

  • @Nightbird87 England !! brother !! XD

  • @eddnoit This is very similar to the concert they played in 08 here in portugal , in Porto, it was great *.*

  • @eddnoit Why would he say "thank you, CHICAGO" at the end, if this is from england?

  • @poopypie111 Your the sort of person that take everything seriously?... He's obviously having a joke.

  • @eddnoit Then why would he say, "thank you CHICAGO," at the end?

  • @eddnoit This show was filmed in Chicago in 2005.

  • @eddnoit

    yeah, England, that's when.... um

  • @eddnoit he asked "when" but ok... lol

  • @eddnoit Um...He says "thank you Chicago" at the end. This is from the Arriving Somewhere DVD, which was filmed in Chicago, Illinois USA in 2005.

  • @Nightbird87 2009. It's on the Arriving Somewhere DVD. Fantastic gig.

  • Great stuff. LOVE it!

  • @wardadams

    Agreed!