Apples and oranges, my friends. Johnny did an amazing cover. As a long time Springsteen fan, I like this better, yet I love that an icon such as Johnny felt strongly enough to cover it. I'm pretty sure Bruce wouldn't have given permission for tJohnny to cover it, if he didn't fel it was an honor.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i can really do without bruce's "accent". it sounds forced and phony. and cash's version sucks. it reduces him to just a voice. bruce's original version is so great- with the subtle touches of deep emotion and mystery that he succeeds, strangely enough, in making cash sound like the sinatra of american folk song. was a little disappointed too to find out theres no song on record for night of the johnsontown flood. ha! but this is still a great song.
Cash has a way of making songs his own even if they aren't songs he wrote. Personally, I prefer the Cash version, but all props to Springsteen for writing a great song...would love to have heard Cash do Atlantic City!
i'd like to think if johnny were alive he'd say he was just playing a beautiful song by a modern master. he introduced people to a classic, like Sunday Morning Coming Down years before. this is as close as we will ever get to a passing of the torch as we'll ever get. i miss Johnny so much, but i thank the powers at be for Bruce Springsteen.
You have to listen, a few times, honestly. Bruce (who wrote & did this song first, off Nebraska, his first acoustic CD, was actually, @ the time harshly judged by MANY, casue wasn't "HIM", it grew to be appreciated (real fans we all liked it). Took several plays to like Mr. Cash's but I do now. It does take a while. Next, "Hurt" again, had to listen a few times to. Grew to LOVE it. So did Trent (NIN), who after seeing the video & hearing it, said "this is Johnny's song now" WOW.
johnny cash is far better at there is no doubt. kevinm you must just be a springsteen fan you would have to be to think hes better at it,jc made it his own
I hear where you are coming from. I had to listen to Mr. Cash's several times. I think I enjoy Springsteen's version better, my husb. says the opposite. That is 100% fine. Like to some younger kids who loved Madonna's "American Pie", as many of us said "wow, she destroyed that". It's hard to think about a totally different artist do a song, from someone who u enjoy or heard it first by them. Mr. Cash made this his in a way. As well as "Hurt", who even Trent Reznor said "wow" this is Johnny's
i dont know man i like johnny cash's version better, but of course he didnt write it which is the hardest part of being a musician. good song either way.
Apples and oranges, my friends. Johnny did an amazing cover. As a long time Springsteen fan, I like this better, yet I love that an icon such as Johnny felt strongly enough to cover it. I'm pretty sure Bruce wouldn't have given permission for tJohnny to cover it, if he didn't fel it was an honor.
beatlelover111 3 months ago
i hate those people that say,, "WOW i was at that gig,,it was awesome!!" btw,i was at this gig and it was awesome!
clawlesslawless 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i can really do without bruce's "accent". it sounds forced and phony. and cash's version sucks. it reduces him to just a voice. bruce's original version is so great- with the subtle touches of deep emotion and mystery that he succeeds, strangely enough, in making cash sound like the sinatra of american folk song. was a little disappointed too to find out theres no song on record for night of the johnsontown flood. ha! but this is still a great song.
roycouped 2 years ago
Cash has a way of making songs his own even if they aren't songs he wrote. Personally, I prefer the Cash version, but all props to Springsteen for writing a great song...would love to have heard Cash do Atlantic City!
EmitFlestiKY 2 years ago 2
i'd like to think if johnny were alive he'd say he was just playing a beautiful song by a modern master. he introduced people to a classic, like Sunday Morning Coming Down years before. this is as close as we will ever get to a passing of the torch as we'll ever get. i miss Johnny so much, but i thank the powers at be for Bruce Springsteen.
matthewfawkes 2 years ago
Moi j'aime bien la musique country comme celle du Boss et non ce que l'on entends dans le feuilleton "Johnny texas ranger "
parygo 2 years ago
springsteens the best version.
its like how everyone says cash's version of hurt is better.
but the original nine inch nails version is 100 times better
MaliceMizery1 2 years ago
You have to listen, a few times, honestly. Bruce (who wrote & did this song first, off Nebraska, his first acoustic CD, was actually, @ the time harshly judged by MANY, casue wasn't "HIM", it grew to be appreciated (real fans we all liked it). Took several plays to like Mr. Cash's but I do now. It does take a while. Next, "Hurt" again, had to listen a few times to. Grew to LOVE it. So did Trent (NIN), who after seeing the video & hearing it, said "this is Johnny's song now" WOW.
malkylamm 2 years ago 2
one of the best melodies ever.
ccreaglesfan 2 years ago
johnny cash is far better at there is no doubt. kevinm you must just be a springsteen fan you would have to be to think hes better at it,jc made it his own
SuperDoodles1 2 years ago
This will ALWAYS be Bruce Springsteen's song.
ShotgunBlues42 2 years ago
I hear where you are coming from. I had to listen to Mr. Cash's several times. I think I enjoy Springsteen's version better, my husb. says the opposite. That is 100% fine. Like to some younger kids who loved Madonna's "American Pie", as many of us said "wow, she destroyed that". It's hard to think about a totally different artist do a song, from someone who u enjoy or heard it first by them. Mr. Cash made this his in a way. As well as "Hurt", who even Trent Reznor said "wow" this is Johnny's
malkylamm 2 years ago 2
i dont know man i like johnny cash's version better, but of course he didnt write it which is the hardest part of being a musician. good song either way.
shane013088 2 years ago 3
I like JC's version better too... but all credits for writing the song to Bruce.
jazeker2 2 years ago
thanks for the awesome share, Tuks! peace2u! eric
no2hate 2 years ago
listen no1 loves johnny cash more than me but the boss is the BOSS!
kevinm1999 3 years ago 8
...this is a great version..iv only heard jonny cash version till this one,,.its good..
mossy86 3 years ago 3
Listen to the one off Springsteen's album.
bugattibowler 3 years ago 3