Alan Tam 譚詠麟& Jacky Cheung 張學友(超級經典對唱) 幻影/情已逝

[karencn1117]

我要修改我之前的评论，唱功这个东西无法定义，没有标准；一个歌­手是否唱得好要看是否能打动听众，阿伦在任何一次现场演唱都做到­了这点。再说声线，阿伦的更清澈，穿透力更强

[ozalice96]

@karencn1117 You are entitled to your opinion but that doesn't necessarily mean Alan Tam is a better singer than Jacky. Jacky's vocal is so full of emotions that he's able to move his audience to tears in his concerts all the time! Alan's own songs suit him better and it's true that he can interpret them slightly better than Jacky. By the same token, Jacky sang his own songs MUCH BETTER than Alan too! So, whoever you idolize is just a matter of choice. Obviously, Jacky has my vote!

[MrTweetyhack]

Can some provide titles for each of these songs? Thanks.

[anyway606]

@MrTweetyhack 幻影/情已逝/愛的根源/只願一生愛一人/雨夜的浪漫/愛在深秋



[MrTweetyhack]

@anyway606 haha, thanks. This matches the characters in the description! This is a really good video, has some of my favorite songs! Too bad I can't Chinese!

[apple185604]

世紀PK!!!!!!

[ChyeHengTay]

owhhh...This is the era of many talented singers..

[zsljulius]

Looks like jacky has more votes

[xiaowla]

学友唱爱的根源，过犹不及，还是校长版收放合度。两人的和音真不­好听。校长跟克勤，阿lam的和唱比较悦耳。

[b93101063]

張學友唱愛的根源，完全進入狀態。



[gilakia]

@MrTweetyhack Nope. There's a lag in the video. Go have a closer look man. Jacky Cheung doesn't need to lipsync.

[MrTweetyhack]

@gilakia Ahh, you are right. I take it back.

[karencn1117]

觉得还是校长唱得好，或许唱功上学友好一点，但是Alan唱得更­有感染力更打动人

[maskriderrx]

@karencn1117 非常同意！！校长唱歌很有感情，很有感染力，轻易就打入你心扉。­。。

[louishongkong]

alan is super much better than jacky.  no doubt!

[robot923]

咁都好比..=.=

[jack94123]

講唱得好0地就當然譚詠麟啦. 不過記得歌詞可能學友好0地...(不信可以去問0下李生)

[vluongabc]

Why can't Alan Tam remember any lyrics... like, ever? :p

[kkabcdef]

85年林子祥和譚詠麟對唱十分十二吋, 大紅大紫的譚詠麟一開聲就想在聲音上壓過對方 最後林子祥用超高音才逼退譚詠麟.

想不到差不多10年後, 又重演了一次, 譚詠麟被大紅大紫的後輩張學友用同樣的方法來上一下 :P

[garykyl]

阿倫好好多.

[h3366991512]

兩位都不同味道 但是情已逝 學友唱得好多了 

譚校長 節拍感不是很好

[RapNameChaudeezy18]

Two of the most hansome Chinese men on the face of the planet!

Why do they HAVE to be heterosexual? :( :(

[star0919ywh]

校長好聽d！

[WuFei0707]

Alan was just mixed up with the lyrics of Jacky's song. It didn't feel professional at all. I really feel Jacky put more preparation and heart on this show.

[ozalice96]

Jacky's interpretation of his own songs is much better

than Alan but Alan's execution of his own songs is

slightly better than Jacky. I guess different songs suit

different artists and they are both great singers in their

own right. Personally speaking, Jacky is more my cup

of tea! Love you, Jacky!

[fly110]

@ozalice96 You're absolutely correct.., different kind of songs fit different artists..., but they both are incredibly awesome..~

[ozalice96]

@fly110 Thanks. Best wishes to you from Down Under!

[kwong23426299]

0:20 絕對同意！

[winghowwh]

雖然張學友真係一個好好既歌手 但企係譚詠麟隔黎...刀下立見

[PerfectDiver]

@winghowwh 睇多幾d學友既live先講喇~ 歌神就係歌神

[winghowwh]

@PerfectDiver 唔該你聽多D呀麟既LIVE先講野喇...

講壓場技巧 張學友都係差幾班

人地張學友係學譚詠麟既台風

學佢唱功(早期)

張學友既偶像係譚詠麟你又知唔知呀

歌神歌神 ...

第一代情歌歌神係譚詠麟呀 睇下樂壇歷史啦高人

[aaronloklok]

學友感情不夠校長好……

明明D歌既感情表達係淡淡悠情，卻唱到 要生要死……

學友過份賣弄技巧……我唔係好鍾意……especially 愛的根源

而雨夜的浪漫學友和得好難聽……

校長：從容

學友：太著緊……

如果只看這次演出，我覺得克勤會唱得好過學友~

[PerfectDiver]

@aaronloklok 睇多幾d學友既live先講喇~ 歌神就係歌神

[MCTO0111]

忘詞有什麼大不了！學友都甩咀喇！慈善節目，臨時臨急，好聼就o­k喇！

[MCTO0111]

忘詞有什麼大不了，學友都有甩嘴呀!慈善節目，臨時上陣！好聴咪­得囉！

[funnybunny9396]

love jacky!!!!

[Bobby0917]

谭咏麟絕對可以稱得上是忘詞校長

[xarm0844052]

@Bobby0917 譚詠麟這樣子忘詞太對不起庾澄慶了吧

[hobecky]

love Alan Tam

[MCTO0111]

@hobecky 同意