اگر کسی میخواهد به جواب شبهاتی که مشیری مطرح میکنه رو ببینه اینو "وب سایت مصطفی حسینی طباطبایی" تو گوگل جستجو کنه. تو سایت آقای طباطبایی چند تا کلیپ درمورده نقد آقای مشیری وجود داره.
that is the problem my freind, for instance the story of mahdi, there is not document or even evidence that this shei's zoro even born, but based on that yek kalagh chel kalagh we have some naive gullible ignorant uneducated people belive in this imajinary figure, even rationaly his existance is meaningless, please read kasravi's book if you are after truth.good luck.
Dote Gerami,momene aziz,az inke az eslam defa mikonid kasi bahsi nadarad.bahs inast ke javab soal ra nadadeid o bahsi digar ke khod eshtebah ast be mian keshideh eid.
barardar gerami, tabari be zaman sadre eslam nazdik tar bod ya movarekhin shiee?
nesbat tabari ba zaman pighambare eslam mesle nesbate ma(aknon) ast ba doreye naseredin shah.
arabballer..bikhodi az eslam defa nakon. No matter what shit you have to say..Islam has shown the world for 1400 what it´s worth and what becomes of a muslim..nothing but garbage.
lets analyze: moslim in spain for 800 years... NO force conversions of the people. moslims ruled india for 1000 years, if they were to convert at the point of the sword there wouldnt be a single hindu left. lets see... zoroastarian... still in iran, lets see, coptic christians (since the begining of xtianity)... molims ruled middleast for 1400 years now... if there was EKRAH in DIN, you would not see a single xtian, jew, or zartoshti alive. moshiri just talks alot of shit.
Kadban Moshiri gerami. Osulan be mosalmane (moemen), bakhesus as noe Shie, ab dar havan koobidan ast. As bachegui mahgzeshoon chenan por as khorafat va in harfha mishe ke dige jaii baraye kharad nemimooneh!
this is very interesting. this guy is reading out of TARIKH TABARI... this "history" was written 300 years after Prophet (sa), and its is ALL BASED ON HEARSAY. hear say mean "yek kalagh chel kalagh" none of this will hold water in a court of law.
ok, if you going this dirction then what makes you think the saying of shieas are not hearsay? tabari va vaghefi are the histories that both suni and shie reffer to, but the pick and choose
Shoma enghadar doroogh be Eslam mibandin , Zabane arabi La ekraha fi din ro tarjome konid . Be khoda ghasam ke shakhsiate Peiambare eslam ba dorooghaie shoma zire soal nemire . Ghoran ra la aghal be farsi bekhanid ta bebinid Mohamad faghtat peiambare khoda bood va hamchon yek Periambar zendegi kard .
باز هم مغالطات بچه گانه با درون مایه تحریف
MrCheshmak86 7 months ago
اگر کسی میخواهد به جواب شبهاتی که مشیری مطرح میکنه رو ببینه اینو "وب سایت مصطفی حسینی طباطبایی" تو گوگل جستجو کنه. تو سایت آقای طباطبایی چند تا کلیپ درمورده نقد آقای مشیری وجود داره.
navvabk 10 months ago
طرح جدیدی ارایه می کنیم، مبنی بر اهدا هفتاد میلیون آروغ و گوز برای سلامتی! پیغمبرخدا علی ابن ابی طالب: امام زمان
bikhoda1 11 months ago
that is the problem my freind, for instance the story of mahdi, there is not document or even evidence that this shei's zoro even born, but based on that yek kalagh chel kalagh we have some naive gullible ignorant uneducated people belive in this imajinary figure, even rationaly his existance is meaningless, please read kasravi's book if you are after truth.good luck.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
Kiram to dahaneh Mohammad.
Ridam be islam.
Kos e naneye harchi Basiji o Sepahi.
Kos e naneye Khmenei va ridagm be ghabr e Khomeyni.
epknman 2 years ago 2
Afarin! Besyaar jalebe!
houmie 4 years ago 4
mehdiassadi
to boro be farsi bekhoon bebin ke che kose sherayi oon mohammade koskeshe bache baz neweshte
khodaye ma iranian allahe to nist
khodaye ma ahuramazdast
man ridam be har chi arabe koskeshe az 1400 sale pish ta emrooz
damnislam 4 years ago 3
kale antar zan
yaani chi "bikhodi" defa nakon?
kossher migin...vaghti javabetoono midano zaboonetoon kootah miad az roo toon mizarin... ba har haal kheili kharin.
amooballer 5 years ago
Dote Gerami,momene aziz,az inke az eslam defa mikonid kasi bahsi nadarad.bahs inast ke javab soal ra nadadeid o bahsi digar ke khod eshtebah ast be mian keshideh eid.
barardar gerami, tabari be zaman sadre eslam nazdik tar bod ya movarekhin shiee?
nesbat tabari ba zaman pighambare eslam mesle nesbate ma(aknon) ast ba doreye naseredin shah.
hal kodam "ALL BASED ON HEARSAY" ast?
BIDGANI 5 years ago
arabballer..bikhodi az eslam defa nakon. No matter what shit you have to say..Islam has shown the world for 1400 what it´s worth and what becomes of a muslim..nothing but garbage.
KalantarZand 5 years ago
LA EKRAHE DIN
lets analyze: moslim in spain for 800 years... NO force conversions of the people. moslims ruled india for 1000 years, if they were to convert at the point of the sword there wouldnt be a single hindu left. lets see... zoroastarian... still in iran, lets see, coptic christians (since the begining of xtianity)... molims ruled middleast for 1400 years now... if there was EKRAH in DIN, you would not see a single xtian, jew, or zartoshti alive. moshiri just talks alot of shit.
amooballer 5 years ago
Doste Gerami comment shoma ro pak nemikonam..be in dalil ke digaran bebinand yek momen be DIN dar moghable enteghad che axolamali dare...
Defa az Eslam aziz mesle ine ke bekhaeid ye ajozeye 1400 sale ro bazak koni o jaye ye dokhtar 14 sale ja bezani..
GANDESH KHILI VAGHTE DAR OMADE..
BIDGANI 5 years ago
Kadban Moshiri gerami. Osulan be mosalmane (moemen), bakhesus as noe Shie, ab dar havan koobidan ast. As bachegui mahgzeshoon chenan por as khorafat va in harfha mishe ke dige jaii baraye kharad nemimooneh!
seeksake 5 years ago
this is very interesting. this guy is reading out of TARIKH TABARI... this "history" was written 300 years after Prophet (sa), and its is ALL BASED ON HEARSAY. hear say mean "yek kalagh chel kalagh" none of this will hold water in a court of law.
amooballer 5 years ago
ok, if you going this dirction then what makes you think the saying of shieas are not hearsay? tabari va vaghefi are the histories that both suni and shie reffer to, but the pick and choose
kuroshe1 2 years ago
if the stories or ahadees dont match with Quran, or are against it, those ahadees are null. thats the standard.
amooballer 2 years ago
Shoma enghadar doroogh be Eslam mibandin , Zabane arabi La ekraha fi din ro tarjome konid . Be khoda ghasam ke shakhsiate Peiambare eslam ba dorooghaie shoma zire soal nemire . Ghoran ra la aghal be farsi bekhanid ta bebinid Mohamad faghtat peiambare khoda bood va hamchon yek Periambar zendegi kard .
mehdiassadi 5 years ago
baba to ke miai name Khoda ra tu dahanet mibari, miduni vajeh Khoda az kojah miad, ke miai zere Arabi mizani?
Hamoon lighatet Arabo Farhange Sarboridane.
Yekam boro Khodavande Zartoshto ra ba Allahe Mohammad moghayese kon, bebin Khoda mitune Allah bashe, ya Allah hamoon Ahremane!?
ariapars 5 years ago