A whole lot of the lyrical content of this album, including the title, is borrowed from a Luc Sante poem called Unknown Soldier. I sort of wonder what they were going for.
@srfrr no dude its not hipster, well okay it is a little, but not compeltely, its got a bit of original post-revival feel to it, and lets face it, that's one of the only genre's that can save us from the evil that is hipster, i personally wish there could be a complete punk revival, but that probably wont happen with all this indie and screamo bull shit so we have to band together and support post-punk revival because its the only thing we got, its all that's original these days : /
@LutraphobiaProd nothing about a revival is original. Hipster is a word, not a mass of people. I mean seriously, you're not using your head when you say shit like "save us from the evil that is hipster". You sound like some old war vet talking about how much he hates hippies, but you don't have the years or the conviction to actually hate 'hipsters', so it's just empty talk. This music was happening way before modern stereotypical 'hipsters' so don't label it that, even a little.
im trying to find songs from "they threw us in a trench..." live on youtube. Any footage out there? they don't seem to play any of them at shows anymore either, which i guess i could understand.
Look, the point is not which band is more "gay". Liars and Arctic Monkeys encompass two completely different styles and genres of music. To even begin to compare is idiocy.
Maybe I'm out of the loop on this one but I guess they have two different versions of this song? Because on my album it's a completely different song, very fast paced.
Yeah, I know it. I just said that the sound reminds me Arctic Monkeys. I think that maybe Arctic Monkeys copy the sound. I think this song is great, but I love too Arctic Monkeys. That´s a matter of taste. But nobody can deny that Liars are more original
see i dont hear gang of four at all. i guess i hear pop group, but i think people need to stop saying that any kind of punk music with melodic basslines sounds like gang of four or reggae influenced.
What makes them sound so similar is the basslines that drive the melody along, the abrasive punk guitar that comes in and out of the song, and the unusual drumming. Plus the singer even sounds a little like Jon King. Oh and riff that starts at :50 sounds exactly like "To Hell With Poverty" by Gang of Four.
the unusual drumming being handclapping instad of a drum beat? The 'abrasive punk guitar' is hardly attributed to just the gang of four, his voice sounds nothing like Jon King on any other song and neither do their riffs. To hell... and Mr. Your... are both bands poppiest songs. Listen to both back catalogues and get back to me if you think the compairson's still there.
haha you fucking wish! Only comparison is they were both ahead of their time. Only Liars were'nt ripping anybody off as blatently (aside from maybe The Fall).
I truly believe that they sound nothing like Gang of Four (who i like alot), i've seen Liars live about 4 times, met them the same amount, heard every album and every track and apart from a few seconds of guitars and maybe his vocals (on this ONE song) there's no comparison. I'm not afraid of saying they sound like other parts of bands at certain points (i.e the Fall) but as a whole, no one like them.
I liked this style for Liars the best. It helped me bridge the gap from noise rock and punk rock to indie rock. I like this song. I thought this was one of their best albums. I loved the experiemental feel it has. :)
Nice, nice. Sounds like Gorillaz's Punk, in a way.
Breedin9Ground 5 months ago
this sound so much like Good Music ahah
ratmbb 6 months ago
This sounds so much like Test Icicles
TimeForDadTime 6 months ago
needs more cowbell
akf2000 6 months ago
4dislikes?! fuuuuck you!!!
yes1985wastheyear 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GO TO MY CHANNEL TO SEE ME ON FIRE
blanketshades 10 months ago
dude I can't believe the yeah yeah yeahs did a cover of this. both of these bands are awesome!!!
Foreignstar 11 months ago
one of those songs where you kinda have to make up your own lyrics
TheRobash 1 year ago 2
Haha looking it up though maybe they just heard an episode of This American Life they really liked and misquoted parts of it for an album
EvanTeH 1 year ago
A whole lot of the lyrical content of this album, including the title, is borrowed from a Luc Sante poem called Unknown Soldier. I sort of wonder what they were going for.
EvanTeH 1 year ago
nosiri'mok...
Kela08 1 year ago
what is the best lairs album
crazychadmb 1 year ago
@crazychadmb They Were Wrong so We Drowned...
TransparentVisions 1 year ago
angus is the greatest
crazychadmb 1 year ago
No sir, I'm O.K.!
christlicker 1 year ago
Love this song and video. When art meets mania!
CarlLikes 1 year ago
Great music.
HandwhistlerBen 1 year ago
umm... mr. you're on fire!! lol
7evann 1 year ago
lol @ 1:11 rocking out
gomezchild 1 year ago
So amazingly hipster... Piss on it!
srfrr 1 year ago
@srfrr no dude its not hipster, well okay it is a little, but not compeltely, its got a bit of original post-revival feel to it, and lets face it, that's one of the only genre's that can save us from the evil that is hipster, i personally wish there could be a complete punk revival, but that probably wont happen with all this indie and screamo bull shit so we have to band together and support post-punk revival because its the only thing we got, its all that's original these days : /
LutraphobiaProd 1 year ago
@LutraphobiaProd Shut up.
christlicker 1 year ago
@LutraphobiaProd listen to more music
hamofthewilly 1 year ago
@LutraphobiaProd boo
srfrr 1 year ago
@LutraphobiaProd nothing about a revival is original. Hipster is a word, not a mass of people. I mean seriously, you're not using your head when you say shit like "save us from the evil that is hipster". You sound like some old war vet talking about how much he hates hippies, but you don't have the years or the conviction to actually hate 'hipsters', so it's just empty talk. This music was happening way before modern stereotypical 'hipsters' so don't label it that, even a little.
blackandpink17 7 months ago
@srfrr and your uploaded videos are gay, its not a problem at all :-)
okavipra 1 year ago
im trying to find songs from "they threw us in a trench..." live on youtube. Any footage out there? they don't seem to play any of them at shows anymore either, which i guess i could understand.
KyostiG 1 year ago
who really gives a fuck about "skins" I honestly dont know what that is...
isolationeitheror 1 year ago
Nice 80s pants Andrew ;)
xoMusicLIFExo 1 year ago
SCI FI !
bbok12 2 years ago
Exists to fuck with your brain waves?
sweetttina666 2 years ago
Both versions are amazing! a great song done wonderfully by two amazing artists.
SonoHanazaki 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah yeah yeahs one is loads betterrrr
ItsGeo43 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you're a fucking idiot.
jasonbigelow 2 years ago
TOMA! YA!
josemp18 2 years ago
This was on Naomi's episode of skins Series 3. :)
iFreyaah 2 years ago 3
the yyy cover is so much better than the liars!!
and i can see how this sounds like the arctic monkeys, but the arctic monkeys are much better.
hollcoll 2 years ago
The yeah yeahs cover is the SHIT!!
Shardz6 2 years ago
wow, this doesn't sound like liars at all! crazy stufffffff.
vanessalyst 2 years ago
but i guess thats what happens when you leave new york...ugh
TheHiddenHavoc 2 years ago
good god. how have the liars escaped my musical radar for so long? did this angus fellow really date karen O of the yyy's?
TheHiddenHavoc 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the yyy cover is so much better
and artic monkey is such a better band then this
lalalatdwp 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i agree, arctic monkeys are better
but the yyy cover really, really sucks..
Dionneman 2 years ago
How can you even begin to compare Arctic Monkeys (spell it correctly at least you twerp) to Liars? They are two completely differing styles of music.
InTheFlowers00 2 years ago
Arctic monkeys are gay in comparing with liars
okavipra 2 years ago
Look, the point is not which band is more "gay". Liars and Arctic Monkeys encompass two completely different styles and genres of music. To even begin to compare is idiocy.
InTheFlowers00 2 years ago
Man im sorry, my post is for the guy DIONNEMAN, this you tube lines are so trickey . . .
okavipra 2 years ago
Comment removed
okavipra 2 years ago
Arctic monkeys are gay in comparing with liars
okavipra 2 years ago
ahahah cooolll
vomitcreature 2 years ago
i hear........foals.....
in this...........
isolationeitheror 2 years ago
Foals came AFTER this!
InTheFlowers00 2 years ago
yeah i know...but still
isolationeitheror 2 years ago
very arctic monkeys
ijustsigneduptobagu 2 years ago
Maybe I'm out of the loop on this one but I guess they have two different versions of this song? Because on my album it's a completely different song, very fast paced.
Zoootex 2 years ago
I like the Yeah Yeah Yeah's cover better than the original :)
stephen181 2 years ago
Seriously, man? The Yeah Yeah Yeahs cover is an abortion of this song. Such a back alley job.
tdawgmark3 2 years ago
one of the greatest songs in the history of the world! seriously!
punkb0ner 3 years ago 19
I totally agree. The first time I heard that album I fell in love with it. I have yet to hear all of their other albums entirely, but love the Liars.
joseharr1985 3 years ago
@punkb0ner Thanks. I wish it didn't require the "seriously" but thank you.
smugybear 4 months ago
The guitar of this songs reminds ne the sound of Arctic monkey
Punketalero 3 years ago
but liars (and this song) was before arctic-monkey-time ;-) both are great, but this song is better than any of the arctics
nevrevr 3 years ago 12
Yeah, I know it. I just said that the sound reminds me Arctic Monkeys. I think that maybe Arctic Monkeys copy the sound. I think this song is great, but I love too Arctic Monkeys. That´s a matter of taste. But nobody can deny that Liars are more original
Punketalero 3 years ago
So we think same way, dig that ;-)
nevrevr 3 years ago
@nevrevr no
RepettoDance 1 year ago
it puts the jiggle on the ass
eltonmesquita 3 years ago
Gang of Four anybody?
adredo9 3 years ago 3
also a great band! (and I'm aware of your point)
fjallman90 3 years ago
see i dont hear gang of four at all. i guess i hear pop group, but i think people need to stop saying that any kind of punk music with melodic basslines sounds like gang of four or reggae influenced.
cartoonist2000 3 years ago
What makes them sound so similar is the basslines that drive the melody along, the abrasive punk guitar that comes in and out of the song, and the unusual drumming. Plus the singer even sounds a little like Jon King. Oh and riff that starts at :50 sounds exactly like "To Hell With Poverty" by Gang of Four.
adredo9 3 years ago
the unusual drumming being handclapping instad of a drum beat? The 'abrasive punk guitar' is hardly attributed to just the gang of four, his voice sounds nothing like Jon King on any other song and neither do their riffs. To hell... and Mr. Your... are both bands poppiest songs. Listen to both back catalogues and get back to me if you think the compairson's still there.
cruiserscreek 3 years ago
Too true. Fit it in a box as soon as you hear it! why???
cruiserscreek 3 years ago
haha you fucking wish! Only comparison is they were both ahead of their time. Only Liars were'nt ripping anybody off as blatently (aside from maybe The Fall).
cruiserscreek 3 years ago
I thought Gang of Four when I heard their first album. I think there are plenty of comparitors. That doesn't disrespect the liars one bit.
threebobs 3 years ago
I truly believe that they sound nothing like Gang of Four (who i like alot), i've seen Liars live about 4 times, met them the same amount, heard every album and every track and apart from a few seconds of guitars and maybe his vocals (on this ONE song) there's no comparison. I'm not afraid of saying they sound like other parts of bands at certain points (i.e the Fall) but as a whole, no one like them.
cruiserscreek 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i saw this band and they suck a shit load of dick
psholland1 3 years ago
Do you?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
benherne1990 3 years ago
polyrhythmic punk-funk at it's best and weirdest.
theblurter 3 years ago
which album is thsi from?
which one do nay of u recomend?
i wanna get the they were wrong so we drowned one
admaski 3 years ago
it's from they threw us all in a trench and stuck a monument on top (blast first/mute 2002)
fergsgref 3 years ago
i saw this on tele in an Asutrian cafe
well shocked they'd b playign sumthin like the liars!
admaski 3 years ago
I liked this style for Liars the best. It helped me bridge the gap from noise rock and punk rock to indie rock. I like this song. I thought this was one of their best albums. I loved the experiemental feel it has. :)
AintGotSkillz 3 years ago
Christ i cant imagine Liars ever being like this now, thank fuck.
TheIkaraCult 3 years ago
In my oh-so-humble opinion, I think this is the best The Liars ever were.
JaredLikesCandy 3 years ago
I actually like their current, heavy rhythm style more. It feels more like a breath of fresh air.
AWM05 3 years ago
way back when this came out it was a huge breath of fresh air. the style just got done to death in the following years
mrjez 3 years ago
Way back? This was only like four years ago. Maybe six at best. You fucking kids under the age of 25 have no perspective on time.
WeMustBeStopped 2 years ago
well the album was originally released in october 2001. so that would be 8 years. jackass
tinyspecks 2 years ago 2
Eight years does not approximate "way back," which was my point, li'l britches. Get it?
WeMustBeStopped 2 years ago
and my point is that you are pointless
tinyspecks 2 years ago 2
brilliant
chilly007 3 years ago
yeah, but the singer reformed under the same name, they technically never broke up.
jok3rinthepack 3 years ago
Yay! First comment, i just ordered this cd after previously listening to samples, this is old, but i like it!!
jok3rinthepack 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ya my uncle is the bass guitar player in this band but its too bad they broke up a few years ago, the lead singer left for austrailia
jesmo6459 3 years ago