I'm gonna be lynched, but I think it's far too rigid, mainly the beginning. Menuhin seems, generally speaking, sometimes out of the music, out of his instrument, not really here when he plays, even if he's a virtuoso. Suppose it's a matter of reading of Bach's music. I prefer the interpretations of Stern or Oistrakh, but I must admit this recording is one of the best he did.
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
@18GAKUPO Baroque composers generally didn't write in many dynamics in their pieces because the performers of that time were expected to interpret it on their own. I agree that he did a nice job with it.
Particurlamente não gosto tanto do Menuhin como violinista acho que as vezes pela caracteristica do seu som algumas vezes o som dele sai muito sujo e não tão claro mais esse concerto na minha opinião éa melhor interpretação de todas.
HHHHEI!!! Actually what BWV is it???? i see there are 3 song that same, but the titles are different. someone call it bwv 1041, someone call it bwv 1048, someone call it bwv 1058 too. which is true???
menuhin's bach always Unique in every thing. Bach himself is present inside Menuhin's Mind,and Heart. Althrough his so many recording sof Bach's Concertos he always put something new. I'm preparing to upload his last Stodeo recordings for these Concertos as a Soloist, as well as a Conductor. It's just to mention here Menuhin recorded these Concertos with the top ranked Conductors, including his teacher Enescu, Monteux, etc but I'm so sure all of you w'll like his recordingaViolinist&Conductor
hola imusiciki yo como violinista me encanta bach el concierto en la menor demuestra como un caprucho dentro del compositor, lo que mas me gusta de bach es como le saca a sus obras las mejores formas menores de tono
Subscribe to me, I swear on my x-box I will subscibe back!!!
pyroasians 1 month ago
i can play this song!!!!! with the violin is obvious
tomy19061996 2 months ago
LEGENDARY VIOLIN PLAYER VIDEO, Y U NO HAVE NO DISLIKES?!
PCGanci 2 months ago
i love how he plays it slower then most so you can really get the feeling of the music.
i am playing this right now and this really helps me hear the intonation.
thanks
llamadramacatfish 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm gonna be lynched, but I think it's far too rigid, mainly the beginning. Menuhin seems, generally speaking, sometimes out of the music, out of his instrument, not really here when he plays, even if he's a virtuoso. Suppose it's a matter of reading of Bach's music. I prefer the interpretations of Stern or Oistrakh, but I must admit this recording is one of the best he did.
Againstwalls 2 months ago
Comment removed
Againstwalls 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Lightningman10000 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Lightningman10000 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Lightningman10000 4 months ago
Very good! One comment though at the beginning should be for smoother or crispyer depending on what style, and play faster. Overall, very good and hope this comment would help you.
Lightningman10000 4 months ago
@18GAKUPO Baroque composers generally didn't write in many dynamics in their pieces because the performers of that time were expected to interpret it on their own. I agree that he did a nice job with it.
thepsybrary 6 months ago
Getting slow !
makesolid 7 months ago
@makesolid Actually, he speeds up a teeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeny bit.
PCGanci 2 months ago
Particurlamente não gosto tanto do Menuhin como violinista acho que as vezes pela caracteristica do seu som algumas vezes o som dele sai muito sujo e não tão claro mais esse concerto na minha opinião éa melhor interpretação de todas.
jeffersonfsoares 7 months ago
allahım şurada türkçe bilen yok mu ya:)???
MrCansu 10 months ago
@MrCansu Ben biliyorum :P
GobbleGobbleTurkish 9 months ago
great!!!
ferediiii 11 months ago
What's the name of the first piece?
Mrspeddy3 1 year ago
@Mrspeddy3 concerto in A minor
bianca93xD 1 year ago
HHHHEI!!! Actually what BWV is it???? i see there are 3 song that same, but the titles are different. someone call it bwv 1041, someone call it bwv 1048, someone call it bwv 1058 too. which is true???
aghaanantyab 1 year ago
@aghaanantyab 1041=A minor concerto, 1048=brandenburg no. 3, and 1058=g minor harpsichord concerto(no. 7) based off of this concerto
hope this helps
counterpoint35 1 year ago
menuhin = superlative musician and magnificent and truly genuine individual
themusicdr 1 year ago
SUBLIME.
31122051 1 year ago
Comment removed
polymath7 1 year ago
beautiful!
MyHaloFan117 1 year ago 2
Silence !!! I want to listen !!!!!!
955151t 2 years ago 43
nice played , but with harpsicord it sound way better , it gives that baroque touch
Dirkovic80 2 years ago 10
Such a sweet tone.
Not at all overly assertive, like Perlman's recording.
And Menuhin was only 17 when he made this recording!
Astounding maturity.
987bry 2 years ago 9
according to the info he was 20 when this track was recorded :P
Xsilord 2 years ago
@Xsilord Oh, twenty? Are you sure?
polymath7 1 year ago
@polymath7 yeah, born 1916, and it was recorded in 1936.
Xsilord 1 year ago
menuhin's bach always Unique in every thing. Bach himself is present inside Menuhin's Mind,and Heart. Althrough his so many recording sof Bach's Concertos he always put something new. I'm preparing to upload his last Stodeo recordings for these Concertos as a Soloist, as well as a Conductor. It's just to mention here Menuhin recorded these Concertos with the top ranked Conductors, including his teacher Enescu, Monteux, etc but I'm so sure all of you w'll like his recordingaViolinist&Conductor
Mozart99900 2 years ago 3
whenever I listen to his playing I feel like the way I play is total useless compare to this beauty.
maryam6384 2 years ago 4
lol, ive been playin for 4 years and im learnin this, its easy!
violinprodigy100 2 years ago 4
muy buena pieza, la voy a comenzar a estudiar : D
AkuzameConTuHermana 2 years ago 3
his tone is t3h pwnage
seahyimin 2 years ago 9
it's wonderful!!!!!!!
robbe8889 2 years ago 8
you should read his books dude hes a good writer
festershred 3 years ago 6
If this is the recording I'm thinking of, he's around eighteen or nineteen years old here.
polymath7 3 years ago 3
Isn't this the recording Meuhin did with his teacher, Georg Enuescu? (forgive me if I've mis-spelled the latter's name)
polymath7 3 years ago 2
hola imusiciki yo como violinista me encanta bach el concierto en la menor demuestra como un caprucho dentro del compositor, lo que mas me gusta de bach es como le saca a sus obras las mejores formas menores de tono
5 stras
crhistomus 3 years ago 2