Added: 5 years ago
From: jthelms
Views: 5,004,797
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (5,784)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This song will be played at my funreal.

  • One word.... Powerful!

  • I never though t I could like the organ so much.

  • That organ is fucking badass.

  • Damn, the song is so good, and the video is perfect, my friend.

  • This song is pure philosophical genius. listen people

  • Love the strain in his voice, specially at "Still my heart beats so slow". Very sincere, which is hard to come by.

  • this video you made is perfect imo. it fits music so goddamn right

  • Somehow this song fits my life so much.

  • Glad to know how it turned out, now I don't havta sit thru that 70's crawler

  • awesome band, awesome movie, awesome video

  • Best video on YouTube.

  • Never have I seen a song capture a scene so more beautifully. Bravo, sir.

  • this song is tearing my soul, didn't know it until I saw the trailer of Shame that uses it.

  • this song makes me want to name my new band "clint feastwood"

  • i wish i could die in a deep sleep of ice freeze listening to this song, while judas, tom sawyer, martin luther and robert frost look on and approve my indie super lifestyle/outfit/mustache... in toronto, portland or brooklyn... any one of these three

  • Bronson, Fonda, Arcade Fire - brilliant

  • ultra kewl song! and i lurve westerns!

  • love this movie... and i love arcade fire. what a combo!

  • i feel like this is a great damn vid for the song.

  • Some of the most brilliant editing I have seen, so much emotion conveyed, this video is the most beautiful thing I have seen in awhile. Great job!

  • Brilliant song and video to match. Good job.

  • god, i hate these fucking ads

  • i get shivers from this movie+the song

  • The best film ever! 

  • Diggin this song.

  • This movie is good but a little slow in action but check it out "Once Upon a Time in the West."

  • How could you dislike this song seriously.

  • like it if House brought you here.

  • I must not rape the replay button

  • Macklemore - Kings.

  • I cannot tell you how beautiful this video is. I could tell you how the music ties brilliantly with the images, how the lyrics create an emotional core to the perfect camera work, or just say how cool it is. Truthfully, it's just...beautiful.

  • Do I the only one to be jealous ?

  • If only Clint were in the video...

  • House

  • OH MY GOD ! That's the...twentieth time that I watch that video, and I finally catched the sense of the "clip" !

  • @sidera95 Me too, and i don't know why but i cried!

  • greatest unoficial trailer I have EVER seen. really good job

  • I honestly have to admit that Peter Gabriel's version is emotional, sensual, better.

  • @TheChangeMyLife Just because it's slower doesn't mean it's emotional. Or sensual. Or better. I think that Wyn Butler's delivery of the song would have to be the best, based on the fact that he wrote the song based on personal emotions. All Peter Gabriel did was try to interpret that emotional expression.

  • hu toddy bas i gajs thumbs up if you get it

  • they make me feel proud to be canadian

  • My brother has this album on vinyl and it sounds amazing!

  • So so good :D

  • THUMBS UP! for montreal artists!

  • @fastblackshapes MONTRÉAL FTW!

    

  • the guy who made this video, hes a student in my high school English class, it was for a project to label all the parts of a story. ex: foreshadowing, flashback, suspense, irony, etc. etc.

  • !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!

  • does anyone want to know what I came to see this video? I mean like if you're interested in knowing why I came like because of a movie or something.

  • Nearly five million. Arcade are brilliant as is this video with it. Congrats all round

  • My older bro showed me dis movie wen i was 9, im pretty sure it scarred me for life cuz i remember wen we were going to see true grit, i was pretty darn scared to cuz of tht scene wit the boy and his father standin on his shoulders to keep him alive :\ i come back as a 12 yr old listenin to arcade fire, comin across this song and rememberin this movie tryin to figure out the name of it!

  • Love this movie and the song fits

  • Me encanta! conmovedora historia de venganza, y por supuesto una gran canción!

  • "We are living in a age that calls darkness light" Becoming truer by the day.

  • @DickyDer1 wow thats actually ana amazing quote

  • @Beastify9pointO its a lyric in the song...

  • @DickyDer1 What do you mean by this?

  • @freddierice its a lyric in the song meaning we glorify the ugly in our society money sex etc

  • i think this is the greatest video on the net

  • your video is so good, theres an advertisment on it now....i remember being the 243 veiwer of this video and there was no ad

    

  • NICE WORK LUV IT  CHECK OUT SEMAJ MY BODY

  • i think God edited this

  • fantastic music video! its also really amazing how old this movie is and still the picture and the colors are so beautiful.

  • @mvman14 Pure Sergio Leone magic (:

  • This should be the official video. Fantastic.

  • WOWWWW!!!

    

  • No, you brought two too many.

  • brilliant video, perfect

  • I like this song. watch?v=Z5xOPjJ43BA New Song

  • rainymood. com + this = :O :D

  • “People say that your dreams are the only thing that saves ya” W.B.

    How do you like the cover version I did of this song?

  • 0:54 , I can't help loving that his face is all tan, then you look at his neck and your like, "It's Snooki's Twin!"

  • Wow they need to make more songs like this one i cant get enough of it!

  • "Just because you forgot that don't mean you're forgiven" That line alone fits so well with the clip.

  • 11

  • man... i wanna see this move.. where can u see it? i loved the ending so i wanna see the full story :D

  • @TheNepaleseWarrior Its "Once Upon a Time in the West" by Sergio Leone

    

  • @imtheballs2 cheers man thats helps :D now ill go see it. wht wud u rate this movie out of 10?

  • @TheNepaleseWarrior Oh dude, this fucking movie is epic. Its long as fuck, and theres some scenes that are just not needed, but, its worth seeing. i definitely give it an 8 or 9 out of 10. If you enjoyed "The Good The Bad and The Ugly" you'll love this movie.

    

  • best silent film edit ever

  • I think both versions are fantastic in their own way.

  • such an awesome video!

  • Deserved

  • @stwikehimcenturion deserved again and again

  • fuck advertisements

  • @delmerman 0o  ~

  • pwned.

  • love the movie, love the song love this fucking clip!

  • This is the greatest clip I have ever seen on Youtube! Thanks!

  • Beautiful combination man!

  • what movie is this

  • @TheLegodorks

    Once Upon a time in the West.. The Best Western Ever.

  • Comment removed

  • poor old Michael Macintyre couldn't hold him on his shoulders any longer :'(

  • So efficiently incredibly powerful

    added to Narcotrip playlist @quentindecagny

  • Life is so fucking serious, so fucking serious so fucking drafty so fucking lifey so fucking words so fucking here so fucking life right now so fucking life

    Oh god god save us Win save us god fucking fucked god fucking fucked god fucking fucked god fucking fucked god.

  • @MattyMattThing wtf?

  • @MattyMattThing  Schizophrenic Much?

  • @sillyoctopuss I think you mean multipl personality disorder.

  • @steviewarnerbro good joke.

  • Questa canzone è l'ottava meraviglia del mondo! grazie Arcade Fire!

  • @Hybridnight wat

    

  • I watched this movie because of this song and loved it. Now I watch this video and get all roweled up!!

  • I just watched Once Upon a Time in the West because of this video. Thank you jthelms. Thank you. One of the best movies i've ever seen. One of the best songs i've ever heard. I never watched the full video until now. This scene and song were meant for each other.

  • Ive seen this videa litteraly a hundred time but it never stops amazing me!

  • I still hate Phil Collins.

  • great movie, great song, they do go well together. Still hating on you tho!!!! :)

    

  • Does this remind anyone else of Pink Floyd?... No?

  • @buddythecow Peter Gabriel

  • @zalgui wasnt he in genesis though?

  • GREAT THE MOVIE WAS JUST SPOILED....

  • @Cryptically

    I'm more inclined to believe we discover them. Thinking along the lines of the question, "do we ever really create anything new," I wonder if we can really say that we've created an idea. And then, creating seems to imply ownership, but can we really own an idea?

  • That hanging scene at 1:44, even before seeing the video to this song I passed an image of it , without the outlaws on the screen, on Google...what is the name of that place please?

  • Arcade fire should just make this the video for the track, its so well edited its crazy, couldn't have done a better job :)

  • this video is AWESOME.

  • @deadlyhandsomegirl there is a button for that.

  • Sergio Leone+Arcade Fire=a good day

  • this song reminds me of Serj Tankian's (SOAD) philosophy that music comes from inside, music comes pre-arranged, ready to be discovered, and the artist is a skilled performer at best.

  • great chillout song? i don't know, the lyrics are quite heaavy. at least after i first heard Peter Gabriel's version of this song. (IMHO - Peter Gabriel made it more powerful. but Arcade Fire is good as well. :) )

  • Platón.

  • my mind holds the key

  • It's like my mind & body are mesmerized and don't know what to feel, so I feel everything, -including things I've never felt before- at once. It's overwhelming.

  • here play this harmonica while your father stands on your shoulders.....

    ...

  • goosebumps

  • This is better than the official music video... (:

  • hey mama... how bout some cookies?

    No dice...

    Dis' ain't ovah!

  • Amazing song.

  • this is one of the few songs i believe

  • @PLAZTiKMonkey

    Don't even go there..

  • @PLAZTiKMonkey is is possible to unlike something when never liked in this first place? if so, it will be applied here.

  • House M.D. brought me here :P

  • Reminds me of Red Dead Redemption..

  • Pergolini puto! del rock cuadrado no salen en Cual Es.

    bardeando a Arcade FIre y Radiohead diciendo que son aburridos...

  • how can someone not like it??

  • Comment removed

  • This song was so good, I actually saw the whole movie just to get the video.

  • very few. VERY VERY FEW bands write to the degree that arcade fire does. intelligently meaningful.

  • This video has been wrongly named. In my unprofessional opinion, it should be called: "Corkscrew for the bottle of emotion." just saying

  • great chill out song :)

  • Hat jemand ORF Doctor House gesehen ? Da war dießes Lied drinnen In der Vorschau um Zuschauer anzuwerben sieht man wie cuddie sagt : "Es ist meine Schuld !" . und dann sieht man House vom Blakon spriengen . Ich dahct6e das waäre das vorhergesegte Ende von Dr.House , aber Gottseidank gibt es noch eine ganze weitere Staffel :) Puhh :D

  • @DerTeufel0707 Nikotin war es nicht. Sowas hast du in Tabak drin. ;) Es nennt sich Vicodin, was er nimmt.

  • Dr. House is coooool :-D. Schock lass nach ... O_o P.S. cooler Song!

  • @Wiggsser Oh ja das kannst du laut sagen :)

  • Just heard it on a Dr. House episode. Immediately went to search for the song on YT, I just love it. :D

  • @DerTeufel0707 me too

    

  • @DerTeufel0707 wie fandest du die heutige episode, ich dachte ernsthaft, jetzt springt er!

  • @Luca144 Jo, ich dachte schon "ach du Kacke, Dr. House eventuell nur noch ohne Dr. House?!", aber dabei wars nur das Nikotin und wollte in den Pool springen. :D Die neuen Folgen sind echt krass.

  • Comment removed

  • i heard peter gabriel did pretty nice cover of this

  • @purifyz I heard that everything you hear will not always be true.

  • this is one of those few songs that feels like you've know it for your whole life, that you know the words to before you even listen to it for the first time.

  • @alizaza23 The human story is the same no matter who tells it.

  • Comment removed

  • @alizaza23 It's because they lyrics are literally a total of three sentences recycled a billion times.

  • Wow bellissima la combinazione tra immagnin e musica, si combinano perfettamente :-)

  • Mackelmore anyone?

  • @thenextlegendofzelda  Yes sir

  • Depressing yet never fails to put tingles down my back. It makes me want to charge into battle or something haha.

  • somebody have the translation please?

  • this makes me wanna be in a western movie and this song is playing as i do somthing really badass in it.

  • Amazing job harmonizing two great pieces of art.

  • i luv the actors :)

  • I literally LOL'd when I read the end credits. Sergio Leone, Arcade Fire and then Edited by J Tyler ? Its a bit too much to put your name along side these guys just because you put their music to a movie clip.

  • @viksam009 why? it's his creation, HE edited it, why not put is name? he also paid credit to the makers of the movie and the song, I don't see where is the problem.

  • @viksam009, copyright died a year ago or so i heard some h4ckers done it?

  • Amazing! Well done! canadians rule!

  • What's this song about?

  • @Duckieperson It's about fear.

  • As good as this song is, the real music for this scene is better...

  • House M.D. 

    Ep. 16 S7

  • @Ch3ls4wy I think the Peter Gabriel Version they used was SHITE, they should of used the Arcade Fire original. So much more pain.