Siobhan Magnus - Through The Fire Top 10 American Idol

[disneyprince56]

the studio version i think is better, but this is good

[TFF921]

simon is so spot on, its the same old thing, honestly. i love her, but...

[bitemehoonk]

So Simon said that if this was the first time he sees her, yada yada yada.... then he went on and said he's getting bored of the screaming at the end. That's contradictory man.

[DianaLinaL]

I actually kinda like it at times, some parts are bad, but I actually like some paerts

[jmbgouveia]

FUCK the judges!!!!! My idol is Siobhan and the rest is shut, history. Love ya and all your family Great Sioabhan. She haven't got time to improve the version. shes the best yearslight of the others. love ya girl lady angel

[ikilledstjimmy]

Wow, there were some really bad notes in there... she can still sing really well but this was definitely not one of her best performances...

[SiobhansNo1Fans]

Look at that *asshole Simon* look at his face, he just can't wait, to rip into Siobhan!!! he has set her up to fail, hes been working on her from the beginning, THIS is unfair!!! PLEASE help me, help Siobhan, defeat this Jackass!!! VOTE for Siobhan!!!

[SiobhansNo1Fans]

This is not a contest between *Siobhan and Crystal* anymore!! *Jackass Simon* has made this US Siobhan Fans, against Simon, We can all see what he has done to Siobhan, This is unfair, and rude, PLEASE help me, help Siobhan, *Beat down that Jackass, and VOTE!! for Siobhan, No matter what, VOTE!!! over and over again, at least 50 times every Tuesday!! SHOW!! that Jackass, we will not stand for his, unfair tricks

[agators212]

her high belts are so mixed and not connected with her chest register...its so evident with this song.

better performances of this song from better vocalists

chaka khan (the ogirinal) with kelly price watch?v=w-SzpxPLp54

charice penpengco, zsa zsa, nina (althgouth she sucked in this performance)

watch?v=H0to-8Bl4tA

regine velasquez watch?v=vCrZ3g7ieOw

jaya watch?v=ykHlnoVfXCc&feature=re­lated

deborah cox watch?v=Z2TOXdkBHv4

[yeahu96704]

The girl has a resemblance to audrey hepburn. If they would just make her up right she would be a knockout. And I agree Simon is an ass.

[meta22]

she is still my favorite.... praying she will be safe tonight... GO SIOBHAN!

[meta22]

she is still my favorite.... praying she will be safe tonight... GO SIOBHAN!

[wesv71]

what the hell?? the sounded like a screeching cat!!!

[lvu16]

still love her

[katchieqt]

she looked crushed by the end... :(

[mygialaura]

She is still my favorite. If I could vote, I would vote for her.

[itsmarcleon]

STILL BETTER THAN THE OTHERS!

<3

[Dougcomet]

she was crushed and broken at the end. Still my favorite but she has to recover and pick much better songs than the crap she just sung. She's like Catherine McFee but more unique and dosen't need to over reach every song. I don't think she'll need saving tomorrow but is one person who qualifies when it comes time to save a person.  No place to go but up.

[MrWwerealwrestler]

please vote for her...she doesn't deserve to be eliminated....we know that she is very very good..this is just one of her worst performance because no one is perfect...give her second chance just like how the people gave danny a second chance in his rock week performance....please people support siobhan...1 mistake is not enough to end her dreams.

[cbotten106]

The sheep who watch this show will believe exactly what they are told by the judges. That is the reality of reality television.

[Anifreak561]

Easily her worst performance yet, it was very pitchy but that note was still good. If only I could vote I'd vote till my fingers bleed! Everyone pray for Siobhan, she made 1 song mistake this shouldn't be enough to send her home! God if only I could vote.

[jasunderpar]

Very easily her worst effort but still my absolute favorite. She's received so much praise that even though this one hurt her as she clearly held back tears with the comments at the very end, it can be good at times to have this happen - she'll learn and just get better and better. Like a good team who always wins - losing once can bring you down from that unrealistic high and get you back on track.

[voldemortidol1]

she started veeeery pitchy... but she did her high note very well in this sing.. she did not screech, which was good. but she was veeery pitchy at the beginning.

[sharkpoodle]

I wonder if she has been hearing all the positive feedback, and she is letting it get to her. I think she was a little nervous, but maybe it's because she's trying to live up to everyone's expectations. Just a thought.

[lkmaryrob]

She's the only contestant I've ever voted for. Just voted about hundred taking a couple minutes off.

[jeffymon420]

"For the chance to be with you" --yuck.. she blows those notes "For a chance of lovin you" idk why she didn't stick those notes. it almost sounded like her voice was cracking. i've never heard her sound that bad. nevertheless she is the most interesting, courageous, and relevant artist of the remaining ten; so she'll be back but i hope she watches the performance and tells herself i can NEVER do that again. My final 2 prediction: Siobhan vs Crystal....possibly Lee.

[khenessy1]

@jeffmon420

i agree with you totally. those were terrible notes. makes me sad to hear her that bad.

it obviously wasnt a good performance from HER, but would be a strong performance coming from some of the other contestants. judges were too hard on her.

[shukigkato]

I know, those two parts were just terrible it's just so sad:(

But still, the rest of the performance was pretty good if not great and the judges had no reason to throw her under the bus like that!

[eduzinhoxvre]

I LOVED IT

SIOBHAN YOU ARE AMAZING

[1myron1]

is amezing siobhan the best

lov elove love love siobhan!

[ParamoreVzla]

This was a horrible song choice..

[nickrb23]

She's still easily my favorite, and the one I look forward too most. She most certainly isn't boring like some of the others.

I feel bad for the comments. She is so kind hearted. Even after said "I'm gonna call it manslaughter", she says "thank you" so innocently like he meant something good. Please vote for Siobhan!

[lkmaryrob]

I think some of Simon's comments are screwing her up. After House of The Rising Sun he basically said she was weird and ugly, hard to regain your confidence after that.

[shukigkato]

Simon has been unbelievably critical of Siobhan this year, it makes me sick!

[A7XHellBlaze]

Pretty disappointed, I really love the high notes, but the rest of the performance was way off. Siobhan is still my favorite and I will vote for her like 500 times. I hope she still gets through tomorrow.