Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (383)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The part where she 'killed' the man is there to represent her perhaps, cheating on him or breaking his heart. Like the term "Back stabber".

  • Comment removed

  • i like that video but its not good for kids to watch it scared me how she killed him and she had a cegeret and a glass of whine the other video fits the song and really touched me luv u katy perry<3

  • Why did she kill him ? :O

  • wat was the blood for did she kill him xxx

  • i don't understand this version of this video

  • this Version is good but i Like the other Version better. The other one really fits to the song :D Katy Perry luv <3

  • THIS

  • To be honest... this version was quite nice, but didn't get to me as much as the official version did.

  • This version is a thousand times better than the official version which comes in very remote.

  • sooo, she killed her boyfriend and goes on a downward spiral and ends up in some twisted threesome relationship? sounds about right to me

  • @GiGixx621625 I dont think she actually killed him, i think they were trying to symbolize her stabbing him in the back(by cheating)

  • I love her eyes sooo much. If she dies before me they should pop out her eyes and put them in my sockets.

  • she's so pretty on that white dress..

  • LaST FrIDAY NIGhT BeST ReMIX!!! :) /watch?v=QQnPRlMzil4

  • I like this version way more.

  • Please note that the cigarette is not LIT, she probably doesn't smoke.

  • 3:35 she looks so messed up.. like she needs to be in a mental institiute lol

  • !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!he­re I am,thingking of u.

  • Katy Perry smokes?

    Lol

  • pause at 1;20. she looks like barbie doll. :D

  • her eyes are so pretty, im jealous! lol

  • ฉันชอบเพลงนี้

  • I prefure the other video,it had meaning to the song this one isn't so great,but still I adore this song! :)

  • Yum

  • O.o Where did the video come from?

  • @ZiahLovesYou This was going to be the first video for the single, but they decided another one (:

  • she's so beautiful!

  • Comment removed

  • Thank goodness she re-did the video for this song.

  • fuckin crazy bitch.....

  • @juhsscallme fuck you

  • this song gives me goosebumps..

  • this song gives me goosebumps..

  • you know that brand and perry are stopped going out

    and why does that guy die in the vid so confusing ^.^

  • everytime i hear this song i just want to cry..tnx katy.........

  • huhu! this song is dedicated to me!

  • she goes out with that brand idiot = fail>..<

  • @knocktheknivesout ....... O:

  • Never fail to get goosebumps at 3:32

  • im not a katy perry fan . but i love this song :P

  • i like the other video bettr..... however this is a gud vid:)

  • stop showing ur boobs

  • @freakubi She's got big boobs, it's kinda hard not to

  • i like the other variation of the vid better. this one is sort of psychotic.

  • I like it ♥ .. !!

  • uiiichhh nunca lo habia visto !! asesina perry pero bueno GENIAL!!

  • The other video is better.

  • nce,,,,lav it♥

  • nice song... i like this song...

  • This is really just horrible. All it's showing is her face. Just, no. I like the original better. I also love Matt Dallas, and the 40's so.....

  • me enacnat esta cancion sera porqueun pienso en ti como dice la cancion

  • ♫ Awesome ♫ *-*

    ♥♥♥ I love it ♥♥♥

  • i want Katy and Travis Maccoy!! they were cute together

  • did she cut off his thing...?

  • HOOOOT!!!!

  • why she so pretty x[

  • what the fuck man.  why dose she NEED to smoke in this video? This songs so amazing and that just ruined it for me.

  • @FullMetalFerret6 it's to show her stress?

  • @mexxbox But was it really necessary to show it through stress through something so destructive to your health? I mean why not show it through her expressions. Or how she touches her hair. There are much more effective ways to communicate stress.

  • @FullMetalFerret6 agreed, but you gotta remember, 'pop' songs are going out to people who aren't so keen on picking up subtleties, rather obvious things, like cigarettes?

  • @mexxbox True enough. I still find it sad that the only way such an audience can recognize stress is through such a poor habit.

  • @FullMetalFerret6 Agreed

  • @FullMetalFerret6 cos shes sad :(

  • @FullMetalFerret6 She only smoked? :L

  • @FullMetalFerret6 lol she's SO not smoking for real

  • i loike this vid better than the real one!!! :D

  • katy has so many different dimensions

  • I watch it for the third time and i think I got the real meaning...

    It's all about her breasts! Right??!!

  • There's only 2 options?? like or not?? Should have a "I'm cofuse" or "lost here" option.

  • Wierd... I didn't get the idea yet... so... She killed the guy that she was in love?? She's a psycho??

    Now what? She is married?? or the new guy cheat on his wife with katy??

    Cofuse!! Why she smile covered with blood?? The guy who made this script... he has problems, i'm serious!! He should be working with lady Gaga!!

  • 13:13. WHAT DID SHE DO TO HIM. :P

  • PMS commercial gone wrong :o

  • keep pressing 6: tsu tsu tsu tsu

  • k the meaning of the video isnt her cheating on a bf or anythin if u look there is a gurl in the video n basically it has lesbian intensions...if u listen 2 the lyrics...starting at 1:50 to 2:00 she talks about how disgusted she is w/ the fact she was w/ a man n not a gurl...n if you research it...her publisher n producers actually made her remake the music video for thinking of you bc of the lesbian intentions n didnt want her to portray herself in tht way n thts where the 2nd version comes in

  • she looks soooo terrible on this video! i really dont believe it was her!

  • Thinking of you ,,, with something you promise and you cant remember it ,,, never mind i'll be take it by myself ^^

  • i prefer the official video it just makes more sence

  • Katy Perry Germany loves you you are awesome!!!

    I hope to hear much more songs from her.

    Let´s go Katy!!!

  • People don't look deep enough into the video. I think this is very, very well done especially for a low budget music video. I think both versions are brilliant

  • She stabbed him in the back...get it??? She didn't really kill him, just cheated on him and was a backstabber. it's symbolism

  • i like the real video better

  • what the fuck did i just watch?

  • lowww

  • outch....

    i fell it...

    its so hurt...

    outch....

    ilike this song

    its relly hurts to

    realize...

  • ..uhmm..the other video is greater than this one..

  • @chiqceegee15 agreed

  • uyu8y

  • is she happy he is dead?watch 3:32-3:6 creepy

  • i absolutley love katy like, to death,but i dont like this vid.it doesnt fit the song and isnt like katy.the other one i sso much better<3

  • LOVE YOU KATY PERRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!xxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx :D <3

  • why is this remember my to evanescence

  • OMG SHE KILLED HIM!!!!!!!!!!!!:O (2) IS SCARED

  • OMG SHE KILLED HIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:O

  • is tht really her /?? cuz this is my first time seein this

  • The other video was sooo much better than this one. It actually told a story, and i love it, kinda like The Notebook. Anyways, point it i don't like this video, kinda weird. Other video suited the song a lot more :)

  • i dont understand the whole blood ordeal.

  • SAY UR CRUSH NAME 15 TIMES

    KISS UR HAND 10 TIMES

    POST ON 2 OTHER SONGS

    LOOK AT UR HAND

  • wait can someone please explain why there are two vids?

  • theres a diffrent version of this video

  • First: I love Katy Perry, and in this her eyes look so beautiful

    Second: I think this video is much less depressing than the other.

  • Best actress!<3

  • This song just breaks my heart. She lost the one she loved, OH so much, and now stuck with one she doesn't feel for... because she cheated. And she feels terrible :(. This is just too sad.

  • 3:45... barbq sauce? o:

  • The Video in my opinion is that she had this great guy whom she loved very much but she ended up loosing him because she cheated on him (stabbed him the back, hence the blood) And we pretty much see how miserable she is without him in the darker scenes where shes wearing red. (Happy scenes whit guy she loves is when she is wearing white).... my view :P

  • is so weird!

  • she made two videos???? wow i didn't know that cause when you look up "thinking of you" you get a different version

  • dontt get it ?

  • @JettyTim i think he boyfriend was cheating on her so she killed him or the girl... i don't get it either

  • Check out the latest News on Bruno Mars

    on my channel

    /miketvnow

  • ohhhh i get it! she "stabbed him in the back"!...hmm i like the other vid better

  • wow,,, i never knew that this song is from her .. Ö.Ö

  • i love this one so much more. it makes alot more sense with the song

  • omgosh the real one is much better :D

  • is this katy perry in the video?

  • @makeupluvr30 yea it's her, it's just been soo long since this song

  • missin you drb.

  • shes so pretty. :O

  • The other video way way better!!

  • i dont understand this vid can someone explain it

  • @ilhedley The guy she wants to be with, is the one she cant be with. So she is talking about when she is with the NEW guy all she can think about is the OTHER guy.. She is too in love with the OTHER guy to move on with the NEW guy... Classic relationship song, but I still love it....

  • @ilhedley when u see katy in white thats her relationship with her bf the white represents innocence, when shes in the dark room with the guy, thats the guy she cheats with, she ends up stabbing him(bf) in the back, the blood in her hands is from when she did the crime (stabbed her bf in the back) like cheating on him & she feels guilty about it. im horrible at explaining lmao hope you understood a little.

  • @missmarilyn91 don't think she is cheating on her ex. she actually cheating this new guy because she is married with him and still thinking about her ex

  • how sounds the name of this korean guy???

  • Sorry, this is formulaic and lightweight. I've heard a lot worse, though. I just think there is a real lack of edge and substance to most music produced these days. It's all about style and image now - scratch beneath the glossy surface and you find nothing. Nothing at all.

  • I miss u col

  • thats messed up 

  • this video confuses me, i dont get it and dont like it, sorry

  • thumbs up if katy perrys hot in california girls

  • ich liebe sie wenn sie da so sitzt !

  • don't get mee wrong i really like this video but i LOVE the official one with the war theme make me cry its a lovely song sung by a georgous women.xx!!!!!!!! I LOVE YOU KATY PERRY YOUR MY IDOL!!!X <3

  • I luv DBSK too... but TVXQ'll comeback with only 2 members.. Uknow and Max.. I really miss the beauty voices of Hero, Xiah...

    I luv this video.. thanks

  • @TheHanaquu yeah i was fan for about two weeks (still am) and than people kept saying I hate SM and i was like whaaa why didn't they create them them i found out what happend when i wrote that i thought nobody was going to say anything haha lol

    ~sorry~

    sometimes i rant l0l

  • @NesiaBoo96 hehehe...i knew about them last 2 months..and i research their songs....oh it is so powerful my super favorite song that they sung is LOVE IN THE ICE....it is really super duper beautiful...

  • @TheHanaquu yeah your right.....i really love tvxq too......

  • @TheHanaquu ssssssssss

  • means?im confused with the video..but i love the song

  • at the end did she kill the guy or something???

    its so weird

    O.o

  • @ethyl1234 she's not killing the guy.

    i think she's singing about that she has to work as a prostitute, but is always thinking of her only real love.

  • what is this song about? ive been wondering this for over a year

  • Whats with all that blood? Was that rly nesscesary? And BTW, i love DBSK... But i wished they were back together agn... Even though JYJ n homin was both coping quite okay... i still miss the songs they sung together...

  • Whats with all the blood? Was that rly nesscesary???

  • deep

  • I perfer the other video... This one is still great. :) Love this song. <3

  • i hate social studies homework.

  • lol, no offence, but when i watch this video, it seems to me that she is thinking about " the girl she kissed" in her other song xD

  • in 3:21 was that blood or wine?

  • @lykstarflame10 blood

  • Katy Perry doesnt smoke that is just disgusting

  • Can someone PLEASE explain this video to me??! I know what the song is about but this music vid makes no sense

  • Comment removed

  • @L0zer797 I think maybe a guy that she married was stabbed to death and she joined a whorehouse? since there was that guy and the other girl?

  • @JacobLuver226 Thanks! I'm kinda thinking the same thing too but in the video it looks like she stabbed him that's why I'm confused lol

  • Can someone PLEASE explain this video to me??! I know what the song is about but this music vid makes no sense

  • I love the song and video... but why make her a killer with a bloody mess?

  • Her smile towards the end was creepy. Reminded me of that Paranormal Activity chick lol

  • why do artists do more videos for the same song? /:)

  • IM SO CONFUSED

  • @obbsesivecollection join the club! i dont think anyone knows what this video is about ahh :D

  • last time i see this. never got it so weird. other better. :D

  • @MiSsYlOoLz nice one

    :D

  • WTF? IM SO CONFUSED!

  • shes so beautiful :(