@MetalMan2k Wow. I just now discovered this song while I was sleeping with headphones. Then I try to look for this gem of a song on youtube, only to discover that the nin fan inside of me already heard it 3 years back! Wow.
I really like it, I think that the video is very appropriate to the music... but I think that the white and black idea is to much similar to Hurt. And I didn't liked your font selection, the grungy scratchy type font. Whatever... It is pretty. Luck!
good vid. the only thing threw me off was your font selection at the beginning the grungy scratchy type font wasn't a very good choice this song isn't grungy and scratchy its more calm serious gentle and the vid is serious and sad. so maybe pick a serif font that has a gentle serious sad feel to it. but other than that great video.
There is an interesting juxtapositioning of the rather calm instrumentals to the complete tragedy of this WWII Hiroshima/Nagasaki footage. I like this video because it's important for us to never ever forget what happened at Hiroshima/Nagasaki! But, Like lingojac, I thought you were supposed to do some filming that reflects your local talent, so to speak. This NIN festival is a chance to show your ability to interpret the music from 'Ghosts'. I guess you can do that many ways. Fascinating!
I think you can use anything that is not copyrighted, but I'm pretty sure stock war footage is... public domain? I don't know, I just liked how they complemented each other. thanks for the comment.
A good portion of your footage is from the film Hiroshima Mon Amour . It is protected under copyright law internationally. it was created by the filmmaker Alain Resnais. He created that footage for a propaganda documentary he was commissioned to make but the project was scrapped. SInce Resnais had all this footage he decided to use it in the Hiroshima film.
first of all why are you calling me a freak lol, you don't know me and you couldn't be farther from the truth... and more importantly...I'm trying real hard to understand why are you're talking about gringos?
this is creepy..i always had these pictures in my mind every time i was listening to aphex twin's "at the heart of it all" from "further down the spiral..i always thought that this is what lies there in the heart of humanity..darkness...paranoia and the atom bomb.....the horror
People are crazy. Can't we all just get along. I want one of those mini tanks to protect my household. Run for your lives! A storm of death is coming...
Of all the Ghosts videos I've watched that utilize archival footage, this one's got to be the best. The music fits creepily well...and some of the footage you chose made me cringe. Nice work!
the video its really cool, see hirshima and nagasaki after the bomb the people, see how to feel the people its fantastic (not fantastic the people on this conditions)the consecuens of the bomb, the reality, its very very nice, exelent!!!
I like this one quite a bit. And to everyone who criticizes alot of these videos, this is all supposed to be a big art project, and if you dont appreciate someone elses art then dont bother criticizing them.
seriously, most of these film festival entries are too much alike...someone with something completely different yet relevant will win, not all of this same stuff footage...
I'm sick of people acting like this is their big break or Trent's going to sign them... all you people need to stop acting like your shit don't stink and actually upload a video!
I like it... Why? Because those who forget the past are destine to repeat it. This is just a reminder of what could be in the future.... anywhere in the world. Good Job!
Why was I never shown this footage? I mean, the bombings are no secret but why is this hid under a rock? I guess the U.S. wants to pretend it didn't happen.
This video was very profound. Perfect accompaniment to the music. It impresses the feeling of healing. Shots of survivors carting away the dead. Good idea.
Hey man. The footage you used did go pretty well with the song selected, but I would have liked it much more with user created footage. Have any other entrys?
man! love your concept of the video..the song did match on the video!awseome! I gave you the highest rating and added you as my favorite..geesh..your a simple genius..lol..keep it up..hope you could make it..
Despite the imagery this sound reminded me of those first few minutes before you fall asleep. Allow me to explain. You're laying down and silently complaining to yourself about the fact that you have been trying to fall asleep for the last half hour. When your thoughts finally blur and the unconsciousness you've benn searching for teases you it's almost instinctual how we snap awake and all too alert. Mere minutes later we're fast asleep. This sound reminds me of those sensations.
Very emotional, the footage was very cohesive mostly and the song choice was great. Like others said, it does have a very strong "Hurt" vibe, but it's different enough to be really interesting. Awesome!
two words to describe this video: Real and Awesome. and Gringos
JimmyJamaica68 1 month ago
Comment removed
MetalMan2k 5 months ago
@MetalMan2k Wow. I just now discovered this song while I was sleeping with headphones. Then I try to look for this gem of a song on youtube, only to discover that the nin fan inside of me already heard it 3 years back! Wow.
MetalMan2k 5 months ago
great video i like it
rhinehardhein 7 months ago
i wish this song would just keep repeating the acoustic guitar part
StickyInADarkBlueCut 1 year ago
wow powerful stuff. thank you warnerbro's for banning cut chemists tune and replacing it with something fresh
mcmilesable 1 year ago
great song love th vid
Rtikw 1 year ago
Fuck my doctor's prescirption! Great work! Full shinning 5 starts!
DarkSunDaughter 1 year ago
The end is near
seiya209 2 years ago
fallout 3 !
MooseLakerz 2 years ago
Hmm what music is this ? if it is some half acoustic NIN song then its a one i have missed.
Anywhere i can find this song ?
SattesCircle 2 years ago
It's from the Ghosts I-IV album (which I thought was quite amazing).
dark1x 2 years ago 5
Good video...I freakin love NIN and their music!!!!!!!!!!!!
silveremi2004 2 years ago
Comment removed
MNiroArt 2 years ago
I really like it, I think that the video is very appropriate to the music... but I think that the white and black idea is to much similar to Hurt. And I didn't liked your font selection, the grungy scratchy type font. Whatever... It is pretty. Luck!
Winterraisen 2 years ago
I don't know if you submitted this to the Film Festival they held for Ghosts, but you should have. Would have done very well.
Also great choice of tracks. 34 is one of my favs. Gives off the same vibe as the fragile with the de-tuned instruments.
jharbid 2 years ago
good vid. the only thing threw me off was your font selection at the beginning the grungy scratchy type font wasn't a very good choice this song isn't grungy and scratchy its more calm serious gentle and the vid is serious and sad. so maybe pick a serif font that has a gentle serious sad feel to it. but other than that great video.
BenUhl88 3 years ago
the hiroshima holocaust - ever any elaboration on it as the gentile holocaust?
phoebus1966 3 years ago
I love this song and video, overall ghosts has good atmosphere and immersion, makes you sleep/dream easy though.
KillingSpreeFreesBee 3 years ago
Well done. It should be mandatory viewing for anyone that thinks reducing the nuclear arsenals worldwide is a bad idea.
EVPClassABC 3 years ago
really scary. people shouldnt foget this tragedy
some thinks that russia had been crushed hiroshima and nagosaki. What a crap
hisheatn 3 years ago
There is an interesting juxtapositioning of the rather calm instrumentals to the complete tragedy of this WWII Hiroshima/Nagasaki footage. I like this video because it's important for us to never ever forget what happened at Hiroshima/Nagasaki! But, Like lingojac, I thought you were supposed to do some filming that reflects your local talent, so to speak. This NIN festival is a chance to show your ability to interpret the music from 'Ghosts'. I guess you can do that many ways. Fascinating!
ennui1812 3 years ago
this is a really great video, but weren't you supposed to use only original content?
lingojac 3 years ago 2
I think you can use anything that is not copyrighted, but I'm pretty sure stock war footage is... public domain? I don't know, I just liked how they complemented each other. thanks for the comment.
kryptx 3 years ago
A good portion of your footage is from the film Hiroshima Mon Amour . It is protected under copyright law internationally. it was created by the filmmaker Alain Resnais. He created that footage for a propaganda documentary he was commissioned to make but the project was scrapped. SInce Resnais had all this footage he decided to use it in the Hiroshima film.
MNiroArt 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well freak, it WAS a ghost town after the bombing wasn´t it... sad... gringos are dumb...
antenamantis 3 years ago
first of all why are you calling me a freak lol, you don't know me and you couldn't be farther from the truth... and more importantly...I'm trying real hard to understand why are you're talking about gringos?
kryptx 3 years ago
Great stuff, kinda reminds me of the stuff in the Hurt video.
Death2Bigots 3 years ago
I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH
And the pictures really go with it...
jamesusillXD 3 years ago
this is creepy..i always had these pictures in my mind every time i was listening to aphex twin's "at the heart of it all" from "further down the spiral..i always thought that this is what lies there in the heart of humanity..darkness...paranoia and the atom bomb.....the horror
whatisdeafisdead 3 years ago
AT LAST!!! A video that is WELL DONE!!!!
Brilliant juxtaposition -- no... MARRIAGE -- to Trent Reznor/NIN's unparalleled evocative music!
DrTh0masW0nder 3 years ago
People are crazy. Can't we all just get along. I want one of those mini tanks to protect my household. Run for your lives! A storm of death is coming...
pigtelevision 3 years ago
very nicely done
live11wire 3 years ago
for me you should try to sync shots changes with music, basically try to sync pitures with music. i think it could make it better
freitag666 3 years ago
cold....dark....despair....yep NIN
oneznzeroz 3 years ago
Of all the Ghosts videos I've watched that utilize archival footage, this one's got to be the best. The music fits creepily well...and some of the footage you chose made me cringe. Nice work!
dxanex 3 years ago 2
the video its really cool, see hirshima and nagasaki after the bomb the people, see how to feel the people its fantastic (not fantastic the people on this conditions)the consecuens of the bomb, the reality, its very very nice, exelent!!!
rochebalia 3 years ago
good work krptx!! when I heard this song for the first time, the first thing I thought about was things about the asian culture!!! :)
LLawliet18 3 years ago
me too... I thought it had a very strong asian vibe too it. Out of all the tracks on Ghosts this is my favorite. Thank you for the comment.
kryptx 3 years ago
i mean its obvious that people are critical,when others waste with trents songs.
i think self recorded material has more depth
sickboyduke 3 years ago
I like this one quite a bit. And to everyone who criticizes alot of these videos, this is all supposed to be a big art project, and if you dont appreciate someone elses art then dont bother criticizing them.
rjbishop1 3 years ago
seriously, most of these film festival entries are too much alike...someone with something completely different yet relevant will win, not all of this same stuff footage...
vampiresean 3 years ago
and what do you mean by win? This is a not a contest if you have not heard... There are no winners or losers, just people expressing themselves.
kryptx 3 years ago
I'm sick of people acting like this is their big break or Trent's going to sign them... all you people need to stop acting like your shit don't stink and actually upload a video!
kryptx 3 years ago
do not credit these stock films....that took you how long ??a day
LizzyxBaby 3 years ago
show me yours and then let's talk, OK.
kryptx 3 years ago
hehehehh!!! great come back!!! that very true to what you said!!
LLawliet18 3 years ago
Cutting stock footage to a song doesn't take a lot of work or creativity, but still this was cool and looked good.
Andee02L 3 years ago
It didn't but I had a vision that this would be a great thing and to me it twas... thats all that matters, right?
kryptx 3 years ago
I love it !
schlubinette 3 years ago
Hiroshima - Nagasaki
shaokem 3 years ago
i like it
dustinwad 3 years ago
i like this one. its the best one ive seen so far. the song goes good with the video too.
:]
VitaBrevisxo 3 years ago
I like it... Why? Because those who forget the past are destine to repeat it. This is just a reminder of what could be in the future.... anywhere in the world. Good Job!
MarinePinUpGirl1986 3 years ago
sorry i'm all stock footaged out...i don't like it....sorry...
fleshfit 3 years ago
good work buddy..
haightmachine 3 years ago
Good Job!
What's with all the Negative Nancies for the film festival? Everyone getting/giving a 3 star, that's sad, I give it 5 star :)
A good choice for the song too, this is a good track & haven't seem many other submissions for it.
The visuals are powerful, compliments the song well. How much video editing did you do? did you leave any scenes fully intact?
petemayo 3 years ago
the images are pretty goood. Could see this playing on a big screen while nin is performing, just like "right where it belongs"
brayshizzle 3 years ago
Why was I never shown this footage? I mean, the bombings are no secret but why is this hid under a rock? I guess the U.S. wants to pretend it didn't happen.
mr5elfde5truct 4 years ago
This video was very profound. Perfect accompaniment to the music. It impresses the feeling of healing. Shots of survivors carting away the dead. Good idea.
setanta75 4 years ago
Hey man. The footage you used did go pretty well with the song selected, but I would have liked it much more with user created footage. Have any other entrys?
tehdanno 4 years ago
Oh, this is just too sad. Very well done.
danielacastilho 4 years ago
man! love your concept of the video..the song did match on the video!awseome! I gave you the highest rating and added you as my favorite..geesh..your a simple genius..lol..keep it up..hope you could make it..
psychokiller1660 4 years ago
Despite the imagery this sound reminded me of those first few minutes before you fall asleep. Allow me to explain. You're laying down and silently complaining to yourself about the fact that you have been trying to fall asleep for the last half hour. When your thoughts finally blur and the unconsciousness you've benn searching for teases you it's almost instinctual how we snap awake and all too alert. Mere minutes later we're fast asleep. This sound reminds me of those sensations.
OnDutyNinja 4 years ago 2
Very emotional, the footage was very cohesive mostly and the song choice was great. Like others said, it does have a very strong "Hurt" vibe, but it's different enough to be really interesting. Awesome!
Ringfingerpromise 4 years ago
great song, moving but grim
metaltenango 4 years ago
Is there a time limit for submissions? Someone send me a message let me know thanks.
ominousmaximus 4 years ago
It has an "Hurt" vibe.
MyNameIsTobias 4 years ago
Nice comment! That's the same thing I felt at first, although the feeling is a little more centralized to one event.
kryptx 4 years ago
I really think the look of the film adds to the overwhelming feeling of despair... at least for me.
kryptx 4 years ago
Very Nice I totally agree with the asian Feel too it I thought of the same asian type of visualazation but different Kudo's too yours though!!!
joeaggressive 4 years ago
would like to see a higher res version of this one.
malco2001 4 years ago
It can't be higher res because the video was, idk... made about 50 million years ago. They didn't have high tech film back then.
Nice job on the video. =)
rarefy77 4 years ago
Thanks rarefy77.. You couldn't have said it better.
kryptx 4 years ago
good job
vincekrochak 4 years ago 2
depressing and powerful.
uglykid80s 4 years ago 2