I enjoy all the videos of this production individually, but I can't help but think the lead soloist is always overacting. He never seems to really get what he's saying, looks too caught up in the music.
He's inconsistent, it seems. There are moments in the song he looks like he really feels it (from an acting perspective) and times he's so off the mark. But if you ask me, in a show like this, YES of course the acting is important... but it's definitely way more important you sound good as long as your acting isn't laughable.
OMG! This is amazing!!! You don't find high school students who can sing this up to the standard that it has. I think you raised the standard! Congratulations!!!
omg i didnt know he directed this... holy fuck, talented!!!! Im doing this show and im musically directing and playing piano onstage for the solo songs that arent mine, this shw is such an inspiration!!!!! <3
this is so unbelievably stunning. this is my favorite musical. everybody is phenomenal. ive listened to this so many times and it gets better everytime! well done! i wish i could sing as well as you guys
Good Job for a white boy...but it loses soul when performed with an all white cast..dont get me wrong great job..not your fault, it was just cast badly, and the "LORD" during the bridge was sharp. But Good Job
There's a difference. Because white is considered normative in this country, a white presence on stage adds little additional meaning. A black presence does add something, since this black experience is something that an audience can draw meaning from.
A black person singing about being on a ship suggests an image of the slave trade, which deepens the meaning of the song.
That said, I do think the song is fine to be sung by a white person.
This is a super delayed response, but I agree. It doesn't matter the least bit if the soloist is black or white (or anything else), as long as he has some soul.
the song is about christopher columbus sailing to america, hence "on the deck of a SPANISH ship in 1492" (which is the year columbus sailed). so it is really just as appropriate, if not more so, to have a white person sing it.
@kitbish Actually, considering they're talking about women and children, they're probably talking about the OTHER Spanish ships in 1492 - of exiled Jews :) same point probably applies
Hey there..this is AJ Holmes..I directed it and played Man 2 (she cries..etc..) It was done at Agoura High School on May 5th and 6th, 2006. This is the closing night performance. I'm glad you like it! :D
Mate, I happened to come across you performinbg 'she cries', and I hope you go into musical theatre. I'm going to drama school in a few years and I hope I'm half as good as you. good job, its rare to see a musical theatre performance that's sincere.
i have now watched every video you've posted from "Songs" and i am IN LOVE. this is one of my favorite musical, and as if you didn't already know it, you guys did a PHENOMENAL job with it!!!!
love watching this video. so beautifully done!!
derrickmtjordan17 2 months ago
Loved it. Mind telling me where I can find the sheet music to this song? I've searched EVERYWHERE.
mamanissa93 6 months ago
This is so brilliant. I get chills everytime I listen to it.
Hollyberry6595 1 year ago
Good Job guys!!! Had the goosebumps at the end!
Aisler 1 year ago
@kitbish it's not about columbus
Otody 1 year ago
This is a good production. Tempo is a hair too fast. Good singers though, especially given their age
BroadwayVBtime 1 year ago
Comment removed
abbyaecous77 2 years ago
5:19 ! goosebumps much ! loves it <3
OMFGiloveyoumum 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh my god! could that wheelchair bound dude ham that beggining up anymore...talk about self indulgence
dieselpower666 2 years ago
its supposed to be like that
Mzisi 2 years ago
hehe..u guys do a great job!!
mandyroni 2 years ago
Absolutely amazing!!!!
TimonyErt03 2 years ago
You guys are absolutely amazing! I love this play.
xXBabyEsraXx 2 years ago
Comment removed
SimsVids15 2 years ago
Is the bass part taken up an octave? I could have sworn that the legit recording is even lower.
thetubkins 2 years ago
I just wish he hit that high note higher!!!
gogo245 2 years ago
it was too high... by a whole tone.
Mzisi 2 years ago
A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You guys, each and every one of you, are soooo amazing! I still can't believe you guys are doing this and you are in High School!
ppkiwi0305 3 years ago
Granted these vocals are incredible for a high school production. Well done.
lkin3 3 years ago
I enjoy all the videos of this production individually, but I can't help but think the lead soloist is always overacting. He never seems to really get what he's saying, looks too caught up in the music.
lkin3 3 years ago 2
He's inconsistent, it seems. There are moments in the song he looks like he really feels it (from an acting perspective) and times he's so off the mark. But if you ask me, in a show like this, YES of course the acting is important... but it's definitely way more important you sound good as long as your acting isn't laughable.
zjoke 3 years ago 2
Just amazing! And that final chord progression... probably the best balanced and most perfect harmony I've ever heard!
crazyt1 3 years ago
OMG! This is amazing!!! You don't find high school students who can sing this up to the standard that it has. I think you raised the standard! Congratulations!!!
Dtriptow 3 years ago
I like this somewhat better than the original.
i would love to find a theatre group over here that did this show, i would love to do it:(
xnemoooooox 3 years ago
stunning. There is some real talent here.
FaulkesN 3 years ago
you all did wonderful loved it
brocktonbrian 3 years ago
Ya'll better get it! I'm so impressed by what I've seen and heard so far. You're high school kids performing the hell out of some VERY tough music.
kfaced 3 years ago
wait u driected it and played man 2
DAMN!
impressive, stunnning, fantastick, - doesnt even descirbe - and yes i would kill for some of those notes in my range
mikeL09stagelife 4 years ago
omg i didnt know he directed this... holy fuck, talented!!!! Im doing this show and im musically directing and playing piano onstage for the solo songs that arent mine, this shw is such an inspiration!!!!! <3
shorterac989 4 years ago
this is so unbelievably stunning. this is my favorite musical. everybody is phenomenal. ive listened to this so many times and it gets better everytime! well done! i wish i could sing as well as you guys
britbexsinger 4 years ago
Yours is the best production I've seen on youtube. And the others are community companies and university productions too. So kudos!
drenched 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
eek!!! such powerful, moving, and well-informed writing lost on such a meek and timid young voice.
DeLiCioUsFiReS 4 years ago
Timid? I didn't think any of it was timid at all. they put passion into this.
JessieBlueForever 4 years ago
what are u tlkng about?
mikeL09stagelife 4 years ago
Good job, excellent casting. Its nice that it isn't a carbon copy of the cast recording.
Puzzgal 4 years ago
Good Job for a white boy...but it loses soul when performed with an all white cast..dont get me wrong great job..not your fault, it was just cast badly, and the "LORD" during the bridge was sharp. But Good Job
Jekkonni 5 years ago
racist. if i said any show "loses" something when performed by an all black cast, i'd be castigated.
Ahha3289 3 years ago
There's a difference. Because white is considered normative in this country, a white presence on stage adds little additional meaning. A black presence does add something, since this black experience is something that an audience can draw meaning from.
A black person singing about being on a ship suggests an image of the slave trade, which deepens the meaning of the song.
That said, I do think the song is fine to be sung by a white person.
benkrauss 3 years ago
This is a super delayed response, but I agree. It doesn't matter the least bit if the soloist is black or white (or anything else), as long as he has some soul.
zjoke 3 years ago
the song is about christopher columbus sailing to america, hence "on the deck of a SPANISH ship in 1492" (which is the year columbus sailed). so it is really just as appropriate, if not more so, to have a white person sing it.
kitbish 2 years ago 2
so whats your point>
Mzisi 2 years ago
@kitbish Actually, considering they're talking about women and children, they're probably talking about the OTHER Spanish ships in 1492 - of exiled Jews :) same point probably applies
Kayrahsfic 1 year ago 5
@Kayrahsfic Actually, the song is about struggling to survive and crying out to God because you have nowhere else to turn.
LizzieAldridge 1 year ago
dayum. i want those notes in my range.
youprobablysmell 5 years ago
can anyone tell me when and where this was performed? it is stunning.
cobdmp 5 years ago 2
Hey there..this is AJ Holmes..I directed it and played Man 2 (she cries..etc..) It was done at Agoura High School on May 5th and 6th, 2006. This is the closing night performance. I'm glad you like it! :D
pianoman1114 5 years ago 3
Mate, I happened to come across you performinbg 'she cries', and I hope you go into musical theatre. I'm going to drama school in a few years and I hope I'm half as good as you. good job, its rare to see a musical theatre performance that's sincere.
HepzibahSmith 4 years ago
@pianoman1114 wait....this is a HIGH SCHOOL production? holey moley.
DaytonSalvo011 11 months ago 2
wow...amazing...and he's in a chair...wow
jepriy 5 years ago
Wow. You guys are the best SFANW people on here. I
NathanD2006 5 years ago
there is hardly any difference between the cast on the cd and you guys...amazing!
BuffyBOT 5 years ago
loved it
barnettk 5 years ago
i have now watched every video you've posted from "Songs" and i am IN LOVE. this is one of my favorite musical, and as if you didn't already know it, you guys did a PHENOMENAL job with it!!!!
mattzmud 5 years ago
beautiful
Merideejo 5 years ago
ya betta SANG that song lol...amazing!
TrCg8hb 5 years ago
You guys rock my sox!!!!!!!!
jrgesh 5 years ago
woohhh its shaun . . thats crazy i like the groove. . . aight man
hubbardfan 5 years ago
You guys are incredible.
N0B4R4 5 years ago
wow
act4ever 5 years ago
Terrific
barry90 5 years ago