"Pathetique 3rd" by Ludwig van Beethoven 悲愴第３楽章 ベートーベン作曲

[dakuxz]

セプテットの原曲だよな〜って覗いてみたらやっぱみんな同じ考え­だったかｗ

[balancosmin1]

Fuck dislikes, this is pur music !

[hazuki812]

ホントだ最初亡き王女の為のセプテットっぽいねｗ

[sylsof]

WONDERFULL

[superbiroy]

weird rondo tempo!

[rainydreamovo]

too slow

[soleil375]

BGMにぴったりです。。。生で聞きたい。。。。＼(^o^)／　ｂｙままん

[r9r9r9r9r]

@soleil375 ままんありがとう！！太い頃で恥ずかしい。。。

[badata69]

ok.....love the song!!! could be MUCH faster.....heard a few mistakes....BUT,.,,,,,,I WISH I COULD DO IT!!!! keep practicing.....you are getting there!!!!! Thanks for playing for us!!!!

[DmCeciNeji]

Freddy Kempf's interpretation is better...

[mozartHeavenToHell]

a little too slow in general, and rushed in some places like the very end. the general tempo is good for a rehearsal but not for the actual performance because the concert tempo is allegro; this is only allegretto. the emotion is too stiff and not very musical (not as musical as the piece should be performed).

[bigbearpaws]

@mozartHeavenToHell Not too much emotional expression - this is Classical not Romantic music. Tempo is sometimes much too slow.

[souya229]

やっぱり東方の亡き王女のためのセプテットのベースはこれか^^­

[r9r9r9r9r]

@souya229  うｐ主です。どれ！？URL貼ってください！

[souya229]

@souya229

普通にyoutube内で調べりゃでますよ

[andrewkpchin]

"Pathetique 3rd" by Ludwig van Beethoven 悲愴第３楽章　ベートーベン作曲

[GrandeCero]

Great play! I really liked it. Its definetley shows the feminine side of the piece. I am not a critic cause I can't perform that but from the way you play it I'd say it is a great jump of improvement. The video is only half part of the story. The hours of practice that you did plus your performance is 4.3 out of 5 Stars.

[pineappledam]

its toooo slow D:

[pmmdrt]

there are a lot better performances.

[jemokjemok]

LOL half piano performance, half fashion show, both fail. If she can get flowers for a performance like that, i should get a fkin ferrari for my performance.

[Jeffparanormia]

It's like a music box is playing... enough said. About as much emotion as a Toyota Auto assembly robot. Sorry....does not compute!

[rockarcano]

its good i loke it i like it more if is speed but this way is great too

[wkfdaniel1]

I think it's very good. good tempo that  let audiences have time to enjoy it.! good playing, keep up the good work!

[hotbebimauz]

i dont really know why, but i dont like this interpretation at all. the notes are too short, to mechanical..

[artisann010]

I did notice that it sped up in some places. But, I really like this version. I've heard some people placy it so fast that the song loses so much of it's depth. It's not about pounding the piece out as quickly as you can. And, it really is quite difficult to play at 96,like it's marked. However, if your going to play it slower, then keep the tempo steady throughout.

[hellobello00]

i think the tempo ist just right, better play it slower than mechanically and without emotion... keep on like that:)

[daisukekowai]

おそくないですか？

フレーズの終わりもっとためましょうよ。

[cutebabeT]

You should play faster

The Tempo is wrong! You don't go slow at first then fast then slow again. Trust me! Take this advice! Use a metronome or something! Besides that, you put a lot of feeling into the music. =)

[allthenamesrtook]

i love this interpretation as it has its own style and is very cleverly played im takin my grade 8 and would love to be able to play sumet like this :D

[Lowrither]

Tempo ,Wrong chord , Faster ... is not all ....This is music , simple and clean , and i like it ! that's all

[nehpets1000]

sounds too muddy at places this slow

[christinewouters]

very good

[thecolouramanda]

Try listening to Freddy Kempf's. God at work.

[wclmyy]

I really think Freddy Kempf played a bit fast. I love the interpretation at a length of 4:15. This girl played this movement like a snail, and some part a bit blury. I simply think she couldn't play fast at some point....

[DeinKrankerNachbar2]

Im also playing the "Pathetique" at the moment and I highly respect this interpretation cause I know how hard it is to play it proper even in this speed. And thats even though I play piano for more than 10 years.

[krono3457]

うまいよ！ちゃんと、おとが聞こえる。

[weasledude15]

何か　少し　遅かった

[ikasumin1215]

遅くないですか？

頑張って下さい。

[AreaGB]

My Ex Girlfriend played this song too... it makes me so sad when i hear that :( .... carla i love you and i miss you :(

Gökhan, Germany, Franconia

[joelweisberg]

She deserved a better response.

[Corrupt5358]

I agree with both comments - I like it faster and that's how I'm used to hearing it. BUT I'd much sooner have it played properly than rushed.

[JMagMusic12]

beautiful interpretation of this piece

[YAMAHAYZFR12589]

good！

[naihah96]

sloww..i like it fast

[nancy286]

instead of insulting why can't we learn from the performance here?

Constructive crticism okay... but why the need to use such horrible words?

[BAKEDPIANIST]

i like it faster , good job though

[Killua40]

very strange in 2:50-3:10...overally not bad

[julietteariel]

way to deliberate

[ihvamullet]

wrong chord at 1:05

[SirArmengol]

Everybody talking about the tempo... She plays as a machine!

[aIIenxwaIker]

excellent but like bluetiger said it "should" be faster XD by like 6 or 8 beats faster XD it would sound betterXD

[bluetiger500]

I prefer it a bit faster but overall flawless just wonderful

[BrunoCt86]

anyway, if you play this piece between 120 and 168 bmp. You're absolutely correct. that means your playing the "allegro" well

[kitedh]

its intentionally slow.

fags

[nora1262]

stop with the other "f" word, will you?

[kitedh]

because you say it? lol

[nora1262]

kitedh said "because you say it? lol" in response to my request that he/she/it not use derogatorily call people "fags." I'm not quite sure what this person means by that. Maybe it was my comment that people who are overly critical don't matter. Well, your comments don't mean much to me if you're going to be nasty about it. Sometimes, it seems, people who are the worst critics think at least as little of themselves. Can't you just stop it?

[kitedh]

faggot.

[nora1262]

As though I didn't expect that.

And now I'm going to end this little tiff so that the young lady can get better comments from better people. No more replies from me. The email alerts will be deleted without readin.!

[kitedh]

how sad :(

anyway, i love her interpretation

[nora1262]

yes, of course. It is a fine interpretation. (yes, I lied. But I'm replying only to say that I agree. No need to insult anyone. OK now?)

[kitedh]

of course milady

[Firesale92]

hm there are many faults in it but i think its normal bkz this is very difficult...

and for those that are flaming all time "its to slow its to slow" make ur own version, upload it and show us, that u can make it better.. i think that most of u are only little bastards that cant hit 2 times the same note ....

[nora1262]

Agreed. I would never want to post anything because comments on here are by and large WAY too critical by people who, frankly, don't matter. These aren't professionals, you know. And this young lady plays a whole lot better than I do. Why are people so mean just because no one knows who they are? Don't be jerks.

[guitarrahero]

slow..

[natber27]

So when David G posts his own playing of this sonata i hope he's ironed out all those teething issues like tempo, expression, passion at his young age, teacher choice obsession re view count. It wasn't that bad! The memorisation work is admirable. How about a bit of constructive criticism next time you're on you tube.

[Wimbwicket]

Just play it faster and with more expression and it would be good :). Just check Freddy Kempf :)

[lokopiano]

Not neccesary faster (despite i prefer it faster), but as a music and not as a stupid Czerny etude.

Freddy Kempff play it better BUT is not a great deal.

lokopiano

[pianodesu]

When It's slower It sound too heavy, so the faster version is better.

[tanaznazdel]

161,578 views for this? You gotta be kidding! Let's face it, this piece is supposed to be played much faster!! It sounds like this is the tempo you would be playing when you first learn the piece! Congratulations for getting 161,578 people to view it! I must add that there was no passion and no expression to this piece. Furthermore, her teacher must bear the blame for this....This girl needs to re-post with a faster tempo!

[salamence47]

I really understand the critics about your tempo!

but I know that you are still a pianist and you're a girl right? so maybe that's the answer of your being slow in this piece.

[Zupadupabanaan]

hmmm... eighter you should practice some more, or you should stop playing... because IT SUCKS!!!! its too slow, no emotion, far too many mistakes. I dont know who posted this video but "Pathetique" should be more like "pathetic"... omg, i guess Beethoven just turned around in his grave hearing this... You rather crap all over the piano on the middle of the stage, even that will give people more pleasure.... Just please stop making me puke all over the floor...

[SparkyXX]

In the wise words of a great man, "CRY MOAR."

[shiHo1613]

haha...now she sounds RIGHT to the title...

PATHETIQUE !!

[Hannenlink]

try to play it in 9:04 min.

[Hannenlink]

When you play it a little bit slower, you better play it backwards

haha

[Hannenlink]

i tink she is stoned

haha

[Hannenlink]

echt heel slecht.

bah, foei

[T1carus]

slow and unflavoured pereformance

when you play a peice take note of the name for example this is pathetique and you should play like you hate it

[Hannenlink]

yes

[jgkflgkfl]

your bad and slow and have too many mistakes , practice practice practice maybe one day you can play this in resonable way

[Hannozwan]

To be honest, I understand the critique. Its indeed a bit slow and sometimes brakes take a little to long, or emotion is put on the wrong place. Nonetheless this still is a reasonably good performance that shouldnt be underappreciated.

[ksirminoh]

i think it is good beeing slow !

congrats!

[radiaxin]

This performance is mediocre at best.

[thekoolgal]

great performance !! im playing it slower than u right now omg i cant play fast with this ... hehe just started learning ... is it just me or is there snoring in the background i noticed from like 2:59 seriously...... or is it just my hearing? XD

[hirotadaito]

第2楽章も聴いてみたい！

[gamer4251]

よくできました。

But anyways, great work. That's about the same speed I play it :P

[LVEM111]

to slow

[Likeaperv]

why are you so rude man? hope you got a better video of u or someone that could do it faster as you say, its a master piece n she did great.

[salamence47]

Even thought it is slow...

it is nice to hear...

atleast it was clear!!!

:)

You played it clear and good!!!

I really like the way you play

the piece in 2:10 !!!

YOUR SOOOO GOoDDD!!!

thanks for posting!

("_)

[lilsumtin1234]

oohh.. u can talk.. post you're own vid then. let see how bad a pianist u are... oh. let me ask first. r u pianist..? LOL..

(i've opened my mouth for a minute there..haha)

[yojopiano]

*pff* I play concerts in Munich, Berlin, Friedrichshafen, etc. ...

and that is really played too slowly and there are too many mistakes ...

[lilsumtin1234]

And your proof is..?? where? how come i don't see one? lolz.. explain all the details on where she had gone wrong that made the piece sound like a piece of shit.. and if u had.. i will go on my knees and say sorry 'SiNCERELY' :) fair enough?

[SparkyXX]

If you don't like it, don't listen to it, and try not to be a prick.

[lorenamerino]

should have been just a tinny little bit faster, but i enjoyed it

[pa60028]

1つ1つ音がきれいにでて、とても良いと思います。

もうちょっと速いほうがいいかな？とも思いますが。

[74lou]

She plays WONDERFULLY.

She is a flower among the flowers and she has her own interpretation of BEETHOVEN.

AWESOME :*****

74lou

[chibinessroxsheep]

0o0 すごい...

I'm learning this for my next exam, and I'm so scared! I love the tempo of this version. (the fast one scares me...) きれい です^_^

[hintingyou]

i enjoy this slow version more then the fast version :D

good work.

[magnatuss]

greetings from venezuela!!

excellent...!!!

loved it!

[GoldenMusician]

This was really well played, articulation hit correctly. But the tempo could be adjusted just a bit. I feel it's a bit too slow. You don't have to be a slave to the score either :) - Feel free to add some artistic rubato :) - Check out my channel, I've got some compositions in there - I'll upload a video of me playing fragments of "Chopin's scherzo no.2 Bb minor" But I'll go more into detail of that when I get the material. Once again, nice playing.

-GoldenMusician

[nmyty7]

名曲を大事に演奏しようと思う気持ちが良く伝わってきました。

最後の音は、もっと伸ばしてもよいのでは？

１つの楽章だけの場合は、楽譜どおりでなくてもと、素人耳では思­いました。

[LobatosMetalManiac]

beautiful and awesome piece for a beautiful woman =OO great combination!

[ueno6341]

ちょっと遅すぎひんか？

[jb0811]

Could've taken a bit faster but not bad.

[HubertCumberdale22]

Wonderful!

Greetings from Switzerland ;)

[SEBASTIANFFX]

Great!!!!!!

Greetings from Colombia.

[hilxoxo]

Beautiful!!, and I'm not talking about the music...

美しい解釈、美しい女の子

[4yetnot]

Восхитительно!!! My respect from Russia.

[r9r9r9r9r]

вы!!!

[salamence47]

YEah!!!

Maybe your right... you should play it in this tempo because you are a girl...

but I think you could play this fast if you want to... Right???

By the way, Great performance...

I also watch your video as your rehersals...

thanks for posting!!!

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thank you kind comment!

Yes, I might can play it in faster tempo.

But I felt nervous in the concert.

I shall practice more!

[darthinigmus]

i don't know about the tempo being faster, but I think just having it COMPLETELY memorized is enough...I should know, b/c I'm trying to memorize for auditions in 2 days!

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thanks your comment!

How was your auditions?

[NarutoFantaisy92]

It is surprising myself I have 13 years I began piano i hope one day be as it

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thank you!

I want to listen your play.

[NarutoFantaisy92]

she's amazing!

[momoiscrazii]

A lot of people do this piece waaaay too fast!

[salamence47]

yes... It should be fast because it is in Rondo Allegro in tempo and no in Adagio...

[momoiscrazii]

NO I mean this person did it well...durh

Some people go rushing off

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thank you =)

Lots of people talk me to play faster.

I would like to learn like that.

But I am in pleasure reading your comment.

[tioangelw]

mal muy mal si no tienen talento para que suben estas mierdas jajaja

[buttdad58]

I think I'm in love....

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thank you!!

[brian777999]

Who is the pianist ? I cannot read Japanese.I quite like her interpretation. Many other pianists play it way too fast.

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thank you!

You are a kind man.

But I reccomend Freddy Kempf's talked by pianoman654.

[iambananananananana]

too slow and mechanic.

come on, i wanna see you weeping like a baby!

[wildbrunette51]

agreed

[KleinesEtwas007]

very good. and not that fast like the others.. They just don't get it...

[davidweiner23]

kore wa ii desu nee!

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thank you!

You use Japanese well(^-^)

[Wouk1805]

Is it a slowmotionned video ?

[theshacho]

You did a great job! Where is "MORI NO HALL"? I wonder if I have ever visited this place, while I am Japanese.

[r9r9r9r9r]

Thank you!

MORI no Hall is in matsudo-city, Chiba-pref.

Where are you?

And I wonder do you do mixi?

[1337Kira]

Gonna have to agree,

It's decent.

But really generic =/

[Wochechule]

I think she doesn't play it well.. without any expression....I don't like it....

[crudosoy1]

Oh.. so you probably know what to play with expression means.. right?

[josettepouilloux]

yes ok pathetic is the english word and pathetique is the french word which means the same. it comes from pathos(grec) which means pity. did not know it also meant moving or pitiful.thanks anyway I Learned something about this word

[josettepouilloux]

beautiful cant understand y its call pathetic coc its far from being pathetic?

[Stratmastuh]

"Pathetique" not pathetic. I do not believe it translates to pathetic.

[mehdital]

thats the same thing but in french

[Nocticus]

Maybe Beethoven was a perfectioniste, and after he created his pieces he thought they were pathetic?...

I don't know, but thats what I usually think for some of the things I make.

[MI6MI5]

The bass is too loud

[h04246]

Splendid. It's very beautiful. Calm and soft tone touched my heart... Thanks so much!

[overbends]

If you guys think this is slow, you should hear me play it!

Ha, well done.

[DePianoViolinGirl]

please, much faster!

[Desmonddd2002]

why isn't she playing the first and second movement?

[r9r9r9r9r]

I played those another concert.

Thanks comment!

[buskern]

I like it. It is played at a pace I could probably handle, and so has encouraged me to give it a go. But I promise I wont put it on Youtube!

[ugigignu]

mhhhh... non mi piace come interpreti Beethoven. Troppo meccanica, senza sensibilità... naaaaa

[8613942187]

thats right...but i would practice like that...it's way too slow and no there's temperament in it...beethoven was much more radical.....many things to do...you keep your tempo not in all cases.....

[Zippolata]

Dah de dah,,,,,la de dah....... Please leave Mr B to western pianists..... They have the speed and dexterity to perform as he would. Too slow by 20 in C/......This will and has bored me to tears......Bye....

[ELkuken]

Wow, racism

[missymoosical]

Never, ever say Mr B again. BTW, race has nothing to do with piano, as anyone should have realised by now.

[ndinosan]

POOR BEETHOVEN!!!!!!!! TOO SLOW. TOO CLOCWORK, MECCANIC, INSENSIBLE. AND ALSO ERRATED. AN ESCUTION FOR A BABY OF 6 YEARS OLD! By an italian pianist.

[missymoosical]

Hey, lay off mate. Every pianist has their own interpretation. I think she played it beautifully.

[ndinosan]

The interpretation is a thing..play in a errated way is a grammatical error...for the musical's grammatic..some parts are with errors...and is impossible to ignore it

[missymoosical]

I'm sure you'll survive. And by the way, when you say 'grammatical', do you mean 'technical'? We're talking about music, not language. =)

[ndinosan]

Well...but a "C" is different to a "G"...and in a part were is a "C major", is impossible to play a "D major". The pianist of this video play the Patetica in a dilettant way.

(I talk about MUSICAL's grammatical, about rules and things of MUSIC and not about language!!)..

[xcydnas]

OMG, she played so well and she's so beautiful. I love her.

[maxibusch]

yes... thats right

[swanningaround]

As the others say, it is a little "slow". Also, the phasing is slightly wrong. However, you have an excellent technique and play very few wrong notes! I'm sure that you can correct these small things.

[ELkuken]

how can an interpretation be wrong? of course the wrong notes are another subject

[im4mur4]

そうだよ。

[supahayato]

ちょっと遅いかな?

[mcjojo2046]

画質がいい

[szrtkl]

too slow!!!!!!! come on you could go a little faster

[chirolax]

hello

well

far far away of here

you still playing the piano

haha

good, bye and good luck in your job!!!

princess of the pianoforte

[jacline28]

good job=] i cant play like this smooth...sigh

but, its a bit slow,

it sounds like u are in a hurry...

it improves at the end=]

anyone agree?

[IchEsseKindern]

um... just curious, how can it be slow but sound a like its in a hurry? Some parts of the song naturally sound hurried, as thats the way its written. Some parts messed me up because it would change from eighth notes to triplets and then back to eighths, and it always made me think I was rushing the eighths after the triplets when I played them too slow.

[BJBlitzstein]

Somehow you made it sound delicate. If Beethoven were female... Brava.

[sswizard]

lmfao... brava....wow...

[Fizzyboy4]

My thoughts exactly.

[jpseoul]

fantastic.