this is soooooo slow...also you can tell it should be played faster because the strings are going so much faster than the director on the main melody parts. The conductor obviously thinks that his interpretation is more important than coplands original tempo.
you know what everybody who dissed us? We were good for the amount of our experience. I had fun in London. yeah it wasn't perfect, but you know what we did it for fun and the audience loved it!
look, im playing this in my youth orchestra..... it is a very difficult piece. and i dont think that taking it slower afects how well they did. the notes were almost perfect. the conductor of this orchestra is my middle school conductor. i know he was very proud of them considering that this is an adult orchestra piece and they were very brave to take it all the way to london to perform.
I'm currently playing this song in sinfonia, and I'm a middle school. yes, the conductor also conducts at one of the middle schools. The conductor has taken his orchestras to many festivals and we have won high rankings. Those who complain about the slow tempo, no matter how the music is played, South musicians try their best and we should be proud that they did. It's not like at last minute the conductor can change the tempo and have the whole orchestra screw up.
this has absolutely nothing to do with America or perfection. they're not together and their sound/ the audio isn't great. I realize this is an orchestra of young people but my youth orchestra just sight read this piece on saturday at performance tempo without stopping and it sounded way better than this...
While they are brits and everyone is firing off how they cant capture the american spirit (its way true) but they ARE a young school orchestra...of course they wont sound amazing, you dont need to go balls to the wall criticism on them : /
We're taking it at this tempo at my school for now. They sound pretty good but at times, they didn't sound the least bit together. It could just be the audio.
the instrumentation in this is great but like the other two commenters said, they really need to pick up the pace. they slowed this down a ridiculous amount. imagine trying to use this version during a western movie or something like that..
Egads did they seriously slow this down by like 30 bpm? The up and down runs by the string section sound fucking horrible that slow. I understand that they are children...then if they can't play it that speed then too bad. I wouldn't expect anyone outside of a prodigy orchestra to be able to handle this song before late high school at a really good program. You don't hear Flight of the Bumblebee at 160bpm do you? It's insulting to the people that can actually play this song that you play it slow
I agree that the pace is a bit slow, but there is absolutely no need to be rude about it whether they are British, French or even American. Your bigotted attitude just displays a lack of intelligence!
I played this peice in the high school orchestra at Carnegie Hall when I was in 5th grade. The tempo needs to be faster. enough said.
JoshyKel 2 months ago
Eww! Torture to the ears!
OrodesIII 2 months ago
that clarinet solo at 2:04 is supposed to be for the oboe no?
jamyupsuhsuh 4 months ago
Young people tend to play a slower tempo. But this is pretty good guys. The sound is nice. Hope you had fun in London. That's most important.
frankcannn 5 months ago
this is soooooo slow...also you can tell it should be played faster because the strings are going so much faster than the director on the main melody parts. The conductor obviously thinks that his interpretation is more important than coplands original tempo.
LoveFrenchhorn 5 months ago
you know what everybody who dissed us? We were good for the amount of our experience. I had fun in London. yeah it wasn't perfect, but you know what we did it for fun and the audience loved it!
Mateja170 10 months ago
look, im playing this in my youth orchestra..... it is a very difficult piece. and i dont think that taking it slower afects how well they did. the notes were almost perfect. the conductor of this orchestra is my middle school conductor. i know he was very proud of them considering that this is an adult orchestra piece and they were very brave to take it all the way to london to perform.
pianoviolinplayer 11 months ago
What the fuck is this? hahaha pathetic
jtizz711 1 year ago
Are they playing is slow motion ???
JubalCalif 1 year ago
I'm currently playing this song in sinfonia, and I'm a middle school. yes, the conductor also conducts at one of the middle schools. The conductor has taken his orchestras to many festivals and we have won high rankings. Those who complain about the slow tempo, no matter how the music is played, South musicians try their best and we should be proud that they did. It's not like at last minute the conductor can change the tempo and have the whole orchestra screw up.
crazycellolady 1 year ago
a tad slow, but work on listening to other sections of the orchestra, that's what got my philharmonic orchestra through it..
200169878 1 year ago
Comment removed
SantaFe158 2 years ago
Makes me feel good about the youth orchestra i am in
supersam1475 2 years ago 2
I feel it is a little slow...but I am not an expert
tyrant4lyfe 2 years ago 2
Hahaha.
ReignOfPraine 2 years ago
i hate london
CiscoNast 2 years ago
@CiscoNast
Well as Londoner I hate whichever place that you are from.....though how can I hate a place that I don't know?
mike5012tx 1 year ago
this is good, but it seems kinda under tempo
TwilightsCalling 2 years ago 2
age don't matter
just experience
VlilV 2 years ago 6
It's a complicated "grown up" piece for a student "young" orchestra. I applaud the ambition of the conductor or whomever chose this for them.
NelsonClick 2 years ago 2
2:14 is where it really gets painful...
this has absolutely nothing to do with America or perfection. they're not together and their sound/ the audio isn't great. I realize this is an orchestra of young people but my youth orchestra just sight read this piece on saturday at performance tempo without stopping and it sounded way better than this...
Therearemen16 2 years ago
FUCK U... amarica is perfect (lol)
we just started this in my orchestra and we all stopped and just started cracking up, but our teacher just plowed on conducting
karattop71 2 years ago
It's the sound of Texas.
WildBluebonnet 2 years ago
While they are brits and everyone is firing off how they cant capture the american spirit (its way true) but they ARE a young school orchestra...of course they wont sound amazing, you dont need to go balls to the wall criticism on them : /
LoVeBlooDPlus 2 years ago 3
Absolutely terrible. For crying out loud!
quantumleap7219 2 years ago 2
LOL
MisterAtoms 2 years ago
We're taking it at this tempo at my school for now. They sound pretty good but at times, they didn't sound the least bit together. It could just be the audio.
surfininalaska 2 years ago
wow....it's a dance....not a ballad.
spyderwalk 2 years ago
needs to be a lot faster. i just heard it at my school area concert. the highschoolers did great on it
StrangerYouKnow 2 years ago
this needs to go wayy faster. the basses need to get the notes right.
abecedarianx 2 years ago 7
@abecedarianx yeah, this needs to not suck (in order to be good).
yisacknayrabin 1 year ago
geez.. that's not the american feel I must say.. Not the right performers to get it down!
CISGam0rIntel 3 years ago 2
ya I agree its too slow, I bet they would be able to go faster
caityrox05 3 years ago
Poor version, too slow. Sounds like a middle schools version.
deppjj2000 3 years ago
Comment removed
SantaFe158 2 years ago
the instrumentation in this is great but like the other two commenters said, they really need to pick up the pace. they slowed this down a ridiculous amount. imagine trying to use this version during a western movie or something like that..
payeco 3 years ago
It is just not an easy piece to master period.
mwp62 3 years ago
Egads did they seriously slow this down by like 30 bpm? The up and down runs by the string section sound fucking horrible that slow. I understand that they are children...then if they can't play it that speed then too bad. I wouldn't expect anyone outside of a prodigy orchestra to be able to handle this song before late high school at a really good program. You don't hear Flight of the Bumblebee at 160bpm do you? It's insulting to the people that can actually play this song that you play it slow
Padfoot85 3 years ago 2
F'in Brits really need to pick up the pace!
agoodintention 3 years ago
@agoodintention
I agree that the pace is a bit slow, but there is absolutely no need to be rude about it whether they are British, French or even American. Your bigotted attitude just displays a lack of intelligence!
mike5012tx 1 year ago