Green Day - Who Wrote Holden Caulfield? @ Madison Square Garden NYC 7/28/09

[bassgeek3]

This song and 80 are two of my favorite green day songs and they are always overlooked.

[greendayisawesome100]

@randomrando2012 no i just looked at the back cover of my awesome as f**k cd and it says "Who Wrote Holden Caulfield (new york)" it might be on the dvd but on the cd this audio is on it

[ohgravity1000]

@greendayisawesome100 Madison Square Garden is in New York dumbass

[greendayisawesome100]

@ohgravity1000 i know its in new york, some guy was saying the recording was in phoenix and i was correcting him

[ohgravity1000]

@greendayisawesome100 oh ok my bad lol

[thisisnotfakeandgay]

this is in Awesome as F**k!!

[Trecool085]

This song was taken from this concert for awesome as fuck ^^

[greendaykicksass1101]

right before this he fucked up on stuart and the ave. it would be amazing he would play stuart and the ave.

[redheadcover]

this is the performance they used for the Album Awesome as Fuck

[ElementalheroJake444]

damn i didnt know they still performed songs from kerplunk!

[xINiNJAzIx]

this is the one on the Awesome As F**K Album too;D

[Schwapoffski]

@randomrando2012

Oh sorry, right :D

[Schwapoffski]

is that the awesome as fuck version?

[twyst19]

@Schwapoffski it sounds like it huh!

[Raisume24]

<3 <3 love this song!!! <3 <3

[JimmyBlade69]

y the fuck are you all saying its ur fav from awesome as fuck this concert was in 2009 the damn album came out in 2011 -.-

[gdfobmcrsum41]

@JimmyBlade69 they took songs from their 21st century breakdown tour and put it on the cd. it is very well possible that this is the track on the cd. it says from new york on the track. 21 guns was from mountain view, and that show was in september of 2010

[BobMarley6795]

@JimmyBlade69 cuz this song came out on kerplunk! in '92

[JimmyBlade69]

@BobMarley6795 Yeah i know but billies not saying This is my favorite song off awesome as fuck hes saying Kerplunk and everyone in the comments are saying that billies saying its his favorite off awesome as fuck and thats not what he said

[JimmyBlade69]

@BobMarley6795 u dont understand what im saying -.-

[LolaLavonda]

this song is phony!!! 

[hyrule109]

@LolaLavonda what do u mean?

[LolaLavonda]

@hyrule109 it was a reference to holden caulfield.

[101guitarest]

Favourite song from

awsome as f**k

Kerplunk 

[trippinxtremezebra]

this was an awesome concert.....

[101guitarest]

this is from my favourite album awsome as f**k

[Ty13rlikespie]

THIS is the same recording as awsome as fuck the same night i just watched two other ones that were he same too haha

[RandysWrestling]

You guys want to hear some more old shit or what? ...If you have AAF you'll know what I mean ;]

[MrBlaza13]

this song -from NYC it's on Awesome as Fuck as MP3 song !

[ddiamondd]

i was really happy watching this until I saw "that other guy" in the background. why green day why?

[ciroesposito47]

it's in Awesome as fuck!

[14hoklaamchengh1]

they used this in awesome as fuck

[geezyoursoft]

fuckin love the old school classics!!...shame when they played dominated love slave and going to pasalaqua (sydney) ...hardly no one knew the fuckin words!!

[xJeffo1x]

I think I just broked the replay button o.O sorry youtube.

[Rockguitarist4511]

Best Song from Awesome as fuck :D check out my cover aswell :)

[JuulYT]

Hey wait, this is also on Awesome as Fuck. =D

[MrReCkLeSsAbAnDoN182]

this is my favorite song from kerplunk! it's fucking amazing!

[MurderCity21]

This Is going to the Live album.

I Guess It was Awesome As Fuck.

[Punkshitt]

Its my favorite too <3

[Jesus1Of1Suburbia]

I seriously hope they play this at manchester

definetly my favousrite song!!!!

Its just so fucking epic!!!!

[basketcase0191]

they're best song ever? i think so... if they played this every set i'd travel around the world with them

[Whatsername2609]

this is Billie Joe's favourite song of green day!

[GoingToPasalacqua12]

he said its his favourite from kerplunk

[Whatsername2609]

yeah i know! but @ an interview with fuse a fan asked him which song is his favourite of all their songs and he said:"who wrote holden caulfield'!

[GoingToPasalacqua12]

ah right didnt know that, sweet!

[hadododo6]

@GoingToPasalacqua12 mine too :)

[nyzmrock]

@Whatsername2609 its also his favorite book, Catcher In The Rye!

[Docas633]

@nyzmrock that's really cool. one day i was on holiday, bored like hell and my mother lended me that book in english (i'm portuguese). when i started reading it and saw the name Holden Caulfield, i automatically recalled this song and got interested in the book. it's a great book and song btw!

[GreenDayandJoanJett]

@Whatsername2609 no his favorite from KERPLUNK! xD ♥

[iOakland]

@Whatsername2609 Wrong, it's just his favourite from Kerplunk!

His favourite Green Day song is Paper Lanterns as he said himself.

[naruto0f0olympus]

@iOakland when did he say that

[FaithandMisery]

That squeak right after Billie said that was his favorite song off Kerplunk was me. I'm 99% sure. The camera was just a little too high to catch my head.

[cannabisbisbisbisbis]

thanks for sharing

[AsleepToMusic]

man i hope they play music like this at todays concert!!!!!!

[AndEis93]

your vids r awsome man!!!

[LPRory]

GREAT GREAT quality