@jofjonesboro you are OBVIOUSLY not a trained singer or musician... as you are not able to distinguish between tortured animals and people who can actually sing with any electronic enhancement... you may not like what Celine Dion does but you cannot take away the immense talent that she is... There many singers I do not care for as far as material or style but I am always able to put aside my personal taste in face of talent..
And I fear for the cats in your area... what horrible analogy!
Of course Celine isn't Edith Piaf. Celine is vocally a better singer than Edith Piaf. However, Edith Piaf sings with pain and Celine sings with joy so it is a totally different thing. Like comparing apples to oranges.
No one can sing like Edith Piaff. She is a legend. I don't know french but when i listen Edith, i can feel the song and almost understand the lyrics. I couldn't feel the same way with Celine Dion. Of course she is a great singer. But Edith is another story!
Nossa , quando dizem que a musica é a lingua dos Anjos, duvidava , até conhecer Edith Piaf,. Existe ótimas versões, mas a original é a que mais emociona.
She has a great voice, but I think she overdid this song with it and did not felt it the way she should have while singing such a beautiful, meaningful song. I much prefer Piaf's original and Loius Armstrong's version because of that.
Celine has one of the best voices in the biz, but she doesn't FEEL this song. You can't fake it. It's still a good performance, but the reason Edith or Judy and others without great voices have the status they do is that they bare their souls with their audience, something very, very few perfomers of any kind do. It is extremely rare, painful and precious.
I just listened to Renee Olstead, Vladimir, Edith Piaf and Celine Dion sing this song. Celine blows them all away with her version and the above singers can really wail too. Celine est la meilleure chanteuse du monde--Celine is the best singer in the world--my opinion.
What I just tried to say in French which is "pending approval" is that I have heard Edith Piaf, Renee Olmstead, et Vladimir also sing this song. The winner is "Celine Dion". She is the best singer in the world and will always be the best. I know that I butchered the French, but I think anyone reading it will make out what I was saying. Please post it in French--I try to do my best.
Eh bien.....J'ai ecoute Edith Piaf chanter le meme chanson, et Rene Olstead, et Vladimir. Le gagneur est Celine Dion--le meilleure chanteuse du monde et pour toujours. Je baragouiner le francais, je le sais. Mais tous les vous comprendre ce que j'essaye pour vous le dire.
Toujours belle à entendre et vivre pour les amoureux...Immortelle...
nathemmie 2 months ago
CAN A FLUENT SPEAKER TELL ME HOW HER FRENCH IS? THANK YOU!
RomaShop1 3 months ago
Celine just doesn't "sell the heart" like Edith Piaf....
dtr0005 3 months ago
I like Celine, but no one can sing "La Vie en Rose" with the emotion that Edith Piaf conveys and permeates
amberbbv 5 months ago
@jofjonesboro you are OBVIOUSLY not a trained singer or musician... as you are not able to distinguish between tortured animals and people who can actually sing with any electronic enhancement... you may not like what Celine Dion does but you cannot take away the immense talent that she is... There many singers I do not care for as far as material or style but I am always able to put aside my personal taste in face of talent..
And I fear for the cats in your area... what horrible analogy!
hmmfun 5 months ago
grande chanteuse moins émouvante que piaf mais superbe aussi
lediabledelabastille 5 months ago
Of course Celine isn't Edith Piaf. Celine is vocally a better singer than Edith Piaf. However, Edith Piaf sings with pain and Celine sings with joy so it is a totally different thing. Like comparing apples to oranges.
jandminnkeepers 6 months ago in playlist jandminnkeepers's Favorited Videos
celine,i love you forever..........FRANCAISE.........
paris-france
tedayrom 6 months ago
Nop, not doing it form me...at all!!!
victhemachine 7 months ago
Check this out on youtube. That'll do it for you.
Soraya Arnelas - La vie en rose
Quach7 6 months ago
Celeine Dion...ahhh.
Herestome2 7 months ago
Celine is a great singer in her own right but i believe Ediths voice had a special "vibrato thing going on also much more from the heart !
ronnied828 7 months ago
wonderful voice *_*
MelanieStellina 7 months ago
Celin Dion es una gran cantante, pero esta canción para interpretarlaa solo Edit Piaf te hace volarr al escucharlaaa ......
AMAG1910 8 months ago
No one like Piaf!!!!!
amber123446 8 months ago
No one can sing like Edith Piaff. She is a legend. I don't know french but when i listen Edith, i can feel the song and almost understand the lyrics. I couldn't feel the same way with Celine Dion. Of course she is a great singer. But Edith is another story!
fener97 10 months ago
I so enjoyed the swing style of this rendition by the darling Celine...wow.
thanks
mamamialove 10 months ago
Muy a su versión es buena, a secas nada del otro mundo, se estanca en una seca ''buena interpretación''
adrianitaTH 10 months ago
What a beatiful song sung by one of the great female singers ever..
n1950m 11 months ago
There is no doubt that Celine is a great singer. But, I just can't stand how she always has to twist the song and make it sound like a country!
MsStefanah 11 months ago
Merveilleux ! quelle voix !
Edith Piaf était très douée et Céline Dion l'est aussi :D
marounette17 1 year ago
she is good, but edith put such feeling that anyone can
dutydu 1 year ago
I'm sorry, better than Edith!
Pfsif 1 year ago
she just can't help doing that voice shtick of hers, even with this sweet, classic song.
jonnj1975 1 year ago
Edith Piaf was a talent. This woman is a hack.
zycycle 1 year ago
@zycycle ...not a friendly comment...- Edith Piaf had a very special way to sing. I is very hard to do - I tell you this as a singer! Daiandrah
sunlightforeveryone 1 year ago
LOVE IT, LOVE IT, LOVE IT !!! AND CELINE LOOKS AMAZING <3
simonaloveceline 1 year ago
Tutta musica che fa sognare...solo x coloro che sanno cos'è il vero romanticismo,grazie Paolo
maxmilianficca 1 year ago
✿⊱╮✿⊱╮✿⊱╮ throwing flowers for you <3
khayerei05 1 year ago
poles apart from that of Piaf
chengchunnam 1 year ago
@0311RFLMN You mean Merci beaucoup...
XdisXesXwhyXimXhawtX 1 year ago
one of the great female singers of our time.celine beautiful celine. merci bocoups.
0311RFLMN 1 year ago
looooooooooooooooooooooooove it
MultiPopsinger 1 year ago
IT'S SO SEXY!!!
elphiebusayong 1 year ago
Folks, there is now need to compare her version with Piaf's. She sings it like Celine Dion. Period.
otahg 1 year ago
@otahg Amen, amen, amen, amen. I could not agree with you more.
ShylohSTFU 1 year ago
Nossa , quando dizem que a musica é a lingua dos Anjos, duvidava , até conhecer Edith Piaf,. Existe ótimas versões, mas a original é a que mais emociona.
sgcorretor 1 year ago
@sgcorretor Amo Piaff e com certeza as versões cantadas por ela são as + bonitas, ouça La Foule acho q vc vai gostar.
bidycraw 1 year ago
Wow so beatiful!!!!but this song it's perfect in the edith piaf voice...
chaguito2010 1 year ago
Wow so beatiful!!!!but this song it's perfect in the edith piaf voice...
chaguito2010 1 year ago
She has a great voice, but I think she overdid this song with it and did not felt it the way she should have while singing such a beautiful, meaningful song. I much prefer Piaf's original and Loius Armstrong's version because of that.
nyditamix 1 year ago
she does a great job, but I am sorry no one can do it like Edith Piaf The little Sparrow
pompeygirlGA 1 year ago
This is so much better than any other version.
Zayrina 2 years ago
@saynomore
Truer words were never spoken.
rikku9zashi 2 years ago
i love this version..n celine, ur voice..magnificient!
saraswed79 2 years ago
excellent performance, but i feel like she was trying too hard to make it HER song...no-one can out-do the original
saynnomore 2 years ago
Celine is the best. Simply the best. love her so much!
shikma 2 years ago
Celine has one of the best voices in the biz, but she doesn't FEEL this song. You can't fake it. It's still a good performance, but the reason Edith or Judy and others without great voices have the status they do is that they bare their souls with their audience, something very, very few perfomers of any kind do. It is extremely rare, painful and precious.
gdpetti 2 years ago
This gave me chills.
She is amazing.
TheLiquified 2 years ago
Best love song ever. She's a GREAT singer.
EvilKillerFlan 2 years ago
celine is the best... i love her.
zorabinette2911 2 years ago
To me, this is the epitomy of angelic.
jandminnkeepers 2 years ago
this song is beautiful!
lianeclarke 2 years ago
better than grace jones wild crazy crack hoe lookin' ass ...J't'aime Celine
Cerrillafied 2 years ago
This has to be the best French version of La Vie En Rose by a female vocalist I've heard to date. THANK YOU for sharing!!
onlyheaven 2 years ago
I just listened to Renee Olstead, Vladimir, Edith Piaf and Celine Dion sing this song. Celine blows them all away with her version and the above singers can really wail too. Celine est la meilleure chanteuse du monde--Celine is the best singer in the world--my opinion.
124bjw 2 years ago
Renee Olstead has the way better Voice!!
marcrichiger 2 years ago
What I just tried to say in French which is "pending approval" is that I have heard Edith Piaf, Renee Olmstead, et Vladimir also sing this song. The winner is "Celine Dion". She is the best singer in the world and will always be the best. I know that I butchered the French, but I think anyone reading it will make out what I was saying. Please post it in French--I try to do my best.
124bjw 2 years ago
Eh bien.....J'ai ecoute Edith Piaf chanter le meme chanson, et Rene Olstead, et Vladimir. Le gagneur est Celine Dion--le meilleure chanteuse du monde et pour toujours. Je baragouiner le francais, je le sais. Mais tous les vous comprendre ce que j'essaye pour vous le dire.
124bjw 2 years ago
It is worth to learn French just to understand this gorgeous song.
This is the best love tribute a woman has ever written to a man.
vioro58 2 years ago
Good job! And this from a guy that doesn't care much for Celine Dion.
frankish08 2 years ago
inolvidable vivir enamore
lucanolala2008 2 years ago
Celine Cherie, je vous aime mon amour,,, avec toi ma vie est "La Vie en Rose",,,
fbett111 2 years ago
Celine cherie, je vous aime mon amour avec toi ma vie est "La vie en Rose"
fbett111 2 years ago
Sublime!<3
MELOCHE33 2 years ago
Sublime! <3
MELOCHE33 2 years ago