da kidev, lanzgva gineba imati iaragia, vinc tavisi azrebis dasacavad sxva sashualebas ver pulobs. mogcons misha an badri?-tkvi ratom mogcon da ikneb mec dagijero,da bolos,viscavlot ertxel da samudamod ertmanetis pativiscema, tu ar gvinda aseti ram (2nombris da imedis darbeva) ganmeorsdes saqartveloshi
imat gasagonad, vinc mishas da badris gamo ertmanetsagineben: badri rom damnashavea, sul ar nishnavs mishas udanashaulobas. xalxi quchashi badris sikvarulis gamo ar gamosula, misham ki es qvekana sakutar memkvidreobad miichnia da rasac unda aketebs. tkven ki, ver xvdebit, rom vigaciis brma iaragad iqecit. jer erti, ratom unda vlanzgot da vaginot ertmanets, tu misha mogvcons an ar mogvcons? tu kamati unda vinmes, argumentebit ikamatos
amis shemdeg fiqrobt rom misha magaria? romel demokratiul qveyanashi xdeba tv-is ase darbeva? da adamians es rom moscons,imas saertod gaegeba amqveynad rame? sxva saqmea badris miznebi da danashaulebebi. drom achvena, rom is saartvelos mteria, magram es ar unda gazlevdes uflebas, telekompaniis ase darbevisa da jurnalistebis cemisa. sheizleboda eteris gatishva anzidan da amit damtavrdeboda kvelaferi.da kidev, ar sheizleba politikuri simpatiebis gamo, zaladobas dauchiro mxari.
gaixaret xalxo irakli badris asuli iudashvili gaskvanches germaniashi da male dasvaven tbilisis reisze ! anu amit damtkicda rom misha martali iko tore germanelebi arasdros ar daapatimrebdnen tkuilubralod da shetitxnili braldebebit ! dagerxa iraklia tu ver gishvela badrias fulebma ? tu gegona rom gadarchi ? miigeb misagebs she gamkidvelo shen unda dalpe cixeshi pidarastebis kamerashi rom dgeshi atjer giknan saknavi ikidan rom gamoxval pomada unda gesvas da kalgotka gecvas !
abkhazetiru ze qartuli ena da azrovneba idevneba. es xalxi shevardnazis dros mishas ginebashi iko axla ki saakashvils udzvrebian. sinamdvileshi ki tavisi tavis meti araperi ar ainteresebt. male albat patarkacishvils sheuzvrebian tu rame gadaugdes iqedan ra tqma unda.
me kide imedi makvs rom kargad dagamtvreven kbebs da rac sazizgrobebi ilaparaket sul cxvirshi amogadenen ! is giorga naxet rogori damandrajebulia albat rom aakenes skami sveli iko ! miiges am badriashvilebma misagebi amati aferisti dedas... es shobelkatebi ver isveneben !
giorgi gamsaxurdia kaci ki ara klea. cotne kacia vin mxedrionelebze laparakob cotnestan mimartebashi xelisuflebashi gaixede da naxe vin arian ruruebi ruruebis banda martavs saqartvelos
You are very "nice" calling me "debili." This is your problem that you don't listen to anyone and you are very negative. That's why Georgia is behind of industrialized world becuase you are reading and listening to wrong people. I don't want to inusult you, but I'd like to tell you candidly that first you have to learn how to speak to people.
gogo ar gamagizho,jer eg erti 11 clisas internetshi ra ginda? mere meorec win aris sheni mascawlebeli da maset sisuleleebs ratom gikitxawt? magistwis gagishwit kviprosse? erti sitywac ar daichero im sheni debili mascawleblis da locwebsac sheeshwi da iscawle kargad:)
geus1 unamuso kaci xar kremlis agentia 150 atasi kaci vinc iq gavida 2 noembers? sadam xuseins bombavdnen da CNN ar dauxuria bagdadshi. marla bnelebi xar amas ro ambobt
gogoladze, erti kartwelis sheuracyopis pasic ki ar aris eg sheni dampali imedi.internetshi xom shemodixar? caikitxe da twiton gansaje miukerzoeblad, ra xdeba sakartweloshi da wis ciskwilse asxams ckals eg uimedo imedi.
tan yvelaze dzalian amati azri magizianebs.da saertod saqartvelos sul sxvanairad uyureben.magram is ki vici rom saqartvelo yvelaze magari qveyanaa da guli shemtkiva am situaciis gamo.da vimedovneb rom yvelaperi kargad iqneba.
eg araperi tamuna shen sheni azri gamotqvi,qveyanashi tavs deben demokratiaze nishnavda am qveyanashi xalxis azrs pativs cemen.chemi azrit erti da igivea.ise yvela magari gagizianebulia.mec ar var exla saqartveloshi,USAshi vscavlob da es ori dgea internetshi var da sainpormacioebs vuyureb.
ancushka da kokokolkhi aravis gasagizianblad ar gamiketebia komentari, sakutari azri gamovxate,me sakartveloshic davamtavre da amerikashic vscavlob, da daskvnebs ise vaketeb, modi carsulze nu vilaparakebt problema axla gvakvs tore tamar mepis dros supersaxelmcipo rom vikavit da rustavelma vepxistkaosani rom dacera eg kvelam icis
giorgis saqcieli mec momewonaa. iqneb exla mainc mixvdes xalxi, rom is yvelaperi damontajeb uli arari.s vgijdebi, rogor ar unda am xalxs tvalebis gaxela. imaze irevian rogor gagvibeda polician xelis shemobrunebao. amerikashi policias daumorchileblobisatvis sheudzlia dagapatimros da eseni uflebebis dargvevaze laparakoben. ra sircxvilliaaaaaa. eseigi ar mogvewoneba mtavroba da ase unda vamxot yovel 4 weliwadshi eretxel?
ara, koko gamsaxurdiaa kaci, mxedrionis tetri lentit ro damariazhobda anda Cotne, rusebis xelzemosamsaxure nabichvari) Giorgi kacia da kacurad moikca, misi zmebi arian nagvebi:)erti "Konstantine-Khachika" da meore "Cotne-Vasia"
ty predstavliaesh; 100000 kotorye protestovali s chamodanami v Rossiu. Tem bolee vas ne samoletnogo soobshchenia. Pozhaluista ostavaites; na meste a to vy pol;zuetes; aeroportom Yerevana. Eshcho i tseny podnimete na nashi aviareisy v Moskvu
navernoe tebe kto to kogda to govoril chemodan vokzal izrail no ty okazalsya gde to eshcho i pizdish ne po teme. A vse vy mechtali by o chemodane vokzale ROssii. Tol;ko zabyl chto pered vokzalom est; eshcho viza kotoraia dlya vas mechta
chemodan , vokzal, ijevan, khachik:) soti raz govoriu, ya ne evrei, i ne zhid,. zhid-patarkacishvili i ego zhopozicia, xyindravkin s kompaniei i izhe s nimi. Naxui mne tvoi zasrani aeroport Yerevana ne nuzhen, Ya v Moskvu na zadania ne letaiu:)
chemodan vokzal ijevan byl marshrut Gamsakhurdia esli xorosho pomnish'. My tam vstretili ego kogda Azerbaijan otkazal ego v ubezhishche. Kstati ya sprosil v drugom forume o proisxozhdenii Khaindrava. Zdes; est; telemost ImediTV s Markovym gde Ivlian imeet takoi nos i tak kartavit, tak kartativit..
malen;kiy zhidenok??? Do six por pomnish; slova ob Izraile??? POchemu v profile ne pisesh; otkuda pizdish'. Legko da gde to sidet; i ukazyvat; kto dolzhen poexat; kuda. Kike
khachik mnogo budish pizdet, zarabotaesh gemoroi. Vi vsiu zhizn rusakam zhopu lizali tak i prodolzhaite:) A zhidi-tvoi mama s papoi i finansist zhopozicii:) poimali tvoego dashnak-krunka s kokoshkoi-zasrancem i ottraxali kak sleduet. budete pizdet, eshe poluchite:)
Pro finansista zhopozitsii nikto ne somnevaettsa. Tol;ko vot finansist pozitsii tozhe zhidenok. Interesno chem eto Soros ne ugodil Badri. Mozhet odin respublicanets(sudya po tomu chto prodaet svoe imushchestvo FOXu) a Soros Democrat. Vot nashli oni pole bitvy- Gruziu
me mishal dedamovtyan
leonardo123775 1 year ago
es ra sashineleba iyo agar minda am drois gaxseneba.
Iamnukri 1 year ago
da kidev, lanzgva gineba imati iaragia, vinc tavisi azrebis dasacavad sxva sashualebas ver pulobs. mogcons misha an badri?-tkvi ratom mogcon da ikneb mec dagijero,da bolos,viscavlot ertxel da samudamod ertmanetis pativiscema, tu ar gvinda aseti ram (2nombris da imedis darbeva) ganmeorsdes saqartveloshi
tazotazo2008 4 years ago
imat gasagonad, vinc mishas da badris gamo ertmanetsagineben: badri rom damnashavea, sul ar nishnavs mishas udanashaulobas. xalxi quchashi badris sikvarulis gamo ar gamosula, misham ki es qvekana sakutar memkvidreobad miichnia da rasac unda aketebs. tkven ki, ver xvdebit, rom vigaciis brma iaragad iqecit. jer erti, ratom unda vlanzgot da vaginot ertmanets, tu misha mogvcons an ar mogvcons? tu kamati unda vinmes, argumentebit ikamatos
tazotazo2008 4 years ago
amis shemdeg fiqrobt rom misha magaria? romel demokratiul qveyanashi xdeba tv-is ase darbeva? da adamians es rom moscons,imas saertod gaegeba amqveynad rame? sxva saqmea badris miznebi da danashaulebebi. drom achvena, rom is saartvelos mteria, magram es ar unda gazlevdes uflebas, telekompaniis ase darbevisa da jurnalistebis cemisa. sheizleboda eteris gatishva anzidan da amit damtavrdeboda kvelaferi.da kidev, ar sheizleba politikuri simpatiebis gamo, zaladobas dauchiro mxari.
tazotazo2008 4 years ago
gio9988 internetshi ki ara live shic gitireb kofas she axvris gagdebulo sadac ginda iq gnaxav da shegisruleb shesasrulebels she klis tavo
gogoladze80 4 years ago
gogoladze she kleo internetidan ro blatoab , shen vinmem ra me gakadra ro iginebi sheni dedas shevetsi she kalosho
gio9988 4 years ago
shavimusha saakashvilis momxreebo mogitkant dedis mutlebiiiiiii. saakashvili fandarast
gogoladze80 4 years ago
gio9988 eee axvaro shen dedas miatesla misham tuchebze sheni deda movtkan me
gogoladze80 4 years ago
dasaketi daiketa !
shavimusha 4 years ago
gaixaret xalxo irakli badris asuli iudashvili gaskvanches germaniashi da male dasvaven tbilisis reisze ! anu amit damtkicda rom misha martali iko tore germanelebi arasdros ar daapatimrebdnen tkuilubralod da shetitxnili braldebebit ! dagerxa iraklia tu ver gishvela badrias fulebma ? tu gegona rom gadarchi ? miigeb misagebs she gamkidvelo shen unda dalpe cixeshi pidarastebis kamerashi rom dgeshi atjer giknan saknavi ikidan rom gamoxval pomada unda gesvas da kalgotka gecvas !
shavimusha 4 years ago
didi siamovnebit mivateslebdi am gogos tuchebze
gio9988 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
abkhazetiru ze qartuli ena da azrovneba idevneba. es xalxi shevardnazis dros mishas ginebashi iko axla ki saakashvils udzvrebian. sinamdvileshi ki tavisi tavis meti araperi ar ainteresebt. male albat patarkacishvils sheuzvrebian tu rame gadaugdes iqedan ra tqma unda.
LADOQARTVELI 4 years ago
მარტო ამის გამო უნდა მოეტყნას სააკაშვილს და მაგის ბანდას დედის მუტელი
jafaraa 4 years ago
me kide imedi makvs rom kargad dagamtvreven kbebs da rac sazizgrobebi ilaparaket sul cxvirshi amogadenen ! is giorga naxet rogori damandrajebulia albat rom aakenes skami sveli iko ! miiges am badriashvilebma misagebi amati aferisti dedas... es shobelkatebi ver isveneben !
shavimusha 4 years ago
orda neler oluyor acaba
sweet1453 4 years ago
giorgi gamsaxurdia kaci ki ara klea. cotne kacia vin mxedrionelebze laparakob cotnestan mimartebashi xelisuflebashi gaixede da naxe vin arian ruruebi ruruebis banda martavs saqartvelos
gogoladze80 4 years ago
markaschool, sheni xatrit chven ki vilotzebt. Exla chemi xatrit chen mastavlebels utxari tzignebi gamotzvalos :-)
pgthinker007 4 years ago
debili xar supta!!!uscavlelo!cigni caikitxe!
marikaiscool 4 years ago
You are very "nice" calling me "debili." This is your problem that you don't listen to anyone and you are very negative. That's why Georgia is behind of industrialized world becuase you are reading and listening to wrong people. I don't want to inusult you, but I'd like to tell you candidly that first you have to learn how to speak to people.
Have a great day!
pgthinker007 4 years ago
xalxno me var 11 clis magram davdivar kviprosis sakvirao skolashi...chvens mascavlebels akvs cigni sascaulebze da im cignshi aris natkvami ert kals gamoecxada gjvmtisshobeli da utxra rom xalxxno raukenit chem sayvarel sakartvelos?me ukve male amdens vejar davexmarebi sakartvelos.daanebet sakutar tavebs tavi,gaeshuret eklesiisaken da ilocet torem mesame msoplio omi sakartvelosac gadauvliso!!!dzalian gtxovt ilocet!!!
marikaiscool 4 years ago
gogo ar gamagizho,jer eg erti 11 clisas internetshi ra ginda? mere meorec win aris sheni mascawlebeli da maset sisuleleebs ratom gikitxawt? magistwis gagishwit kviprosse? erti sitywac ar daichero im sheni debili mascawleblis da locwebsac sheeshwi da iscawle kargad:)
twischi 4 years ago
geus1 unamuso kaci xar kremlis agentia 150 atasi kaci vinc iq gavida 2 noembers? sadam xuseins bombavdnen da CNN ar dauxuria bagdadshi. marla bnelebi xar amas ro ambobt
gogoladze80 4 years ago
gogoladze, erti kartwelis sheuracyopis pasic ki ar aris eg sheni dampali imedi.internetshi xom shemodixar? caikitxe da twiton gansaje miukerzoeblad, ra xdeba sakartweloshi da wis ciskwilse asxams ckals eg uimedo imedi.
twischi 4 years ago
deus1 romel giorgi gamsaxurdias kacobaze laparakob im giorgis kacobaze vinc tavis rdoze mgebrishviltan mushaobda da shevardnadzis mtavrobas icavda?
gogoladze80 4 years ago
stop terorism and dictate of saakashvili
gogoladze80 4 years ago
tan yvelaze dzalian amati azri magizianebs.da saertod saqartvelos sul sxvanairad uyureben.magram is ki vici rom saqartvelo yvelaze magari qveyanaa da guli shemtkiva am situaciis gamo.da vimedovneb rom yvelaperi kargad iqneba.
ancushka 4 years ago
eg araperi tamuna shen sheni azri gamotqvi,qveyanashi tavs deben demokratiaze nishnavda am qveyanashi xalxis azrs pativs cemen.chemi azrit erti da igivea.ise yvela magari gagizianebulia.mec ar var exla saqartveloshi,USAshi vscavlob da es ori dgea internetshi var da sainpormacioebs vuyureb.
ancushka 4 years ago
ancushka da kokokolkhi aravis gasagizianblad ar gamiketebia komentari, sakutari azri gamovxate,me sakartveloshic davamtavre da amerikashic vscavlob, da daskvnebs ise vaketeb, modi carsulze nu vilaparakebt problema axla gvakvs tore tamar mepis dros supersaxelmcipo rom vikavit da rustavelma vepxistkaosani rom dacera eg kvelam icis
tamuna29 4 years ago
rac moxda sashinelebaa, ar sheizleba es kartwels mogcondes. bewr kwekanashi wkopilwar da sakartweloze ganatlebuli eri ar arsebobs. mishas amerikuli ganatleba geamakeba? mec wscawlob ucxoetshi magram akaur propesorebs kartwelebs ar shewadareb.civilizacias ras ucodeb.sakartweloshi civilizebuli saxelmcipo roca arcebobda, evropelebis da dges "civilizebuli" saxelmcipoebis cinaprebi xeze dadiodnen.
kokokolkhi 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FUCK ALL THAT SHIT THINGS
pafillo 4 years ago
au demokratia dzalianac kargad icis yvelam raaa!
ancushka 4 years ago
vinc ar icis sitkva demokratia xalxis azrs nishnavs, magram am azrs gamoxatav archevnebze da ara kuchashi parlamentis cin rogorc civilizebur kveknebshi xdeba (sakartvelo ara mkavs mxedvelobashi, kartvelebi civilizaciisgan da ganatlebisgan dzalian shors arian dges dgeobit) rogorc arasdros ise vamakob misha saakashvilit, misha ise moikca rogorc bevrjer mokceulan misi kolegebi evropis gacilebit demokratiul kveknebshi.. xalxis dezimipormaciistvis metic gekutvnit, mokvarulis donis jurnalistebo
tamuna29 4 years ago 2
icit ras getyviiiit.rato rustavi 2 ar daixura vardebis revoluciis dros opoziciis mxardacheris gamo?rato daxures imedi?imitom rom eshiniat,radgan dgitidge xalxi xvdeba ra nagav saxelpciposhi vcxovrobt.qveyanashi sadac tavs deben demokratiaze sruli diqtatura supevs.aravintqva arao raaaaaaaaaaa!
ancushka 4 years ago
sruli versia ar akvs aravis?
sasacilo 4 years ago
ai patarkacishvilis nair mafiosebs da ukanasknel kriminalebs rom ablataveben is xelisupleba iqneba dasamxobi. yvela normaluri saxelmwipo amas gaaketebda. ki mesmis rom xalxi dazaralda, magram rogor sheidzleba gulgrilad uyuros mtavrobam rusetis mier qveynis damxobas.zomebis migeba aucilebeli iyoooooooooo......
natiaaa 4 years ago
ai, saghad moazrovne adamiani!
geus1 4 years ago
koko gamsaxurdia zmebiturt gamodga nimushi imisa, rom buneba shvilebze magrad isvenebs. nazirala da tanac idioti!!!
geus1 4 years ago
tumca giorgi gamsaxurdiam kacoba sheinarchuna da samshoblos moghalate rusetumeebs tavze daaxura. yochagh, giorgi, ar shearcxvine mamis xsovna!
geus1 4 years ago
giorgis saqcieli mec momewonaa. iqneb exla mainc mixvdes xalxi, rom is yvelaperi damontajeb uli arari.s vgijdebi, rogor ar unda am xalxs tvalebis gaxela. imaze irevian rogor gagvibeda polician xelis shemobrunebao. amerikashi policias daumorchileblobisatvis sheudzlia dagapatimros da eseni uflebebis dargvevaze laparakoben. ra sircxvilliaaaaaa. eseigi ar mogvewoneba mtavroba da ase unda vamxot yovel 4 weliwadshi eretxel?
natiaaa 4 years ago
sasacilo kaci xar ra gogolazem swori gitxra
vinaa bicho giorgagamsaxurdiaa kaci??? mamaisis mkvlel rejims rom sheekra da gazaglda?? shen zmao qartveli xar ki? tbilisi gaizarde tu chuchmeketshi a? ra faseulobebit vcxovrob erti gagvagebine!
tvistomi 4 years ago
ara, koko gamsaxurdiaa kaci, mxedrionis tetri lentit ro damariazhobda anda Cotne, rusebis xelzemosamsaxure nabichvari) Giorgi kacia da kacurad moikca, misi zmebi arian nagvebi:)erti "Konstantine-Khachika" da meore "Cotne-Vasia"
geus1 4 years ago
geus1 gaige zmao ra giorga pavlikaa marozovi ...kacurad shexede tuzma xar..shenc mase moiqceodi to?
tvistomi 4 years ago
YES!!!!!! kremlis nagavebo da patarkacishvilis naxlebnikebo-"Chemodan, Vokzal, Rossia!!!!
Gaumarjos tavisupal, zlier, gacmendil, dezinpicirebul SAQARTVELOS!!!!
geus1 4 years ago
ty predstavliaesh; 100000 kotorye protestovali s chamodanami v Rossiu. Tem bolee vas ne samoletnogo soobshchenia. Pozhaluista ostavaites; na meste a to vy pol;zuetes; aeroportom Yerevana. Eshcho i tseny podnimete na nashi aviareisy v Moskvu
arakhachatran 4 years ago
nichego, dopolzut. Zhidenka usatogo svoego poprosyat, on im svoi transport videlit:)
geus1 4 years ago
Usatyi im dast den;gi, tol;ko eto podnimet spros na samolet Yerevan Moskva. POzhaluista pol;zuites; marshrutom chemodan vokzal batumi konstantinopol'. Etim marshrutom v 20 gody vospolzovalis dedy Salome Zurabichvili.
arakhachatran 4 years ago
navernoe tebe kto to kogda to govoril chemodan vokzal izrail no ty okazalsya gde to eshcho i pizdish ne po teme. A vse vy mechtali by o chemodane vokzale ROssii. Tol;ko zabyl chto pered vokzalom est; eshcho viza kotoraia dlya vas mechta
arakhachatran 4 years ago
chemodan , vokzal, ijevan, khachik:) soti raz govoriu, ya ne evrei, i ne zhid,. zhid-patarkacishvili i ego zhopozicia, xyindravkin s kompaniei i izhe s nimi. Naxui mne tvoi zasrani aeroport Yerevana ne nuzhen, Ya v Moskvu na zadania ne letaiu:)
geus1 4 years ago
chemodan vokzal ijevan byl marshrut Gamsakhurdia esli xorosho pomnish'. My tam vstretili ego kogda Azerbaijan otkazal ego v ubezhishche. Kstati ya sprosil v drugom forume o proisxozhdenii Khaindrava. Zdes; est; telemost ImediTV s Markovym gde Ivlian imeet takoi nos i tak kartavit, tak kartativit..
arakhachatran 4 years ago
vaa
xalxi raebsa cers to
gagijeba sheizleba
gavartki patarkacishvilsac da mishasac
sakme asea:
orives vkidivart da chven tavze dadian
xoda ertmac gaasxas da meoremac sakartvelodan
utmelidze 4 years ago
martali xar...
nAvigAciA 4 years ago
Bravooooooo!!!! mag oligarhebis da banditebis "televizia" didihania dasahuri iho!
gnikoladze 4 years ago
Eee, samarcxwino ara isa kide. Patarkacishvilma rusetis gadaxdil fulebse kargad wer iprostituta ai dardi.
ikogeo 4 years ago
uime, martla ra samarcxvinoa :((
guli mwydeba saqartveloze...
nAvigAciA 4 years ago
shen sheni tavis upro metad unda shegchves!
gnikoladze 4 years ago
vitom ME ratom?!
nAvigAciA 4 years ago
aba, aba, kremlistivi erti adgilis micema da rusebis elchebtan konsultacieze sirbilisamarcxvino araa! gansakutrebit aset dros, roca realuri imedai teritorialuri mtlianobis aghdgenis da qveynis saxelmcipod gadaqcevis! Gavartyi "zhopozicias" da yvela Badrijans!!! Mcvane shuqi, Misha! Dahka magat!!!
geus1 4 years ago
100% martali har
gnikoladze 4 years ago
samarcxvinoooa...arnaxuli umsgavsooobaa...fuf
Tamu0Geo 4 years ago
sacklebi:))))) Bargis chalagebashi xom ar mogexmarot rom shtatebidan gaajvat? Chemodan, Vokzal, Rossia!!!!
geus1 4 years ago
malen;kiy zhidenok??? Do six por pomnish; slova ob Izraile??? POchemu v profile ne pisesh; otkuda pizdish'. Legko da gde to sidet; i ukazyvat; kto dolzhen poexat; kuda. Kike
arakhachatran 4 years ago
khachik mnogo budish pizdet, zarabotaesh gemoroi. Vi vsiu zhizn rusakam zhopu lizali tak i prodolzhaite:) A zhidi-tvoi mama s papoi i finansist zhopozicii:) poimali tvoego dashnak-krunka s kokoshkoi-zasrancem i ottraxali kak sleduet. budete pizdet, eshe poluchite:)
geus1 4 years ago
Pro finansista zhopozitsii nikto ne somnevaettsa. Tol;ko vot finansist pozitsii tozhe zhidenok. Interesno chem eto Soros ne ugodil Badri. Mozhet odin respublicanets(sudya po tomu chto prodaet svoe imushchestvo FOXu) a Soros Democrat. Vot nashli oni pole bitvy- Gruziu
arakhachatran 4 years ago