Garbage - Witness to Your Love

[KR3259]

Andrea you are the best ! Thanx for finding and posting all this good stuff, see ya on the garbage FB page ;)

[marknaki123]

i just listened to this song for the first time..the chorus is amazing....im sooo excited for the new record

[Soulsearcher1able]

<3 them forever :)

[AtmaGyan]

Sounds a bit like their old stuff... thanks for uploading & for the link! :)

[gabolpz]

Me encanta esta cancion... espero que regresen pronto con un nuevo albúm

[blankpods]

love you Shirley :D

[richhawk123]

Who are you really andrea111292 ? And how did you come by all this Garbage? Ha Ha

Love it all Thank you so much!

[Fairrrytale]

I miss Garbage! Been a fan for 12 years and only seen them live once (for which I am more than grateful!) I'm longing for a new stellar album and a tour!

[Raverine1013]

Man this song is awesome!! Thanks for uploading! :D

[citizenkong]

She is so beautiful.

[kittykatt4211]

I love her songs...she is awsome..

[MrPussystroker]

wow nice song thanks for uploading

[lecnb]

This was a charity track for the Pablove Foundation :P Rumors have it that they're hitting the studio, but nothings certain.

[6aokan]

there is a new album after absolute garbage?

[OneWingedAngel1025]

andrea your awesome because...

1: you've got ALOT of Garbage songs you put up on youtube

2: you've got awesome pics of the band especially Shirley and...

3: you made it so we can download this song

thanks soo much!! ^_^

[andrea111292]

@OneWingedAngel1025 Thank you so very much! =D

[Andreasleon27]

i miss shirley are they doing a comeback?

[tsadyan00]

are they still a band or did they broke up?

[barolito]

Thank you so much for this one.

I can't wait for the new album.

:)

[TroyBilt007]

When did this albumn come out????

[andrea111292]

October 2008

[jtarantula3390]

this is epic, big, amazing

[MrNiceGuy1996]

I first heard this song today and i loved it right away. This is one of the Garbage songs. Now i'm listening to it over and over again because it's so awesome :)

[andrea111292]

Thanks for listening to it on my channel! Take a look at the acoustic version that Shirley performed in november 2009 too! It's a response under this video!

[blueunikornz]

very good song! As usual, Garbage makes the best music!!

[Adirial]

when did this song come out?

[andrea111292]

October 2008!

[TheRabidfan]

andrea111292 you seem to be an authority on Garbage. Did an album come out in 2008 that I didn't know about? Or is this from Shirleys unreleased solo album? Did Garbage tour for it/Are they touring? The things i would do to see them play live. I slept through my chances to see them back in the day, much to my regret... This as an awesome song.

[andrea111292]

No sorry...none of these is true. This song was released on a charity album for the PabLOVE foundation in 2008. Since then Shirley & Butch performed this song and Life On Mars in November 2009 in Avalon (still for PabLOVE foundation!). Check the performances on youtube or on my channel! =D

[AngelDisguise09]

hi man great job XD luv this song n garbage n SHIRLEY! <3

[telidaros]

it's so sad.finally i listened to her in a new song though.

[ahenderson25]

why does this song cut off at the end?

[andrea111292]

It's supposed to be like that

[ahenderson25]

lol, its cool how u know everything about garbage. if i have any questions, i'll be sure to ask you first

[andrea111292]

Thanks eheh! =D

[herssoncruz94]

wow this song make me feel so young............and im only 15 yrs old lol it must do wonders for all the old ppl lol

[voutespancar]

I love her small tits

[63thejack]

@voutespancar

be careful! i am a french jealous guy!!! lol ;-)

[jtarantula3390]

This song is so damn beautiful. LOVE IT, inspiring, yet sad, gorgeous, epic!!!!!!!!!!

[testamen100]

temazzzzzo¡¡¡¡

[jambridge]

Is there anywhere I can still buy this?! The link from Shirley's facebook to buy it doesn't seem to work for me.... Considering this track is for charity I would prefer to buy it than download it for free... BUT WHERE????

[andrea111292]

I think it's hard ...and so sorry to say that the kid of Pablove Foundation just died some days ago...condolences for that poor kid that should have had a little of hope with the money of Give.Listen.Help ..

[Dinolovinn]

the memorial was beautiful Pablo was a great little boy I'm happy to have known him when this song came on almost everyone in the audience burst into tears one of the most memorable songs in my life

[bickly777]

Shirley sounds amazing

[andrea111292]

This is on the charity compilation Give.Listen.Help :)

[SophiesInsanity]

Ahh awesome.

Someone said it was selling at UrbanOutfitters, was this a long time ago?

xxx

[andrea111292]

Oh well they started selling it in October 2008 who knows if you could still found it : /

[elkartian]

i really take offence at people copying this track for people ,even shirley said everyone should buy this as the money is for a childrens cancer cause i bought mine and it arrived from usa last week.i hate the freeloaders and the so called fans who send then to people cheating shirley mansons work

[andrea111292]

She posted this track on her facebook page , everyone can listen to it for free and also download it so easily for free. I don't understand why I should be guilty just because I like people to try music . Trust me , I love buying music and also I want other people to buy music. I'm not the guy you should say those things to .

[nodoubtgarbagehole]

the last portrait is the best!

[MyTrophySpace]

I love it! Where can I get the track?

[andrea111292]

I may email it to you

[elkartian]

how dare u email free versions of this song ,you certainly are not a garbage fan cheating kids out of their cancer charity money .shirley herself requested in an interview that every1 should by this and not copy it

[andrea111292]

I can't fly to America and try to find this album , sorry . They chose not to sell it in Italy , what can I do? But somehow I agree with you . It's just that I try and want other people to try , and then I buy it and eventually , I hope that someone goes and buys it after he'd listened something I posted here on youtube or sent through email.

[uekassei]

not everyone can afford to buy albums.

should we not be allowed to listen to music if we don't have the money to pay for it? i'm pretty sure that djs play music on the radio, all day, everday.

should we be charged for that, too?

[uekassei]

music isn't only for the rich.

[elkartian]

i am unemployed, it is about intergrity and honesty i never download anything and think of the artists.i only bought this charity cd last week from pablove links on the garbage site i did not have to go to the usa they have a europe and a usa paypal basket ,some fans dont care as long as they can get the music for free,yes shirley posted it on facebook for you to listen to it ,not an offer to download it or send it by email for free,listening is not a problem its the free emailing i object too

[andrea111292]

I get your point and well I partially agree.

If someone wants this mp3 , it can be found on emule , on torrent and eventually on facebook so easily . So if I send it to someone by mail it's not that big of a crime.

[elkartian]

true,not that big a crime, they can listen here for free as you can on shirleys facebook but she has a link to buy it , if you want to own it .i would rather tell them they can buy from pablove and 90% of the money goes to funding childrens cancer which i think is an awsome cause. i am sure the recievers of free emails will just burn it onto a cd and pay nothing , who am i to be concerned as a true fan i support what Shirley wished for,that was ''if u liked the song buy it do not download it''

[ScienceProjek]

I Love This Song

[gat1982]

5 stars...

[emmabury]

Where could I download this song?

[andrea111292]

Emule . Or I could send it to you through email

[pinyluvr]

does anyone have the link to d-load the track by any chance?

[andrea111292]

I could email it to you

[RocknCorruptrepublic]

Mission Accomplished! I've been trying to catch her making a grammatical error for months! I think other than that her grammar is perfect. But there you go haha

[RocknCorruptrepublic]

About the "Was we ever...." thing, she also says "where we was entwined" in Kick My Ass.

[andrea111292]

I know this too . But to me no prob. The more the song is against the grammar , the more I love it!

[ChathamFr0]

It certainly has to do with her accent/language. I wouldn't really call it a grammatical error, as I would a difference in language.

[RocknCorruptrepublic]

Regional colloquial language perhaps.

[karatefoo]

I miss their old energetic songs :(

Girl Don't Come

Queer

I Think I'm Paranoid

Push It

Supervixen...

[andrea111292]

You can name the whole first two albums ... and also some songs of BG and BLM...

[miguelKzAr]

The "Was we ever so young?" discussion is a good one.. but it's not the first time that i listen to "english" people say this... and i live in England, about the song: catchy, fresh but.. in the end i like it :)

[blueshirt12]

she's scottish, not english

[miguelKzAr]

I perfectly know she is scottish... :) i was saying as in "english" / UK language and the way that is spoken

[bld1555]

fucken hot

as per usual!!

[TheKinkyShrink]

This has grown on me.....

[HakoTheMonkey]

What a beautiful song...I always loved Garbage, they're just incredible...

[andrea111292]

Anch io :D

[TheKinkyShrink]

Was we ever so young?

Grammar!!!

[andrea111292]

Yeah ,grammar!

You are english , could u enlighten me about this ? Cause I don't know what it means ! :D

[TheKinkyShrink]

She should've said 'were we ever so young'... :P

[SophiesInsanity]

Haha I noticed that but I like the way that it is 'was we ever so young' it sound better x

[wormvortex]

getting a bit too generic poppy for my liking.

[noelliamjohn]

canzone fantastica (come sempre per i grandissimi Garbage) ma cacchio quando un nuovo album???

[andrea111292]

Magari nel 2009 ??

Mi fa piacere di vedere un altro fan italiano!

[UNiV3RSE]

e qui ce n'è ancora un altro :°D non la conoscevo proprio sta canzone... ma è proprio così o non è completa? ?___?

[andrea111292]

Piacere!

Bene , questa canzone è molto probabilmente una di quelle scartate dalle sessioni di bleed like me , con la differenza che questa l' hanno rilasciata su una compilation per la beneficenza.

E per essere una canzone scartata secondo me è anche molto bella...

[Schneebuddy]

I love the way Shirley belts out a tune, always exactly on key, simply a wonderful example of her talent. Singing softly then exploding into a melody, brilliant.

[dspikey]

they are my favorite band but I must say this is sounding a bit generic, needs a bit more.....kick its over produced

[CocaineHabbit]

don't worry, its not new material but an unused track from the "bleed like me" sessions. butch vig said he'd like the next album to be much more stripped down.

[jordyxxxjordy]

Shirley was doing some radio interviews after she joined the cast of The Sarah Connor Chronicles, and in at least one of them, she said the band did indeed get together to record this track in 2008.

[andrea111292]

Well !

It's positive to me! Maybe they enjoyed that little and brief comeback ?

[rossodinotte]

garbage vi amo!punto.

[andrea111292]

Gia, non finiscono di sorprendere

[brantheman216]

Don't worry, hun, I loves me this song :-D

[subhuman78]

The feel of this song reminds me of 'Perfect' by the Smashing Pumpkins...

Kinda feels like a great band losing its way...

[andrea111292]

losing its way ???

It doesn't seem so . This song has been written and recorded in little time , not to be single or on a garbage album .This is not garbage . This is A charity song of garbage.

And I love it as a charity and simple song.

Could u think of an ultra powerful song like vow as a charity song??

[idanilolaranjeira]

Musica muito diferente do estilo da banda =/

[andrea111292]

But still awesome!

[idanilolaranjeira]

i agree you. The sound is diferente but garbage is a great group,definitely. I love them, girl.

=]

[nodoubtgarbagehole]

oh my God, thanks you! Beauty & Wise Shirley

[mrkfitz]

thanx 4 the lyrics!!! 5 Stars

[andrea111292]

Thanks ^^

[puacino]

Però mi piace! Poi le due foto di Shirley dal min 2'56' mi fanno impazzire!

[andrea111292]

Si vabbe...l ultima poi e classica :D

Se ne sarà accorta mentre si vestiva??

[puacino]

Forse l'ha fatto apposta! ;-D

[andrea111292]

Mah ...cio ke e sicuro e ke non indossa MAI il reggiseno :D

[puacino]

Vero! Mhmmmmm... ;-D

[andrea111292]

Mai visto il famoso video di stupid girl??

[puacino]

Sì perchè?

[andrea111292]

Io intendo il famoso live ...non il video ufficiale.

[puacino]

No... quale?

[andrea111292]

quello dove le esce la tetta da fuori !

[puacino]

Ah! c'è anche qui su youtube, quello che dura pochi secondi? Sì l'ho visto. L'avevo anche scaricato tempo fa!

[andrea111292]

No guarda l hai detto anke tu ! Quello dura pochi secondi e poi e anke in bassa risoluzione e non coglie la scena giusta.

Il video lungo e stato rimosso non so xke U_U

[puacino]

Ah allora non l'ho mai visto. Cmq il perchè sia stato rimosso puoi immaginarlo ;-D

[andrea111292]

No non posso ,visto ke ce ne stanno tanti di video come quello e uno l hai messo anche tu su paola e chiara XD

Credo ke sia stato cancellato l'account dell uploader

[puacino]

Può essere.

[mintyxox]

new song?

what about shirley's solo album???

[andrea111292]

This is garbage.This has nothing to do with shirley 's new album so!

About her album...who knows? It s quite ready to be released ...

[gat1982]

i like...

[cebene]

this song transmits a powerful melancholic feeling, it's very special...

[Placebo59200]

Reformez le groupe svp svp svp svp Garbage nous manque beaucoup trop !!!!! On vous aime, ne nous laissez pas, ne nous abandonnez pas !!!! Vos fans qui vous aiment !!!!

[whydoyouloveme21]

it's perfect! a perfect return, but is just a song! shit! shirley come back soon!

it's true! this song makes me cry, i don't know...

[andrea111292]

agreed!Perfect return !

[4352297]

from what album is this?

just curious..:D

[andrea111292]

I don't remember the title...it's a new album which sales are devolved to charity...

[subhuman78]

It's called "Give. Listen. Help. Volume 5"

[andrea111292]

Right

[Lanedude08]

I don't know why, but every time almost feel like shedding a tear every time I hear this song. It's not normally a song I would shed a tear on or anyone would. It's weird, and feels sort of good, to.

[andrea111292]

It's because it remembers u of something , i think!

[Lanedude08]

Probably my childhood. Whatever it is, it still shows Shirley and the boys still have got it!

[grbgrockme]

thanks andrea! i was thinking in find the lyrics someday, but instead, you put them there!

Amazing!!!!!

[andrea111292]

Thanks ;D

[KalikaInLeather]

oh ok so this si the new song, I thought it was just one that I had never heard of before... thx for havin put it.

It reminds me of run baby run, coz someone did a vid with this song for th movie christiane f, and this song has the same kind of feeling. Could easily go in such a movie (in my opinion)...

[andrea111292]

In my opinion , every song of garbage could easily go in some movies.

:D

[thisislyon]

M..

Fabulous.

LYON

LLYONL

[nodoubtem456]

This song is so pretty!

[hugozal]

Great! Thanks for posting this song. I love it :D

[andrea111292]

Thank you for watching\rating\commenting and obviously it's amazing that so much persons love her!

[Auxiamber]

Another great song!!! :D Garbage 4EVER!!!

i love shirley! <333

[andrea111292]

Yeaaaaaaaaah!!!!!

[carlosmb16]

Amazing!

I need the lyrics !!!!

would you post a link or the lyrics pls? :$

[andrea111292]

Lyrics inserted!

[carlosmb16]

Thank youuu !!!!!!!!! :)

miL GRACIASSSS!

[acapuroviento]

Ahhhhh

she's so fucking great!!

[andrea111292]

Amazing !!!!

[joker66k]

I love this song!

[andrea111292]

My favorite song!! ^^

[FabianL2007]

So great to hear a new song from GARBAGE!!

Shirley's voice sounds awesome.

[doremi5002]

great new song from garbage

thank you fabian for sharing it

lilly

[andrea111292]

Oh!So thanks Fabian for sharing my video!

[Erycolacerta]

nice to see some new garbage, I can't wait for a new album!

[kurtisit85]

bravo magari lo ordini, io ho visto che a salerno c'è ancora :) no non lo trovo giusto neanche io ma i garbage non è che poi si facciano tanta pubblicità, ci ho messo mesi per reperire il dvd

[andrea111292]

Vabbe quando vado a Paestum mi faccio un giro a Salerno :D

[kurtisit85]

neanche se lo paghi alla consegna?

beh su quello anche io appena mi sarò sistemato reperirò tutte le rarità

[andrea111292]

U_U vallo a dire tu ai miei genitori...

Cmq lo cerchero dappertutto!! Ce l ho fatta con gli altri album! E poi cavolo vendono quegli orrendi cd, e non vendono un CD ke ha venduto 2 milioni di copie??? Secondo te e giusto ke la musica debba fare questa fine??

[kurtisit85]

possibile? ordinalo da internet allora :)

[andrea111292]

gia ci ho pensato.

Ma mio padre non vuole U_U

Quando saro maggiorenne e lavorero comprero tutti i singoli e le edizioni speciali.

[kurtisit85]

Certo, ho tutti i loro album, il dvd (quanto ho faticato per reperirlo) e la limited edition di beautifulgarbage, quella occupa il posto d'onore in casa mia. Per quanto riguarda bleed like me, mi fiondai alla ricordi a salerno mezz'ora prima che aprisse per essere uno dei primi ad acquistarlo :)

[andrea111292]

Io non lo trovo a Napoli! U_U Mi manca solo quello!!

[kurtisit85]

Andrea caro lo spero perchè i garbage sono la mia ragione di vita, da quando li ho conosciuti ho apprezzato la vera musica e come si dice il primo amore non si scorda mai, quel meraviglioso settembre 2001 che bei momenti quelli

[andrea111292]

Io ho iniziato da marzo 2007,un po piu tardi ...XD

Hai anche bleed like me originale?

[kurtisit85]

Lo so che è contenuta in una compilation però resta il fatto che sono ben lontani dal sound che mi ha fatto innamorare di loro. Io spero tanto che si riprendano non possono farmi questo io vivo per loro. Non so se ti conviene venire a leggere i commenti lasciati sul forum, finora non sono positivi.

[andrea111292]

Dai ti ho detto che e una canzone di poco conto!

Neanche un b-side!

Scommetto che ti sorprenderanno con un nuovo album! Quando mai non l hanno fatto?

[kurtisit85]

deluso, profondamente deluso.

These are not the Garbage that I love or loved?

[andrea111292]

Questa e solo una canzone che hanno fatto insieme ma non e stata mai messa su nessun album o singolo. Secondo me e adorabile.

Ascoltandola piu volte l ho trovata stupenda!

[KeaneQueen11981]

I them I wish they would put out a new ablum already

[andrea111292]

Everyone does!

[doumora]

I´m tired of this hiatus...

please, come back!!!

:(

[KeaneQueen11981]

I agree whwere the fuck are they?

[andrea111292]

Shirley s acting in sarah connor, duke s in Madison...

I would like they come back together!!!!

[scrashtrash]

wow! sounds so happy i love it :D