Kouchesar-e Shab (1) - Lotfi

[ShorYuReppa1]

aghar cheh shabhaseeyas javabe eshgh nasezas golamon gharghekhoneh khar to khonehpor riyas khoda yareasheghas navash tapeshedelhast khorshidkhanom toyerasbadelamon hamnavas bezan dobare labkhandbahamm bebandimpeymanrogholeye damavand kayirane sarboland bekhake paketsogandbe eshghet hastim pabandin khonehbeheshte mas

[cemasettin]

Anlamiyorum ama müzile sözler bana alacagim duyguyu veriyor

[rvgraph]

Kouchesare Shab

[dn32844]

@puku1018

Would you be dissent enough to elaborate about your message to me? Just tell me whom do you think my comment was towards, and then Ill give an answer in kind to your message.

[dn32844]

همه جا باید یه سر خر داشته باشیم. آخه بتو چه مرتیکه.

[puku1018]

you are out of your mind, you absolutely ignorant and truly out of touch to write such unfair comment shame on you !

[Simajooon]

khely hal mikonam dar in gorbat vaa tanhaei-

[dn32844]

سیماجون

کجائی؟ آمریکا یا اروپا؟ اگر در امریکائ کدام ایالت هستی‌؟

[abadancalifornia]

تو هم دلت خوشه،،تو این وسط دنبال چی‌ میگردی!!!

[layal7]

can any one explain what he is saying pls??

[Tadjik83]

bei dieser music braucht man keine schlafmittel mehr .....

[espug]

what is this main theme?

could someone tell?

[azeryny]

it is obvious that neither one of you is listening to the music

[CaspiansC]

Leave politics alone. Get it!

It is all music here..

[SHAHIN1357]

man ham ba hamsab kamelan movafegham. Lotfi mazhare yek motrebe khodforookhtaye fased ast ke tar ra be ghole ostad Jalile Shanaz tar ra tanbih mikoneh! lanat bar navazendaye darbare Khamenei!

[yeye368]

hi, what u mean his a motrebe. could u explan more? thanks

[khokh79]

nik mok ya li houdi vive islam

[Needee9]

sorry is master loitf a darvish sufi??

[azeryny]

you can count them on your left hand, therefore based on chance - most likely not

[niloomhh]

kheiylii ghashang bod mamnon

[awyar1]

baghan ostad hastand omid varam iranian be hamchin honarmandani khad mat konan va ghadreshon ro bedanan ba sepas az ostadane honar ke farhange iraniro por rnag kardan

[hamsab]

THE PROBLEM IS THAT YOU ARE NOT A MUSICIAN AND CERTAINLY HAVE NO KNWOLEGE OF THE REAL ART OF TAR PLAYING! lOTFI IS THE WORSE TAR PLAYER IRAN HAS EVER WITNESSED! HE WAS A NOCHEH!OF MR EBTEHAJ AND IT WAS HIM WHO BROUGHT LOTFI TO RADIO AND TV DURING SHAH S TIME, WHAT HE PLAYS IS NOT A TAR PALYING STYLE IT IS RATHER KHORASANI TAMBOOR, HIS MEZRAB PLAYINGS ARE FULL OF MISTAKES, HE IS JUST PLAYING LIKE A PRIMARY STUDENT AT HONARESTANE MUSISIGHI! HE IS JUST A CHARLATAN HE CAN NOT READ OR WRITE MUSIC.

[tehranprint]

hatman to navazandeh hasty valy az in tarifet malome mosighi nemidoni nazar dar morede Ostda lotfi ham ejbari nest kasi ham be harfet ahamiat nemideh

on mosbat ham man eshetbahi zadam.

[Diganiga]

whats a good tar or setar artist i can listen to? i like vocals too.

[setarehira]

what is it to do with being a muslim? lotfi is a great tar player, do u think u r a good muslim that u talk this way about an master! and anyway who are u? r u a musician, that ur saying all these, if u say lotfi is a bad tar player then u dont even understand what music is.

[sohaihstar]

Hamsaab I do agree with you. I am musician and have been a pupil of Ostad Ali Akbar Khan Shanazi. He hated Lotfi. He is a lousy begger who only knows the direction of wind, A true opportunist!he has many RAPE CHARGES IN LONDON AND ROME. now he is the motreb of Khamenei by his manghal and bafoor! Shame on this corrupt man!

[kambizz1]

Draging someone's name in mud is not in persian culture. Ostad Shahanazi would never say such remarks. I respect your background as a musician and I respectfully think you made poor choices of words about your fellow "Hamvatan" regargless of music tast. With respect

[Booysooz]

Ebtehaj is indeed the Hafez of our time. I htink many of his peoms are even more beautifull than Hafes'.

[m4rtike]

ebtehaj,,,,,hafez in gharn

[tehranprint]

Ostad lotfi yeki az bozorgane mosighie irani hast kasi ke noavari kard va dorod bar ou bad

dar zemn aslan mojahed nabodeh.

[lovepersianmusic]

معلوم است که نوازنده نیستید.لطفی نه استاد است و نه نوآور اتفاقا در موسیقی یک مرتجع است که با هرچیزی به جز ردیف میرزاعبداله مخالف است او ننگی است بر دامن موسیقی است یک توده ای سابق و خالا هم نوکر و پامنقلی خامنه ایو خدا شر این مردفاسد را از سر موسیقی کم کند

[tehranprint]

aval shoma khafesho chon shoma ha joz bi ehterami chi zi nemidind age shoma navazandeiin tarze harf zadan nest hala Ostad LOtfi harchi bode ke hamash shaye e hast hala age on nange mosighea irani hast chera serchesh kardi.

shoma boro konet to bedi behtare ta ehzare nazar koni

man az baghie dostan mazerat mikham

man ro bebakhshid chon javabe in adama robayad injory dad.

[kermanshaah]

دوستان بهتر است رعایت نزاکت هنر را بفرمایید. شما هم جناب بهمن رحیمیان چرا اینقدر شلاق را بر سر فلان سازمان میکوبید!لطف فرموده اندر جنایاتی که ملایان بر سر هنرمندان میهنمان آورده اند انتقاد کوچکی هم که شده اظهار بفرمایید و مرزتان را با رژیم هنرکش روشن بفرمایید! موفق باشید

[enayatm]

A lot of people here are having a go at Master Lotfi.

I hope you guys at least respect and believe Master Hormozi (or you are going to deny he was a master too?)

Please see my video post and listen to what Master Hormozi says about Ostad Lotfi.

It is coming out of Master Hormzi's mouth so I rest my case and let the viewers judge for themselves.

[bahmanrahimiyan]

Bia, inam aksol amale Mojahedan. Ta ye nafar oona ro mibare zire soal mishe mozdore regime Iran.

Man az regime akhona motanaferam amma dar eyne hal oona ro ve vatan foroshane mojahed mesle Masoud va Maryam Rajavie 1000 bar tejih midam.

Be Lotfi har che bechasbeh mozdori nemichasbeh. Ino hame shagerdash midoonan.

To khodet chi baret hast? Mitooni yeki az karhaye sadeh Lotfio bezani ke zer mizani?

[morningvictoire]

bahmanrahimiyan مردک حقیر کم مایه تو را همان بس که منطق نداری و بیسوادی اگر نوازنده بودی که این چنین وقیحانه گستاخی نمیکردی! ضمن اینکه معلوم شد از مزدوران و شکنجه گران کثیف وزارت خونخوار آخوندی هستی وبا لطفی ملعون مزدور! از یک آخور ملاها تغذیه میشوی! ننگ بر تو مزدور آخوندها

[bahmanrahimiyan]

Man PhD daram. To chi dari joojeh mojahed?

[bahmanrahimiyan]

morningvictoire

By the way, this Video was recorded in Germany you ignorant person.

You know nothing.

[lovepersianmusic]

دوستان اجازه بفرمایید بنده به عنوان خلیفه کلاس استادعلی اکبرخان شهنازی این مساله را روشن کنم که متاسفانه آقای لطفی هرگز به عنوان یک شاگرد خوب کلاس محسوب نمیشد و از این نظر استادان از ایشان ناراضی بودند.مضراب آقای لطفی بسیار ضعیف و قدرت بداهه نوازیشان فوق العاده کم مایه بود

[bahmanrahimiyan]

lovepersianmusic

Chera harfe moft mizanid. Tamame assatide Iran Lotfio gabool daran.

In hame asar az Ostad Lotfi va digar asaatid hast.

Aslan shoma ki hastin ke khalifeh kelase Ostad shahnazi boodeh bashid?

Shoma chand asare be ja mandani be moosighi Iran ehda kardid jenabe khalifeh? Hichi

Faghat neshastid ke zere ziyadi bezani.

[hejran1]

سلام به همه دوستان من یک موسیقی دان هستم کسانی که میگن آقای لطفی نوازنده خوبی نیست به نظر من باموسیقی آشنایی ندارند. و خیلی ها هم چون لطفی در ایران است به او بی احترامی میکنند.اگرلطفی یک فراری از ایران میبود او استادبودی. بی احترامی به لطفی بی احترامی به موسیقی اصیل است.

[lovepersianmusic]

دوستان اجازه بفرمایید بنده به عنوان خلیفه کلاس استادعلی اکبرخان شهنازی این مساله را روشن کنم که متاسفانه آقای لطفی هرگز به عنوان یک شاگرد خوب کلاس محسوب نمیشد و از این نظر استادان از ایشان ناراضی بودند.مضراب آقای لطفی بسیار ضعیف و قدرت بداهه نوازیشان فوق العاده کم مایه بود

[bahmanrahimiyan]

lovepersianmusic

.مضراب آقای لطفی بسیار ضعیف و قدرت بداهه نوازیشان فوق العاده کم مایه بود

Pas vase ine ke tamoome Iran Lotfio mishnasand amma to poshte ID = lovepersianmusic gayem mishio faghat zere ziyadi mizani.

Ageh mardi ye tike az tareto to youtube post kon va az mardom bekhah ke comment bedan.

In az to Mojahede badbakht bar nemiyad chon boz delin o jorat nadarin khodetoono neshoon bedin.

[morningvictoire]

مردک حقیر کم مایه تو را همان بس که منطق نداری و بیسوادی اگر نوازنده بودی که این چنین وقیحانه گستاخی نمیکردی! ضمن اینکه معلوم شد از مزدوران و شکنجه گران کثیف وزارت خونخوار آخوندی هستی وبا لطفی ملعون مزدور! از یک آخور ملاها تغذیه میشوی! ننگ بر تو مزدور آخوندها!

[bahmanrahimiyan]

Bia, inam aksol amale Mojahedan. Ta ye nafar oona ro mibare zire soal mishe mozdore regime Iran.

Man az regime akhona motanaferam amma dar eyne hal oona ro ve vatan foroshane mojahed mesle Masoud va Maryam Rajavie 1000 bar tejih midam.

Be Lotfi har che bechasbeh mozdori nemichasbeh. Ino hame shagerdash midoonan.

To khodet chi baret hast? Mitooni yeki az karhaye sadeh Lotfio bezani ke zer mizani?

[bahmanrahimiyan]

hejran1

Shoma dorost mifarmaid. Man ID ina ro to site haye Mojahedi didam. Ina to kalashoon rafte ke chon Lotfi Rish dareh hezbollahie.

Aslan Mosighi be siasat che rabti dareh?

Man migham ageh mikham be ostadi towhin konam bayad aghalan 50% az savad o tavanaye oono dashteh basham ke baraue mezrab o bedahash irad bgiram. na?

[sohaihstar]

ای بیچاره لطفی کی ملت ایران از شر آدمهای پلیدی مثل تو و علیزاده و ناظری خلاص خواهند شد> شماها مزدوران خودفروخته ای هستید که در بارگاه خامنه ای جنایتکاران و پای منقل این آدمخواران حرمت سازها را سر میبرید. ننگتان باد!

[bahmanrahimiyan]

sohaihstar

Tamoome Iran midoonan ke Lotfi o Alizadeh az avabeghe moosighie Iran hastand.

Ina dar oon fazaye basteh sai mikonan ke mosighio zendeh nigah daran.

Az koja mighin ina khod foroshan? Hala Har ki to Iran zendeghi mikoneh khod foroshe?

Pas mighin chikar konan? Mesle shoma mohjahedine be Aragh Farar konan?

Ya vaseh Masoud o Maryam Rajavie johar lag ahang besazan?

Khod forosh kieh?

Ageh ina vase khamanehi mizadan kheili vazeshon az in behtar bood

[morningvictoire]

bahmanrahimiyan you are an ignorant idiot fan of a criminal called LOTFI! enjoy this cheap music! You only deserve this kind of mollah pasand music! Shame on you mozdoore regime!

[bahmanrahimiyan]

morningvictoire

Mr or Ms Idiot first of all I have a news flash for you. Not everyone who dislikes Mojahedin are a mullah parast and regime's pupet.

I just hate Mojahedin because they sold their countrymen out and went and kissed ass from Saddam. They killed their own countrymen for Saddam. How is that for being a mozdor?

Lotfi che crimi anjam dadeh? Hala digeh dari khial bafi mikonid?

[Dellavari]

Ei azadiran ta key Tohmat be in o an zadan

4e netighei migiri Aslan Heife Vaght ke ba adame Nafahmi mesle To Sohbat Kardan???

Dorud Be Hame Honarmandane Asheghe Iran Zamin Nabud bad Tafraghe Afkanan.

[nimaah]

honare ostad lotfi natanha dar technic balke dar sadegee va letafate ghet e ye entekhabeeyash meebashad

[azadiran]

گر موسیقی میدانستی میفهیدی لطقی نوازنده ضعیفی است. مضرابش غلط است . هرگز برای یک اثری مثل هزاران قطعه ای که شهناز نواخته نزده ومیفرمود لطفی بجای اینکه تار را بنوازد انرا میزند یعنی تنبیه میکند شان لطفی همین که نوکر خامنه ای شده و پای منقلش تار را میزند

[bahmanrahimiyan]

azadiran Ageh to mosighi midoonesti mifahmidi ke Lotfi v Shahnaz styleshoon fargh mikoneh.

Bezar barat sadeh begham. Baazi az adama mesle to Mojahede khianatkar be vataneshoonan vali baazia vatan parastan. Baazia Taro ba narmesh mizanan, baazia ba selabat.

Ostad Shahnaz Tar ro zoghi mizanan va Radif kar nemikonan.

Ostad Lotfi shagerdan Radif va assatid Hormozi, Shahnazi, Boromand, davami ..hastan

In khodesh baese tafavote sabk mishe. Pas Lotfan boro ye chizi yad begir baad zer bezan

[morningvictoire]

U shut your dirty mouth SOB!

[bahmanrahimiyan]

SOB?

Man dirt mouth hastam ya to mojahede vatan forosh?

Ki raft Aragh be Iran hamleh kard o sarbazaye bi gonaho kosht vase Saddame khonkhar?

Ki zede melatesh aslahe gereft?

Khejalat nemikeshin? Hala gir dadin be Lotfi?

Dastetoon be khar nemreseh paloono tekoon midin badbakhta?

[jarem81]

we have to respect ostad lotfi.He is a gift for our world!!!!!

Ablahahan do not understand this way of expression.Thatswhy they search themselves.

mowafqh basheed

[jeffman3003]

javabe ablahan khamoosheest

[zemestaneh]

ostad lotfi navazandaye binazire tar mibashad va ashkase bisavad nemtunan dark konand ke ostad lotfi chi mizane. faghat kafie raste panjgahe lotfi ba shajarian va hamchenin concerte abu ataa ra goosh konid ta bebinid ostad lotfi kist.

[samooel7]

man nadidam kesi be andazeie ostad lotfi betoone ba tar be in zibaei harf bezane

[shurchapkuk]

هر انسانی در زندگی میتواند رفته رفته بهتر و انسان تر شود. اما گویا توده ای ها از این قاعده مستثنی هستند.آنها همواره بیشتر در لجن فرو می روند

[ema1344]

fuck you

[morningvictoire]

As a doctor of music and a pupil of Ostad Ali Akbar khan Shahnazi,I share the same view with hamsab on Mr.Lotfi.He is very ordinary tarist whose skill is deadfully primitive and rudimentary. you judt feel a Tar student is playing. His chap -rast,riz and on the top his improvization is incredibly poor. he lacks sense of ornamentation!he should work a lot to improve himself.Moreover this is not Tra he is playing it rather is TANBOOR!!

[filsoofimusic]

با احترام به شما. آیا اینکه شما دکتر هستید دلیل کافی خواهد بود تا ما استاد را کنار بگذاریم آیا استاد شجریان که ادعا می کند ساز لطفی مانند یک ارکستر هست احتیاج به دکترا دارد؟ پرویز مشکاتیان جایی گفته بود بیداد(قطعه ابتدا) بدون مضراب لطفی نمی توانست اجرا شود

[filsoofimusic]

و سر آخر اینکه ما ایرونیها کی می خواهیم دست از منم منم دست برداریم .دسته کشی از این نوازنده به آن نوازنده ؟دوست ندارید باب میل شما نیست بفرمایید ساز قوی مضرابان را گوش کنید

[bahmanrahimiyan]

Dmet garm filsoof jan.

Ina alaki gir dadan be Lotfi. Khial mikonan har ki rish dareh hezbollahie.

Ostad Payvar ham migoft az daste Lotfi tala mibareh.

[keroine9]

Take your fake doctorate and put it in your ass.

[bahmanrahimiyan]

morningvictoire

You wont know what Tar is if one hits you on the head you muppet.

You are a Doctor? Ok Mr Doctor. In your text you used the expression tarist. The correct word is Tar Player. Is this the height of your education?

Where did you study? Mojahedin University of Baghdad?

Did your Dad played Tanbur like this?

[raimarpratin]

The more small and mean spirits criticize somebody like Ostad Lotfi...the more they praise him.

[madi672003]

now this is real music ......... just look how he is into the music when he sings !!!!

[BIDGANI]

ei kash ostad lotfi hichgah TAR ra raha nemikardand

[danbagheri]

very good, Persian music is very deepp. I wish holliwood could sometime see Persian culture and civilization for what it is , and stop making films that demanizes it.

[lavaashack]

az ye ozgale mojahed mesle hamsab azin behtar ham entezar nemire. yeki nist bege baba to boro kare siasi khodeto bokon be mooosighi o honar chi kar dari

[SonOfseabass]

Lotfi is a great artist. It is mistake to present opinion as facts when it comes to art. It is like saying that blueberry taste better than strawberry - and i have proof ! I love Lotfi's playing. Argumets should be left to science and minds that can't feel ....they can only observe with stone heart attempt to form opinion from "education". They no nothing of love and don't know their own heart. But in time they all will. We all do.peace

[entalebi]

that's a shame... please don't even give yourself the right to talk about OSTAD LOTFI... dark kardane honare ostad lotfi khodesh honari mikhahad ke hamekas nadarad... I can say with confidence that OSTAD LOTFI is the only Nabegheye Mousighi in iranian traditional music after nasle talaeeye darvish khan o ostad hormozi o boroomand...

[kaftar]

I don't understand why you guys are fighting together,cant you just listen and enjoy it, and whoever does not like it that is ok too.

[mkhounani]

Wonderful, wonderful.

[mosaffer]

thanks , it is nice music

could you pls translate the poem

[hamsab]

Bear in mind that Lotfi started playing tar when he was quite old for learning that around 18 years of age! If you can show just one real chaharmezrab like the one played by Ostaad Shanaz or Majd I will agree with you/ unfortunately he does not understand the art of TALFIGH SHER VA MOOSIGHI. this song is full of mistakes! that ordinary listeners can't get them!

[mreza1979]

Hamshab

I checked your profile.now I got why you are so against Iranian culture and Iranian masters.You are free to say and think whatever u like but we won't be like u and your master Rajavi.

[hamsab]

I did not mean to insult any one. but he reality is mr.Lotfi is by all means a very low profile tar player. his MEZRAB and fingers are truly week. he has no RIZ or any snse of ornamentation. whereas Ostaad Jalil Shanaz is an Icon. He always complaies that these player instead of playin tar they puinsh it. Please learn some degrees of music then juge my staement on him.

[Fazel1341]

Danke !!!

[Fazel1341]

Sie verstehen gar nichts!

[hamsab]

It is a shame that a Mullah looking guy holding a tar and playing such losy and weak Tar bears the title OSTAD LOTFI! his voice is hundred times better than his playing! although he has no briliant voicebut iy is more bearable! this man is a true symbol of a charlatan in iranina music! please notice he is quite tipsy too!

[tpl97]

your brain is totally f#%$!ed buddy!

[marhahs]

hamsab, i checked your comments on this site. one thing is clear you are immature. stop spreading hate. the reason why people listen to music is not charmezrab or technique, the reason is something that you are missing. music that is so much tied with humanity and love is by its first message far from the bullshit you are writing as comments under lotfi videos.

clear your mind. good music is from people and for people.

[mamali42731]

Sorry for you !

[saberi17]

iam sorry to read such opinion .

what you got ? do you know something better?

sad ,sad,sad ,go and learn about iranian music..........(answer to hamsab)

[nasy12]

Hamsab: You better learn and then make a comment.