Hearing this rendition again a few months later, I am struck, again, by Marsh's magnificent balance of power and sheer tonal beauty. His sound is perfectly balanced as well between what classical singers call "chiaroscuro," or dark and bright timbres.
No question: Calvin Marsh was a first-rate baritone, with a voice both beautiful and powerful. And Rudolf Bing was a world-class BOOB for treating Marsh as at best a comprimario. Bing's ears must have been full of cement. ---
Bing might have been having a very bad day. Misjudgments abound, we know. But one listening to Marsh's voice and his magnificent sound "speaks for itself." I feel Marsh is equal to Merrill though just below Warren and admit to doubt as I do "pretend discussions and sound comparisons" with some excellent Verdi passages from the top "Baritone Operas." My only lament: why didn't Marsh record more opera?
Such a beautifuly balanced sound & such musicality! Rudolph Bing's taste could be questionable at times (to say the least).
legatofancier 7 months ago
Thank you so much. I have to sing this tomorrow and it is wonderful to hear such an accomplished master perform the piece.
louisrose 10 months ago
Hearing this rendition again a few months later, I am struck, again, by Marsh's magnificent balance of power and sheer tonal beauty. His sound is perfectly balanced as well between what classical singers call "chiaroscuro," or dark and bright timbres.
Nobody like him today:) --
stevevandien 10 months ago
Great voice. It was unfortunate that Marsh was at the Met the same time
the anti-American Bing was general manager. He treated numerous
American singers very badly: B. Sills, J. McCracken, E. Farrell, C. Turner,
E. Conley, M. Curtis-Verna, etc.
Why the Met board allowed this is puzzling.
rockgor 11 months ago
No question: Calvin Marsh was a first-rate baritone, with a voice both beautiful and powerful. And Rudolf Bing was a world-class BOOB for treating Marsh as at best a comprimario. Bing's ears must have been full of cement. ---
stevevandien 1 year ago
Thank you for posting such a great voice and singer!
jussi2100 1 year ago
Bing might have been having a very bad day. Misjudgments abound, we know. But one listening to Marsh's voice and his magnificent sound "speaks for itself." I feel Marsh is equal to Merrill though just below Warren and admit to doubt as I do "pretend discussions and sound comparisons" with some excellent Verdi passages from the top "Baritone Operas." My only lament: why didn't Marsh record more opera?
blakemooney 1 year ago
This is my Grandfather, Calvin Marsh, singing at my parent's wedding ceremony in 1964! Thank you Joe for posting this!
soprano1222 1 year ago
Glorious! Thank you for putting that on.
Lillibet60 1 year ago