I've heard the russian version live. They actually sang it. Well they must not have felt comfortable singing the english version live I guess. Either I hate pop music but I absolutely love t.A.T.u.!!!! :)
@lambroisienne ...Most people/bands mime nowadays. I do understand a little why Tatu might have mimed on this night though. You gotta remember these ladies are Russian and English isn't their first language. Maybe they just didn't feel comfortable singing in English live as in the Studio they can try many times in English to get it right.
Do you think t.A.T.u. would still rock the world if Yulia/Julia kept her natural hair color? Cuz we all know that's her real color. She dyed it dark for the band.
@GAMINDORE i don't understand how you try to point out something stupid but then misspell "sync" its lip syncing. try to be literate next time you decide to be a sass, thanks !
@GAMINDORE except this time you butchered the spelling on "didn't", i mean really you learn contractions in grade 3. how did you even manage to make a youtube account without basic intellectual skills. at no point did i ever mention william shakespeare, so I don't even know what you're trying to point out...if it has to do with spelling he didnt write the dictionary or anything he was just a play writer.. calm down.
@makeupsforevs You are probably a troll, you are unsatisfyied because your boss did not pay you or he is farting upon your nose. Well, my friend, go wash the dishes of the dirty cat house you work and go leave me alone, fart smelling...
@GAMINDORE okay first of all, I'm not a troll. second of all what kind of stupid thing is it to refer to someone as a troll. are you just mad because you're an illiterate imbecile who is totally get owned on youtube comments? like your diss sucked, you worded it like fcking shit, i could have a fricken fetus write a better paragraph then you. and really, farting? how old are you, two and a half? like honestly you are so stupid, its ridiculous. anyways enjoy your pathetic life you piece of shit:)
@makeupsforevs Listen, your dirty prostitute, I am not interested in your dirty services, I really don't want to have a sexual disease from you. So go away...
@GAMINDORE I'm not sure what instrument he was playing. I just wanted to alert people to his face, so I selected an obvious instrument to help illustrate my point. I guess I should have said "the face of the male homo sapiens who appears to be on stage". MY BAD, Gandalf.
I don't know why, but this song makes me cry yet makes me happy and hopeful at the same time.,.. Does anyone else feel like this when they hear this song??? Thumbs up if you do... Thanks...
@LaveaFirmis hehehe welcome to the future where the guy on the keyboard can mix the voices to repeat in a cool way! maybe you didn't know it was him?:) although most of it are them tuning their voice, thats actually possible so suprise!:'D
@sasorinor First off I'd like to say I like Tatu but no I cant sing for beans lol
I find it very hard to believe thats them live, no voice is that crisp, clean and sound that much like the recorded song and also they are holding the mics differently every time they come to sing and you cant hear any movement of the mic being closer or further away as you do normally, its to consistent like a studio recording
@LaveaFirmis it is them only that the sound has been fixed on since the guys who records the show have edited it to remove noices from the mic, probably not how they sound live but it's close, most artists are close live and their cd's( except rap, it sucks at livexD). so it is studio recorded in a way, still thats how they probably sound live, only with a little more noice(every video like this are like that...)
lol they're lip syncing. how do i know? bcuz near the end at the mother looking at me part the redhead always sings the 2nd verse but here the other girl is singing it YET her voice is somehow exactly the same as the redhead when the redhead sings it lol. i would understand the lip syncing IF they had to dance, but they just stand there while performing and do a little walking around
@valdemar8 plus it's identical to the recorded version, there's very few bands that can be that polished live and a performance is like a signature, always slightly different
They aint lip syncing tha real music is playing in tha background just in case they run outta air they have the music in tha back to make it sound full these gurls got major talent knomsayin
Actually this doesn't sound like the track version. they're not completely lip syncing this. and for the person who said they're a one hit wonder look up all their songs, the majority of them are hits. they're really singing here just listen.
I love these girls, they are amazing. The first song I ever heard by them was "Gomenasai" and I've been listening to them no stop ever since. They're amazing.
You might notice the lip syncing always happens in performances for tv shows or award shows. And when they were younger and controlled by the people they were employed by. They don't like lip syncing themselves.
Hmmmm.....Lip Sync? they had the echo effect on the microphones when they spoke at the end of the song......but that was way too good to be live.....i don't actually know!
During this whole video, i was wondering whether or not lesbians in general shaved themselves down there. I'm not sure why, though.. Might be because of the one on the lefts' hair?
@maniluvbecky why the hell are ya calling me bro and their film clip and this sound the same and one of them stops singing and the words are still playing, you can tell.
@maniluvbecky i might not stop talking. Just stop answering back. You find that this will stop once you find the way to stop them your self by never answering back.
@jose8989ful I always laugh when I see shallow criticism of Lena of Julie in the early years. Seriously, as if they had anything to say about what was lip-sync in those does or not. The fact is, they were kids, and good enough to be invited to Wembley to perform in front of her Highness. That says something about them, like it or not.
Gosh that crowds boring if I'd been there, I guarantee it would have been a lot more noisy.
StarTrekkie1996 2 weeks ago 2
I've heard the russian version live. They actually sang it. Well they must not have felt comfortable singing the english version live I guess. Either I hate pop music but I absolutely love t.A.T.u.!!!! :)
LilyMoth12 1 month ago
@LilyMoth12 All the Things She Said is actually a rock song <__<
countach27 1 month ago
thumbs up if you get a lil sad finding out that they are not real lesbians :D
cueshe008 1 month ago 2
2:41 - 2:43 ... Granny is GETTIN' IT! =D
teddyhl1995 1 month ago in playlist tATu Live
lol, the only two people miming are the two people who are famous
lexichronicle2 1 month ago in playlist tATu Live
Lipsync :( Love the song tho
lambroisienne 2 months ago
@lambroisienne ...Most people/bands mime nowadays. I do understand a little why Tatu might have mimed on this night though. You gotta remember these ladies are Russian and English isn't their first language. Maybe they just didn't feel comfortable singing in English live as in the Studio they can try many times in English to get it right.
gunnerforever89 1 month ago in playlist tATu Live
Lovely Miming, so terrible
SweetT79 2 months ago
I love them :'D <3
bloublouxp 2 months ago
Blonde is Yulia's real hair color. She's hot with blonde hair! Although I prefer her with dark hair. But I wish she'd perform more as a blonde.
3cheers4Ger 2 months ago
my love lena
JALISCO183 3 months ago
hmmm they are just hot together
charlesovery 3 months ago in playlist tATu Live
I love how the audience is just standing and watching, except for the two girls at 4:05 on their seats! Love it.
bubbles6688 3 months ago
@bubbles6688 yeah i noticed that to i laughed my f#@%* A@^ off!
yellowstormful 3 months ago
Do you think t.A.T.u. would still rock the world if Yulia/Julia kept her natural hair color? Cuz we all know that's her real color. She dyed it dark for the band.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
That's Yulia's real natural hair color, right?! So pretty! But I do prefer the dark hair.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
All the Things She Said actually came out in 2002. :) But 2003 in the UK. The 200 KM/H album came out in 2002.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
Yulia is a bit fat... had recently given birth!
Latiao7 4 months ago in playlist tATu Live
yulia's hair. xD
kunoichiOneX 4 months ago 3
Amazing !! *_________*
Latiao7 4 months ago in playlist tATu Live
This has been flagged as spam show
my lovery angel
Keroro2LOVE2 4 months ago
my fav band :X:X:X
S0Ldi3r0fL0v3 4 months ago 14
Yulia. No. That hairstyle is awkward. =____=
Putumon 4 months ago
w«yulia what's hapenned to her bbbbbbbbloonnndeeee!!!
nataliadejesusgomes 4 months ago
tatu <3 <3 <3
TheChElSeA197 4 months ago
2 girls.. *cough*
jupiterdrive 4 months ago in playlist youtube
Holy crap, they look nothing like they should. They must of been cloned..!
kirbymaster2017 4 months ago in playlist tATu Live
omg. that's yulia??
althsun 6 months ago
Que padre suena....exelente arreglo musical...
soyguapoylindo 6 months ago in playlist t.A.T.u.
noo her black hair is gone :,,,(
runstygge 6 months ago
Are their any videos of them singing this not lip singing?
jeremebonesaw 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I LOVE t.A.T.u :))
hiheha012345 8 months ago
they always lip sing this chorus
kiran2914 8 months ago
Someone could me explain the reason for which someone goes to a LIVE concert to see Lipsinking ???? It is something I do not understand.
GAMINDORE 8 months ago
Comment removed
GAMINDORE 8 months ago
@GAMINDORE i don't understand how you try to point out something stupid but then misspell "sync" its lip syncing. try to be literate next time you decide to be a sass, thanks !
makeupsforevs 7 months ago
@makeupsforevs Oh I didin't know Willian Shakespeare is still alive, and correcting me. Oh this is a remarkable fact.
GAMINDORE 7 months ago
@GAMINDORE except this time you butchered the spelling on "didn't", i mean really you learn contractions in grade 3. how did you even manage to make a youtube account without basic intellectual skills. at no point did i ever mention william shakespeare, so I don't even know what you're trying to point out...if it has to do with spelling he didnt write the dictionary or anything he was just a play writer.. calm down.
makeupsforevs 7 months ago
@makeupsforevs You are probably a troll, you are unsatisfyied because your boss did not pay you or he is farting upon your nose. Well, my friend, go wash the dishes of the dirty cat house you work and go leave me alone, fart smelling...
GAMINDORE 7 months ago
@GAMINDORE okay first of all, I'm not a troll. second of all what kind of stupid thing is it to refer to someone as a troll. are you just mad because you're an illiterate imbecile who is totally get owned on youtube comments? like your diss sucked, you worded it like fcking shit, i could have a fricken fetus write a better paragraph then you. and really, farting? how old are you, two and a half? like honestly you are so stupid, its ridiculous. anyways enjoy your pathetic life you piece of shit:)
makeupsforevs 7 months ago
@makeupsforevs Listen, your dirty prostitute, I am not interested in your dirty services, I really don't want to have a sexual disease from you. So go away...
GAMINDORE 7 months ago
LOL at the guitarist at 2:12
katiekinns 8 months ago
@katiekinns Is he the guitarrist indeed ??? He is not featured entirely...
GAMINDORE 8 months ago
@GAMINDORE I'm not sure what instrument he was playing. I just wanted to alert people to his face, so I selected an obvious instrument to help illustrate my point. I guess I should have said "the face of the male homo sapiens who appears to be on stage". MY BAD, Gandalf.
katiekinns 8 months ago
@GAMINDORE Upon further review, he would either be the guitarist or the bass player. I hope that is sufficient for you.
katiekinns 8 months ago
totally lip sync
pantherstealth1 8 months ago
They're atleast 18 and If you could spend time with them make up your mind cause they really sing cute! :)
BensSpirit88 9 months ago
umm how old were they ? someone tell mii
yutzysanu 9 months ago
Why does this sound exactly like the album version....
cr8zyboy20 9 months ago
@cr8zyboy20
Because it's a playback, obviously.
xoruhtra 9 months ago
Great video!
puacino2 10 months ago
Haha I wanna know how old are they first, then I will decide how to look at their short jeans
doggiegunner 10 months ago
My God... They are quite attractive, aren't they?
ubernaffa 10 months ago 4
I don't know why, but this song makes me cry yet makes me happy and hopeful at the same time.,.. Does anyone else feel like this when they hear this song??? Thumbs up if you do... Thanks...
crazymike44 10 months ago 3
which one is which?
lilORANG 10 months ago
I´ll love Lena & Yulia forever...
asalux 10 months ago
who are they trying to fool lip syncing it looks silly because of all the effect and doubled up vocals they might as well not have mics
LaveaFirmis 11 months ago
@LaveaFirmis hehehe welcome to the future where the guy on the keyboard can mix the voices to repeat in a cool way! maybe you didn't know it was him?:) although most of it are them tuning their voice, thats actually possible so suprise!:'D
tatu>haters that can't even sing in the shower
sasorinor 10 months ago
@sasorinor First off I'd like to say I like Tatu but no I cant sing for beans lol
I find it very hard to believe thats them live, no voice is that crisp, clean and sound that much like the recorded song and also they are holding the mics differently every time they come to sing and you cant hear any movement of the mic being closer or further away as you do normally, its to consistent like a studio recording
I wish it was them
LaveaFirmis 10 months ago
@LaveaFirmis it is them only that the sound has been fixed on since the guys who records the show have edited it to remove noices from the mic, probably not how they sound live but it's close, most artists are close live and their cd's( except rap, it sucks at livexD). so it is studio recorded in a way, still thats how they probably sound live, only with a little more noice(every video like this are like that...)
sasorinor 10 months ago
@LaveaFirmis they can have sound effects on the microphones, i've heard.
eloiseamanda 9 months ago
when i saw them coming i was like "WHERES YULIA?"
PrettyOdd25 11 months ago
Просто SUPER
mironicl 11 months ago
Raises the question "how do you do a live tribute to somebody whose musical genius was in studio manipulation?"
pmgruhn 1 year ago
1:03 to skip him talking.
blood0willow 1 year ago 56
@blood0willow ai lov yu
missmilingsexy 6 months ago
@blood0willow thaaaaaaaaanks!
SHPrada 4 months ago in playlist tATu Live
Lip syncers oh well i still love this song FULOLY SICK! I like the chick with the black hair better than her hair now and the outfits aren't great
eshyayes 1 year ago
Lip syncers oh well i still love this song FULOLY SICK!
eshyayes 1 year ago
Uhh Tom Jones!
Ancupola 1 year ago
They should be the ones on all the music videos channels on tv >:(
xXchelsearoxXx 1 year ago
Love it
stephaniebailey2010 1 year ago
YULIA SOLOED THAT!!!! I always thought Lena did that solo part! Daaam
lucarido16 1 year ago
was that old lady her mom?
generalwhoha29 1 year ago
i got a remix to this on my page check it out hip hop version
jayearz 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is this lip sync
OhmygoditsCollin 1 year ago
best singers ever
minty1998 1 year ago
lol they're lip syncing. how do i know? bcuz near the end at the mother looking at me part the redhead always sings the 2nd verse but here the other girl is singing it YET her voice is somehow exactly the same as the redhead when the redhead sings it lol. i would understand the lip syncing IF they had to dance, but they just stand there while performing and do a little walking around
valdemar8 1 year ago
@valdemar8 actually the red head always sings the mother looking at me part...sooooo yea
spashley4ever77 1 year ago
@valdemar8 That, and this version is EXACTLY like the recorded version XD
hidarichan81 1 year ago
@valdemar8 plus it's identical to the recorded version, there's very few bands that can be that polished live and a performance is like a signature, always slightly different
theposhbloke 1 year ago
@valdemar8 Oh well, they're still an amazing band. I knew they were lip syncing also.
xXchelsearoxXx 1 year ago
Woah, What did Yulia do to her hair? Never seen that before..
Still love t.A.t.U, and they're singing, theres just the track playing in the background.
Don't Like, don't watch.
witchofdanight1316 1 year ago
Tired of these MF ads on the MF YT [pass it on]. Tune is not fantastic but reminds me of times gone by. Thank you for uploading.
jesuispret69 1 year ago
good
samabdelghany 1 year ago
I had no earthly idea that Trevor Horn had anything to do with this. But now that I know, no wonder it was such a catchy song.
bluorangefyre 1 year ago
Comment removed
brazidas422 1 year ago
Spacibo! I like this so much!
Ancupola 1 year ago
@Ancupola yes, spaciba, these girls are hot! ;-)
valdemar8 1 year ago
look how big tha redheads booty is im n love wit her ass haha
PimpinOnDaDaily 1 year ago
They aint lip syncing tha real music is playing in tha background just in case they run outta air they have the music in tha back to make it sound full these gurls got major talent knomsayin
PimpinOnDaDaily 1 year ago
Seems to me in this live performance that the band is playing live anyway up on a playback music and voices are in playback too... or not?
Domenix71 1 year ago
what does t.A.T.u. mean?
lifeafter3pints 1 year ago
@lifeafter3pints its short for something in russian that means "she loves her"
Wontaco 1 year ago
@lifeafter3pints
tattoo ;)
iceavantura 1 year ago
1:36 lol look at his face
HAWORTHSHOLLYWOOD 1 year ago
fuck the public
tortillaconpimienta 1 year ago
2003
Wiccant3 1 year ago
Wow,TATU is hot(especially the redhead)!
MrTennesseeVols 1 year ago
wow lip singing and lol tht couple dancing LOL
XfuckyouX24 1 year ago
wow lip singing
XfuckyouX24 1 year ago
Actually this doesn't sound like the track version. they're not completely lip syncing this. and for the person who said they're a one hit wonder look up all their songs, the majority of them are hits. they're really singing here just listen.
cravingdisaster 1 year ago
Trevor
coparush 1 year ago
Tom Jones is the original gangsta, man.
DarkeningSkies1 1 year ago
♥__♥ i love girls
papayask8 1 year ago
they have amazing voices
MegaMilliondollarbab 1 year ago
They lip sing every single time they are live, and they are so full of themselves for a one hit wonder...
SWBJR1 1 year ago
@SWBJR1 Actually they have a lot of very good songs. but, if you don't like em, why watch this?
SlashTheCat13 1 year ago 33
I love these girls, they are amazing. The first song I ever heard by them was "Gomenasai" and I've been listening to them no stop ever since. They're amazing.
MissLoveProtector 1 year ago
грехопропаганда! бедные дурочки....
rossviktor 1 year ago
wow! they're so beatuful and lovely! nice song! hot legs and amazing voices!
onsalyer 1 year ago
1:02
zankyubaruo 1 year ago
Comment removed
zankyubaruo 1 year ago
2:40 - Lmao she's chillen :')
FellPonyz 1 year ago
fit
DazziBoi14 1 year ago
lip sink some more. they're hot and all but come on now. i watch 3 vids of this song live and it all sounded the same just like off the cd.
seemless1134 1 year ago
@seemless1134 hahaha okay so I'm not alone. That's a shame :/. Oh well. I still love them.
BeautifulTragedyx21 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i wanna put my penis in both their butts then in their mouths
seemless1134 1 year ago
@seemless1134 show sum respect u cunt
fig00018 1 year ago
@fig00018 ill show ur mom respect and stick it in her cunt bitch
seemless1134 1 year ago
@seemless1134 yeah yeah go wank off on some porn lil kid
fig00018 1 year ago
Damn glad Yulia didnt keep that haircut long... It dont suit her at all
Talvrae 1 year ago
god they're so cute I love lena :)
Jsilvers10 1 year ago
yulia esta mas gorda en este video jeje se ve rara la neta jejee excelent video very good
fortacibabt 1 year ago
woah yulias hair is different here im used to seeing her hair black
Swaghacks4ever 1 year ago
R they singing Live???????
290aua 1 year ago
liiiiip syyyyynced.
Gryphon311 1 year ago
Jeez do these girls ever actually sing live?
Traynor921 1 year ago
@Traynor921 youtube.com/watch?v=TfXo2Z69eck
You might notice the lip syncing always happens in performances for tv shows or award shows. And when they were younger and controlled by the people they were employed by. They don't like lip syncing themselves.
mesCheerios 1 year ago
@Traynor921 yes they do, if you look for their Dangerous and Moving tour videos they are all live (St Petersburg)
mountgrace 1 year ago
why did they stop singing??
crazymorena24 1 year ago
Lip Sync AGAIN!...
DanielSings94 1 year ago
lip sync. go listen to the original. its the same. i hate fake bitches. thumbs up if u agree
PrestonN1 1 year ago
@PrestonN1 sometimes they don't get a choice. They don't like lip sync either. Go listen to one of their concert performances.
mesCheerios 1 year ago
@PrestonN1 youtube.com/watch?v=YnGbx2TkLdA
mesCheerios 1 year ago
i think the ginger one actually sings live and the other one doesn't, because her accent really comes through.
bluespirtsam 1 year ago
już sam nie wiem która lepsza. jakby tak czarnej (tu farbowanej) dac cycki z rudej to by było mejdżik %-)
ulvPL 1 year ago
awesome song
DarkDemolitionStar 1 year ago
who are those random background singer ppls? lol at the old lady dancing xD
ratlover35 1 year ago
the girl on the left looked better wid her old hair style
xxANG13xx 1 year ago 35
@xxANG13xx Withe her hairstyle they look like twins dont you think
TinkerbellTheGreat 1 year ago
Hmmmm.....Lip Sync? they had the echo effect on the microphones when they spoke at the end of the song......but that was way too good to be live.....i don't actually know!
theonlykickasskid 1 year ago 2
@theonlykickasskid it was lip syncd bc Yulia had a voice cyst at the time bc of her being pregnant
fluffybunny360 1 year ago
@theonlykickasskid i think the ginger one actually sings live and the other one doesn't, because her accent really comes through.
bluespirtsam 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow a video they didnt make out in
iluv2cook4u2 1 year ago
wow a video they didnt make out in.
iluv2cook4u2 1 year ago
I love TATU,They're really erotic on stage! :)
BigMDS67 1 year ago
why they never sing "live", always playback, i want to hear their real voice =D
dantes8625 1 year ago
wow the crowd are zomibes
MrDrumerguy123 1 year ago
2:43 xD!
DeluxeFantasy00 1 year ago
During this whole video, i was wondering whether or not lesbians in general shaved themselves down there. I'm not sure why, though.. Might be because of the one on the lefts' hair?
Maanesyge 1 year ago 4
@Maanesyge Yeah lesbians generally shave down there ;)
lovelymissabby 1 year ago
omg there's fucking big 2003 a you'll write 2004...
RadkaVejdy 1 year ago
WTF she has a mullet
TheJammyboy1 1 year ago
THEY ARE AMAZING
mirjettaaa 1 year ago
they sound exactly like the song...
FreakyYaoiFanGirl 1 year ago
If there is any sound off its the video feed, they aren't lip syncing.
runincircles70 1 year ago
they aren't singing this.
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 yeaa they are
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@maniluvbecky you can tell they are lip singing
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 bro they arent like that
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@maniluvbecky why the hell are ya calling me bro and their film clip and this sound the same and one of them stops singing and the words are still playing, you can tell.
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 Ok dude show me at what time in the video ?! does it show that ?
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@maniluvbecky 1:25, 4:18- her mouth is not moving with the words. and stop calling me dude, I'm a chick, man.
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 yea alright & i call everyone the same thing CHICK
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 Ok Chick the Fuking Words are Fuking Echoing !!!!
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 & dont hate on t.A.T.u. Cuz You cant Sing !
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@maniluvbecky I can sing, ig ot the lead in my school musical and don't bloody swear at me and the words ain't echoing.
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
@maniluvbecky plus i bet you can't sing
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 ok STFU! you need to leave me the Fuk Alone !!!!
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@maniluvbecky then why you keep replying, god people are stupid.
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
@MsTwilightfan17 Cause your Pissing Me OFF! Quit Talking!!!!!
maniluvbecky 1 year ago
@maniluvbecky i might not stop talking. Just stop answering back. You find that this will stop once you find the way to stop them your self by never answering back.
MsTwilightfan17 1 year ago
Super!!!
alexflash75 1 year ago
why does she always block out the shhh part
?
violet1197 1 year ago
their accent makes this song SO badass!
vampiiress 1 year ago
LYP SINCING JUST THE CHOURUSSESS
jose8989ful 1 year ago
@jose8989ful I always laugh when I see shallow criticism of Lena of Julie in the early years. Seriously, as if they had anything to say about what was lip-sync in those does or not. The fact is, they were kids, and good enough to be invited to Wembley to perform in front of her Highness. That says something about them, like it or not.
motokomadblood 1 year ago
@motokomadblood how old were they?
violet1197 1 year ago
@violet1197 I would guess, maybe somewhere between 22 and 24 and under a huge amount of pressure to perform.
motokomadblood 1 year ago
@motokomadblood they sing rlly good for around that age they beat miley cryus