i much prefer Amy and Mark Ronson's version. This one is good, and they credit because it's their song, but Amy Winehouse had the soul. The argument that she's singing about a woman and is a lesbian is stupid, it's a cover- she didn't write the song, she just sang it; And that also implies homophobia which is really not okay.
i much prefer Amy and Mark Ronson's version. This one is good, and they credit because it's their song, but Amy Winehouse had the soul. The argument that she's singing about a woman and is a lesbian is stupid, it's a cover- she didn't write the song, she just sang it; And that also implies homophobia which is really not okay.
Why do people fuss over which version is better? They are both amazing in their own respects! Very different from each other... That doesn't mean one is better than the other.
This recording is powerful and captivating in so many ways - but this song has been taken over by Amy Winehouse which is a testament to her transcendent talent.
Of course it makes sense for a woman to sing it. Have people actually never heard of women being in love with each oher aka "lesbians"? Seriously, it's 2009. Live in the now.
lol this is my name only diffrence is that i spell mine like valorie lol but really the name valerie or valorie really meens vigorous and strong so wanted to just say that and if any one spells it like me comment on my page ok ok ok :)
I want this music video for my ipod I like videos that actually take you someplace and have some artistic value. I've never heard this song here in NY... after this I'm going to the Winehouse version to compare.
no she didn't. i've seen multiple versions of hers and every time, she sounds like a cat whining, these guys are better for one reason, they sing and play the song well, she just screeches till the instruments stop playing. she is horrible.
true, except copying songs from others she knows nothing else (ex: "Tears Dry on Their Own" a pale copy of "Ain't no montain high enought" from M.Gaye & T.Terrell barely disguised and emptied of its charm)
true, except copying songs from others she knows nothing else (ex: "Tears Dry on Their Own" a pale copy of "Ain't no montain high enought" from M.Gaye & T.Terrell barely disguised and emptied of its charm)
This is such a great song that there is no "better" only different. I like every version I have heard. Maybe I repeat but those who wrote this created a song that will last. I hope as many people as possible cover this.
Copying is one thing. Winehouse has a version that she makes her own. This version and that one prove a great song is a great song. Valerie, come on over.
Yup. HAllelujah by Jeff Buckley was a cover of Leonard Cohen. A great song is a great song. Personally, I think the Mark Ronson cover is far superior.
hmmm... i like the amy winehouse version a LOT better... that's not to say i like the wretched mark ronson production... all of his percussion is that same dull, distorted, trying-to-sound-like-a-45 kinda lagging beat, and i can't stand it...
but amy winehouse has an acoustic version of this song that's absolutely amazing...
This is by far the better of "Valerie" than the Mark Ronson version, more feeling in this. The orginals of songs are always better, this is another example. "Tired of hanging around" was a very good album. Only got the album because of this song, but I gotta say the album as a whole is ace. Plus the drummer is an Evertonian :p
Shame about the rest of the band supporting that lot from across the park lol
thanks to youtube and amy winehouse, ive had the pleasure of hearing about this band.. as im sure many others have.. had it not been for that... i would never even have heard about the zutons.. i think they owe amy winehouse for helping them gain at lease one fan.
The Zutons had a hit with this 1yr before Winehouse and was in top 40 for at least 6 months reaching N0.9, then returned after Winehouse hit the charts, so The Zutons don't owe her or Mark Ronson anything, also "Oh Stacey" was a hit between times!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i can't stand the amy winehouse version, i don't hate her or think she's got a bad voice, i just think the zutons version is better and they probably deserve more credit than they've got for it.
These guys are great! Ok... so, at the risk of offending some viewers, I would like to say this.
Although these guys are the genius brains behind this, I did enjoy Amy Winehouse's cover, (and i don't even like Amy Winehouse...) I think that Winehouse's version is easier to sing to...
BUT that does NOT imply that these guys aren't equally, or more, fabulous, it just means that I have an opinion.
Indeed. I think this version's the best, but; while sounding a little generic, Ronson/Winehouse's version still sounds lively. The version's also better for playing a trombone part in a brass/sax section in the song. Fuck yes playing this at my first real gig last night.
But yes, if Ronson hadn't took a brass section to this, even that would have made the song suitably smoother for Winehouse. Hell, keep the brass and make it more stately/sleazy than peppy, is my take.
i didnt know this band before,i came to knew them because of amy winehouse, ithink it is good to promote overseas,i live in brazil, i love in amys voice and this this original rock 'n roll ,rocks!!
They're an indie band - they aren't meant to have this so called "soul", nor is this song. I don't quite get why people seem to salivate over this quality known as "soul" as though every song should have it, whatever it actualy is.
This is the first tie I've heard this, and while I like it a lot, I prefer Amy's version. The chorus of this version is very cathy though, like too catchy...
No cockroaches were injured in the making of this video
LaPeepp 7 months ago
i much prefer Amy and Mark Ronson's version. This one is good, and they credit because it's their song, but Amy Winehouse had the soul. The argument that she's singing about a woman and is a lesbian is stupid, it's a cover- she didn't write the song, she just sang it; And that also implies homophobia which is really not okay.
CrispyBanana 7 months ago
i much prefer Amy and Mark Ronson's version. This one is good, and they credit because it's their song, but Amy Winehouse had the soul. The argument that she's singing about a woman and is a lesbian is stupid, it's a cover- she didn't write the song, she just sang it; And that also implies homophobia which is really not okay.
CrispyBanana 7 months ago
this is a really good song. the sax girl is sexy
Sleepinglikesheep 2 years ago
god this original version is so much better than freaking lame amy winehouse's
saxerlr 2 years ago
slutty but nice girl in the NYC area looking for a sexy man who knows how to please a woman!
LaurelCowgal 2 years ago
O RLY?
Gogloplex 2 years ago
hey thts my name
wompas69 2 years ago
What's wrong with enjoying both versions?
froggy556 2 years ago 3
the original its way better.. gooo The Zutons
i love this!
..Mark Ronson kill this song actually..
charlotflame 2 years ago
Call me old-fashioned, but it just makes more sense for a male artist to be singing a song about 'Valerie.' Hence, this is the better version :).
scoobysteak 2 years ago 2
I love Amy's version. She's so unique!
Judy2Day 2 years ago
hell no amy waz way better
corey8oyes 2 years ago
Why do people fuss over which version is better? They are both amazing in their own respects! Very different from each other... That doesn't mean one is better than the other.
dreotingle 2 years ago 9
This recording is powerful and captivating in so many ways - but this song has been taken over by Amy Winehouse which is a testament to her transcendent talent.
pepsipoptarts 2 years ago
Ok dunkintbags calm
the fuck down this song isnt
THAT good
lol
XD
Blue22293 2 years ago
Amy winhouse is a cum guzzling crack whore, she couldn't write a song this good if they paid her in crack rocks.
dunkintbags 2 years ago
why do you hate on amy winehouse?
gibax 2 years ago
I'm not "Hating", That statement is truth. Why don't you mind your own fucking business?
dunkintbags 2 years ago
my dogs got teets
emmac283 2 years ago
The sax player (Abi Harding) sort of reminds me of Kristen Wiig. And behind tina Turner she has the best legs in Rock.
YoHuckleberry 2 years ago
You dolts....The Zutons wrote the original to this song...the amy winehouse version is a cover
romedog4 2 years ago
Amy Winehouse's is much better
jericamcneal 2 years ago
I definitely like Amy Winehouse's voice on this better, with the acoustic guitar. Check it out. But mad props to The Zutons.
Rockykratter 2 years ago
Great song. Cute video.
Judy2Day 2 years ago
I like amy's version .. but this one was needed
jadalyn404 2 years ago 4
I was just googling my first name as opposed to my whole name for once and this came up. haha.
i love my name =)
XxDogLuvaxX 2 years ago
;) Yeah!
valeriethechinadoll 2 years ago
I like Amy Winehouse's version
StanHywet 2 years ago
> Check out the cover by
feeebieee on Youtube.
BLCalifornia 2 years ago
Comment removed
valarieann78 2 years ago
Of course it makes sense for a woman to sing it. Have people actually never heard of women being in love with each oher aka "lesbians"? Seriously, it's 2009. Live in the now.
PlatypusRising55 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the Panic at the Disco version is better :P
MarijuanaGood4U 2 years ago
lol this is my name only diffrence is that i spell mine like valorie lol but really the name valerie or valorie really meens vigorous and strong so wanted to just say that and if any one spells it like me comment on my page ok ok ok :)
ValLexi14 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Jonas Brothers sure do have good taste, you guys are great. Such a fresh sound, great job.
xoxbreannexox 2 years ago
My name is Valerie
webwizard95 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I like Amy Winehouse version wayyyyy better!!
She gives it alot more soul and her voice just sounds great on this track!!!
dirtydancin4lyf 2 years ago
You need death
Wooooootube 2 years ago 2
just voicing their opinion sweetcakes. they're both pretty fantastic versions.
R3unbreakable 2 years ago 2
you needa calm down asap
dirtydancin4lyf 2 years ago
You need a lesson on music and soul
Rhet0rik 2 years ago 6
Listen to the words of the songs, This song is not meant to be sung by a female, dosent make sense when wino sings it.
henryfarrell1 2 years ago 5
ok everybody need to calm down, i didnt ask for any of you to get smart, i have my opinion and you have yours, so u needa chill out iight!!!!!!
dirtydancin4lyf 2 years ago
I want this music video for my ipod I like videos that actually take you someplace and have some artistic value. I've never heard this song here in NY... after this I'm going to the Winehouse version to compare.
Valerie is also a bombshell, her name suits her.
BKsFiNeSt08 2 years ago
I like both the zs and the aw versions, but the amy one is the one I'm truly in love with. this is a really well done video though.
oswaldvonromak 2 years ago 2
its ma name!!!!!!
justanothergirlxox 2 years ago
I preferred the more R&B take by Winehouse, but that's just my tastes.
ekzavier 2 years ago
I like this. but I like panic at at the disco's just as much.
jonesrebel 2 years ago
yayy!
Nox404 2 years ago
woah, im really diggin this song
calivali 2 years ago 2
THE ZUTONS ARE THE BEST!
LadiiLexy21 2 years ago 4
no she didn't. i've seen multiple versions of hers and every time, she sounds like a cat whining, these guys are better for one reason, they sing and play the song well, she just screeches till the instruments stop playing. she is horrible.
darkenlight111 2 years ago
Please, Amy Winehouse is fantastic and made a version better than the original, in my opinion...
Why people dont you stop talking about Amy, leave her alone!!!
We know you dont want it to happen, but she will be okay..
renannit 2 years ago
I f***ing hate amy winehouse for ruining this song
tannburstinn92 2 years ago
true, except copying songs from others she knows nothing else (ex: "Tears Dry on Their Own" a pale copy of "Ain't no montain high enought" from M.Gaye & T.Terrell barely disguised and emptied of its charm)
cheun 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
true, except copying songs from others she knows nothing else (ex: "Tears Dry on Their Own" a pale copy of "Ain't no montain high enought" from M.Gaye & T.Terrell barely disguised and emptied of its charm)
cheun 2 years ago 2
alriiight, the winehouse version is dowpe
electricyouth9 2 years ago 2
i had never heard this song before but i love it! my daughter's name is valerie lol
Squee06 2 years ago 2
I love this song...luv it luv it....name your daughters Valerie ..young moms (I'm 60!!)...like Amy's version too..see I'm hip!!
boilerchick 2 years ago 2
Hey-I'm from Canada! And we love these guys! Rock on! Great sound! Awesome selection of songs! Keep it going!
straightshooter123 2 years ago
My name's Valeria (in Italian lol)
Nice song.. Maybe 'cause it talks about my name xD
valeriuccia1104 2 years ago
my friends kept singin this song to me all the time cos I have ginger hair but I kept dying it dark and they missed it! haha :D
Naddlem 2 years ago
that video and song is AWESOME
mosh88749 2 years ago
I would say both versions are equally impressive. I'm also really impressed by the way Amy used this song and made it her own.
CptUnknown 2 years ago
i love this song but amy winehouses' version is better
nycait882006 2 years ago
i agree
dedrawilliams 2 years ago
love it
johnnyamorrison 2 years ago
I'm Valerie =)
DanceWTheLightsOff 2 years ago
love this song...love the version amywine house sings also
bgd4v 2 years ago 2
This is such a great song that there is no "better" only different. I like every version I have heard. Maybe I repeat but those who wrote this created a song that will last. I hope as many people as possible cover this.
2short2q 2 years ago 5
You want to throw me in jail with Abby, go right ahead. I wont escape.........she might, but I wont.
jimmy25138 2 years ago
i like amy's version better...
webkingirl97 2 years ago
me too.
has more soul
cuntzzzzz 2 years ago
I love them!!!
kittenDecember 2 years ago 3
Copying is one thing. Winehouse has a version that she makes her own. This version and that one prove a great song is a great song. Valerie, come on over.
tecatedan 2 years ago 3
Yup. HAllelujah by Jeff Buckley was a cover of Leonard Cohen. A great song is a great song. Personally, I think the Mark Ronson cover is far superior.
vdeferens 2 years ago 3
seems to me too many copied this song
johnnyamorrison 2 years ago
MY NAME IS VALERIE!!!!!!!
VolcomVal4Ever 2 years ago
Sleep with me
alex9050 2 years ago 3
hahah my name is valerie too :D
gosh, we have a GREAT name lol
valpalz 2 years ago
Zutons are awesome. This song is wonderful. I love Amy's version also.
flproctor 2 years ago
i love this song!!!! panic at the disco did great at this song!!!
petewentz9998 2 years ago
Fuck you
alex9050 2 years ago
I like this one more than that one from amy xP
snoesje95 2 years ago
*is dumb*
Who's song was the originally? Amy and Mark's or the Zutons?
pastpanda 2 years ago
the zutons
tyler5e 2 years ago 4
zutons =)
fabbygirl43 2 years ago 3
originally its zutons
arnikki 2 years ago 3
The Zutons.
livefortoday17 2 years ago
What an insightful comment. Thank you.
angus12345 2 years ago
I was replying to something, not just saying their name :D
livefortoday17 2 years ago
Oh haha, fair enough. Ma bad.
angus12345 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
love it. I also LOVE LOVE LOVE how ronson and amy put their own soul/jazz twist on this song.
go4erfun 2 years ago
Ausgeziechnet!
h6e2r6n0m7e 2 years ago
haha
I love P!ATD cover best
But I still love it ! xD
adelinela 2 years ago
Ahhh of course!
God panic astounds me.
Good song for them to cover.(:
tmzand 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Mark Ronson + Amy Winehouse = The cutest version :]
rarrington 2 years ago
I like this ALOT
its kind of better than amys version
But there both good
freshstars 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love it ♥
chinafrau 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
awsome these guys rock!!
musikdejan 3 years ago 2
that's a parody? XD
nomaatterhow 3 years ago
I liked Amy's version a lot, but I still prefer this version. But really, both versions are good for different reasons.
Oasisrocks312 3 years ago
this is the original...
and the best
dairyfreeking69 3 years ago 3
Too f**king right, much better than the Ronson/Winehouse version!
michiveritas 3 years ago 2
i was trying to take a quick poll. How many people know this song because they like the Zutons?
or
how many people know this song because of Amy winehouse?
musiclov3r2 3 years ago 2
I know this song because i herad from "Live from Abbey Road" performed by the zutons. Graet song and lovely
guekman 3 years ago 2
i heard the song for first time on the"live from abber road" and i know the band there...
i never heard that for Amy...
lauta91 3 years ago
i know this song beacause the Zutons are a local band to me, seen them around my home town for years.
lesterfontaine 3 years ago
I know this song because of The Zutons.
Amy's version is good, but I prefere this one by far.
charliedot7 3 years ago 7
Amy who?
:D
cifeticiofiti 3 years ago 3
hmmm... i like the amy winehouse version a LOT better... that's not to say i like the wretched mark ronson production... all of his percussion is that same dull, distorted, trying-to-sound-like-a-45 kinda lagging beat, and i can't stand it...
but amy winehouse has an acoustic version of this song that's absolutely amazing...
TheDaguerreotypist 3 years ago
man! i totally HATE! amy winehouse for slautering this great song
nikosthefreeman 3 years ago
The only enjoyable part of this video was seeing that gorgeous lion about 3 minutes in
kittenic44 3 years ago
This is by far the better of "Valerie" than the Mark Ronson version, more feeling in this. The orginals of songs are always better, this is another example. "Tired of hanging around" was a very good album. Only got the album because of this song, but I gotta say the album as a whole is ace. Plus the drummer is an Evertonian :p
Shame about the rest of the band supporting that lot from across the park lol
jimboss1986 3 years ago 2
"Valerie" was actually the 7 hit for The Zutons, saw the do the Anfield concert in June '08 they were fantastic.
davekm43 3 years ago
thanks to youtube and amy winehouse, ive had the pleasure of hearing about this band.. as im sure many others have.. had it not been for that... i would never even have heard about the zutons.. i think they owe amy winehouse for helping them gain at lease one fan.
uaaliikamz 3 years ago
The Zutons had a hit with this 1yr before Winehouse and was in top 40 for at least 6 months reaching N0.9, then returned after Winehouse hit the charts, so The Zutons don't owe her or Mark Ronson anything, also "Oh Stacey" was a hit between times!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
davekm43 3 years ago
4gt the Winhouse version this is the original as if you didn't know, another song like Snow Patrol "Run" is going to get forgoten cos of crap covers
davekm43 3 years ago
this version is sooooooooooo much better than the shit mark ronson does
footballcrazy6 3 years ago 4
its not an amy winehouse version... its by MARK RONSON
falexarzan 3 years ago
i can't stand the amy winehouse version, i don't hate her or think she's got a bad voice, i just think the zutons version is better and they probably deserve more credit than they've got for it.
richie0 3 years ago 2
Yea I know, Its annoying how Amy Winehouse gets loads of the credit when this great bad actually made the song. And It is an amazing song.
TimeSplliterV 3 years ago
*band
TimeSplliterV 3 years ago 2
stop comparing this to the shit amy winehouse sings. these are the real brains behind it.
biologu 3 years ago 4
not really
packersfan3489 3 years ago
doesnt the girl in this vid look like amy winehouse kinda
musiclov3r2 3 years ago
i remember hating this song when it first came out, now i love it! :D
hellyeah169 3 years ago
i think, this is better than amy winehouse...respect!
Mellisa1997 3 years ago 4
These guys are great! Ok... so, at the risk of offending some viewers, I would like to say this.
Although these guys are the genius brains behind this, I did enjoy Amy Winehouse's cover, (and i don't even like Amy Winehouse...) I think that Winehouse's version is easier to sing to...
BUT that does NOT imply that these guys aren't equally, or more, fabulous, it just means that I have an opinion.
mwah. bella.
ChuckWeasley 3 years ago 2
see the reason why people are having a fit is because more than likely they had heard a cover before the original.
and both covers sound completely different
i think this song is wonderful;
and panics is good..
but amy, eh.
could've covered a different song better
iatethedinosaurs189 3 years ago
Indeed. I think this version's the best, but; while sounding a little generic, Ronson/Winehouse's version still sounds lively. The version's also better for playing a trombone part in a brass/sax section in the song. Fuck yes playing this at my first real gig last night.
But yes, if Ronson hadn't took a brass section to this, even that would have made the song suitably smoother for Winehouse. Hell, keep the brass and make it more stately/sleazy than peppy, is my take.
DMGDeed 3 years ago
Best version by far, the worst one by a mile was the Panic at the Dickos one
ivanussus 3 years ago 4
people are fucking retarded.
they wrote this song, it's theres.
amys version and PANIC at the Fagos version is nothing but a sham.
"oh but her voice is better"
no its not, its a generic piece of crap.
zutons wrote it, they are the genius behind the song.
iphicrates123 3 years ago 2
i like this song, but dude if you honestly think amy winhouse has a shit voice i question your judgement in music and trust nothing you say.
ganndon 3 years ago
i said it was generic, not shit.
iphicrates123 3 years ago
WOW panic at the discos version is WAAAYYY better!
brendonuriefan1014ev 3 years ago
The Zuton's wrote this song, didn't they? It's an awesome song, and it is better than Amy Winehouse's version
KGMN15 3 years ago
amy's version is rubbish compared to this one
evilcowpat 3 years ago 2
awesome song awesome band
sirjohnny1974 3 years ago
you know when they escape from the jail its based on the alcatraz movie!
beforeandlater 3 years ago
i love the Zutons <3
KGMN15 3 years ago
The zutons are the original & the best, amys version was gd but yoo cant beat the original
megankelly623 3 years ago
i love the song but i love amys voice :S
warast 3 years ago
OMG O_O those guygs can sing!
this suck!!!
Amy winehouse OWNT!
fleurtje717 3 years ago
no way amy winehouse version is waaayyy better than this shit ..!
iluvliam22magrix 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This really sucks compared to Amy Winehouse's cover. Another example of a cover that's way way way way better than the original.
beefmageditor 3 years ago
this song is written by this band you fools...
petehyunsikkim 3 years ago
i didnt know this band before,i came to knew them because of amy winehouse, ithink it is good to promote overseas,i live in brazil, i love in amys voice and this this original rock 'n roll ,rocks!!
danilasad 3 years ago
@ EpieChan: Oh yes i totally agree with you.
schwimmbrille92 3 years ago
Haha that was meant to be a reply to a previous comment.
Seriously, I LOVE this song. I think it is better than Amy's version of it. ^^;
EpieChan 3 years ago
amy´s version is compared to this one boring
tOwTforce 3 years ago
try seaching for Soulshine and their version of Valerie here on YouTube. The band got soul and the singer can sing!
jkannert 3 years ago
This song is really cool, but nothing can be compared to amy's version
paolatrindade 3 years ago
I'm no big winehouse fan but she gave this song what it didn't have...soul. Her live version is miles ahead of this version.
LastPosterStanding 3 years ago
They're an indie band - they aren't meant to have this so called "soul", nor is this song. I don't quite get why people seem to salivate over this quality known as "soul" as though every song should have it, whatever it actualy is.
BCJ1985 3 years ago
zutons do this miles better than tha druged up stick
portvale246 3 years ago
ay theres fukall wrong with drugd up sticks and amys is better than this but it not bad
cashfan123 3 years ago
the wines completely rocked this shit, it feels like the zutons are the ones that remade it
lyricalminded3 3 years ago
Ronson did a good job,but I prefer this song.
Myriadis 3 years ago 5
great song!
Kasio21 3 years ago 2
This is so much better than that Ronson/Winehouse piece of shit. Ronson got an artist's award at the BRITs, even though he's a producer!
Doddmond 3 years ago 4
i agree with u this much more better
tOwTforce 3 years ago
It sure is. :)x
EpieChan 3 years ago
i liked the amy version better lol
i know she was inspired by them but still lol her voice has more soul:P
marrkk111 3 years ago
check out our songs please
leave us a c omment thanx x
Thelostsoldiersinet 3 years ago
im soo pissed that i knew amy winehouse's first cuz now thats the one i hear wen i listen to htis vid!!! nooooo!!!!
grapefruitpie123 3 years ago
Beware of second rate imitations...!!
midlifecrisis1968 3 years ago
this is the origional
hellhound17121989 3 years ago
This one is a lot better then the Amy Winehouse version.
a0040pc 3 years ago
This is the first tie I've heard this, and while I like it a lot, I prefer Amy's version. The chorus of this version is very cathy though, like too catchy...
crisspanda 3 years ago
i didnt know this band ,i first listened this sog on amys voice, good song
danilasad 3 years ago
ok they obviosly get the credit cuz they raught it BUTT!!!amy deffenatly gives it a oumffff!!! a special someting that is not here!!!!
MrFou72 3 years ago
They didn't write it did they though
terricray5000 3 years ago