The great thing about David's guitar playing is that it really isn't that hard to play, technically. But trying to play it the way that David plays it, is literally impossible. The songs he plays are of legendary difficulty because he puts more soul into his playing then any other guitarist out there.
Check out the subtle texture he adds in the solo at 0:25. It's like a rake. It's very quick and subtle - you might miss it, but it's these little things that adds to its greatness. I love it.
A guitar is much Like a woman. You have to hold her in your arms. You have to love her. If she feels right, then she's the one for you. You have to show her lots if attention and take great care of her.. If she becomes warped or twisted, you can remove her neck...
I agree the Gretsch doesn't have the natural sustain as the Start; BUT the Gretsch he uses here is what he used on the orignal recording of Confortably Num.
so you spent £££ to get the latest Fender Custom Shop Black Strat, right to the tiniest ding, and guess what? the man picks up a Gretsch and gets his usual monster tone... bloody great!
@Mancunion1976 I'd have to disagree.... The Gretsch doesn't have anywhere near the ring and sustain the strat has. Almost seems like Gilmore is forcing the guitar to keep up with him. IMO.
@spartansensei of course a strat is a strat, what I meant is that the gear plays a relatively small role when we talk about people like DG and the like.
My comment was directed to all the gearheads who spend lots of money to replicate Gilmour's rig hoping to nail his tone, but unfortunately you can't go buy is fingers and his musicality.
@Mancunion1976 for sure, gilmour's playing is not technicaly difficult, but impossible to duplicate. he can phrase things with 5 simple notes that will just torture your soul.....
@Mancunion1976 Just goes to show the sound is in the player. People can play guitars like David Gilmour's guitars, but only David Gilmour can play like David Gilmour.
@Mancunion1976 It must be my ears and the fact this video is only 360p rather than 760pHD+. I personally found his tone was lacking the mid-range and sustain of the original tone. Gretsch tone isn't my favourite at all.
Mind you, I'd be happy to possess half of his feel, tone and technique. David Gilmour is definitely one of the greatest rock guitarists of all time. When I was a young teenager, I would listen to the solos of Comfortably Numb and tear-up for their beauty and transcendence.
@metalwarrior123 it is his fingers that don't have sustain not the guitar!!! hahaha!!! He is a good guitarist with great writing ability and good feeling but not a technical guitarist!!!
What a beautiful Gretsch guitar ! Not too sure if the tone is as good as the trusty strat though, sounds great in the lower register but a little screachy in the highs ?!
@MixatoFreeKill except for THE best guitarist, jimmy page. I don't disagree that fender's are awesom, just the one's ive played feel more like tools for music instead of, like, an extention. i just bonded really heavy with my gretsch
@SaypheZonE exactly. I'm not saying their not good, cuz when you find an exceptional one, it is SUPER good, but i've had a lot more luck with other brands
man where is the sustain in this? Gilmour probably had the best tone of any guitarist i've ever heard in the 70's and 80's, but this sounds pretty weak
its barely slows you down, and the reason i said he would sound crazy because with scalloped frets your vibrato is greating improved, not that his needs to be any better than it is
+1, he is a melodic genious. One of the best. However, this just dont sound right with humbuckers. he needs to lose that gretsch and go n grad his strat.
Gilmour has such an awesome melodic tone. These solos were written much like alot of his others He would just improvise 5 or 6 solos. Then he would go back and piece together the licks that he liked. Cool concept that helped him write some classic solos like this one. Love it!
@1swede1 I didn't see or hear Jimmy Page at all :S
lol jk jk I think David Gilmour is great but IMO I don't believe this is the greatest or any of his solos are the greatest of all time. Great but again IMO not the greatest.
WAY beyond odd seeing Gilmour with anything other than a strat!!! it is great But that isn't a red and white Strat!!!!!!! are we sure that this is the real David and not some alien replacement?? LOL!
@mfowlie6268 noooooooooo. i would have to say for beautiful tone? little wing was amazing but the guitar work in comfortably numb was amazingly brilliant. ( not that hendrix's wasent. )
gilmour put on some good semi acoustic shows but this song was amazing because bob geldof appeared to sing roger's part
666MattsGuitar666 2 weeks ago in playlist Uploaded videos
what a bending!!
wretcheddog 3 months ago
i like the smile of the woman at 1:05 when david gets his gretsch, she's like "yeah i'll have a great eargasm now" :D
wretcheddog 4 months ago 2
/watch?v=Pn9Mpihgon4&
/watch?v=Pn9Mpihgon4&
/watch?v=Pn9Mpihgon4&
/watch?v=Pn9Mpihgon4&
divinedlink90 6 months ago
I think that sound was ''a bit'' compressed!!! :)
Taldegardo92 6 months ago
if you want to see a great version of this solo, look up marshallmandan
LukeGuitar112 6 months ago
OMG Metallica4LifeDude ... wtf control urself
HossuFlaviu 6 months ago
OMG Metallica4LifeDude ... wtf
HossuFlaviu 6 months ago
"David Gilmour can do more with a single note than anyone could do with the entire fretboard."
DrejStinger1986 7 months ago 7
Fuck Jesus, this is my God!
Metallica4LifeDude 7 months ago
this guitar sounds BAD,BAD,FUCKIN BADDDD!!
2712985 7 months ago
@2712985 yes bad in a bad way :-(
phisterlogsauce 5 months ago
Bob Ezrin on David Gilmour: “You can give him a ukulele and he’ll make it sound like a Stradivarius.”
denooraM 8 months ago 3
he is one of the greatest guitarists of all time but it is all subjective just like comparing jordan with kobe
tonyhq1992 8 months ago
In all honesty I think he could get the same tone from a cigar box and a broom stick strung with cat gut!
WRAPLOCK 8 months ago 4
to be honest. I reckon I texh him a few things. hes good but im better
tarapinkerton 8 months ago
Another thing I read was 'Brick In the Wall II's solo was written with a Les Paul. The strat tone by Gilmour can't be touched though.
All about the mojo. ;)
GobBass 9 months ago
best guitarist ever
phreestylesk8r 9 months ago 4
damn just learnd that solo.looks like i need to learn again..just been schooled.this so much better than album.
jwithe1 9 months ago
The great thing about David's guitar playing is that it really isn't that hard to play, technically. But trying to play it the way that David plays it, is literally impossible. The songs he plays are of legendary difficulty because he puts more soul into his playing then any other guitarist out there.
Greatest guitarist alive.
Chompobar 9 months ago 5
Love this song i done a cover sang it ok! but hey lol have a listen
Liquadia1 10 months ago
for all searchin' the guitar: its a GRETSCH DUO JET 6128T
hasawasa22 10 months ago
Dude, the title is misleading
ElgartheWise 11 months ago
Check out the subtle texture he adds in the solo at 0:25. It's like a rake. It's very quick and subtle - you might miss it, but it's these little things that adds to its greatness. I love it.
USPoliticiansSuck 11 months ago
@USPoliticiansSuck That is nice
olivwa123 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A guitar is much Like a woman. You have to hold her in your arms. You have to love her. If she feels right, then she's the one for you. You have to show her lots if attention and take great care of her.. If she becomes warped or twisted, you can remove her neck...
davidwaters69 1 year ago
id give my right arm to play guitar like gilmour
angus1878 1 year ago
@angus1878 How do you play guitar then?
DanielxMovies 1 year ago 10
@DanielxMovies its in the pickups
frisbeedawgbob 6 months ago
@angus1878 Maybe would be better to give your right foot....
bsharporbflat 1 year ago 2
wtf... wheres the strat
jkhshsh 1 year ago
@jkhshsh this gretsch sound very better for the acoustic way they play
KoralieMegan 11 months ago
I agree the Gretsch doesn't have the natural sustain as the Start; BUT the Gretsch he uses here is what he used on the orignal recording of Confortably Num.
cardonajoe 1 year ago
i just love this guy !!!
one of the best guitarists in the world !!!
how he improvises during the solo is just great !!!
0123mala 1 year ago
When/what show is this from please?
ckolonko 1 year ago
yeah right on .how can it get better than that !
geisterbahn1 1 year ago
so you spent £££ to get the latest Fender Custom Shop Black Strat, right to the tiniest ding, and guess what? the man picks up a Gretsch and gets his usual monster tone... bloody great!
Mancunion1976 1 year ago 61
@Mancunion1976 I'd have to disagree.... The Gretsch doesn't have anywhere near the ring and sustain the strat has. Almost seems like Gilmore is forcing the guitar to keep up with him. IMO.
spartansensei 1 year ago
@spartansensei of course a strat is a strat, what I meant is that the gear plays a relatively small role when we talk about people like DG and the like.
My comment was directed to all the gearheads who spend lots of money to replicate Gilmour's rig hoping to nail his tone, but unfortunately you can't go buy is fingers and his musicality.
Mancunion1976 1 year ago
@Mancunion1976 for sure, gilmour's playing is not technicaly difficult, but impossible to duplicate. he can phrase things with 5 simple notes that will just torture your soul.....
znogypogy 1 year ago 4
@spartansensei even drum have no sustain!!!!
KoralieMegan 11 months ago
@Mancunion1976 Tone is in the hands!
iMpulZ 11 months ago
@Mancunion1976 It's 'cuz David Gilmour has the tonal-mojo in his fingers ;)
BlackBeltNumber3 9 months ago
@Mancunion1976 But When He plays with a strat The solo is better...
Salvodream95 8 months ago 2
@Mancunion1976 but i dont think its a stock gretsch though
tonyhq1992 8 months ago
@tonyhq1992 well yes, it's a vintage Gretsch, so I suppose it has been left unmolested, thus stock.
Mancunion1976 8 months ago
@Mancunion1976 Just goes to show the sound is in the player. People can play guitars like David Gilmour's guitars, but only David Gilmour can play like David Gilmour.
9537912rockstar 3 months ago
@Mancunion1976 It must be my ears and the fact this video is only 360p rather than 760pHD+. I personally found his tone was lacking the mid-range and sustain of the original tone. Gretsch tone isn't my favourite at all.
Mind you, I'd be happy to possess half of his feel, tone and technique. David Gilmour is definitely one of the greatest rock guitarists of all time. When I was a young teenager, I would listen to the solos of Comfortably Numb and tear-up for their beauty and transcendence.
CTuxford 2 months ago
Comment removed
randomtwit 2 months ago
@Mancunion1976
Great comment lol. Now they have to run out and drop 3500.00 on the gretsch
xD
randomtwit 2 months ago
Amazing...what more to say about it?
TheBeerdy 1 year ago
il piu' grande!!!!
leccesesempre 1 year ago
鳥肌が立った。
katryuki1446 1 year ago
???
dvdlopez1 1 year ago
The best there is !!
kokoxp1968 1 year ago
How does he makes that Gretsch sound like a Strat?
crazydiamomd 1 year ago
Muy bueno! Yo le pondría un poco mas de sustain!
elturquitokpo 1 year ago
@cortchubby You must've forgot Jimmy Page
MrSeymoureBush 1 year ago
why his guitar has 0 sustain?
metalwarrior123 1 year ago
@metalwarrior123 it is his fingers that don't have sustain not the guitar!!! hahaha!!! He is a good guitarist with great writing ability and good feeling but not a technical guitarist!!!
babisSSJ4 1 year ago
@babisSSJ4 what you mean, faster is better?
Brandon18valensi 1 year ago
if you want to know how to use vibrato in soloing this is a great example, the feeling he has - brilliant... thanks for posting.
gkpritchard 1 year ago
lol thats insane just switches guitars haha
metallictank 1 year ago
Great song!!!!!! I can listen to this song million of times
rafapencilart 1 year ago
david gilmour is a god
coortybhoy 1 year ago
hendrix , santana , gilmour the best guitarist of all time
imkg09 1 year ago
Gilmour is God. And so is Allan Holdsworth! And so is Steve Hackett! And so is Steve Howe....
cosmicjazzer 1 year ago
I love this song
billottero 1 year ago
watching his perfect bends is making my pants tight
KeatonIsFTW 1 year ago
What a beautiful Gretsch guitar ! Not too sure if the tone is as good as the trusty strat though, sounds great in the lower register but a little screachy in the highs ?!
MattScales 1 year ago
a fender sound better
riquelme64 1 year ago
Gilmour is GOD!!!
nandofer01 1 year ago
More feel than a large gathering of octupi.
Bonkymonk 1 year ago
bello molto bello
michele4710 1 year ago
this solo must be play with a fender xD
MixatoFreeKill 1 year ago
@MixatoFreeKill Personally, I think the Gretch that he plays is better than any Strat, except the original black one he used.
andy123456789A 1 year ago
@andy123456789A no..
his strat is like mine and all of strats in this world
strato is one of the best guitar in the world
expecially this type of songs must be played with a strato
MixatoFreeKill 1 year ago
@MixatoFreeKill Idk. I've never been a fan of the strat. I don't know why. I just don't really like them.
andy123456789A 1 year ago
@andy123456789A
de gustibus...
but there is a reason the best guitarist use the fender..
aniway i like les paul and prs too
MixatoFreeKill 1 year ago
@MixatoFreeKill except for THE best guitarist, jimmy page. I don't disagree that fender's are awesom, just the one's ive played feel more like tools for music instead of, like, an extention. i just bonded really heavy with my gretsch
andy123456789A 1 year ago
@andy123456789A except for my mistake, i'm not english,
your argument hasn't sense...
there are lots of awesome guitars i just said my favourites are cu24,les paul and stratocaster,
i didn't say gretsch sucks!! next time more attention...
MixatoFreeKill 1 year ago
@MixatoFreeKill Les paul's are awesome. I've never played a Les Paul I didn't like. And, sorry for misunderstanding
andy123456789A 1 year ago
@andy123456789A yea you really have to be lucky to get a really good strat. That or you spend a bunch of money to buff it up.
SaypheZonE 1 year ago
@SaypheZonE exactly. I'm not saying their not good, cuz when you find an exceptional one, it is SUPER good, but i've had a lot more luck with other brands
andy123456789A 1 year ago
This man's hands are connected to another dimension.
Bonkymonk 1 year ago
@Bonkymonk Smoke weed much? :)
andy123456789A 1 year ago
Im not worthy, Im not worthy!! Egad, wheres the the strat?!
SammyPrairiechicken 1 year ago
Interesting to hear these solos without all the echo and reverb.
1Doz 1 year ago
PURE GENIUS!!!! I wish i could play like that. Beautiful!!!
ThingsThatVexMe 1 year ago
That`s because there are no overdubs.
tonythetigerII 1 year ago
Isolated video from 'Remember That Night'! Definitely an AWESOME performance!
reckmaster21093 1 year ago
simplesmente maravilhoso...
vankrazypink 1 year ago
he truly is the master. I often compare him to dumbledore. He is simply THAT GOOD.
chronus888 1 year ago 2
man where is the sustain in this? Gilmour probably had the best tone of any guitarist i've ever heard in the 70's and 80's, but this sounds pretty weak
jackyo12345 1 year ago
@jackyo12345 It's the Brian Setzer version.
geojoey15 1 year ago
Well.........it doesn`t get any better than that
whyyeseyec 1 year ago
i like his strat more
john73a 1 year ago 2
He is the master, you are the pupil
gumma71 1 year ago
i saw in a website that this is the second solo after stairway to heaven
nawfalben44 1 year ago
@nawfalben44 no man, they are like totaly not on the same album dude. but that would be bad ass
baswee022378 1 year ago
wow
cookiescotthug 2 years ago
the master , what can you say but thanks dave .
helicopter666666 2 years ago 4
You're absolutely right
ZRUBAVEL96 2 years ago
he seems so happy...
GuitarMasterizer 2 years ago
its a Gretsch G6128T Duo Jet Electric Guitar with Bigsby
RT101894 2 years ago
i bet he would sound crazy if he played with scalloped frets
Savatage420 2 years ago
@Savatage420 whats that got to do with it? scalloped frets is just a feel thing. it actually slows down speed
BigDawg69wh2 1 year ago
its barely slows you down, and the reason i said he would sound crazy because with scalloped frets your vibrato is greating improved, not that his needs to be any better than it is
Savatage420 1 year ago
Any idea what guitar is this?
qwerty09121209 2 years ago
The wrong one
youcrayzee 2 years ago 11
@qwerty09121209
it seems like a grestch
factionn 2 years ago
Lawd, you ain't lying, THE Monster. Dayum! He's been making me crazy for 35 years....
Rittstuff 2 years ago
Full minor third string bends on a Gretsch! Sheesh! the guy's a monster...
6strngz440hz 2 years ago
He probably just lowered the action a lot, It's not really a big deal
ThatPinkFloydSound 2 years ago
@6strngz440hz Not a monster - THE monster.
cosmogang 2 years ago
different but great version too.
Amazing feeling... That Gilmour
fr06floyd 2 years ago 2
Yeah, great solo but I prefer the stratocaster version
Pentatonikus 2 years ago 4
@Pentatonikus - True - the Gretsch has a little more midrange honk - makes you want to hear the Glassy Strat with the nice spanky attack on it.
cosmogang 2 years ago
This version of comfortably numb doesnt capture the intenstity and darkness of the original. I dont like it that much
themann141 2 years ago 21
it doesn't matter to me, each time I hear the solo, I burst in tears.
aden2013 2 years ago 4
Agreed. Its pretty lame.
bosshallucy 2 years ago
@themann141 Not any echo or anything
rickheyes0 1 year ago
@themann141 that's the guitar I think it doesn't have good sustain
mouloudo 1 year ago 2
Waow !
sanremo01 2 years ago
wow david you are brilliant
Cyrax3579 2 years ago
+1, he is a melodic genious. One of the best. However, this just dont sound right with humbuckers. he needs to lose that gretsch and go n grad his strat.
t2t80 2 years ago 2
thats right... sounds better on strat...
aManiNsuit 2 years ago
@aManiNsuit Damm right
roqe666 2 years ago
Gilmour has such an awesome melodic tone. These solos were written much like alot of his others He would just improvise 5 or 6 solos. Then he would go back and piece together the licks that he liked. Cool concept that helped him write some classic solos like this one. Love it!
illaudio1013 2 years ago
gilmour semplicemente mitici
MASERATICOUPECC 2 years ago
He is the Greatest guitar player EVER, no one can match Him and no one ever will.
PINK FLOYD 4 EVER
w26240 2 years ago 4
Played the second solo live at my school. I was like God for a day no joke.
DiabolicalSchemes 2 years ago 5
same
Strangolation 2 years ago
Wicked!
DiabolicalSchemes 2 years ago
What guitar is this?
MRNEWBIEuya 2 years ago
looks like a gretsch i cant remember the model name
sacredgeometry 2 years ago
looked it up its a duo jet
sacredgeometry 2 years ago
Beautiful guitar, dave usually favours a strat doesn't he ? Nice to see him mixing it up and still sounding awesome if not better. A most gifted man.
texaspete66 2 years ago
Bow before the man who wrote and performed the greatest guitar solo of all time.
1swede1 2 years ago 45
@1swede1 this was the first time i heard this solo, and i think its the best solo ever.
calalo54mejia29 1 year ago
@1swede1 I didn't see or hear Jimmy Page at all :S
lol jk jk I think David Gilmour is great but IMO I don't believe this is the greatest or any of his solos are the greatest of all time. Great but again IMO not the greatest.
imdacoolio 1 year ago
@imdacoolio- Everyone is entitled to their own opinions- no matter how incorrect they are. ;)
1swede1 1 year ago
@1swede1 lololol I completely agree... you bastard :P jk
imdacoolio 1 year ago
beautifull nothing more to it
ShadowOfDeth1 2 years ago 5
Best Ever...
No more to say...
samsite696969 2 years ago 7
Agree completely!
fluffycheep 2 years ago 2
wouldnt mide having him as guitar teacher ;D
hubbalol 2 years ago
OMG
avasquesk8 2 years ago
A Master. I'm in awe.
zigarela 2 years ago
i remember this show he also played shine on your crazy diamond on acoustic
xavierslowhand 2 years ago
Great editing work on this one!!!
As for the solo... this is a class act, I just had a dream with this solo and had to look for it on Y.T. !!
elweedo 2 years ago
this is from some DVD?
thanks for sharing
estud7 2 years ago
WAY beyond odd seeing Gilmour with anything other than a strat!!! it is great But that isn't a red and white Strat!!!!!!! are we sure that this is the real David and not some alien replacement?? LOL!
deathtothebots 2 years ago
he uses that gretsch a lot actually
xavierslowhand 2 years ago
never seen it played on a Gretsch before,
Strat Tone is what everyone knows......
this is great though.
overandout58 2 years ago
Quite simply this is A Religous Experience
EriktheNog 2 years ago
this guy is an example , you don't have to be religious to live your life to the fullest
nomad434 2 years ago 2
Has to be the best solo ever! There is so much feel in it, not like many other bands that just play everything as fast as they can.
David Gilmour is an amazing guitarist :)
MrMartinJS 2 years ago 4
awsome
nojyor321 2 years ago 2
On the first solo I prefer the gretsch sound, but on the second solo its too bluesy, and not dark enough. thats just my opinion :) long live gilmour!
FenderCP 2 years ago 3
There have been so manty comf. numb versions.... they all rule!
92Dreak92 2 years ago
a real genius... dont Ive seen him play anything but a strat ( besides acoustic)
mystro810 2 years ago
Clapton is not God, Gilmour is!
cliveburt01 2 years ago 50
@cliveburt01 Gilmour is not god, Hendrix is!
mfowlie6268 1 year ago
@mfowlie6268 noooooooooo. i would have to say for beautiful tone? little wing was amazing but the guitar work in comfortably numb was amazingly brilliant. ( not that hendrix's wasent. )
bloodyterror09 1 year ago
@mfowlie6268 Hendrix is not god, SRV is
aloys69 1 year ago 2
@aloys69 hell yea
Gibsonbloos 1 year ago
this man is god
TheShitGuitarist 2 years ago 3
David gilmour is class.
imoldgregg512 2 years ago 6
His soli are so great
full of feeling and thy bring back memories
DuracellZwerg 2 years ago
Good work getting this video dude..well done!
bizzmashup 2 years ago
hail God!
chokooloko 2 years ago 2
His voice was too quiet in this version. Fantastic nonetheless.
Lunarvx22 2 years ago
that's how good gilmour is. He can make a near acoustic unplugged guitar sound bad ass.
that1loser 2 years ago
the duojet isnt any where near acoustic. im pretty sure its a solid body?
vezza94 2 years ago
Omg nice mix and nice solos :D
Joyster2212 3 years ago 2
i like these solos played on his strat by him better....still kicks ass!
Fenderguitars18 3 years ago
THATS HOW OLD HE IS? Oh well David Gilmour ftw
joshua0226 3 years ago
that gretsch is so legit
imdesigner 3 years ago
David Gilmour is the MAN!!!
666mooser666 3 years ago
totaly epic
dipam7 3 years ago