Pink Floyd - Keep Talking (Publius Enigma)

[KISSrocks419]

Was this the same stage as the one in th Pulse album?

[BlowoutBob]

the aliens had something to do with it.....

[TheVisitors2012]

Next step: TELEPATHY, soon?

[darksider7140]

u morons could not figure this shit out? 2 ec 2 ec 2flpnec think apples and oranges, pick one, cut them in half see over the rainbow, think like mario, think like be like do like alice dorothy hal charlie and willie and the golden ticket, show alice the wall and u see who is adz the hearth of the mother for sufjan keith krug and the rest of the ones who painted the roses red and came out white and saw the beauty in the guide to the galaxy when you see animals in the white house den uc-da lukn...

[tfkel]

3:40

[Tommygun1028]

Pink Floyd Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Pink Floyd The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video, please see our Youtube channel for link, audio/video clips, more info

[Hurtingames]

@jill9ify dumbass. It's an ear

[jill9ify]

woah

[TurboThrash]

I was at this show, best concert i have ever seen or been to.

[happyface4444]

The Prize is the Music Itself.

Speak-Dark Side of The Moon(Speak to Me)

Listen-Meddle(Album Cover of Ear)

Communicate-The Division Bell(Theme of the Album)

Read-Piper at the Gates of Dawn(Chapter 24)

[jill9ify]

@happyface4444 t was a nose on the cover of meddle.

[jill9ify]

@happyface4444 it was a nose on the cover of meddle.

[kjek1]

can anyone imagine what it must be like to stand in front of a packed stadium full of people and play the guitar the way Dave Gilmour does?

hes a lucky bastard, i cant even imagine how great it must feel to have his talent and showcase it in sucha way

[mostlyanthony]

@kjek1 Can you also imagine what it must have been like for David Gilmour when he had to work with such an impossible guy like Roger Waters? Gilmour is a fantastic guitar player and singer, but not so lucky as you think he is.

[Paj777]

RIP RICK WRIGHT xx

[ubertij]

I was here.... utterly unbelieveable! Was on the floor, did anyone here crickets before the show started?

[happyface4444]

if

speak is dsom

listen is meddle

communicate is division bell

what is read?

[ModernPlague]

@happyface4444

Piper at the gates of dawn.

[happyface4444]

@ModernPlague

nice catch. thankyou

[happyface4444]

@ModernPlague

now what is think(i thought it was speak :P)

[ModernPlague]

@happyface4444

hmmm.........Wish You Were Here!

[richymoore]

Enigma Publius, an anagram of "I'm Unsuable Pig" Maybe in reference to Roger previously attempting to sue Pink Floyd for the use of the Pig prop ? To obvious ? Or maybe complete shit . Who knows ?

[reddevilrip]

I was 13 y/o when I heard this son for first time. Pink Floyd is my favourite band an Sorrow is probably my favouritr song

[Muthaslappa]

ENIGMA PUBLIUS

[DiniMcGee]

I dont get that thing of The Publius Enigma, I have read about it but i still dont get it...Can someone explain

[Francesco66216]

hi my name is Francis I write you from Italy, but do you have the complete live of the Pink to giants stadium 1994?can I buy him/it you?can you send me in italy the dvd???how much does it cost me???aspect 1 answer of yours..regards Francis

[VladimirAndZurgruf]

This might help out if you're trying to solve:

Publius-Federalist Papers-Paper No. 11-Alexander Hamilton-Born 1/11/1757... might help, might not. Send this around to anyone trying to solve.

[KoolSpeed]

it truly is amazing how we can find things out like 2001:a floyd oddysey or dark side of oz but we can not find out what is behind the Publius Enigma puzzle.

[sbandat90]

0:00 0:10 wow

[9GRACiEBoO2]

I am so proud I was there. ha haha

[FreshRollyG]

Look into CYBERNETICS

[DelawhereRob]

Does anyone have a video of the full concert of this? The 2nd night when they played Dark Side? I have a bootleg CD of that show.... the Comfortably Numb on that is by far the best I have ever heard!!! I can't imagine him playing it any better than that! I will put it on here soon!

[ermachief]

I was there, my seat was close to this. It was the best concert i have ever seen. I wish they would tour again. Thanks for the vid.

[bons222000]

maybe I'm wrong but it appears to me that the answer to the enigma is something lame.

i saw waters a year or two ago in connecticut. it was great and all, and this show i'm sure was great, but it just isnt the same without the full, classic, lineup. too bad with the death of rick wright that will never happen.

[BazookaChipmunk]

Publius said that he the messenger was unimportant. But who sent the Message. Syd I think. Also, i spelled enigma using webdings, and found several suprises...

[bacofishtaco]

yeah. everything except the N connects...

[smackythefrog23]

@BazookaChipmunk either Syd, or Roger, both of whom were metaphorically at these show, in the form of the inflatable pigs at the top of the speaker towers

[nonsensesomeone]

wow

[wra7h]

ma publius... ok?

[Kochiha]

The "ma" is short for "enigma". It refers to the Publius Enigma, something that refers to how there is supposedly some kind of enigma hidden within the artwork, lyrics, and music of The Division Bell. I've only just started working on it.

[bacofishtaco]

I've begun working on it too. It's amazing!

[smackythefrog23]

@bacofishtaco i have just in the last 2 days discovered this enigma, and it might be that it is far simpler than previously thought.

[vardocrux]

No, a person in front of the cameraman blocked the rest of the message, in photos appear clearly "ENIGMA PUBLIUS"

[wispa1a]

@vardocrux anyone finished this puzzle??

[vardocrux]

@wispa1a No, The Publius enigma game was dropped, and today it remains unsolved. However the game was acknowledged as official by Nick Mason in a interview when he released his book Inside Out.

[mcaz22]

I was at this show....Still the best show I have ever seen in my life from start to finish it was amazing!!!!

[billybats111]

i totally agree!! 14 years ago and it STILL was the best show by far. Floyd in Jersey....hell ya

[ohnjaynb]

When I was a kid, my family took my dad out to this concert. Now that I'm older, I know that I'm so lucky I was able to go.

[SydZanza]

around 3:40 - along the front of the stage

[ZZtopVH]

thank u thank u thank u thank u thank u!

ew, that is sooo sweet

[ZZtopVH]

I'm so interested in the enigma, this video means a lot to me. Just 1 thing...I don'tt see where it says ENIGMA, PUBLIUS

help please?

[xubens]

Isso Pink! você é o melhor estratergista de marketing que já vi, sinceramente. Atraiu o publico pela curiosidade de um suposto "enigma" e conseguiu vender The Division Bell e PULSE muito bem....

parabéns!

[sttrogdor93]

please someone elxplain to me what the enigma is???

[prompen2]

if you wanna know what publius enigma is jusy search at wikipedia theres a lot of information

[davidianC]

it's a feedback loop

[diogoneves4]

maybe the enigma is not possible to solve...it's just a way pink floyd create for humans never stop comunicate...cause it's something that has no answer and people will never stop trying to solve it, always comunicating with each other..just a thought

[Bluesub6]

Or...it was just a ploy by the record company to generate interest in the album.

[EHeroChaosNeos]

Or maybe Publius was lying and he was just screwing around with everybody.

just a thought.

[unfunkit]

or maybe a way to sell more copies or watever

[EHeroFlareNeos]

yeah maybe

[unfunkit]

you have to admit, it would've been a funny trick if it was fake, or a huge suprise if it was real

[EHeroFlareNeos]

yeah that would be funny

[unfunkit]

funny for you and i, but not funny for the individual who spent his entire life on this riddle/puzzle thingy...o well, it happens =]

[EHeroFlareNeos]

yeah that's true

[Wiccanvegan]

@unfunkit I saw this concert in Dallas, and it was awesome. Then I worked on the enigma for eight years, visiting via internet with people all over the world who were also trying to solve it. I learned so much about so many different things in the search for the answer to this puzzle, but to date nobody has solved it. I am definitely interested in learning if anyone does solve it and would love to know the answer!!! redheadwoman1966@yahoo.com

[guineapiggyman]

@Wiccanvegan its unsolvable

[Kochiha]

No, it's definitely real. Nick said in his book that it was more of a ploy by EMI due to some guy there who likes puzzles. The prize is apparently a bunch of trees, which may sound like nothing, but wouldn't you want a free bit of landscaping?

[lazerusincarnate]

ive only just found out about this, and its made me love them even more.

legends.

[CFMPmadSfX]

The members of Pink Floyd had to know about the Enigma. I still dont get it, ive just recently heard about it, and ive been tryin to figure it out. It's difficult.

[BBBDesafio]

I wonder if anyone will ever solve the Enigma?

[campfirealone]

nice 1 that's me off for a spliff now ;D has anybody cracked the enigma yet?

[Eduardo22]

You find this video pink floyd hub

[rashbabu]

this sounds better than pulse version

[dsalageanu]

great video, tnx! I think that the guy who shot this didnt realize what heappened until later :D ...

[turkishdagger]

what? where we going? of course,.HELL

[langesdenia]

i've seen this only in a picture, thanks for posting!!!

[wowser77]

lol

[vardocrux]

Wow! The infamous Publius Enigma!

[critterbug1701]

awsome. Where did you get this?

[reddevils87]

that was freaking amazing!

[solfalsv]

were do u get this videos amazing post more please ure the best

tanks

[vmoller]

acho que o cara com a camera nem se deu conta...

[wowser77]

Sem Nick! where do you get these videos???!