Always brings a tear to my eye. Those who did manage to sing the ave maria really must've felt connected through song at that moment. Gotta love the wonders of music <3
God brought me here ... this guy is from the heavens and he is down here to show us the beauty of humanity and the creativity of the soul that resides in all of us... God bless him.
@xsnokex Don't listen to nonsense. Professional singers all over the world line up to see Bobby McFerrin. This crowd is probably at least 1/3 professionally trained singers and musicians.
@mtnscu True, we have seen what Pavarotti does-or did. Ave Maria DOES however have vocal points in the song-in which as the description states "Bobby McFerrin sings Ave Maria". He actually beatbox's it. There is a difference between beatbox and singing. I am pretty confident that McFerrin CAN sing Ave Maria-kinda wish he did actually.
@tangledline Well, I see your point, and I agree. Though, with him, in this particular case, it is more about singing than beatboxing. I guess it comes down to the way in which each of us - uploader, you, myself, others - defines "sing/ing".
I like arguments which can still be kept in the realm of civility! So rare!
anyone who dislikes this is a moron... one of, if not the greatest vocalizers in history! Such an unbelievable talent and just goes to show that the voice is the greatest instrument :)
And if you're a true McFerrin fan, check him out doing this with just he and a cello solo playing "the Gonoud." (under "Bobby McFerrin - Bach Ave Maria)
performers separate themselves as much as they can possible can when performing, yet Bobby made the audience an integral part of his concert, including the children.
JESUS CHRIST IS A MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND GOD THE FATHER AND ST MARY IS MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND HER SON-CHRIST CONFIRMED BY VISIONARIES FOR 2000 YEARS.
GOD WANTS FAMILY NOT ROBOTS AND ALLOWS ST MARY AND ALL SAINTS AND ANGELS to HELP US!
SHE IS OUR MOTHER IN CHRIST AND BLESSED BY ALL GENERATIONS
"And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ." Rev. 12:1-17-Lady of Guadalupe
I love how Bobby McFerrin gets his audience involved in the Ave Maria version by Bach. It sounds so beautiful! He is so talented with the many musical improvisations that he makes, plus he also has a beautiful voice as well.
@Ramubay So being able to learn things from watching a television show means you were mentally abandoned!? How so? I don't think it says anything about parenting, but if it did, it would show that the parents did a GOOD job raising someone who's able to learn and grow from their surroundings. Certainly not something worth feeling sorry for.
@jadeinshades No, you're wrong, sorry. But, to put it in terms you can understand, thank you for playing, we have some wonderful parting gifts for you including the 2012 home game edition.
@Ramubay Well, thanks for giving me the opportunity to play, I'd like to say hi to my Mom and Dad! If it wasn't for you guys I'd probably be in a library somewhere making something of myself, I love you!
@jadeinshades Stay tuned for Card Sharks! (Roll Credits.) Carol Andrews, production assistant Jim Doll, technical director Gerren Keith, stage manager Jay Stewart, announcer Sheldon Allman, theme Ivan Ditman, musical director Richard Tugwell, assistant to producers Jim DuBois, lighting director Jack Black, sound Eileen Carhart, assistant director Joe Blasco, makeup Alan Gilbert, producer Stefan Hatos, producer Jay Stewart, announcer Carol Merrill, model Monty Hall, Televisions's Big Dealer
@aviopenica It's not the audience who's singing: the audience is in front of him; singers are behind him, on stage: choirs. And can you sing that piece of Bach so beautifully/easily without any mistake ???
@margot2001 of course I can. And, to b honest, here ther'are many little mistakes margot.I know not every "ear" can copy that, but believe me this Mc Ferrin is far 2 be perfect !!!!
@4530NanoMio Actually, this is indeed a composition by Charles Gounod, based on Bach's first prelude from the Well-Tempered Clavier. Schubert wrote also an "Ave Maria" but it's a completely different thing. ;-)
@4530NanoMio what are you even talking about Schubert's ave maria is a totally different thing. Bach composed the Music ( Well tempered clavier Book I - Prelude No. 1 in C major) and Gounod just fused it with his version of the Ave maria ( and no one said that his was the only one there are a lot of them ). Franz Schubert wrote his own music for an opera... i don't mean to troll but you should check your history before you make those kind's of accusations =)
JESUS CHRIST IS A MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND GOD THE FATHER AND ST MARY IS MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND HER SON-CHRIST CONFIRMED BY VISIONARIES FOR 2000 YEARS.
GOD WANTS FAMILY NOT ROBOTS AND ALLOWS ST MARY AND ALL SAINTS AND ANGELS to HELP US!
SHE IS OUR MOTHER IN CHRIST AND BLESSED BY ALL GENERATIONS
"And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ." Rev. 12:1-17
@Dankoeh yes, my friend, really. Don't get me wrong. This guy is very talented. I remember seeing a live performance of him on TV once doing the Wizard of OZ many, many, many years ago. I just felt like typing it in.
family guy brought me here
Philler94 15 hours ago
I used to bring myself here, until I got an arrow in the knee.
chriskras90 21 hours ago
BUT WHAT DOES HE DO?
ZOOOOMG 1 day ago
A link brought me here.
someonep93 2 days ago
r*dtube brought me here
ZzTVLzZ 2 days ago
Sauroman brought me here.
GiggleGumStudios 3 days ago 5
HOO APPA EY AH OOM UFFA AH OH HOO APPA EY AH OOM UFFA AH OH HOO APPA EY AH OOM UFFA AH OH HOO APPA EY AH OOM UFFA AH OH HOO APPA EY AH OOM UFFA AH OH HOO APPA EY AH OOM
elcipotio 4 days ago 2
Always brings a tear to my eye. Those who did manage to sing the ave maria really must've felt connected through song at that moment. Gotta love the wonders of music <3
MangaManiac 5 days ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
gotta see Abi/Ave Maria video...soooo cute
BONGOMAN3003 6 days ago
That was SOOOOOO Cool! Bobby Mc Ferrin is just amazing!
akurlich 1 week ago
Emozionante!
inesagnese33 1 week ago
beatbox battle tv brought me here
TheSaleh187 1 week ago
i came here from watching him fall down stairs
proshx 1 week ago
amazing doo
igorkun2012 1 week ago
awesome..
gabukas5 1 week ago
your mom brought me here, and to your bed.
longhairedhippie1 1 week ago
family guy brought me here
MrMenghis 1 week ago
My mouse click brought me here.
XxDaWnMoDxX 1 week ago
God brought me here ... this guy is from the heavens and he is down here to show us the beauty of humanity and the creativity of the soul that resides in all of us... God bless him.
FrankNazario 1 week ago
OK. This was FREAKIN' AWESOME!!!!!!!
BLACKREDTAILANGEL 2 weeks ago
Bobby really doesn't like to be distracted.
NiedzwiedzM1A1 2 weeks ago
This honest, spontaneous moment of music brought me to tears.. beautiful..
bodhiciva 2 weeks ago 3
"Weed brought me here" comment brought me here.
POPTAYLOR 3 weeks ago 5
I'm more surprised the quality of singers in the audience...
xsnokex 3 weeks ago 13
@xsnokex,
Apparently a lot of it was piped through from a recording
JanJiska 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
@xsnokex Don't listen to nonsense. Professional singers all over the world line up to see Bobby McFerrin. This crowd is probably at least 1/3 professionally trained singers and musicians.
yourmanwatson 2 weeks ago
Amen.
SiegfriedPretsch 3 weeks ago
Weed brought me here
ralphredimix 3 weeks ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Bobby McFerrin 5
Bobby please do Superstition by Stevie Wonder. It would be awesome!
Thumbs up so he may see or be told about the request! :)
wstKRYPTo9 3 weeks ago
it goes like this.. *tu tu tu tu tu tu tu tu..."
oh man he's tuned better than most pianos ^^
TheGrandBrand 3 weeks ago 6
MYSTICAL!! ¡¡MÍSTICO!! AMEN!!
magcarril 3 weeks ago
oh my god... i have not seen such an "attentionfull" person since before
algoppyrin 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Choose Your Difficulty:
Justin Bieber
Easy
Medium
Hard
Very Hard
Chuck Norris
Bobby McFerrin
defc4b 1 month ago
Strange, I searched 'bobby mcferrin' and that brought me here.
brmlolol 1 month ago 7
497 ppl are gay
ExpiredyourFace 1 month ago
@ExpiredyourFace and you using 'Gay' as if to replace 'Stupid' is both stupid and stereotypical, or if I'm right, Politically incorrect.
Stupid things aren't gay, and gay things aren't stupid. Stupid things are stupid, gay things, clearly are gay. :)
Mounce2 1 month ago
The blue link I pressed brought me here.
historyfreak10 1 month ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
The blue link I pressed brought me here
historyfreak10 1 month ago
The blue link I pressed brought me here
historyfreak10 1 month ago
Wimp.com brought me here.
LazyMustard79 1 month ago 20
@LazyMustard79 my cock brought me here HA HA HA I don't give a fuuuuuck who brought you here
frskatefun 2 weeks ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Bobby McFerrin
You know, it was much cooler if they sing the lyrics. It goes like "...ora pro nobis, nobis pecatoribus..." It's latin, but it's so beautiful.
duarterunner 1 month ago
How Cool was that!
oshia27 1 month ago
Music brought me here.
GraditudevsRevenge 1 month ago 164
Bobby is a true gift! With so much heart and soul!
Annie7970 1 month ago 3
What an audience! Most can't clap together let alone carra a tune! Oh yeah, Bobby was pretty cool too.
JustaSmuck 1 month ago
this guy is so peacefull
Cosmic092 1 month ago
<3 -<3 that's sooo cool !!!
kuroshitsuji56 1 month ago
is so beautifully :>>
vxvxdanielxvxv 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Bobby McFerrin
Great however he didn't sing it...I was anxiously waiting for some Pavarotti pounding vocals.
tangledline 1 month ago
@tangledline Any operatic tenor can do Pavarotti. Proper training, and stuff. But how many can do what McFerrin does?
That is the question. And the point.
mtnscu 1 month ago
@mtnscu True, we have seen what Pavarotti does-or did. Ave Maria DOES however have vocal points in the song-in which as the description states "Bobby McFerrin sings Ave Maria". He actually beatbox's it. There is a difference between beatbox and singing. I am pretty confident that McFerrin CAN sing Ave Maria-kinda wish he did actually.
tangledline 1 month ago
@tangledline Well, I see your point, and I agree. Though, with him, in this particular case, it is more about singing than beatboxing. I guess it comes down to the way in which each of us - uploader, you, myself, others - defines "sing/ing".
I like arguments which can still be kept in the realm of civility! So rare!
Have a great weekend!
mtnscu 1 month ago
Ой вэй Мариа)
Budeast88 1 month ago
anyone who dislikes this is a moron... one of, if not the greatest vocalizers in history! Such an unbelievable talent and just goes to show that the voice is the greatest instrument :)
bmiller1804 1 month ago
I have goosempups :S <3
STROUGIDI 1 month ago
A great musician show what is possible ...
I wonder how that would sound, if Jackie Evancho would sing the text.
Would it work? Would it be too heavenly?
bb4aa 1 month ago
Oye-ve Maria! LOL!
parentsofpwnage 1 month ago
And if you're a true McFerrin fan, check him out doing this with just he and a cello solo playing "the Gonoud." (under "Bobby McFerrin - Bach Ave Maria)
Catlovertea4 1 month ago
This is incredible! Music can unite us.
motorolalasershot 1 month ago
494 people are just upset because there is an ad inhibiting them from watching this beauty immediately
aiksmaster8152 1 month ago
493 dont know this song
TheWolskibothers 1 month ago
performers separate themselves as much as they can possible can when performing, yet Bobby made the audience an integral part of his concert, including the children.
clorychina 1 month ago
@clorychina There is a difference between people who truly want to share music, and people who want to sell you something.
eightbowl 1 month ago
I just realised how easily I cry.
SpitsBeaTz 1 month ago 2
Yay! Finland!
PorroFirst 1 month ago
i can't believe the audience was able to do that when like 90% of them probably didn't know it
animegalc4 1 month ago
491 people who don't know who he is
THEGOTXA 1 month ago
Somebody push him down some stairs!
8BitPicklez 1 month ago
Wow this version seems to show what's the real essence of music
settemenolive 1 month ago
Heart warming stuff. We need more of this kind off stuff in these sad times
TheWoodwyndman 1 month ago
chills up and down my spine
thaler543 1 month ago
he plays the microphone XD
1000crossfire1000 1 month ago
Esse cara é um show a parte...
fabiovieiraramos 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Bobby McFerrin
This is absolutely beautiful. The amazing art that comes from unity.
tashamisst1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
JESUS CHRIST IS A MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND GOD THE FATHER AND ST MARY IS MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND HER SON-CHRIST CONFIRMED BY VISIONARIES FOR 2000 YEARS.
GOD WANTS FAMILY NOT ROBOTS AND ALLOWS ST MARY AND ALL SAINTS AND ANGELS to HELP US!
SHE IS OUR MOTHER IN CHRIST AND BLESSED BY ALL GENERATIONS
"And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ." Rev. 12:1-17-Lady of Guadalupe
JezusSlave 1 month ago
I love how Bobby McFerrin gets his audience involved in the Ave Maria version by Bach. It sounds so beautiful! He is so talented with the many musical improvisations that he makes, plus he also has a beautiful voice as well.
grandmaangel44 1 month ago
mcremi u dick head have u got nothing better to do the post crapy comments bet u cant do better
TheLukem1234 1 month ago
i love that he gets the adience involved
TheLukem1234 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is crap, why do you like this please tell me, Im confused, it sounds terrible as fuck.
mcremi 1 month ago
the audience is quite good!
humbertsin1994 1 month ago
When he says the "oy vey" joke he looks like Dave Chappelle playing a white person.
MeinPoopsock 1 month ago
family guy brought me here
NMHAJA 1 month ago 51
@NMHAJA what..? :o
noideaguy 1 month ago
@noideaguy Ye check family guy falling down stairs, try not to laugh
NMHAJA 1 month ago
@NMHAJA me too, hehe
MrShaurd 1 month ago
@NMHAJA You tube is awesome.. it does take one in all directions..
helloayman 1 month ago
@NMHAJA fak family guy
KazysBobelis 1 month ago
@NMHAJA Me 2
isiilenze67 1 month ago
@NMHAJA I feel sorry for anyone who has to find out about anything thru Family Guy. It says they were mentally abandoned by their parents.
Ramubay 1 month ago 3
@Ramubay How did you know that? oO it was a secret until now
NMHAJA 1 month ago
@NMHAJA No, not much of a secret....to the rest of us.
Ramubay 1 month ago
@Ramubay So being able to learn things from watching a television show means you were mentally abandoned!? How so? I don't think it says anything about parenting, but if it did, it would show that the parents did a GOOD job raising someone who's able to learn and grow from their surroundings. Certainly not something worth feeling sorry for.
jadeinshades 1 month ago
@jadeinshades No, you're wrong, sorry. But, to put it in terms you can understand, thank you for playing, we have some wonderful parting gifts for you including the 2012 home game edition.
Ramubay 1 month ago
@Ramubay Well, thanks for giving me the opportunity to play, I'd like to say hi to my Mom and Dad! If it wasn't for you guys I'd probably be in a library somewhere making something of myself, I love you!
jadeinshades 1 month ago
Ramubay 1 month ago
LOVE this!
bluezandsunshine 1 month ago
I'm almost crying since it's just AMAZING... Wow !
RotoGluOn 1 month ago
I tried doing what he that sound he makes in the beginning......EPIC FAIL
FunkyPajamaMan 1 month ago
@FunkyPajamaMan lmao!
MsSkateboardP 1 month ago
Coooooooooooooooooooool...
FunkyPajamaMan 1 month ago
start 's in 2:09
AmadeuSitoW 1 month ago
amazing, clear and precise tones of the arpeggio.
7565plok 1 month ago
how can i learn this language ?
ERSAYK 1 month ago
chhoooooooooooll
TheOldpeep89 1 month ago
The guy is a geniuns!
NareNix 1 month ago
Needs more stairs.
themixedarts 1 month ago
Oi vey Maria:)
AnastasiaArad 1 month ago 4
Comment removed
AnastasiaArad 1 month ago
beautiful! I would have paid to see this concert!
garycalgary 2 months ago
intenation?
garycalgary 2 months ago
and how did i get here from dubstep?
MyQuickscopeking 2 months ago
Bobby's groovy :-)
perryinjax 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nobody plays the mic like Bobby xD
MrFunxy 2 months ago
Nobody plays the mic like Bobby xD
MrFunxy 2 months ago
? wtf
erichw23 2 months ago
(ich glaub derweilen darf ich dass)
((virales marketing :))
DaemonBright 2 months ago
NIGHTWISH!
DaemonBright 2 months ago
nothing special, and the audience was prepared b4, duh !
aviopenica 2 months ago
@aviopenica It's not the audience who's singing: the audience is in front of him; singers are behind him, on stage: choirs. And can you sing that piece of Bach so beautifully/easily without any mistake ???
margot2001 1 month ago
@margot2001 of course I can. And, to b honest, here ther'are many little mistakes margot.I know not every "ear" can copy that, but believe me this Mc Ferrin is far 2 be perfect !!!!
aviopenica 2 weeks ago
ma io ti voglio proprio beneeeeeeeeeeee <3
anninadif 2 months ago
Coming from a cynic.....this makes me happy and gives me hope for humanity.
AndrewDeLong 2 months ago
God's blessed us with one Bobby McFerrin. Thank you!
kwamepooe 2 months ago
One of my favs! Everyone did great!
hooliganwasportbike 2 months ago
whta presentation is this? is this on DVD?
alxluthor 2 months ago
@alxluthor You can find the DVD "Swinging Bach" with this great performance.
blootycess 2 months ago
Brilliant
kunleodebode 2 months ago
lindo
deatrancoso 2 months ago
so amazing :)
just sang along with this video in my choir class today!
dragon3410 2 months ago
perfection
thaler543 2 months ago
we really don't need instruments... we just need one another..
DaniHeroic 2 months ago 52
@DaniHeroic well said mate :D
ebbotube 2 months ago
@DaniHeroic hahaha great :)
Jejoisland 1 month ago
@DaniHeroic or we could learn to use both in an instrumental way
chraven45 1 month ago
LMS if family guy brought you here.
JustTheHDz 2 months ago
Absolutely Super! It makes me cry every time I listen to it. To engage the audience like this. And it worked out perfectly. Beautiful! Thank you!
Durvasa108 2 months ago 15
@Durvasa108 To bad its fake. BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
FunkyPajamaMan 1 month ago
Squidward loves this guy!
sgtwobbles 2 months ago
Awesome!!!
blessedcdc83 2 months ago
GOD BLESS HIM FOREVER...
Whoa!
onlinemeditation . org
fregetyoann 2 months ago
they actually sang along?? where they prepared for this??
Skiddla 2 months ago
@Skiddla its the choir behind him
Alexford24 2 months ago
やっぱすごいなー。
(Posted by Youtube Stream for iPhone (yst.me) on behalf of CBcb180 at twitter)
ystme 2 months ago
ok. now i see how he was presented in Family Guy. his voice is amazing
edwarlkd814 2 months ago
Comment removed
4530NanoMio 2 months ago
@4530NanoMio Actually, this is indeed a composition by Charles Gounod, based on Bach's first prelude from the Well-Tempered Clavier. Schubert wrote also an "Ave Maria" but it's a completely different thing. ;-)
pridoviolino 2 months ago
@4530NanoMio what are you even talking about Schubert's ave maria is a totally different thing. Bach composed the Music ( Well tempered clavier Book I - Prelude No. 1 in C major) and Gounod just fused it with his version of the Ave maria ( and no one said that his was the only one there are a lot of them ). Franz Schubert wrote his own music for an opera... i don't mean to troll but you should check your history before you make those kind's of accusations =)
MentalyDevistated 2 months ago
@4530NanoMio @4530NanoMio
Are you sure?
It's Bach...
Being pedant sucks...
fgcnunes 2 months ago
@fgcnunes
Oh Im soooo soo sorry!!
You are right!!...its Bach..not Schubert!!...=P
I always get confused between them both because they sound so similar at the begining for me!!..-.-
Soo sorry!!
My bad!!(=
4530NanoMio 2 months ago
I wish this had been in HD, how amazing would that sound :D
Honsokka 2 months ago
i dint know who this guy was until i watched family guy...
prboy931 2 months ago
@prboy931 you must be very young. his most famous hit in my opinion is dont worry be happy (1988). I was 18 then :)
zest8 2 months ago in playlist More videos from mojitoo
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU PUT MUSICALLY INCLINED PEOPLE IN A CLOSED SPACE!
kohakuinscribed 2 months ago
huuh appa eh ah uu affa ah oh uuh appa eh oh ah oppa oh iih!
Metzgerfuellsel 2 months ago 4
very beautiful!
ilovemarc90 2 months ago
Oy vey Maria?! Hilarious!
Marraden 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
JESUS CHRIST IS A MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND GOD THE FATHER AND ST MARY IS MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND HER SON-CHRIST CONFIRMED BY VISIONARIES FOR 2000 YEARS.
GOD WANTS FAMILY NOT ROBOTS AND ALLOWS ST MARY AND ALL SAINTS AND ANGELS to HELP US!
SHE IS OUR MOTHER IN CHRIST AND BLESSED BY ALL GENERATIONS
"And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ." Rev. 12:1-17
JezusSlave 2 months ago
dodedodeododdoeeddooodeeedododeooeoededededodeodo! :)
Beartallica86 2 months ago 4
@Beartallica86 really...
Dankoeh 2 months ago
@Dankoeh yes, my friend, really. Don't get me wrong. This guy is very talented. I remember seeing a live performance of him on TV once doing the Wizard of OZ many, many, many years ago. I just felt like typing it in.
dodedodooededododedoededededodododededoedodoedoooooo! :)
Beartallica86 2 months ago
@Beartallica86 hahah very good then =D
everyone speaks music!
Dankoeh 2 months ago
oy-vey maria nice!
Joty1280 2 months ago 2
This is more amusing then that time i saw him fall down the stairs...
southernclassik 2 months ago 104
@southernclassik Stewie!!!
CzechSlovakSongs 2 months ago
Comment removed
ROFLmangoasSOI 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
there are 475 people in this world who are living upside down and think they're actually pressing the thumbs up button...
jammynutnut 2 months ago in playlist Liked
That's it! I want a ticket to go see this man live!
mayhmong 2 months ago
the voice!!!!amazing!!!
vlatkaism 2 months ago
i literally just wet my shirt with fallen saliva
XDarkstarZX 2 months ago
now that s one talented audience
oquetemhoje 2 months ago 6
how cool is that ... dunno how i stumbled across ere but glad i did
bill30ism 2 months ago 4
nowadays rappers?whats a matter with you?
Aidanskate24 2 months ago 2
Thumbs up if you came here to listen to this amazing artist from the Stewie Griffin video featuring him.
watch?NR=1&v=XwX3Z5Er4jk
ArashiAiko 2 months ago 2
I just forgot about all the fucked up shit in the world for a few minutes
lennrt1991 2 months ago 76
that was AMAZING!
cool2t 2 months ago
like if you got here because of family guy
nerdyANDREA 2 months ago 3
@nerdyANDREA you stole my comment! it is ok though cause i got something to thumb up
TheOnlyGHero09 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TheOnlyGHero09 now i gave you a thumbs up ;D
nerdyANDREA 2 months ago
Jeez Bobby is NOT a machine, he is a maestro.
BasicBeatMusic 3 months ago 2
This is really beautiful!!
Outstanding! Fantastic!
WeSellHemp 3 months ago