@MegaGayjesus I think that's a great idea, actually! Have it appraised - you can go to an antiquary, or you can ask someone from the Baker Street Irregulars of the Sherlock Holmes society. The Museum may buy it off you, either the one in Baker Street or the one in Portsmouth, UK. There is one in New York too, if I'm not too mistaken.
Still, after you appraise it, keep me in mind! I've been a Sherlock Holmes fan for so many many years, and I would love to own that. Good luck!
@Serena2583 They beefed it up quite a bit. Holmes only mentions his engagement in passing, and that with an air of making a joke. Watson is rightly scandalised, but the event and topic stops there. We see neither the aftermath, during, or any reaction.
@FullmetalShortOne *laugh* oh, this was a bag of fun though, one has to admit. And remember: we never really saw Holmes in this kind of disguise, and Watson keeps saying he is really fantastic with women when he puts his mind to it. I was more disappointed at 'The Green Gables'. They have Watson get a good beat-up there, and Holmes' reaction is 'oh, you have a bandage, redress that'. Judging by the smuggler's case in canon, I was expecting a more explosive reaction.
@elenore88 So because the producer was a woman, she turned it into a romance novel? Why isn't it the fault of the screenwriter or the director, both of whom were men? This producer was also behind the Cardboard Box and the Dying Detective, and no one complains that those were made into trashy romances.
@brokenrecord64 no not 'because' she was a woman. but 'because' she was a woman with poor taste. And I didn't watch either of the above although I watched pretty much the rest of the series on here. Once she got her claws onto it, it got too ridiculous.
Poor sherlock ceased to be sherlock holmes, and became an overly dramatic version of a hero from a woman who reads too many trashy novels IMO.
She ruined it.
Do all women? Of course not. Stop trying to put words in my mouth.
great story yet again.. Mr. gelert456.. i'm your fan.. you have done great by uploading these jeremy brett series.. many thanks to you!
DrLifeBatra 5 days ago
This story is a wonderful study in the very underpinning of a psychopath in action, What an important study indeed in todays world.
rmpapalucas 1 week ago
A Classic, the best Holmes ever!!..Sir indeed, yhou hath done a great favor..many are the blessings ye desereveth..:)
OmarHaleemOne 1 week ago
@MegaGayjesus I think that's a great idea, actually! Have it appraised - you can go to an antiquary, or you can ask someone from the Baker Street Irregulars of the Sherlock Holmes society. The Museum may buy it off you, either the one in Baker Street or the one in Portsmouth, UK. There is one in New York too, if I'm not too mistaken.
Still, after you appraise it, keep me in mind! I've been a Sherlock Holmes fan for so many many years, and I would love to own that. Good luck!
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
@MegaGayjesus Ah, I can't seem to find you on ebay with a search. Can you link me?
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
@MegaGayjesus ^v^ Have you sold it?
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
@MegaGayjesus Do you have the same nickname on ebay?
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
mrs. hudson, would you vanish?
16isminedonchaknow 1 month ago 6
@MegaGayjesus Have you sold it already?
NekoAlias 1 month ago
Not a bad movie but a bit slow moving. Not a typical Holmes adventure I don't think.
patp464 1 month ago
That was motherfucking romantic.. Poor Holmes
vitaminas135 1 month ago
Sherlock kissed!! Good heavens!
royaljatti 2 months ago
I wince for Mr.Brett....yuck...
TheAolele 2 months ago
most of it is like the book but not all of it. :-)
shugochara0fortune 3 months ago in playlist More videos from gelert456
Is this episode anything like the original story? I haven't read the books and am curious after reading some of the other comments.
Serena2583 3 months ago
@Serena2583
You can read all the stories on line for free. The Guttenburg Project has most of them, and The Sherlockian has links for all of them.
JamesThompson1011 2 months ago in playlist Sherlock Holmes
@JamesThompson1011 Cool, thanks!
Serena2583 2 months ago
@Serena2583 They beefed it up quite a bit. Holmes only mentions his engagement in passing, and that with an air of making a joke. Watson is rightly scandalised, but the event and topic stops there. We see neither the aftermath, during, or any reaction.
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
@Midorikonokami I see, thank you very much.
Serena2583 3 weeks ago
Out.
Of.
Character.
AND not even "canon" if you consider "canon" to be the novels(which I pretty much do).
This is pretty disappointing really. I mean, I'm all for romance but.....no. Just no. -facepalm- Poor Sherlock....
FullmetalShortOne 5 months ago
@FullmetalShortOne *laugh* oh, this was a bag of fun though, one has to admit. And remember: we never really saw Holmes in this kind of disguise, and Watson keeps saying he is really fantastic with women when he puts his mind to it. I was more disappointed at 'The Green Gables'. They have Watson get a good beat-up there, and Holmes' reaction is 'oh, you have a bandage, redress that'. Judging by the smuggler's case in canon, I was expecting a more explosive reaction.
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
this one was produced by a woman. and she's turned it into a mills and boon.
poor sherlock.
elenore88 5 months ago
@elenore88 So because the producer was a woman, she turned it into a romance novel? Why isn't it the fault of the screenwriter or the director, both of whom were men? This producer was also behind the Cardboard Box and the Dying Detective, and no one complains that those were made into trashy romances.
brokenrecord64 3 months ago
@brokenrecord64 no not 'because' she was a woman. but 'because' she was a woman with poor taste. And I didn't watch either of the above although I watched pretty much the rest of the series on here. Once she got her claws onto it, it got too ridiculous.
Poor sherlock ceased to be sherlock holmes, and became an overly dramatic version of a hero from a woman who reads too many trashy novels IMO.
She ruined it.
Do all women? Of course not. Stop trying to put words in my mouth.
elenore88 3 months ago
@elenore88 Ouch :S
Midorikonokami 3 weeks ago
melodrama
elenore88 5 months ago
Sir, you've done a great service to us by uploading this legendary series.
gullkhan0 6 months ago 21