I think it is interesting that while Pharrell was in this ad campaign, as well as another for HP, he has mentioned and blogged on the BBC blog that he uses Macs.
Either way, I don't think using Windows is a bad thing, just thought I should put that out into the universe.
There is nothing wrong with using both, I use a Packard Bell high spec desktop, Sony Vaio laptop and iPhone for my mobile computing, browsing and music, for me that is the perfect combo.
Cause Apple is a corporation which tells lies to gullible Americans. Apple doesn't tell consumers about their vulnerability to be controlled by blackmarket bot nets and root kits to control the MACs. Safari was extrememly vulnerable at a point, and wasn't fixed until a month of notification. PC's have been around for years, and lots of people who do badmouth Vista don't know the capabilities of Vista itself, since it does work more efficiently, and prevents rootkits to control the PC.
Apple has just as many problems as Microsoft, they just have incredible PR, something which Microsoft has been infamously lacking in the last ten years.
i have a interview...when they ask like what platform and he says defiantly mac :) he may have a windows computer for music or whatnot but his main platform is mac :)
i think 15% of the music people are stubborn douche bags ;)
but yeah, most everyone in the music industry use mac, including pharrell. i've seen a video of N.E.R.D. at guitar center, and they had keys plugged into a mac.
thats your opinion. But if you actually sat down with a mac for a day, you'd realize how much less complicated they are. They dont crash and there are no viruses.
thats your opinion. But if you actually sat down with a mac for a day, you'd realize how much less complicated they are. They dont crash and there are no viruses.
it's funny what money can make you do and say ! If you look at some of his videos in the studio here on YouTube , you will see him using a MacBook pro ! Pc s are trash!
I think these commercials came out too late. Way to many people have it in their heads that vista sucks(it's really not that bad but thats beside the point). I agree with the mac ads that instead of spending so much money on marketing, windows should try to fix vista while making sure windows 7 doesn't suck.
I've been programming PCs since I was 13 (now 25) and have worked as a technician, programmer, manager, and worked in consulting capacities since then.
That being said. I bought my first mac a month ago and freaking love it. If I could work on one of those all day I would be soooo happy.
maybe you should try linux, most tech savvy people find it better than windows or macos... apple's mac pro and macbook pro are nice machines even tho they are insanely over priced tho...
ummm isn't it the mac commercial where they say hi i'm a pc and "hi i'm a mac" and the pc is the "nerdy" looking guy ? There's those descriminating "mac" users for ya LOL
lame. as a pc user still think it is lame. what does this verbal spewing have to do with computers. this is supposed to be better than the whole 'shoe circus' nonsense but it is just as bad. no one the Mac users come around to heckle. at least their ads are talking about the product
Ya thats true, PCs are really good fore some things and macs for others. There really is no better one, they are both just tools. Macs for instance are great for photography and video production, where as PCs are excelent for programing and hacking. These commercials just bug me.
ok ya'll are slow.first of all how do you know what pharrell uses to make songs,unless your stalking him or has been in the studio with him then you don't know if he uses a pc or mac so shut up.second of all he is smart.he went to a camp for gifted people,show's how smart you are.third of all if you don't get what he is talking about then why even comment the video.sometimes i wonder if you actually know what your talking about.
Hmm... He's not. you see him working on songs in ice cream vol.1 and he's using a mac every time. and for editing videos. Maybe he uses a pc at home. but for making music. Mac everytime.
I'm a PC because .... insert bullcrap energy bullcrap something about life ... music technology... Extended version is him waiting with a cursor spinning talking bs, then he says power button.
is funny when we all know Pharrell uses Mac ... and he is doing an ad for windows? and funny how pharrell wears bape and ice cream all the time and he does an ad for converse......
I rate pharrell as he makes good music and he is a business guy. But at the same time first he was advertising for HP and now windows, yet he uses Apple Mac products when he creates music. Check his studio time video's and you'll see. I can't believe he got away with endorsing products he doesn't even use and so blantantly as well
cool, i agree with him about our energies still existing--its called our souls! Our bodies disintegrate, but our souls are eternal...hopefully resting in peace-your life decides.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Very close Pharrell, but Everything has an end. Wether you or some rapper believes it or not. Repent of your sins and accept Jesus Christ as your Lord and Saviour. We all including myself will die one day, and where we end up depends on whom you lived for while on this earth. Eternity lies in the decisions you make while you lived. dont go on assuming or guessing.. Dont take my word for it...search the Holy Bible and ask God for guidance... Grace & Peace
Solar calculators work just as well as battery operated calculators. The solar panels take up less space than batteries do. They operate even without direct light. Why would solar power plants be less efficient that nuclear power plants? That's zany. I wouldn't even want a nuclear powered calculator. It's a small-scale example. Solar energy needs to be brought down to earth, as a real option. Let's face it, it's the most rational choice. We just have to perceive a method that pertains.
Your video is one of the top ten rated videos of the week on all of YouTube. No wonder we gave you some love on our channel. Stop by, check it out and dont forget to subscribe!
Obviously he speaks on the future of us humans and is exlaining that in comparison to a computer whether its pc or mac that anything past the on button on your computer is a possibility thats is unknown and through your computer is a lif that you can live without boundries!!!! THE COMPUTER IS THE NEW ENERGY!!!! THROUGH YOU !!!
can someone explain to me what pharrell is talking about and how it relates with a pc? btw it was Julius Robert Mayer who discovery the theory that enery is neither created or destroyed.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Another person who understands nothing about science, or would even be able to recognise or comprehend Einstein's or any other scientist's theories on energy etc, talking out of his arse. GG Pharrell, now run along to your studio and keyboards and stfu when it comes to things you don't understand
The Great AE would be proud of you, Pharrell. Very well put together.
rocabear 2 years ago
is pharrell making a music video in that??
and if this is true
what's the video?
sautuaps 2 years ago
to gnbeatz....what are you talking about? apple has just as many problems as microsoft?
Juan2142 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He's dead to me, ok.
kknev 2 years ago
nice taste in clothing. I guess N.E.R.Ds can be cool.
JMason814 2 years ago 4
Yup, no-one ever really dies's can be cool.
ThisIs2009 2 years ago
I think it is interesting that while Pharrell was in this ad campaign, as well as another for HP, he has mentioned and blogged on the BBC blog that he uses Macs.
Either way, I don't think using Windows is a bad thing, just thought I should put that out into the universe.
haroahyuokei 2 years ago
that's the truth
abelizable 2 years ago
Whats wrong with using both, one is great for music, one great for multitasking
add1ctedg33k 2 years ago 8
There is nothing wrong with using both, I use a Packard Bell high spec desktop, Sony Vaio laptop and iPhone for my mobile computing, browsing and music, for me that is the perfect combo.
derekhess47 2 years ago
sooner or later
davidstuff 2 years ago
So Proud of this dude! I too must admit that I was a non believer of his success.
tranchance 2 years ago
Dang he's so smart
tralynTM 3 years ago 3
pharell is sik he knows about the ENERGY disseminating
Ashantiwarriorkaos 3 years ago 6
BG= BILL GATES
ShawnT93 3 years ago
why he's a pc? why don't you be mac?
ConfusedSponge 3 years ago
Cause Apple is a corporation which tells lies to gullible Americans. Apple doesn't tell consumers about their vulnerability to be controlled by blackmarket bot nets and root kits to control the MACs. Safari was extrememly vulnerable at a point, and wasn't fixed until a month of notification. PC's have been around for years, and lots of people who do badmouth Vista don't know the capabilities of Vista itself, since it does work more efficiently, and prevents rootkits to control the PC.
xKopi 3 years ago
apple has been around for years, too. are you saying that windows has no vulnerabilities?
WellHowdyDew 2 years ago
Apple has just as many problems as Microsoft, they just have incredible PR, something which Microsoft has been infamously lacking in the last ten years.
gnbeatz 2 years ago 3
I am a avid computer use with both a high powered PC and Imac.
When it comes to stability and ease of use for the common computer owners. Mac takes the cake.
Believe that.
VarialProductions 2 years ago
cause hes getting paid...
but honestly, I'm sure he uses both. who really cares?
gnbeatz 2 years ago
His style's unique!
biatch0706 3 years ago 5
i got a pair of those glasses from hot topic
mzdores 3 years ago
Too bad it's not by hot topic, LOL.
xKopi 3 years ago
new rap called NEW ERA
rockin the west cost......
check there intro vid on ma page
deveiona 3 years ago
his glasses are actually RAY BAN WAYFARER!!
jon11259 3 years ago
wrong!!! crome hearts
GoChipGo 3 years ago
NO ONE*EVER*REALLY*DIES*
OhyeahSTL 3 years ago
im in love!!! he is so amazing
kikiDonQuan21 3 years ago 2
HE IS SO LIE SMART YOU CAN TELL BY THE WAY HE TALK.. BUT ANYWAY HAAH I LOVE PHARREll WilliAMS
iShay104 3 years ago
PHARRELL!! STAR TRAK! does anyone know what shirt hes wearin....pls reply THAT SHIRT IS NICE!
jameisbest 3 years ago
plaid bape
princeakeem08 3 years ago
bape
basketball08233 3 years ago
wrong!!! billionaire boys club
GoChipGo 3 years ago
Shame, I though he would be a P.C. Seeing he likes the elite side of life.
nbwinn 3 years ago 2
i bet pharell got a mac really
hotchoccolate23 3 years ago
i think i love pharrel so mutch! <3
he look so good;
kasia13144 3 years ago
if u wont his glasses google 80's vintage glasses and you should find it .. if u wont his hat go to google and search billionaire boys
ImaPcJussLikeBG 3 years ago
There Actually Tom Ford glasses there like $300.00
theneptunes234 3 years ago
Pharrell's Smart Im Still..... A Mac tho!!!!
djdevil0000 3 years ago 4
Sorry Billy, still a Mac! Nice try though! ;)
riffmanforchrist 3 years ago 2
I LOVE PHARRELL WILLIAMSSSSS
famousx 3 years ago 2
he uses mac!
powellYY 3 years ago
how do you know he uses a mac?
metr1s 3 years ago
i have a interview...when they ask like what platform and he says defiantly mac :) he may have a windows computer for music or whatnot but his main platform is mac :)
powellYY 3 years ago
he's wearing a BBC cap
mmaacc8822 3 years ago
what kinda hat is he wearing
mixmastericecreampuf 3 years ago
i think 85% of music ppl use Mac
hereistand2008 3 years ago
i think 15% of the music people are stubborn douche bags ;)
but yeah, most everyone in the music industry use mac, including pharrell. i've seen a video of N.E.R.D. at guitar center, and they had keys plugged into a mac.
this video is stupid liez.
gcab93atyahoodotcom 3 years ago
pc's are better than macs
macs are unnessecarily complicated to use
pcs are easier and get the job done w/o having to lose ur hair
sourmaxxi 3 years ago
thats your opinion. But if you actually sat down with a mac for a day, you'd realize how much less complicated they are. They dont crash and there are no viruses.
mabusfe 3 years ago
thats your opinion. But if you actually sat down with a mac for a day, you'd realize how much less complicated they are. They dont crash and there are no viruses.
mabusfe 3 years ago
Said like a person who has never used a Mac. Mac's are simply superior, case closed.
nbwinn 3 years ago
He walked straight past me in Brighton We he peformed For T4 :D
AnimalCrossing334 3 years ago
smart dude
TR3GGO 3 years ago
it's funny what money can make you do and say ! If you look at some of his videos in the studio here on YouTube , you will see him using a MacBook pro ! Pc s are trash!
dacoldtruth 3 years ago 3
lmao who actually cares if he uses pc's or not
he's gorgeous
bit of eye candy on the tellybox
thats what IM talkin bout!
hmmhmmhmmsmile 3 years ago
yeah does someone knows where i could get those glasses myself
ayebatonyeseigha 3 years ago
can someone tell me where i can get those glasses pharrell wheres???
cloverbum 3 years ago
any NHS hospital in the 50's , lmao
girlsdrinkfeck 3 years ago 3
he likes to say "either A)____"
mkz4321 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
pharrell is such a poser :)
GnarlsBtv 3 years ago
I don't believe for a minute that Pharell uses PCs. I have seen many photos where he has a MacBook in hand or Mac Computers in his studio.
He's a PC for money!
peziak 3 years ago 7
wow, shut up
jag7211 3 years ago
Get a life. It's called freedom of speech and I am just stating a fact.
peziak 3 years ago 2
ok if you used a mac, but PCwindows offered u a few million jus to do an advert, what would u do ??!
reekosuperproducer 3 years ago
ok..hes still gorgeous and he gets PC's as an endorsement..he dosent actually have to use it..& he can use both..its not like use one or the other
freshfaceex3 3 years ago
id use a mac too if i did music
stvsla 3 years ago
I like computers!
Revenge1986 3 years ago
im a pc and im with N>E>R>D.
breezybre277 3 years ago
PC rules.
Revenge1986 3 years ago
nice Original Fake shirt at the start. I want it.
CAZEMM 3 years ago
represent vb!!
autumnspell 3 years ago
I think these commercials came out too late. Way to many people have it in their heads that vista sucks(it's really not that bad but thats beside the point). I agree with the mac ads that instead of spending so much money on marketing, windows should try to fix vista while making sure windows 7 doesn't suck.
nyknicks2315 3 years ago
I've been programming PCs since I was 13 (now 25) and have worked as a technician, programmer, manager, and worked in consulting capacities since then.
That being said. I bought my first mac a month ago and freaking love it. If I could work on one of those all day I would be soooo happy.
xchivitox 3 years ago
maybe you should try linux, most tech savvy people find it better than windows or macos... apple's mac pro and macbook pro are nice machines even tho they are insanely over priced tho...
bmang33 3 years ago 3
this vid makes me tingle.
Know what else makes me tingle?
you watching the vids on our page.
its a matter of national security...sort of.
Do it now!Get into ze chopper!
somethingplanet 3 years ago
i'm a nerd 2 but no 1 would ever guess cuz i'm so goofy/bad i bad at math tho but science/history is me
nikelover6 3 years ago
Interesting pc videos.
wise2tube 3 years ago
I'm a normal, EMPLOYED, person. I don't have to have hair slung over my eye, a bandanna, or thick framed glasses to be somebody. I'm a PC.
JayDMusic 3 years ago
Who the hell is BG? Terrible ads.
svennybob 3 years ago
Bill Gates.Initials not familiar with you? I could recognize that within 5 seconds.
faysal21adigun 3 years ago
I thought he meant the rapper BG haha
rapman69696969 3 years ago
fail
HogieMorgan 3 years ago
MACS ARE PERSONAL COMPUTERS TOO WTF
richard833 3 years ago
ummm isn't it the mac commercial where they say hi i'm a pc and "hi i'm a mac" and the pc is the "nerdy" looking guy ? There's those descriminating "mac" users for ya LOL
dmenacex 3 years ago
THANK YOU!
PC means personal computer, are Macs not personal computers too?
(Noticed how the Mac users downvoted you because they know you're right.)
Dokupenda 3 years ago
lame. as a pc user still think it is lame. what does this verbal spewing have to do with computers. this is supposed to be better than the whole 'shoe circus' nonsense but it is just as bad. no one the Mac users come around to heckle. at least their ads are talking about the product
jayerb 3 years ago
Pherrell sounds like he dont know what he's talking about. Good thing for pharrell that the editors of this video want him to sound intelligent.
ReiKman 3 years ago
dude he was a genuis growing up we was a NERD that's how it started he was offered scolarships to yale in science-biology
comedyworks5 3 years ago
i love comments. ♥ ^.^ ♥
if u like comments please visit my page and leave a nice comment OR even better leave a nice comment on someone else's page =]
rmbmr commentlove loves U and ur comments!
commentlove 3 years ago
I'm totally a PC. I don't give what everyone else says. I like my PC. If you like your mac, Keep your opinion to yourself.
marianosman 3 years ago 7
i own a pc but i've watched this guy use a mac before
karlleeboy 3 years ago 2
lmao
Bojl95 3 years ago
i thought N.E.R.D just stood for nerd plain a simple. I never knew pharrel nwas that smart either
musiclov3r2 3 years ago
Ya dude these ads are terrible
Sampson021 3 years ago
its just windows wont stoop to the levl of macs level n iss just saying maby that guyon ur commercials is a pc but there r way better pcs
reid300 3 years ago
Could agree or disagree if we could understand what you're writing!
Lyk u no, wat r u sayin'?
patricktremblaymusic 3 years ago 2
Ya thats true, PCs are really good fore some things and macs for others. There really is no better one, they are both just tools. Macs for instance are great for photography and video production, where as PCs are excelent for programing and hacking. These commercials just bug me.
Sampson021 3 years ago 2
this has nothing to do with windows or computers it crap
etaisamocha 3 years ago
Imma PC mac sucks!
pinoy405 3 years ago
"Cake batter...........stirry things."
Intelligence is not one of his strengths.
doctorKilljoy 3 years ago 3
i'm a pc!
m3hm0 3 years ago
BBC PC
pearwil 3 years ago
so.....what did this have to do with pc's?
cookiejun 3 years ago 2
man pharrel is speaking so much truth for just one ad!
I loved this man I never knew thats what N.E.R.D stands for!
Kidcky 3 years ago 2
i think you are a donkey
electricsoulbeats 3 years ago
Life without walls??lol
If theres no "Walls" how can there be "Windows"???
KamikazeLive 3 years ago 7
where you get those glasses he wears at???
cloverbum 3 years ago
im a linux pc... :-D
dajtodap 3 years ago
Whats the song in the background?
1994CEM 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Have guys seen the new MacBooks? AMAZING!
jwil2570 3 years ago
"tries" haha that's good stuff.
shitcakes69 3 years ago
don't do drugs, kids!!!!
wolfmei5ter 3 years ago
again spent money for ads and not for improve the oS
rackerl 3 years ago
i think they have money for both.
okreset 3 years ago 2
may be, but there is a BIG different between selling an OS and improving the OS. Think Different!
rackerl 3 years ago
ok ya'll are slow.first of all how do you know what pharrell uses to make songs,unless your stalking him or has been in the studio with him then you don't know if he uses a pc or mac so shut up.second of all he is smart.he went to a camp for gifted people,show's how smart you are.third of all if you don't get what he is talking about then why even comment the video.sometimes i wonder if you actually know what your talking about.
ashysteff14 3 years ago 2
He went to a camp for gifted people! wow he's even smarter than i thought :D
1994CEM 3 years ago 2
Hmm... He's not. you see him working on songs in ice cream vol.1 and he's using a mac every time. and for editing videos. Maybe he uses a pc at home. but for making music. Mac everytime.
mumsaidno 3 years ago
I'm Gman6501 and I'm a PC :)
gman6501 3 years ago
I'm a PC because .... insert bullcrap energy bullcrap something about life ... music technology... Extended version is him waiting with a cursor spinning talking bs, then he says power button.
ObamaSupporter 3 years ago
OsamaSupporter, and your point is...?
Gintaras 3 years ago
For you, it's almost over now.
Loewenthal1 3 years ago
for whom,,,, pharrell ??
reekosuperproducer 3 years ago
lol nah, its his lyrics from rockstar. lool
Loewenthal1 3 years ago
haha thought u was slewin the man himself then, hiss resume is amazing
reekosuperproducer 3 years ago
lool alie it is
Loewenthal1 3 years ago
is funny when we all know Pharrell uses Mac ... and he is doing an ad for windows? and funny how pharrell wears bape and ice cream all the time and he does an ad for converse......
Junng 3 years ago 2
becoz he's such a highly demanded guy, he's super marketable, everyone always gets ideas and influence from pharrell!!
reekosuperproducer 3 years ago
yeah very true. Pharrell was the one who made Trucker hat popular. and bought the bapes to north america
Junng 3 years ago
No he didn't...hahahahaha
ridder1705 3 years ago
so proud of you boo cheers to you! smooches!
anyah88 3 years ago
uhh wow this video has 2 be one of the Silliest and sexiest vids online. just like me! z
bezrabotni 3 years ago
easy pharrell. JUST SHUT UP AND MAKE GOOD MUSIC. Period.
seganti777 3 years ago 3
props to p's glasses
where can i cop a pair of those?
anyone?
girlinthenoir 3 years ago
whats the song in the background?
bijinm2 3 years ago
I rate pharrell as he makes good music and he is a business guy. But at the same time first he was advertising for HP and now windows, yet he uses Apple Mac products when he creates music. Check his studio time video's and you'll see. I can't believe he got away with endorsing products he doesn't even use and so blantantly as well
benni1979 3 years ago
talkin with big words and about einstein..but doesnt know what "the cake batter stirry thing" is..its a spatula brother haha
cmrcr12 3 years ago
what kind of hat is that?
DMA1392 3 years ago
BBC - billionaaire boys club x new era
Junng 3 years ago
thats a billionaires boy club hat
bayo12 3 years ago
cool, i agree with him about our energies still existing--its called our souls! Our bodies disintegrate, but our souls are eternal...hopefully resting in peace-your life decides.
ReciaGomez 3 years ago 3
*cuts* Happy now?
Gartaro 3 years ago
This guy cut's through the bull and gets straight to the point in a very clear way.
Gartaro 3 years ago 5
He's a PC. It was so clear. He would tap pencils, cake batter, and stirrer things.
Remedaos 3 years ago
i LOVE PHARRELL N PC
youngin4life123 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Very close Pharrell, but Everything has an end. Wether you or some rapper believes it or not. Repent of your sins and accept Jesus Christ as your Lord and Saviour. We all including myself will die one day, and where we end up depends on whom you lived for while on this earth. Eternity lies in the decisions you make while you lived. dont go on assuming or guessing.. Dont take my word for it...search the Holy Bible and ask God for guidance... Grace & Peace
inspirationdp85 3 years ago
erm. one, not really the way to handle this.
and most of the things he was saying fits in with the christian belief.
widerangledotcom 3 years ago
lmao is he asserting the laws of thermodynamics? COOL!
IndoMan11 3 years ago 2
Solar calculators work just as well as battery operated calculators. The solar panels take up less space than batteries do. They operate even without direct light. Why would solar power plants be less efficient that nuclear power plants? That's zany. I wouldn't even want a nuclear powered calculator. It's a small-scale example. Solar energy needs to be brought down to earth, as a real option. Let's face it, it's the most rational choice. We just have to perceive a method that pertains.
StarQualityWins 3 years ago
Your video is one of the top ten rated videos of the week on all of YouTube. No wonder we gave you some love on our channel. Stop by, check it out and dont forget to subscribe!
POPTUB 3 years ago
i'm a mac. but i love pharrell
mjlvmr 3 years ago
Liar - you DO NOT USE PRO TOOLS on a pc at the studio, you just dont.
newagebrilliance 3 years ago
It is a a commercial for windows i believe also!!!
offbeetrecordz 3 years ago
THERE FOR IM A PC!!!!!!!!!
offbeetrecordz 3 years ago
Obviously he speaks on the future of us humans and is exlaining that in comparison to a computer whether its pc or mac that anything past the on button on your computer is a possibility thats is unknown and through your computer is a lif that you can live without boundries!!!! THE COMPUTER IS THE NEW ENERGY!!!! THROUGH YOU !!!
offbeetrecordz 3 years ago
can someone explain to me what pharrell is talking about and how it relates with a pc? btw it was Julius Robert Mayer who discovery the theory that enery is neither created or destroyed.
chrisok115 3 years ago
It's probably a commercial for Windows
FokWomanizer 3 years ago
ok then..explain to us what he us talking about
chrisok115 3 years ago
wat kind of glasses frames r those???? does anyone kno???
AverageAsian07 3 years ago
wayfarer
FokWomanizer 3 years ago
thank u>>>
AverageAsian07 3 years ago
I'm a PC...I just wish my vista wouldn't suck so hard
DrownedinDreams 3 years ago 4
im a pc, but i wanna be a mac, but i'm too damn broke...
mista925 3 years ago 3
Its a Bape shirt. If you look closely on the left side of his shirt (right side of the screen) is a small ape head logo.
Jayslugs 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Another person who understands nothing about science, or would even be able to recognise or comprehend Einstein's or any other scientist's theories on energy etc, talking out of his arse. GG Pharrell, now run along to your studio and keyboards and stfu when it comes to things you don't understand
totlolrofl 3 years ago
thats pharrell williams (:
who are you?
charliezxboi 3 years ago
haha
TheHardyKingz 3 years ago
Do anybody know what watch Pharrell is wearing in this video?
thub88 3 years ago
clothes
ThatAzianKid 3 years ago
pc=pussy cat
politpris 3 years ago
Haha, they probably paid him to lie about what he uses.
lpvids 3 years ago
am gonna be hones as possible
Pharrell uses a Mac
RealDefentertainment 3 years ago