hilary duff and joel break-up video

[JessLuvly1]

Nicole is a nasty tramp who has only recently started behaving. Whoever says Nicole is beautiful inside and out is TRIPPEN l0l I'm pretty positive the whole world knows Nicole is disgusting on the inside and especially f'ugly on the outside. To even compare Nicole to Hilary is an insult to Hilary! and to all who hate when people downgrade after having something/someone so good. I agree with those of you who bet Joel regrets his breakup with Hilary....she was so much prettier in every way :)

[thecoolestluzer123]

Hilary is beautiful, but so is Nicole, it's a little hard to decide who was better, because they are both gorgeous inside and out in my opinion. Joel and Hilary seemed like a cute couple though.

[SignLanguageFreak123]

Nicole Richies, is ugly as hell! I'm sorry but that's what I think

[oEZDUZITo]

This video is gayer than AIDS.

[JM4LAJF]

Madchie is soo cute! They're so happy, and happier than Jilary ever could be, so get over this, get over Jilary. Madchie is the future!

[jaclynxox89]

so they were STILL a cute couple. Madchie might be the future but thats only because of Harlow. you dont kno their personal lives, but this is just a fan vid. Jilary IS done. end of story. not to mention a old vid. im a huge fan of hilary and i hate her new bf he just seems like a snob or w.e. but i think hil was happier with Joel because she wrote "Holiday" for him, which the song came out in like Nov. 2008. not too long ago.....................

[JM4LAJF]

What? She wrote a song for him like 2 years after their break up?! how do u know it's about him? And wouldn't her new bf be pissed if that song rly was about Joel? And no, Madchie isn't the future only cause of Harlow, (another child too) but Joel and Nic rly rly love each other, TRUST ME. They'll last for ever, t r u s t m e

[jaclynxox89]

Yeah! I KNOW it is about him since she only had 1 boyfriend after him (Mike!) and they haven't even broken up, and it is a break up song!! Do me a favor and search youtube "Holiday" by Hilary Duff.. it has joel all over it! And yeah, I am sure Joel and Nicole are really happy together! But hilary and joel were happier, in my opinion anyway! (just saying) Also, Hilary wrote Never Stop about Joel on her album, Dignity, which came out in 2007.

[JM4LAJF]

I already checked it out, and i asked about it, they said it wasn't about Joel. And so what if she only had one bf after Joel? What does that have to do with anything? Every damn song you write doesn't have to be about YOU. I don't think Hilary wanna write 50 songs about Joel when she has a new bf, unless her intentions are to piss MIKE off

[emmersxyo]

they were cuteeee

[yAnim13]

perfect punkr0ck combinati0n ..

[gclove7]

aww.. I love you Joel!!

[aussiechickloveslife]

There are different rumours to why they broke up, some say its because of the age difference (but they wouldn't of got together in the fist place if that was the case) and some say its because hilary wouldn't have sex with him ...

but i think its just coz of show biz.. they wanted to go in different directions.. things got out of hand kinda thing =S

thats my guess

[gabe2pac]

joel ur the man

[smiley7925]

hilary and him seemed happy, and all and now joel seems to be dragged around by nicole... so why did they brake - up?? age difference isnt a big deal..

[hilarysfan13]

hialry is happy now again, so its all good :)

[xXxL3TiZi4xXx]

yes but in photos it seems that firts she was happier.....

[itsWasabi]

Hilary and Joel seemed like they had so much fun. Does Nicole give him more happiness? I don't get it. Hilary all the way ♥

[whollypink]

Joel & Hilary made really nice couple. i liked her better than Nicole.

[superiorANA]

god these fat madden boys must be a good fuck, i dont see why they get all the pretty skinny girls

[tightlipped01]

Joels not fat. Benji is a lil on the chunky side though

[superiorANA]

he has a double chin though i do not think they are attractive. she could find a much hotter guy imo.

[JM4LAJF]

No she couldn't, he is the hottest man live!

[elinapple]

hate hate nicole

[missFrenchgirl]

Sry but i don't really like nicole....i want that Joel the boyfriend of hilary is... HILARY + JOEl....The Dream !!! ♥♥♥

[justVme]

Nicole <3 Joel

[TripleB53]

ill always like joel & i respect his choice, but ive noticed that he smiled alot more with hilary than he has with nicole.

[goshxe]

JOEL is so stupid for breaking up with hilary

[tightlipped01]

So it was Joel that broke up with her?

[KatHiEx3]

yeh.. hils so much prettier than nicole.. bet he regrests it now.

[welcometoparadise]

@KatHiEx3 dont think so

[me93cool]

my god nicole for hillary how could he i mean a kid ? why !! they were such a cute couple with hillary

[bubblewrap77a]

Hilary is soo pretty how could he go from Hilary to Nicole.

Now his rebound got pregnant and had a kid

to late

[suyna30]

No se en que estaba pensando el tipo, Hilary se ve que más interesante que Nicole y mucho más bonita, pero así es esto*(!

[JoooooxXx]

aww this is so cute =]

[cinnderalladream66]

they were such a good couple and he just had to break her heart!!!

[rachieface103]

james blunt

-goodbye my lover

[HilaryLover101]

WAT SONG IS THIS?

[babyypham]

james blunt

-goodbye my lover

[troyana306]

deberian regresar buu joel deja a nicole

[itto44]

what's he doing at 0:31?

[MizzPennsylvania]

I WANT HIM!!!!!!!!!!!!

[pantysh0t]

I wish upon a shootingstar that some miracle happens and they get together again because I feel that he still loves her deeply and nicole was only a rebound :/

[Nikoslol]

lol they both stinks.

[AmberMae1015]

they were gross together.

im glad they broke up.

[raegirlx67x]

You know whats a messed up couple...

Marylin Manson and Evan Rachel Wood..

WTF

[xMiLKyWayy]

i hope they can be back together :[

[khemkumari]

is it serious that they break up?

[valemadden]

have you still got doubts? joel now has got a daughter with nicole richie!

[khemkumari]

with who?

[valemadden]

nicole richie, a bitch who's the best friend of paris hilton...:(

[khemkumari]

who?can u give me her pic?

[valemadden]

and how can i give it to you? go on google, you'll find a lot of her pic...

[punkrockalvin97]

hey i have some news u may not know Breakapartherheart. Joel is the father of one of Nicole Richies kids

[RebelessLTD]

Dude! Are you slow or something?!

Harlow Winter Kate Madden. Everyone has known about her for a long time now!!!!

[tub06160]

Who sings this song ????? I love thiiisss song. It's so beautiful

[voestods]

james blunt - goodbye my lover

[tub06160]

thank you

[kiswang]

its james blunt. goodbye my lover is the title

[mayzin2o]

omg theyre so cute together! lol. tha vids so sweet. =)

[LoVeIblink182]

joel and hilary were so cut! this viedo make me cry:'(

[eline55]

me too!!

[xBreakApartHerHeartx]

i kno me 2! i it sucks becuase i love gc soo much ad hilary's new album is killer 2 .ughhhh they were so cute 2 gether

well idk i love gc and hilary is a role model

[funkygal173]

I hate joel madden 4 breaking up wif Hilary duff!!! Actually i never liked him being together wif Hilary but Hilary liked him alot so it must hurt that he broked up wif her and for who?? Nicole? C'mon, hilary is totally better! Right?..

[Mixipixi2]

Totaly agree that Hilary is beta than nicole!!

[eline55]

i agree to!! i hate nicole!! she is so ugly and hilary is beautiful why has joel left hilary for nicole???

[moodiQtr]

Realy u guys i agree with both of u..

Hilary is much much better then nicole..

btw Hilary diservs a man better then JOEL.. =S

[xBreakApartHerHeartx]

idk but woah! why nicole she's an anerexic ugly girl and hilary is beautiufl! why joel! why! well...if he's happy with her and hilary is happy wiht her new guy then i guess it's ok....=[ misss them 2gether thou

[xXTinkerbell666Xx]

yeah to bad the name harlow is the ugliest name on the planet

[jonasbrothers2016]

whatever yall arent true fans if u were then u would want him to be happy. Ive loved the band since i was 8 and i was alwayz in love with joel i would die if i ever met him but i want him to be happy and he was with hillary and he is with nicole. Plus their baby "harlow winter kate madden" will be adorable!!!

[kiymet1002]

i hate nicole i swear to god i want to pull her hair like crazy =P

[ALYNINJA]

Same Here.

[iloveGCxoxo]

yea i like hilary more too shes more his "style" if ya no what i mean. but its his choice it maybe will be a good one or a bad one.

i only worry about billy personally lol.

[JTlol123]

i actually think hillary and joel had it good

plus nicole richies on drugs

hillarys not

[gerardwaymad]

nicole is gunna ruin everything for joel

[robloweissexy123]

joel 0mg u were so smart 2 break up with Hilary u r so better off with Nicole

[skiks1]

joel 0mg how could you beak up with hilary

[brcuriosa0obama08]

It sux that nicole is preg.

Now it would be to weird if they did ever get back together..

Too bad they made a NICE couple. They both looked soo happy together.. Luv you Hilary!

[GCandND]

Joel looked a lot better when he was with hilary than with Nicole. he looked so much happier.

[songwei27]

true.

[WhiteHeartCherry]

I Agree!!

[rouhanaelhage]

i bet if hilarys watchs this ! she would cry cause she likes that song!

[riotgurl202]

u have to luv this video

[ba11en]

u suck

[Shariiey]

She is beautiful

[randomized00]

i hate this song it sucks

[riotgurl202]

this song make me cry all the time joel and hilary we always be togeather on my mind it just sad joel didn't run after hilary and get her bac i just love them and gc and this video and song by james blunt omg i aleady cryin

[Josie107]

people cant really say anything u dont really now what there really like hilary could have just not liked him any more or it could have been the other way around

[licclesweetheart123]

but i thought that he broke up with her ! , i love u hilary ! she is my idol ! i some one like joel is very luky

[Didyouhear]

Hillary is stupid to dump him <3 Joooel< 3 And joel is not the kind of man who treat a girl bad,no joel is kind of a gentleman And i love him < 3 Good charlotte in mys heart <3 Joels sweet voice <3 But Joel and Hillary was cute together...Good video thow ! Thanks < 3 JOEL MADDEN < 3

[umsnake99]

i like both hilary and nicole the same. but i think that hilary was better for him then nicole.

[me122693]

she broke up with him.check tvtome out it says her friend said he wasnt mature enough for their stay together n u can tell he loves to have fun. but i think joel is dumb he loved her for two years and yet 3 wks after the break up he was with richie.she said she was sad and didnt noe joel at all cuz when they wre together he would hate when celebs do taht.check it out on usmagazine.but fuck joel is insanely hott!!!

[kymmhmgck]

hilary got rid of joel.

so hes not stupid.

it was her..but they were perfect, and i miss them together, and love them both.

[9sujata]

they're meant 4 each other! ........where did nichole com from?

[pinkspinker]

the sounds a little fuzzy. i like it, except for the sound...

[GCevule]

Hil:-)is better than Nicole:-!!!!

[elizabethtrzn29]

wow hes so stupid, nicole is trash, hilary is better in every way

[lovecherrygirl]

Joel wnt find a girl like Hilary. NEVER! believe me. he'll regret this. he gave up this great chance. HE'LL REGRET!!!!

[shift2507]

who asked u that,shut up cocksucking motherfucker

[nobodydoesitbetter17]

i used to HATE the idea of hilary and joel, but then i realised that they are PERFECT together! it's so sad that they broke up. joel deserves better than nicole, she's really rude and a bad example! and i completely agree with misslara. JOEL WILL REGRET THIS. and he will NEVER find a girl like hilary.

[pre3pinsk8r]

she ;oved hi, so did he

[Minireb123]

errr i'm not a big fan of hilary's but she's better than nicole!

[misslara911]

OMG that is so sad! She really loved him, and he just let her go! All I can say is that I am 100% for Hilary, and Nicole shoud burn in hell. You know, one day in the future, Joel will realise what a mistake he has made, but it will be too late. He will NEVER find anyone else like Hilary, and he WILL regret it, but all I can say, is that I hope he thinks that SKANK - NICOLE RICHIE is worth it. Hilary is the best one for him, without a doubt xxxxx

[gcbowler8]

hillary broke up w/ him

[KandiKan]

hahahah good for her JOELS A DOUCHE

[gcbowler8]

i wouldnt call him a Douche.....he shoulda stayed with her cuz then he woudln't've gotten what's-her-face pregnant and be pretty much forced to marry her cuz he's a good father and will stay w/ the baby.

[molsi1]

I don't like any of those girls.. Joel needs to find hemself a punkgirl<3

[KandiKan]

HAHAHAHAHAH that was funny. i pee'd a little.

[ride2livexlive2ride]

hahahahahhahaha ew!

[fabulousfan01]

i'm so glad that joel broke up with hilary duff. ps i HATE hilary duff. i'm happy that joel is now with nicole a funnier and better person

[xocatastrophie]

Bitch.

[xXgcroxxXx]

that is such a shame to show hilary duff while playing a James Blunt song. tsk tsk tsk...such a shame

[GrotesquexXxGirl]

I almost cried too...So sad *sigh*

[actorchild]

I love Hilary and Nicole.

[gothderdz]

so sad..i almost cried...

[loraleiandhaley]

they were so cute!

[salvesta]

joel u fuucking cuunt

[getoutwhileyoucan]

haha. im GLAD they broke up. i really dont like hilary. [[i used to know her, but then she got more famous. she called on my 9th birthday, but had to go to a photoshoot before she even talked to me for 3 minutes. i kindof stopped likeing her... then.]]

[PrK61802]

ok u really new hilary

[getoutwhileyoucan]

i did. honest to god. but i didnt like her. screw popularity, screw fame. they dont mean anything, the only thing that matters is how you treat people, and she didnt treat people well.

[PrK61802]

ok if you know so much about her cuz ur lying ur dont knwo wo she is how do u knwo she si a horrible

[plantman69]

can you say liar

[purplestar3d]

i didn't like that couple !...

[ko0olevilgirl]

joel has gone out of his mind for dating ms bitch NICOLE

[shafroyalty]

I SO AGREE!

[juzzme123]

this vid is so sad...*sob*

[xGlamourxQueenx]

Hilary was wayyyyyy to good for him anyway.

[getoutwhileyoucan]

hilary was too good for him? mm, try the other way around.

[maximekuh]

EMO

[idontknow1227]

This is James Blunt, I do believe.

And, I didn't think they seemed right at first, but then they grew on me. I thought they were really cute.

Jilary was a lot better than Maditchie is.

[lemmonscart]

who sings the song?

[shafroyalty]

James Blunt

[11barnk]

I agree with xpunkyXwantXacookiex... kinda... I mean I like Hilary alot more than Nicole... that stupid bitch!

[crazmo4ever]

WARNING WARNING WARNING WARNING

Jealous bitches are everywhere beware of them

[dsjacksparrow]

shit dude you're right... thanks for the heads up

[rabyaj]

I don't really like Joel for Hilary...

[koswa]

they broke up.

how sad is that?

sad...

NICOLE sucks.

[gcgirl91192]

i dnt lyk hilary nd i dnt lyk nicole. period.

[wssskid]

can u all stop saying she have bad teeth ok! she don't n you all are stupid 2 say that

[xpunkyXwantXacookiex]

8 year age difference? soo? age is only but a number.

but oh well. i used be to like: god i hate hilary!! but now i feel bad cuz they made a good couple.

[SkyroseMaiden]

cool video !

[puddycatdoLL]

They should get back together they suit each other,although it was hilary who ended it.

=[

[molly87659]

there is an 8 year age differrence so i undertand

[kajandra]

she looks like a horse..wiht her ugly teath..

[wolfspirit1313]

LOL!^^ I AM LIKE GGGRRRRR!!!!!! she is evil! and now nicole is evil!!!!!>,<

[dowlingchicks]

Ko0l, video!!! Its sad!!

[misteryemilycat]

thank god they broke up!

but i hate nicole!

[inseriousdenial20]

I hate it that they broke up, age should never matter if your in love then your in love there isn't anything that is going to change about it anytime soon. I love the slideshow though, perfect song for it.

[tudenina54]

they were such a cute couple! why is he dating nicole? is he mad? she is so ugly! hilary is way much better!

[cwitz]

so sad dat dey've broke up.... de song makes it even sadder.. huhuu... sobs..T.T

[aintgonnalive4ever]

it would be way better if the pictures wernt so blurry.

[funziegurlz77]

YESS!! they made such a lame couple but better than him n nichole...but if hes happy then so am i

[i9love9you]

at least hilary has her real hair and not SUPER SKINNY but ha=ilary is slim

[runerich1]

are they broken up now?

[HDvirus1993]

ahahaha!! since november 06..!! ...tsk tsk..

[xXMyBrokenWingsXx]

this is well sad, nicole ritchie is so fake.

[Evacheah]

they look so cute together..richie sux..she looks skinny and skinny

[brendamaryvdd]

OMG am i the only one that dosent no y they broke up can some body fill me in PLEZ!!

[Entwistle905]

Hilary got pwned! Hilary sucks at singing and this is in mushed quality.

[jenhymack]

uhh joel is not a goth. wth. anyway, joel and hilary make a waaay better couple than joel and nicole richie. uggh i hate her. i dont blame benji for being pissed off. why nicole..?? i hope joel and hilary will get back together.. they looked so cute and happy together.

[steffanyluvsbenji]

Yes it's true, they broke up in november, now he's dating Nicole (Skank) Richie. They are even living together (which by the way pissed off Benji and their neighbors ^^). I hate Richie

[tarzan16]

wow when did this happen? and is it true or just a rumor?

[Martrydom]

As much as I 'dislike' Hilary Duff, they did make a pretty cute couple. Nice video too

[2princes98]

nice video...

[Pinnaccle]

Very cute

[marinakt]

Jepp, Nicole Richie ;) Ther realy fith =) But..realy sad :( That they broke up:(

But..life goes on..i hope you two are good friends ;) From me (L)

[bogoshipda06]

Now he is living with nicole richie!

[watford4eva]

haha goooood she was wayyy to good for that fuckin goth, good on hilary :) shes way 2 fit for that big eared gimp

[JulietteFlowers]

estoy sper feliz x k cortaron jajajajajajajajajaaaaaaa arrriba Lindsay Lohan espero que Joel recapacite y deje a Nicole y corra a los brazos de Lindsay jejejjejeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[facethestrange]

oh....i cant believe they broke up!!!!i thoought it was going good too!! they seemed soo happy together!!

[woahcanada]

awww

they were the cutest couple ever.

i miss jilary :(

[Bahbsi]

they were such a nice couple ='(