Added: 3 years ago
From: VsefLian
Views: 429,802
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (335)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I used to have a Cingular phone.... then I took an arrow to the knee

  • Too bad they made her into a country artist.

  • @blessedcursor They didn't turn her into a country artist, she always loved country.

  • i remember when Cingular was a phone company...

  • @OnFiafoGod I only just realized how old this addition is seeing the Cingular ad lol

  • @OnFiafoGod I literally just said the same thing...xD

  • YEAH SORRY.... my mom had it worst...... she asked me once, how is love a "ferriswheel"? That is what she heard for 20 yrs....she thought love is like a circle,like a ferris wheel.....the poor thing!

  • paula is adorable in every way though...

  • Hahaha that's back when it was Cingular and not AT&T.

  • Great performance. The only thing that would've made this better is if she'd done Pat Benatar's dance from the "Love Is A Battlefield" video.

  • Paula Abdule, you always sound drugged. Wtf.

  • @dolassar nah, maybe a little tipsy....let's just say I'm sure there was a little more than just coke in her cup lol

  • I hate this show, but that was awesome.

  • ★ ...nuff said..well typed

  • damn that was good

  • Excellent performance.....Thanks for posting

  • That was rough !

  • You can tell Randy knows crap.

  • I have loved Pat Benetar all my life... I never thought I'd here this song sound this good by anyone else! What a set of pipes :)

  • It was a good performance but Pat is still the Tiger...

  • I like what shes doin wit her butt :)

  • WTF are the judges talking about?!!!! She killed it! She's amazing!!!

  • Man she rocked it!

  • wow. Simon said shes tryna be a tiger when shes a kitten. is he talkin about himself?? cuz i dont see that at all

  • this was a great performance

  • Sung well but words in wrong order.

  • Well she did great but maybe they weren't impressed cause it wasn't really her style... she shines the most with country

  • Whats this? Randy's hatin! Isn't that Simon's job?

  • ...............has she had work done???

  • The sad part is... People think now-day "country" is "country" but in truth it's either rock that carried over from the 80s and didn't develop a harder sound during the 90s or it's just stupid bullshit that follows the same suit that most people are conned into believing is country. Carrie as "rock" would've been better then some stupid shit "country".

  • This song is from 1983, when I was in high school. Pat Banitar had a very rebellious voice and had power in her performance...a rebel in every song. This is a very, very close imitation and it's a very hard voice to follow and do justice to it. Same is true for Bonnie Tyler. Very hard voice to follow and an icon. But all these idiots can say is "it's ok?". These idiots don't have any clue in my opinion. This level of singing of such famous 25 year old iconic songs shows real musical talent.

  • my buddy claims to have got a kiss on the cheek from her when he was 14

  • @monkeyrearend Who? Pat Benatar?

  • I love you Carrie. You were great. God Bless <3

    I love all of you Country Girl Rocker or Tiger lol <3

  • she sounds good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • curiosity brought me here and this is all kinds of wrong

  • Its pretty simple, a county singer out of her element. She tried her best. Not at all horrible, but not the best.

  • I love Carrie Underwood... but she was kinda off. I mean her voice was nice but what would you expect her voice is amazing. But her rhythm and timing to the song was off. Youtube pat benatar and play the song, then come back, youll see what im talking about

  • and now she's one of the most famous Country artists in America

    lol@Simon

    SHE'S A TIGER NOW!

  • She's incredible. And gorgeous. And just the nicest person <3

  • WTF A KITTEN WHO WANTS TO BE A TIGER???

  • Incredible- you are truly blessed! 

  • I thought that she did well. I liked it and enjoyed it. I listen to a lot of music from a lot of artists and I think it was a well done performance...done well enough for me to like her cover of this song.

  • Yeah she screwed them up but it didnt show hahaha LOVE HER!

  • I think im the only one whon notices the cingular thing on the side lol that now is called at&t lol

  • almost as good as the original

  • @TheChillSwagga WTF??? PAT BENATAR AND ANN WILSON ARE THE BEST VOICES IN ROCK. CARRIE HAS A GOOD VOICE BUT COULD NEVER MATCH UP TO THEM. SORRY

  • @XfuckyouX24 yes they are! but i actually got goosebumps from carrie underwoods version. thats why i said that.

  • No one compares to Ann or Pat!!

  • @XfuckyouX24

    Your wrong

  • @XfuckyouX24

    Your wrong

  • @edwoolful Fuck you ANN AND PAT ARE THE BEST FEMALE ROCK VOCALIST OF ALL TIME PERIOD!!! FUCK YOU AND GOOD NIGHT!!!

  • Wow, i didnt know she had such a powerful voice. Nice

  • What the fuck is wrong with the sound!!!

  • love is a battlefield eh :)

  • Hmm Simon. Now that she's a tiger, you look like a pussy.

  • From the expression on Simon's face, I think he was trying to hide the fact the he had a huge boner from watching this performance! Look how awkward he is sitting and notice that he only says a few words! I don't blame him, lol!

  • One of my favourite performance from her include Alone, Independence day, god bless the broken road, angel brought you here, inside your heaven and many more.

  • holy shit shes amazing

  • WOW

    That was amazing

    

  • ya who knew she would be sooo talented now??? lol

  • What do you have to say now Simon?!

  • Not bad....just proves how amazing Pat Benatar is though!

  • this is a hard song to sing, she did good

  • She can actually sing something other than COUNTRY?! Something Lauren Alaina is not able to do (not that we have seen anyway...)

  • Man, she killed it. the judges were Trippin'...

  • "Simon Cowell who?"...Am I right Ms Underwood !??

  • that was incredible. She can sing her tits off. What an incredible voice... and that's what those judges had to say? That seems insane... no wonder these Disney idiots all end up on the radio... you have a star like that in front of your face, and all they can say is "it was ok". Morons...

  • Less Tremolo please.

  • wrong words :P

  • LOL @ cowells comment

  • Wow, those judges are awful. NONE of them could sing like that.

  • Love is a Battlefield is one of my favorite songs. Even though she isn't as good as the original, it's great.

  • @CaptainessValentina IKR! but i <3 carrie underwood

  • Carrie underwood can sing every song she hears and every song she pick up

  • was she 16 or 22?!?!? i keep hearing different stories -.-

  • @KnowYourEnemys 21 at auditions might of turned 22 during the live shows.

  • I remember seeing this for the first time on TV when I was 10. Carrie was my favourite!!!

  • I'm Carrying underwood...

  • What was wrong with this performance? Nothing, I loved it! I'm so glad that Simon is gone, this year the contestants seemed more relaxed....

  • lol simon is just so shamelessly blunt. his facial expressions!! lol carrie can be tiger kitten, i don't care!! she was rockin it!

  • They're trippin'.... she sounded great haha

  • Katherine St-Laurent sang this amazingly on Canadian Idol.

  • CRRIE UNDERWOOD IS THE BEST WHOEVER WON AMERICAN IDOL!

  • I love carrie's hair straight :)

  • cingular!

    

  • Paula <3

  • I think she nailed it, they definitely over shot this one!

  • great performance!!!!!

  • realise they had to cut the song down but at least put the lyrics in to make sense, pointless

  • @TheDangerousKid that statement did't make sense. ;]

  • @TheBrokensinger1 lol :)

  • @TheDangerousKid I agree, If they had to cut the song, why not just do the first verse? But yeah, she did a great cover.

  • shoot fuck the damn judges i think that she waws awesome and i hav stuck with her since the beginning :D!!!!!!

  • she did get the words wrong tho....she missed "heartache to heartache we stand"

  • @RiotGrrrL89 she never missed it they just have to cut the song short and make a short verison to sing as not time to sing all of it so they never did the first part.

  • I think she SLLLLAYYED IT!

  • oh this is not good

  • Grest

  • Man Simon was fat that time. & Ryan was HOT.

  • I love Carrie Underwood .Her and Kelly Clarkson are my favourite singers from American Idol. I never heard of Carrie until 2007 when I heard her singing that song Ever Ever After from Enchanted.

  • i think this is my favorite AI performance of hers...its so awesome!

  • Carrie has a beautiful voice and is a true idol

  • Maybe missed a note or two, but Pat Benatar would be proud of this performance

  • idk why the judges try to keep her from trying new things! shouldnt that be a good thing??! This is such and amazing performance

  • HELL YEAH!!!!!

  • Jeez. So lame. Where's Brooke White?

  • she did good no great!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • She definately did this song justice Carrie is pretty amazing i'm a big fan

  • carrie is seriously so amazing there is no one better then her on the planet

  • @kellytaylorjenegarth Do you even know her? Didnt think so.

  • @DarbyKill87 uummm at singing

  • nobody can sing as good as pat benatar.

  • i didnt even notice she messed the words up

  • carrie underwood and kelly clarkson

    are the only the only stars that won this show.

    you find a winner every season

    but not a star.

    carrie is just amazing.

    i love her so much.

  • @livetodancexox thats so not the case.... did u witness season 3 wen FANTASIA WON?? clearly u dont know music cause fantasia was a star then and even more now. oh yea i likes kelly. she kool 2

  • @WesleySmith2012 please. fantasia needs sex scandals and all that BS to maintain album sales and to stay relevant, you NEVER hear ANYTHING bad kelly or carrie, and they sell good and deliver a good performance. im not saying fantasia isnt talented bc id be lieing if i said she wasn't. but all the other AI winners who won this show faded out and didnt have the longevity to last that a true star has. like kelly Clarkson or carrie underwood. not everyone has that factor.

  • @livetodancexox  fantasia is complete crap that is all.

  • @jefehbk i dont think fantasia is crap. she does have a nice soulful voice. but not everyone has staying power or the it factor that carrie underwood has. she sells albums and manages no controversy right when those albums comes out. she gets the attention through music. and same thing w. kelly. not a lot of artists do that. half the hollywood drama is made up. you know if they have a movie or album coming out.

  • @livetodancexox well jordin sparks is good also i like her carrie underwood and kelly clarkson

  • @livetodancexox

    David cook. and i know Scotty will and Lauran. :>)

  • @mitchanderson7 they are all good. but david faded out awhile ago. im not saying the other stars aren't talented but many stars not just from AI can't maintain the fame for long because they dont have staying power that few others do. thats just hollywood. some ppl are born to be a star, some people are born to be a singer. both are lucky.

  • @livetodancexox OMG i couldnt have agreed with u more. I've been saying this same thing for years and years, to me Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood are the ones that I will ever acknowledge as true American Idols. I just love them two and since I saw them audition I've had my eye set on em XD

  • @icehearts01 me too! they are just fabulous!

  • @livetodancexox umm no jordin sparks umm pia toscano scotty mcreery and david cook david archeleta and there all good

  • @bigs19761 none those people have the star factor that Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood have. You can argue all day but thats not an opinion its a FACT! I never said they were not all good, of course they are talented but most people from american idol whether than win or lose do not last very long afterword. Its only Kelly and Carrie who go to number one and STAY at number and win countless number of awards and sell out massive arenas. Not everyone is cut out to be a star. Its rare.

  • @bigs19761 (cont) even Simon Cowell will agree. He is right everytime. He made a prediction saying that not only will Carrie win the show but she will go on to sell more records than anyone ever will in Idol history. and maintain superstar status. she did all of that. you can not say the same about the other contestants. No one went farther than Kelly and Carrie from this show.

  • @livetodancexox Perfectly said.

  • @livetodancexox You obviously don't know what a "star" is...for you to say that only Kelly and Carrie are the stars in this show is so inaccurate. How old are you?

  • @alexgarner22 um that does have a lot of truth to it. Look at all the other winners of American Idol. Their 15 minutes ended a long time ago.You don't hear about them,their music is NEVER on the radio or charts, (i listen to the radio all day and all night and all kinds of radio (r&b, country, pop,etc) Now part of being a star is good sales and airplay. The only STARS from american Idol people ever talk about and or buy albums are Kelly and Carrie. And i have FACTS and stats to back that up.

  • @alexgarner22 (cont) There are a lot of good singers on American Idol but just because they are on a singing show doesn't mean they are gonna be a star. A lot of the fade out afterward. A star has LONGEVITY meaning they can last a long time in the industry and do well with all their projects.Not everyone has staying power. Kelly had one road bump with the My December album not selling as much as her past albums but brought it back. and clearly a lot more people agree with me. so good day

  • @alexgarner22 (cont)You won't find a star every season. Thats a fact. Now, there are some stars who did NOT win the show but ended up making a good name for themselves like Daughtery and Jennifer Hudson. But anyways, go look at sales, popularity, award wins, etc it is all Kelly and Carrie maintaining it thru the years. whether you wanna believe it or not

  • @livetodancexox  i totally agree with you there Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson are by far the two amazing women from American Idol

  • Randy annoys me. D:

  • Stupid judges... She was AMAZING!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @alohasx7261 yoս ϲаո wаtϲh tv frοm all over tհe ԝοrld οո yοur pс ϳuѕt by dοԝnloаdіոg sοme рrοgram, it'ѕ gοt tհousаnds οf ϲհаnոels οn it. ϳust ցo tο linevid com (рut a . beforе thе сοm obviously, іt woո't let me pοѕt liոkѕ for sοmе reasoո) іt's not eхactly frеe but іt's just oոе tіmе рayment aոd іt ԝorks reаlly well

  • The judges comments are funny, especially after she has had 2 triple platinum albums.

  • Lol I love the judges comments...if she did this in Holland they would praise her into heaven and the judges would be standing and dancing on the table of excitement.

  • I love her voice!! And this sounded REALLY great!! love her!!

  • What part did she mess up the words?

    And is this country rock? 

  • @LoboWarriorForever at 1:23 she sings "No promises no demands", she should have sung "Searching our hearts for so long".

    Either way, she did a great job on this song.

  • @LoboWarriorForever its juts 80s rock she made itsouthern rock though cuz thats what country rock is called southern rock lol and idk what she messed up on everytime i listen to it then the original i cant find the part she messed up according to them

  • Comment removed

  • Pat is better, but this is alright

  • very well sung, i never knew she was so hot...

  • :o omg simon is fat

  • I remember in the news after this was on TV they said something about her hip, like she was hurt or something. can't remember :)

  • I like this just as much as the Pat Benetar version tbh

  • AWESOME!!!!!

  • pitchy notes my ass.

  • Exactly!

  • This was amazing and a different side to Carrie then were used to

  • It's not that this version is bad, it's just that she's trying way to hard to push her voice to a level it's not meant to go. She should have sung the song in her own style. That said, I like Brooke White's version much better because she interprets the song in a way that fits her voice so beautifully.

  • "Watching a kitten who wants to be a tiger"? I'd love to hear the judge's thoughts on Carrie rocking out to Paradise City. :P

    I love her as a country artist and that's where her heart is, but girl definitely knows how to rock out.

  • I love watching this video and seeing randy and simon hate on her

    look at last season of idol LOL.

    i don't know how any of them got good comments

  • she really knows how to sing and bring out the lyrics

  • Her such a small girl but, she has a big voice.

  • how the hell did they not like it? she did an amazing job I swear this girl can sing any song and make it sound good

  • Is there any song she can't sing?

  • They sure cut that song up in lots of places but...I still loved it, Carrie covered Heart and Pat Benatar? I love it.

  • i hate simon!!!!

  • I dont understand why she sings country she should sing all genres country is just boring sometimes sorry but carrie rocks!!!!

  • @freddyncarrie2005 I think she is a country pop artist. She sings with such a strong emotion!!

  • she has the best natural voice i've ever heard

  • Carrie Underwood is SO fucking beautiful.

  • Was Simon's comment a compliment or a diss?

  • wow she is AMAZING!

  • Thumbs up who clicked on this vid because od southpark.

  • she did great!!

  • That was freakin' amazing. so powerful.

  • This just shows that Carrie can do ANYTHING!!!! She is awesome

  • i love how she gets shit on after rocking the song

  • I love Simon Cowell's remark...,,lol check it out

  • what is she doing singing fkin countryy shee rockss!!