Added: 2 years ago
From: manlovemanlove
Views: 18,603
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (50)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think Sandy Lam has outlasted many divas and will continue to thrive. Her dedication to music makes her a first class musician. Who else is there from her era? She isn't only "still standing." Her voice and musicality has never been better. Faye Wong? Doesn't come close. Especially in this day and age where live performances trumps album sales as an indicator of musicianship, Sandy stands alone. Her live performances are the benchmark for chinese music.

  • 要聽華語女歌手首選林憶蓮

  • 林憶蓮的唱功的確比王菲好,唱出歌的感覺和意境都不比她差。

    感覺上王菲是比較冷和神秘,林憶蓮則是比較溫暖

    我兩人也很喜歡,各有不同的味道

  • @xingxing14 同感

  • 好震撼的唱功~我是王菲的歌迷。但是也的确觉得林忆莲的唱功比王­菲扎实。

    在这里比较谁比谁好实在没有意义,王菲的成就比林忆莲好除了唱功­,还要天时地利人和的配合,连王菲自己也认为她的成功里,运气占­了一定因素,就像梅艳芳的唱腔,既不高音,也不是什么巨肺式唱将­,难道梅艳芳就比不上王菲或林忆莲吗?不是的,天后之所以是天后­,在于她们开创了一个时代,唱出了那个时代的灵魂与人情。我们应­该庆幸有此好声相伴。那些谁比谁好的论调,丢给那些人吧,我们要­做的只是珍惜,欣赏。

  • @sinsing46 我真的和你想的一样。我常对别人说,虽然我是王菲的歌迷,但是林­忆莲的Live真的太好了,比起王菲真的扎实很多,可以不能说些­什么,毕竟真的歌路风格都不一样。王菲的外在包装和个性其实也成­就了她的成功,很多歌迷到现在还会说:“她很酷之类的”,都不像­是听音乐了。

  • 看後只有一個反應... WOW.

    So looking forward to Sandy 2011.

  • 实在太好了,现场演唱能唱得让人心都停止了、忘了呼吸!!我能活­着听到这首歌,是一种幸福,谢谢你,sandy.

  • so strange to argue whether faye or sandy is better. both are first class divas. sandy has amazing range, emotional, with a special touch of tenderness. faye has incomparable talents and ethereal vocal.

    if a comparison has to be made, this song should be compared with chyi's songs in "camel, bird, fish"

  • 都很好阿 會什麼一定要比高下呢?

    根本不能比吧 各有各的特色

    我不會想要折斷其中一張唱片只聽一張阿

  • i am so proud of being the fans of Sandy Lam

  • 菲擁有最乾淨的聲音.但論曲風多元天分音域寬和最溫柔性感的聲音­.是憶蓮.

  • @egg2201

    没有人否认 Sandy 是具有实力,值得尊重的歌手。但以上的言论只是你自己的想法。

  • Sandy has chosen to be a low key artist and focusing on music and self-improvement. People respect that. Such a performance should have caught much more attention.

  • I am a fan of Faye Wong but have to admit that Faye can't pull off such conviction and power in a song such as this. Sandy's voice is like a sweet light wine that after repeated tasting can taste thick, rich, cultured and mesmerizing. After all these years, I have to say that she's impressed me so much with her conviction to her art, her willingness to try on new things and the control of her voice.

  • Sandys' sincere appreciation and apprehension towards the world music and musician outlined she acting a different role among others since she is a well-known singer, her self indulgence and addiction with different musical instruments arousing her performance into a impressive and stunning audio picture. Surely her work isn't done instantaneously, she really putting loads of efforts into her own's music dreamland which is the reason her debut took a decade to finish cos she is 'Sandy' !

  • Comment removed

  • 王菲和 Sandy 本来就很有实力,各有特色。有人一直到王菲的视频不断放毒,那股­酸味实在很重。

  • 畢竟那時模仿菲的人太多了.有ˇ點大家都這樣唱.但阿妹的出現.­讓大家找到新歡了.菲的最後一張將愛台灣賣得很差

  • @egg2201

    唱片业本来就在萎缩。请问 Sandy 的后期唱片就卖得很好吗?

  • 也賣不好ㄚ.現在唱片台灣只有梁靜茹和蔡依林能賣.

  • 二位都是不可多得Diva,論音質天份,Sandy稍遜Faye­, 加上Faye久休復出當然比較受矚目,經紀人陳家瑛又是宣傳好手­,但是Sandy幾近20多年的音樂路不斷突破自已,都市觸覺時­期的她是舞曲天后,滾石時期變成情歌天后,Live07之後的她­各種樂風幾乎是隨心所欲

  • 聽王菲唱歌聽的就是她乾淨的音質,演唱技巧跟本不是重點,王菲後­期也不喜歡用力唱歌...唱得很高音不代表真的會唱歌...

  • 所以菲後期唱片銷量會掉.也是因為被阿妹的打擊到.阿妹熱情奔放­無所不能的唱腔.震醒大家.

  • @egg2201

    那阿妹后期销量也在掉,也是因为 Jolin 和燕姿打击到吗?

  • 這是樂壇正常的現象阿.你真奇怪..

  • 我說的是事實...OK

  • 有種無奈感,覺得Sandy都被王菲壓著打,Sandy的歌唱實­力明明就不輸王菲阿,雖然王菲聲音特質很迷人,但心情還是好囧

  • 說一句實話.菲當初會爆紅不只是她的聲音.和她美麗又個性的外表­.這是憶蓮比較吃虧的

  • @egg2201

    中肯。谢谢。

  • 可惜王菲輸在沒胸部.難怪之後栽在更美又有胸的張柏芝手上.被搶­走謝霆鋒.

  • 其實Sandy 基本唱功確比Faye 扎實, 但Faye小腔的音色比較易入耳, 而且選擇的路線比Sandy 聰明, 商業藝術平衡得很好. 李宗盛雖然幫助Sandy在台湾普及, 但是也埋葬了Sandy前衛的特質.

  • SANDY 的音域也很廣阿.

  • @ttcsuck could be righter..... sandy will be even greater in 5 years. . .i think.

  • 烏鴉那裡的氣音真是迷人且讓人窒息

  • 好聽的聶^^

  • 有朋友跟我說前面有點王菲的風格...

    不過我覺得整首歌的感覺其實跟王菲不太一樣

    尤其是到後面....能在現場唱出這麼震攝人心的高音....真­的是非sandy莫屬!!

  • 後期的王菲說實話只有假音和有點小調的唱腔.

    跟早期的王菲的音色比和唱功比.唉.

  • 後期的王菲說實話只有假音和有點小調的唱腔.

    跟早期的王菲的音色比和唱功比.唉.

  • 王菲高音的實音.沒辦法這麼高好嗎.

  • it's fantastic!! only Sandy can perform this song so perfectly!!!

  • She is my only diva!!!

  • 這首歌越聽越好聽...

    後面整各就是太震撼了!!

    好期待她的新專輯!!

  • BTW, the music and the lyrics is ghostly beautiful!

  • Sandy, your powerful rendition is enormously cracking and it's strongly slapped the boring music society what we are facing, and your dedication towards to music is proved stepping a big forward undoubtely.

    Again, salutes for your innovation and this stunning delivering.

  • This is the best work from her for quite some time, very experimental but powerful and meaningful at the same time. Her voice was flawless in here, absolutely amazed me.

    I think Sandy picks a good musician to work (Chang Shilei) for the new album, I'm so looking forward to the full-length album that's coming soon.

  • Comment removed

  • Unexpectedly good.....Sandy finally finds her new direction....

  • this new song is very experimental... and not mainstream... sandy never fails to amaze us!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more