the fact that the 9th symphony can be adapted to english or german or whatever lyrics is a praise for this piece... it has managed to transcend language, culture and other merely human properties... for it stands as the best piece of art depicting godly ideas understood by all creatures at all times!!!
To those who are saying this isn't Beethoven's 9th I issue a challenge. I would like to see, on the original piece, the words to this song. Until I see this I will continue to presume that Beethoven left this song wordless for the reason that he knew many would interpret this song many ways, and that not one of those ways would be wrong. I take my Hat off to Andre and the Opera Babes for yet another beautifully performed piece of music.
This was pleasant enough, but it's not Beethoven's Ode to Joy. Before you jump down my throat, please hear me out. Firstly, Beethoven, and music of the Romantic Era in general, worked with rather specific forms of music, other forms and harmonies that are available to us now were either not used or not considered - and for good reason as most neo-romantic music is rather weak. Secondly the "Ode to Joy" piece is merely the words of Friedrich Schiller's poem "An die Freude" set by Beethoven to the
final movement of his 9th Symphony - the above is not even a translation of "An die Freude" so this cannot even be called a version of it; this is something completely different set to an arrangement of the Choral. Finally - remember by the time that Beethoven wrote this piece of music he was completely deaf and so the point of whether he would like this version is rather moot. Maybe he would see it as better, maybe he would deem it too weak. He wrote the original without being able to hear it
any where else but within his head. He obviously wrote it with a specific aim in mind and to change this - to remove part of it's vigour and timbre which so suit the poem which is set to it - is to do just that; to make it different from it's initial intent. I'm not saying that this is bad, but those who say it is not Beethoven are right. It's an arrangement, pleasant to listen to for sure, but nothing more than that. And titled completely wrongly.
That was so beautiful. Hearing the Opera Babes with an orchestra and choir and a nice video is a lovely rendition compared to the orchestral versions. The sound is magnificent.
On a side note, why do arguements arise about people like it? If you don't like something, it's fine to say so, and if you don't think this is a good version of Beethoven's 9th then that's your opinion. Respect each other's opinions- someone may believe he wouldn't like it, others do. Be nice!
How dare you presume that you know that this interpretation is not what Beethoven would have liked? Sure, it doesn't accord to your preferences, but you are a miserable arrogant by daring to suggest this is not Beethoven's 9th.
If you have some mystique way of communicating with the long de-composed Ludwig, let us know.
Frankly, you have no way of knowing that this is NOT his 9th symphony.
There is also a way you can tell - this sounds like a rehash of Del Mar's work - which was - quite frankly- a joke. The leading professor David Levy, an expert, even sneered at it.
hi there i would love to be able to play these short videos on andres site and also the ones they send through to me from time to time but they will not play they keep coming and going of can some one help me re this that would be great cheers for now from oz
Why not? You make a great sweeping statement about it being bad.
How do you know Beethoven wouldn't have liked it?
How do you know it doesn't compare?
Frankly, I am sick of reactions which pretend to have insight in hiw the great original was performed.
Frankly, you are a 21st century citizen, and I respectfully suggest you have no idea as to how Beethoven would have wanted it performed two years after his death (he himself would probably have no idea either).
What the hell are you talking about? Beethoven's ninth was played DURING his life time. The Ninth Symphony was premiered on May 7, 1824 in Vienna - Beethoven didn't die until 1827 !
Beethoven was even THERE at the premiere and ASSISTED in DIRECTING the performance. The Kapellmeister was Michael Umlauf and his notes point to his NEED of Beethoven being there. Even though Beethoven was almost certainly deaf by this time - he still knew the entire piece note-for-note.
What the hell are you talking about? Beethoven's ninth was played DURING his life time. The Ninth Symphony was premiered on May 7, 1824 in Vienna - Beethoven didn't die until 1827 !
Beethoven was even THERE at the premiere and ASSISTED in DIRECTING the performance. The Kapellmeister was Michael Umlauf and his notes point to his NEED of Beethoven being there. Even though Beethoven was almost certainly deaf by this time - he still knew the entire piece note-for-note.
All believing, all embracing Earth below and sky above. There will never be a power Greater than united love. O light of hope enduring Ever in our hearts reside. Now, the time to stand together. No man may alone abide. All as one in every nation By our bearing will be bound. Peace, the true and humble treasure Through compassion will be found. O light of clearest vision No illusion shall divide. Now, the time to stand together. No man may alone abide.
I also think Leonard Bernstein is one of the best performers of Beethoven's music. His recording of the Ninth Symphony with the Wiener Philharmoniker and Martti Talvela singing the Bass part is one of the greatest performances of that piece.
(IMO) the best version of Ode to Joy (Complete) is/was performed by Leonard Bernstein. This man came the closest to being able to understand Beethoven. (Forgive any spelling errors, its 4:00am for me right now)
Fantastic! What talent! Does anyone have a better recording of this that can be uploaded to play back in YouTube's new HQ mode? We've got to get this incredible version up for everyone to enjoy now and in the future.
What we have in this life are only symbols which point to an incomprehensively grander reality. Sure, many of these symbols impress us, but they are powerful because our intuition tells us that they are just a good tease. It is what remains hidden below the iceberg, that we sense and yet cannot see, that causes us to pine. And we stupidly focus on the flimsy little symbols poking above water that only help convey the insight. Ode to Joy is a dazzling symbol, but a mere shadow of things to come.
Ich habe nie zuvor "Freude schöner Götterfunken" auf englisch gehört, ein wenig komisch aber doch hörenswert.
Und nun zur Info: Beethoven No 9. ist die Europa-Hymne auch nur der vierte bekannte Satz, jedoch nur instrumental. Weil es eine neutrale Melodie sein sollte, die jeder kennt. Das ist gelungen, oder?
LOL! I can only sing it in English. The director of my grammar school choir taught songs and hymns which were fairly advanced for children,such as Mozart's Exultante, Jubilate, and the best sopranos had solid coloratura technique before they could spell the word. However, she taught us to sing in Latin and English only. Yes, the EU succeeded with their choice. My hands are itching for my piano as I type this.
It's a shame the lyrics are so hard to understand; they are awesome! If you want to know what they are, do a search for "Ode To Joy Andre Rieu Opera Babes lyrics" :)
I dont have anything against this beautiful Song in English. They can sing it in Spanish, in Japanese, in Russian so that all People can understand his text and that they can live after this wonderfull ideas behind this Song of World-Peace and that every Human is a Brother and Sister to each other.
But I hate People which only want to make Money and thats the only reason that they sing this song in English.
This wonderfull Song should be in translate in any Language but for Free!!
Regarding the "language" controversy: I laughed as I realized that the diction is so bad I initially couldn't tell in which language they are singing. This is neither "Beethoven 9" nor "An Die Freude," but an arrangement of one of the greatest melodies ever written. The words don't matter. Beethoven would like this. It isn't his his symphony but is moving and beautiful in any language. As G B Shaw said,"The poetry that lies too deep for words does not lie too deep for music." That's what counts.
was zum teufel das singt man nicht englich was soll der scheiß ohne witzt ich liebe das lied aber ds hört sich so total scheiße an sogar die japsen hamm das deutsch gesungen eine schande ist das
Just Google "Opera Babes Ode Joy Lyrics". Theirs is not a translation or even an interpretation of the Schiller poem but rather entirely new lyrics in English. For Schiller sung in English may I suggest my You Tube homepage : )),,,,
CLOCKWORK ORANGE - Brilliant!
jhangirk 1 week ago
This has also been adopted as the anthem of Europe.
limerick59 2 months ago
Fantastic lyrics
Jammin2vibes 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
kikuri2008 3 months ago
its in english you just dont here it in oprea.
TheLewisburgess 4 months ago
nvm
Marshalbrucemathers9 5 months ago
how disrespectful to womwen calling them babe ur terrible
im 13 and i know right from wrong :@
Marshalbrucemathers9 5 months ago
@Marshalbrucemathers9 They're called the Opera Babes, that's what they call themselves.
Brownie91JMB 4 months ago
@Marshalbrucemathers9 lol shutup
gmstokes 4 months ago
seriously, what language is it?
Jorjeca 7 months ago
the fact that the 9th symphony can be adapted to english or german or whatever lyrics is a praise for this piece... it has managed to transcend language, culture and other merely human properties... for it stands as the best piece of art depicting godly ideas understood by all creatures at all times!!!
27akram 1 year ago 2
23 deaf people were here
kamikadze230 1 year ago
@kamikadze230 Beethoven was almost 100% deaf and composed this.
VeranzaTheKing 5 months ago
Who's hotter? The chick with the short hair, or the chick with the long hair???
THE CHOICE IS YOURS!
TheIlluminatus503 1 year ago
@TheIlluminatus503 The book basically brought me to this song. Great book so far!
brizzlekizzle 6 months ago
youtube.com/watch?v=RuPiqhHMFN8 better quality^^
Keglibaum 1 year ago
I'll have a great life if these girls sing to me every morning.
remudus1 1 year ago 2
Excellent.
nycolas1712 1 year ago 4
Angles sings
MObaid27 1 year ago
classicalrelated do us a favour and shut ur hole haha
mclean7771 1 year ago
When was this made?
RexBlazer1 1 year ago
Wow man wow
I love this. A little piece of heaven on Earth.
summer20105707 1 year ago
@Zenryobrownwolf ohhh take a chill pile sigh
thexxxduelxxx 1 year ago
<3 <3 <3
zZzCrazyHorrorFanzZz 1 year ago
To those who are saying this isn't Beethoven's 9th I issue a challenge. I would like to see, on the original piece, the words to this song. Until I see this I will continue to presume that Beethoven left this song wordless for the reason that he knew many would interpret this song many ways, and that not one of those ways would be wrong. I take my Hat off to Andre and the Opera Babes for yet another beautifully performed piece of music.
Inufan2005 1 year ago
Bellisimooooo!
Pekamoon 1 year ago
This was pleasant enough, but it's not Beethoven's Ode to Joy. Before you jump down my throat, please hear me out. Firstly, Beethoven, and music of the Romantic Era in general, worked with rather specific forms of music, other forms and harmonies that are available to us now were either not used or not considered - and for good reason as most neo-romantic music is rather weak. Secondly the "Ode to Joy" piece is merely the words of Friedrich Schiller's poem "An die Freude" set by Beethoven to the
Xyalon 1 year ago
final movement of his 9th Symphony - the above is not even a translation of "An die Freude" so this cannot even be called a version of it; this is something completely different set to an arrangement of the Choral. Finally - remember by the time that Beethoven wrote this piece of music he was completely deaf and so the point of whether he would like this version is rather moot. Maybe he would see it as better, maybe he would deem it too weak. He wrote the original without being able to hear it
Xyalon 1 year ago
any where else but within his head. He obviously wrote it with a specific aim in mind and to change this - to remove part of it's vigour and timbre which so suit the poem which is set to it - is to do just that; to make it different from it's initial intent. I'm not saying that this is bad, but those who say it is not Beethoven are right. It's an arrangement, pleasant to listen to for sure, but nothing more than that. And titled completely wrongly.
Xyalon 1 year ago
That was so beautiful. Hearing the Opera Babes with an orchestra and choir and a nice video is a lovely rendition compared to the orchestral versions. The sound is magnificent.
On a side note, why do arguements arise about people like it? If you don't like something, it's fine to say so, and if you don't think this is a good version of Beethoven's 9th then that's your opinion. Respect each other's opinions- someone may believe he wouldn't like it, others do. Be nice!
Sapphire848 2 years ago 2
Sorry i dont like it. It´s.. not Beethoven...
Zenryobrownwolf 2 years ago
lol not Beethoven? this play is from Beethoven only performed by somebody else
fransjeclevers 2 years ago
Yes of course but it´s not good pervormed. Beethoven had wrote other and THATS ist Beethoven 9 Symphony not this.
Zenryobrownwolf 2 years ago
@Zenryobrownwolf
How dare you presume that you know that this interpretation is not what Beethoven would have liked? Sure, it doesn't accord to your preferences, but you are a miserable arrogant by daring to suggest this is not Beethoven's 9th.
If you have some mystique way of communicating with the long de-composed Ludwig, let us know.
Frankly, you have no way of knowing that this is NOT his 9th symphony.
Only Beethoven could tell us that.
Cheers.
ClassicalRelated 2 years ago
@ClassicalRelated Well Perhaps because it bears very little resembalnce tp whta he wrote.
halloerde 1 year ago
@ClassicalRelated
There is also a way you can tell - this sounds like a rehash of Del Mar's work - which was - quite frankly- a joke. The leading professor David Levy, an expert, even sneered at it.
antihero85 1 year ago
You're right..it's not Bait Oven...let's dig him up and make him play it for us.
midnighttilldawn 1 year ago
Excellent.
nycolas1712 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
hi there i would love to be able to play these short videos on andres site and also the ones they send through to me from time to time but they will not play they keep coming and going of can some one help me re this that would be great cheers for now from oz
6007529 2 years ago
he's right why does everybody think they're a expert on classical music?
fransjeclevers 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
hmm........ bad
it doesn't compare to te great original
xetytos 2 years ago
Why not? You make a great sweeping statement about it being bad.
How do you know Beethoven wouldn't have liked it?
How do you know it doesn't compare?
Frankly, I am sick of reactions which pretend to have insight in hiw the great original was performed.
Frankly, you are a 21st century citizen, and I respectfully suggest you have no idea as to how Beethoven would have wanted it performed two years after his death (he himself would probably have no idea either).
Thumbs down to you.
ClassicalRelated 2 years ago
@ClassicalRelated
What the hell are you talking about? Beethoven's ninth was played DURING his life time. The Ninth Symphony was premiered on May 7, 1824 in Vienna - Beethoven didn't die until 1827 !
Beethoven was even THERE at the premiere and ASSISTED in DIRECTING the performance. The Kapellmeister was Michael Umlauf and his notes point to his NEED of Beethoven being there. Even though Beethoven was almost certainly deaf by this time - he still knew the entire piece note-for-note.
antihero85 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ClassicalRelated
What the hell are you talking about? Beethoven's ninth was played DURING his life time. The Ninth Symphony was premiered on May 7, 1824 in Vienna - Beethoven didn't die until 1827 !
Beethoven was even THERE at the premiere and ASSISTED in DIRECTING the performance. The Kapellmeister was Michael Umlauf and his notes point to his NEED of Beethoven being there. Even though Beethoven was almost certainly deaf by this time - he still knew the entire piece note-for-note.
antihero85 1 year ago
Day by day the dawn is breaking
On the bond of brotherhood.
O light of pure intention
All dissension cast aside
Now, the time to stand together
No man need alone abide.
fransjeclevers 2 years ago 15
fransjeclevers 2 years ago 20
This has been flagged as spam show
GERMAN IS SUPERIOR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jakesibley 2 years ago
I am sorry for all concerned. This was broadcast from VIENNA.
Why should there have been any doubt about this?
ClassicalRelated 2 years ago 2
i`m sure you know best big man,but can i just take this oppertunity to say these to munters are awfull! i thank u.
bigmopettin 2 years ago
WTF ITS NOT GERMAN!!!!
not bad tho but its still best in german
Cycon626 2 years ago 4
It's english "nichris5566" ;)
1kappa4 2 years ago
What language??
nichris5566 2 years ago
Hello,
Don't tell me you are going to revive the language discussion again?
Its ugly head has been reared in the past, and I do not envisage allowing a discussion on this topic again.
ClassicalRelated 2 years ago
@nichris5566 german
Marshalbrucemathers9 5 months ago
Does anyone recognize the location for this video (the lion statues, etc.) Thanks!
thistle2007 2 years ago
A Bavarian girl I know told me it's Vienna.
regnatarajan 2 years ago
I think it's Bonn.
Beethoven borns there :)
MiNDBLiZZaRD 2 years ago
In Europe, thats the best i can give you lol. Italy from the looks of it.
newm123 2 years ago
Viena , Schonberg castle, i belive
dangypsie 2 years ago 2
In the background you see the yellow castle of Schonbrunn and also the building behind the castle called Gloriette.
Nachtvlinder74 2 years ago
I also think Leonard Bernstein is one of the best performers of Beethoven's music. His recording of the Ninth Symphony with the Wiener Philharmoniker and Martti Talvela singing the Bass part is one of the greatest performances of that piece.
BSIFr3yr 2 years ago
(IMO) the best version of Ode to Joy (Complete) is/was performed by Leonard Bernstein. This man came the closest to being able to understand Beethoven. (Forgive any spelling errors, its 4:00am for me right now)
AndrewDeLong 2 years ago
voices of angels
sidDkid87 2 years ago
best part starts at 2:45
TazPoweredVideos 2 years ago 3
ja ja aber ich kann hören sie nicht zu gut... aber das Lied ist gut...
erickblooplala 2 years ago
Fantastic! What talent! Does anyone have a better recording of this that can be uploaded to play back in YouTube's new HQ mode? We've got to get this incredible version up for everyone to enjoy now and in the future.
thistle2007 2 years ago
Truly a song worthy of the highest honors man can recieve!!! If god had a theme song, I'd hope this would be it!
AndrewDeLong 2 years ago 2
This is it. But "Ode to Joy" is only a sixteenth note in His infinite orchestral masterpiece.
Domreiter28 2 years ago
Lol. Well said. But still, a sixteenth note found within the expanse of the eternal is quite a note to behold. No?
AndrewDeLong 2 years ago
What we have in this life are only symbols which point to an incomprehensively grander reality. Sure, many of these symbols impress us, but they are powerful because our intuition tells us that they are just a good tease. It is what remains hidden below the iceberg, that we sense and yet cannot see, that causes us to pine. And we stupidly focus on the flimsy little symbols poking above water that only help convey the insight. Ode to Joy is a dazzling symbol, but a mere shadow of things to come.
Domreiter28 2 years ago 3
I never heard "Ode of joy" in an english version. So it was a little bit arkward, but enjoyable also.
Only for information: The part of Beethovens No. 9 were Ode of joy is sung is the anthem of the european union but only instrumental.
Because it should be neutral but a melody everbody recognize. They suceeded, didn´t they?
Tjami81 2 years ago
Und nun nochmal auf Deutsch:
Ich habe nie zuvor "Freude schöner Götterfunken" auf englisch gehört, ein wenig komisch aber doch hörenswert.
Und nun zur Info: Beethoven No 9. ist die Europa-Hymne auch nur der vierte bekannte Satz, jedoch nur instrumental. Weil es eine neutrale Melodie sein sollte, die jeder kennt. Das ist gelungen, oder?
Tjami81 2 years ago
Tjami81:
LOL! I can only sing it in English. The director of my grammar school choir taught songs and hymns which were fairly advanced for children,such as Mozart's Exultante, Jubilate, and the best sopranos had solid coloratura technique before they could spell the word. However, she taught us to sing in Latin and English only. Yes, the EU succeeded with their choice. My hands are itching for my piano as I type this.
acotw67 2 years ago
This is one of my favourite versions of "Ode to Joy" but then it's a beautiful piece of music however it is sung. Thanks for posting :-o)
NetworkNorm 2 years ago
Bravo! Beautiful! Always a treat to listen to.
mra2z 3 years ago
It's a shame the lyrics are so hard to understand; they are awesome! If you want to know what they are, do a search for "Ode To Joy Andre Rieu Opera Babes lyrics" :)
j67123 3 years ago
Once you have the lyrics in front of you it just kind of clicks and then it becomes easy to understand.
BigDaddyBongos 3 years ago
The beauty and soul of mankind is interwoven into the pure tones of this musical piece that encompasses the heart and soul of man's romanticism.
Thank you for sharing. May the light of this song touch China, touch every nation, touch every human
Let it forever ring in the hearts of mankind!
theTruthSeeksAll 3 years ago 4
I dont have anything against this beautiful Song in English. They can sing it in Spanish, in Japanese, in Russian so that all People can understand his text and that they can live after this wonderfull ideas behind this Song of World-Peace and that every Human is a Brother and Sister to each other.
But I hate People which only want to make Money and thats the only reason that they sing this song in English.
This wonderfull Song should be in translate in any Language but for Free!!
Lopikon 3 years ago
Hi,
This video has attracted an endless discussion about the merits (or not) of an English version of this song.
I do not entertain to have this discussion continued ad nauseam.
From now on, any messages attempting to revive this discussion will be deleted.
ClassicalRelated (aka Gerrit)
ClassicalRelated 3 years ago
Regarding the "language" controversy: I laughed as I realized that the diction is so bad I initially couldn't tell in which language they are singing. This is neither "Beethoven 9" nor "An Die Freude," but an arrangement of one of the greatest melodies ever written. The words don't matter. Beethoven would like this. It isn't his his symphony but is moving and beautiful in any language. As G B Shaw said,"The poetry that lies too deep for words does not lie too deep for music." That's what counts.
PTCello 3 years ago 3
PS PTCello,
I'll let your reaction stand, even though it appeared just after I posted my note about ending the discusion about language versions of this song.
I quite like your contribution.
ClassicalRelated 3 years ago
Thank you. Actually, we must have been writing at the same time, because when I posted my note, Your comment had not yet appeared.
PTCello 3 years ago
Im English, but I do think it is better in German, or it will end up having its origins hyjacked
Guyisaritelegend 3 years ago 2
it's breathtaking yet it felt so corny... hahahahahaha... but still wonderful performance...
darnmat 3 years ago
The german version is the bast.
darkspell117 3 years ago 3
Yes, it is English!!!
xxxxxxBadBoyxxxxxx 3 years ago
Do they sing in German ? This version is a little weird.
dbenasic 3 years ago
i think it's english
thetikia2 3 years ago
The ode to joy is always sung in german.
Schalkeboy04 3 years ago
Nice girls.......
xxxxxxBadBoyxxxxxx 3 years ago
WAHRET DIE DEUTSCHE SPRACHE
Verein Deutsche Sprache e.V.
xvclaudiavx 3 years ago 3
poor Beethoven
werwarich 3 years ago 2
que bontio
soyelquesoy85 3 years ago
Purely Awesome!
AndrewDeLong 3 years ago
Gotta luv the opera babes...
DARIVSARCHITECTVS 3 years ago
Fly!
PhilipBerridge 3 years ago
So weit her ist es mit Deinem Deutsch ja auch nicht, nicht mal kor_igiert.
Aber inhaltlich schließe ich mich an. Englisch ist hier kein Gewinn.
schattensand 3 years ago
Horror.....
griselle4419 3 years ago 2
Es gibt weitaus miesere Arrangements. Ich mag Rieu trotzdem nicht.
ElScotty1983 3 years ago
Too bad Beethoven was deaf when he wrote this, imagine writing something so beautiful and not being able to here it.
Teterkids 3 years ago 4
But luckily he can't hear this awful rendition!
blichilde 3 years ago
A true ode to Beethoven!
Teterkids 3 years ago
Beautiful!
Teterkids 3 years ago
Inspired! How can this fail to move the soul
theseoldshoes 3 years ago
rebecca (the one on the left) wrote the lyrics
rudesololight 3 years ago
this is a the most beautiful version i have heard of that song.
4766462 3 years ago
The sound is sooo beautiful.I love them!
vedraville 3 years ago 3
English? *beurk*
kaloemptrek 3 years ago
was zum teufel das singt man nicht englich was soll der scheiß ohne witzt ich liebe das lied aber ds hört sich so total scheiße an sogar die japsen hamm das deutsch gesungen eine schande ist das
tim080888 3 years ago 8
wenn du jetzt nicht 2japsen" sagst, gebe ich dir voll recht. =)
volkerkk 3 years ago
ich muss korigieren japaner sorry
tim080888 3 years ago
Beautiful!
lobo81865 3 years ago
just wondering, what concert of his was this from??? wonder if this one's on dvd or not.
whjman07 3 years ago 2
Sounds fantastic! Andre Rieu & his orchestra with the opera babes is top grade stuff to listen to.
Vee6watchman 3 years ago
die stimme un den text auf deutsch....das wär dann wohl die beste interpretation dieses liedes
lukki111 3 years ago 5
Mouais... rien ne vaut l'original :P
SnakkyDoll 3 years ago
English lyrics? Epic win. I can't make out all of it, though. Does anyone have a transcript?
ArgentumKalibrum 3 years ago 3
the translation is pretty bad i think
Brachiale 3 years ago 2
I can't really make out what they're singing at all, so...
ArgentumKalibrum 3 years ago
Just Google "Opera Babes Ode Joy Lyrics". Theirs is not a translation or even an interpretation of the Schiller poem but rather entirely new lyrics in English. For Schiller sung in English may I suggest my You Tube homepage : )),,,,
rhineceres 3 years ago